Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be exasperated with posters who refer to ‘the terminally offended’?

312 replies

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 14/03/2024 21:11

Been lurking on a couple of threads recently and I just get so frustrated by posters who use these phrases:

”People are offended by EVERYTHING these days.”

”Snowflake”

”The terminally/permanently offended”

etc

It’s just so empty and pointless; you could equally have used these phrases against, say, people objecting to page three photos a few years ago (and, to be fair, some of these posters probably did).

People get so angry when prejudice is pointed out to them. You just know they’re aching to say “This is political correctness gone mad!” but they at least know that’s been discredited, so they pull out one of those other meaningless catchphrases.

AIBU to wish that people could actually articulate a reason that people shouldn’t be offended by insidious prejudice rather than just slinging pointless insults?

OP posts:
WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 19/03/2024 12:52

CurlewKate · 19/03/2024 12:34

@Ofcourseshecan That's not what a micro aggression is.

What is a microaggression? I’ve read the Wiki explanation but it all seems very ill defined (and quite widely criticised as a concept by people who work in the field - as opposed to by inveterate naysayers).

Is the CP ad a microagression? There seem to be lots of institutions that recognise microaggression towards women.

CurlewKate · 19/03/2024 12:34

@Ofcourseshecan That's not what a micro aggression is.

CurlewKate · 19/03/2024 12:33

@TempestTost "I'm happy to analyze people. And what I conclude is that some people are stupid in their analysis and also some are in fact virtue signalling, terminally offended, people."

I'm sure some people are. The reverse also applies.

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 19/03/2024 12:28

Ofcourseshecan · 19/03/2024 11:20

I think the concept of ‘micro aggressions’ is very dangerous. It encourages a sense of victimhood.

Someone looks at you the wrong way, or you think there’s something sneery in their tone, or they turned away when you were approaching them. Any of those could be completely innocent, or by someone who hadn’t even noticed you. But if you want to find fault, they’re micro aggressions.

In all honesty, I think that is just you misunderstanding micro-aggression as a concept.

OP posts:
FourLeggedBuckers · 19/03/2024 11:37

Not every stereotype is actively harmful, but stereotypes that reinforce prejudices that are tangible existent in society - those reinforcing misogynistic, racist, homophobic (et al) stereotypes - aren’t appropriate for use in advertising.

Ofcourseshecan · 19/03/2024 11:20

I think the concept of ‘micro aggressions’ is very dangerous. It encourages a sense of victimhood.

Someone looks at you the wrong way, or you think there’s something sneery in their tone, or they turned away when you were approaching them. Any of those could be completely innocent, or by someone who hadn’t even noticed you. But if you want to find fault, they’re micro aggressions.

LancashireTart · 19/03/2024 11:06

TempestTost · 19/03/2024 00:07

I'm happy to analyze people. And what I conclude is that some people are stupid in their analysis and also some are in fact virtue signalling, terminally offended, people.

This is the best post on the whole thread. 👏

CurlewKate · 19/03/2024 07:48

I do think one of the things we keep tripping up on is the word "offence". I'm not offended by common stereotypes of women, for example. I just think they aren't helpful. Generations of advertisements have presented women and girls as weaker and sillier and more focussed on their appearance and more domestic than men. And if girls and boys grow up surrounded by that it's going to have some effect on how they see the world. I'm not suggesting the advertisers have malicious intent. But surely it's better to show a more progressive vision whenever possible?

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 19/03/2024 06:24

TempestTost · 19/03/2024 01:03

It's not really very easy to create a lot of content without ever using "stereotypes."

The thing is, stereotypes are fundamentally generalizations about groups, and some generalizations are true, statistically speaking.

The idea that popular stereotypes about groups are mostly inaccurate has been studied extensively, and it's pretty much been show to be completely untrue. There is actually a really high correlation between common stereotypes and actual statistical facts about groups.

The problem with stereotypes is assuming they are true of individuals and then treating individual people as if they are just a kind of representation of the abstract image of that group.

What this means for things like tv, or advertising, or literature, is that if you try and subvert the stereotypes every time, chances are it won't ring true to viewers, when you take it in the aggregate. If in every ad the mum is a beast, racing ahead of the dad and kids on her bike, people know it's advertisers playing the game, not a real attempt to make a funny commercial.

And because a lot of stereotypes are true, they also reflect many people's experience, so it's a way to connect. Maybe that ad didn't subvert people's views about mums on bike, but maybe a lot of mums connected with the experience of lagging behind?

A lot of the frustration people have with those who pick at all these things constantly comes from the sense that they are looking at every statement, interaction, and image from the view that it is either upholding, or subverting, some kind of underlying power dynamic that is evil. A lot of the time that just isn't the right lens though, it's irrelevant and inappropriate.

Well, yes, plenty of stereotypes are based in a sort of truth. That’s where they came from. But a stereotype is generally reductive is some way. And can be harmful more often than it’s helpful.

It’s not just the same as a statistical likelihood. For example, statistically, most families consist of some configuration of parents + children. Far, far fewer households consist of grandparents + children or aunts/uncles as primary care-givers for the children. So most advertising will work off that. That makes sense. It is not a stereotype as such; it’s just a common sense interpretation of the most common, practical circumstances. The reason people live like this isn’t based in prejudice.

By contrast, women (due to a massive weight of sexism through history of which you can’t be unaware!) are viewed as less. They are sneered at on a class level. Men do wield their physical superiority over them. They are more likely to be the one running round after everyone else on holiday, completely knackered. And these likelihoods are based in that highly prejudiced backstory. This is a stereotype. Based in reality but undesirable because of its reductive connotations.

It doesn’t take a great deal of thought to see that another reminder of that stereotype could be a little tiresome.

OP posts:
BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 19/03/2024 06:09

Underthinker · 18/03/2024 22:06

@FourLeggedBuckers what seems unjust to me in your way of looking at things, is that all the power is in the hands of offence finder. If you perceive sexism/racism in an advert for example, then that is part of some noble search for meaning, whereas the people who don't see prejudice in the same product are incurious at best and bigoted at worst.
It doesn't matter to you if the creator intended the negative meaning or holds that prejudice.
It doesn't matter if most people don't see the prejudice, or need it explained to them. (E.g. many didn't know "unfit mum" was a stereotype)
It just has the air of a witch hunt about it to me.
And I accept and appreciate your goal is to combat prejudice, but is there nothing to be said of thinking the best of people and assuming good intentions until proven otherwise?

There’s not necessarily any power there - but there should be the freedom to point out the issues in an intelligent way. There’s not necessarily any power in calling someone a snowflake either; it’s just silly and exasperating.

OP posts:
pikkumyy77 · 19/03/2024 03:00

So we come down to it: the greatest sin is to somehow make just regular folks uncomfortable? That can’t be a sincere reflection of an experience or belief that is different from yours—it has to be “waffle” or “virtue signaling?”

TempestTost · 19/03/2024 01:03

It's not really very easy to create a lot of content without ever using "stereotypes."

The thing is, stereotypes are fundamentally generalizations about groups, and some generalizations are true, statistically speaking.

The idea that popular stereotypes about groups are mostly inaccurate has been studied extensively, and it's pretty much been show to be completely untrue. There is actually a really high correlation between common stereotypes and actual statistical facts about groups.

The problem with stereotypes is assuming they are true of individuals and then treating individual people as if they are just a kind of representation of the abstract image of that group.

What this means for things like tv, or advertising, or literature, is that if you try and subvert the stereotypes every time, chances are it won't ring true to viewers, when you take it in the aggregate. If in every ad the mum is a beast, racing ahead of the dad and kids on her bike, people know it's advertisers playing the game, not a real attempt to make a funny commercial.

And because a lot of stereotypes are true, they also reflect many people's experience, so it's a way to connect. Maybe that ad didn't subvert people's views about mums on bike, but maybe a lot of mums connected with the experience of lagging behind?

A lot of the frustration people have with those who pick at all these things constantly comes from the sense that they are looking at every statement, interaction, and image from the view that it is either upholding, or subverting, some kind of underlying power dynamic that is evil. A lot of the time that just isn't the right lens though, it's irrelevant and inappropriate.

TempestTost · 19/03/2024 00:07

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 14/03/2024 21:57

Found one!

Are you not interested in analysing human behaviour? Do you think that looking into the reasons and motivations behind our words and actions is worthwhile?

I know we’re all in a hurry most of the time, but I think it’s worthwhile to stop and think about the implications of the prevailing ideas/behaviours we see around us. Often we do harbour prejudices. Why is it so wrong to uncover them? Surely that leads to progress?

I’m not taking about being offended. That’s the line thrown at thoughtful people- you’re ‘permanently offended.’ It’s so reductive.

I'm happy to analyze people. And what I conclude is that some people are stupid in their analysis and also some are in fact virtue signalling, terminally offended, people.

FourLeggedBuckers · 18/03/2024 23:46

Underthinker · 18/03/2024 22:06

@FourLeggedBuckers what seems unjust to me in your way of looking at things, is that all the power is in the hands of offence finder. If you perceive sexism/racism in an advert for example, then that is part of some noble search for meaning, whereas the people who don't see prejudice in the same product are incurious at best and bigoted at worst.
It doesn't matter to you if the creator intended the negative meaning or holds that prejudice.
It doesn't matter if most people don't see the prejudice, or need it explained to them. (E.g. many didn't know "unfit mum" was a stereotype)
It just has the air of a witch hunt about it to me.
And I accept and appreciate your goal is to combat prejudice, but is there nothing to be said of thinking the best of people and assuming good intentions until proven otherwise?

I don’t think that’s a logical conclusion from my standpoint at all.

I didn’t actually say that the intent of the creator is irrelevant- I said that the meaning inferred is also valuable - or relevant - even if it wasn’t what was intended. I stand by that - a reasonable human might say something with good intent and be met with offence taken from it by others. A reasonable human responds to that by questioning whether those offended have a point (or not), and considering whether to change how they express themselves going forward. A reasonable human does not respond with “woke snowflakes everywhere, permanently offended 🙄” - because that’s putting their own ego above the opinions and feelings of others.

As for whether the feeling of offence is widespread or not - I’ve explicitly stated in previous posts that it’s relevant whether it’s individual offence or significant minority offence or majority offence. You’re projecting your own interpretation onto my viewpoint here.

Assuming good intentions until proven otherwise is reasonable when you aren’t dealing with a society in which systemic prejudice exists. To even suggest that is, in my opinion, to deny the existence of that systemic prejudice, and that is a concerning starting moral point.

Turkey98 · 18/03/2024 22:47

How people wish to express themselves is part of the person they are, a core part of their expression of identity - it is always inappropriate to offer feedback or critique unless you are personally asked by them for that feedback.

The same applies where a meaning is being assigned to a statement believing there is a malicious intent - trying to find any hidden meaning or not viewing any statement in a natural way is not taking offence, but looking for and assigning a belief without asking the originator first is divisive.

People who feel they need to comment on how someone expresses themselves as you point out are rarely offended, but they are acting inappropriately and do deserve a label of trying to change other’s behaviour and values to match their own - “constantly preaching” is probably a better term.

Offence can never be given, it is purely a response by the one who is offended. It is possible to take never take offence, but rather just disagree if the conversation is an exchange of views. Irrespective of what is said, the offended are putting themselves in that state - its is solely a problem they alone have created. In essence, taking offence is always an unnecessary reaction that is being expressed, and the similarity is that those accused of being permanently in this state seem to have a lot of unnecessary and inappropriate reactions to others reasonable views and language.

If you find yourself thinking about someone else language or underlying meaning more than once or twice a year it is very likely the pejorative terms mentioned, despite not being accurate do apply to you and you should stop interfering with others self expression, assigning your own meaning to their choice of words and just concentrate on your own communication.

Underthinker · 18/03/2024 22:06

@FourLeggedBuckers what seems unjust to me in your way of looking at things, is that all the power is in the hands of offence finder. If you perceive sexism/racism in an advert for example, then that is part of some noble search for meaning, whereas the people who don't see prejudice in the same product are incurious at best and bigoted at worst.
It doesn't matter to you if the creator intended the negative meaning or holds that prejudice.
It doesn't matter if most people don't see the prejudice, or need it explained to them. (E.g. many didn't know "unfit mum" was a stereotype)
It just has the air of a witch hunt about it to me.
And I accept and appreciate your goal is to combat prejudice, but is there nothing to be said of thinking the best of people and assuming good intentions until proven otherwise?

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 18/03/2024 21:54

FourLeggedBuckers · 18/03/2024 21:53

Yet again, I really can’t agree with you on that. Not on any part.

OK.

FourLeggedBuckers · 18/03/2024 21:53

Yet again, I really can’t agree with you on that. Not on any part.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 18/03/2024 21:50

FourLeggedBuckers · 18/03/2024 21:48

Well it’s nice to know that reasoned and respectful debate is alive and well on the internet, eh?!

TBH I thought my (accurate) response was less ill tempered than what was said to me.

FourLeggedBuckers · 18/03/2024 21:48

Well it’s nice to know that reasoned and respectful debate is alive and well on the internet, eh?!

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 18/03/2024 21:39

pikkumyy77 · 18/03/2024 21:37

But to say they are ephemeral and “instantly forgotten” though perhaps true is not the whole truth. Ad campaigns can reinforce social shibboleths or break them. Not an ad campaign but famously actors smoking or not smoking or wearing hats or not wearing hats in films has had enormous influence on popular culture and the purchase of those items.

The interesting thing is that you insist on spending tons of time arguing a fairly petty point (advertising is not a proper focus of concern or study) which is trivially false. It has been the focus of study, and remains an area of political and social contestation. Who gets to advertise and what they show is of enormous social import: cigarette ads, abortion add, ads for prostitution? Do you ever ask yourself why you take for granted the artificial and market/state constructed advertising space? Your determined ignorance is not proof that you see the world clearly but rather that you prefer a passive stance.

Without wishing to be discourteous, that is some right high octane waffle.

pikkumyy77 · 18/03/2024 21:37

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 18/03/2024 21:24

Got it. There are some memorable ads and some success stories. I don’t know whether the Gold Blend couple helped sales, for example, but the campaign was good entertainment. Same for the Cointreau flirters. And the Milk Tray Man (what a shit product that was).

The vast, vast majority of ads (bearing in mind that most aren’t TV ads and that the days of mass audiences are long gone anyway) are just ephemeral and instantly forgotten though.

But to say they are ephemeral and “instantly forgotten” though perhaps true is not the whole truth. Ad campaigns can reinforce social shibboleths or break them. Not an ad campaign but famously actors smoking or not smoking or wearing hats or not wearing hats in films has had enormous influence on popular culture and the purchase of those items.

The interesting thing is that you insist on spending tons of time arguing a fairly petty point (advertising is not a proper focus of concern or study) which is trivially false. It has been the focus of study, and remains an area of political and social contestation. Who gets to advertise and what they show is of enormous social import: cigarette ads, abortion add, ads for prostitution? Do you ever ask yourself why you take for granted the artificial and market/state constructed advertising space? Your determined ignorance is not proof that you see the world clearly but rather that you prefer a passive stance.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 18/03/2024 21:24

5128gap · 18/03/2024 21:18

You said that adverts have little to no impact and I was reflecting on that, and that ad sprang to mind. The impact of that was game changing both for jeans and underwear (or perhaps that was Eddie Kidd...?)

Got it. There are some memorable ads and some success stories. I don’t know whether the Gold Blend couple helped sales, for example, but the campaign was good entertainment. Same for the Cointreau flirters. And the Milk Tray Man (what a shit product that was).

The vast, vast majority of ads (bearing in mind that most aren’t TV ads and that the days of mass audiences are long gone anyway) are just ephemeral and instantly forgotten though.

5128gap · 18/03/2024 21:18

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 18/03/2024 21:08

Eh?

I do remember it well. I’m not sure of the relevance though.

Did I overlook the Center Parcs dad stripping down to his undercrackers in the Parc Market?

You said that adverts have little to no impact and I was reflecting on that, and that ad sprang to mind. The impact of that was game changing both for jeans and underwear (or perhaps that was Eddie Kidd...?)

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 18/03/2024 21:08

5128gap · 18/03/2024 20:59

I'm guessing you don't recall Nick Kamen taking his 501s off in the launderette?

Eh?

I do remember it well. I’m not sure of the relevance though.

Did I overlook the Center Parcs dad stripping down to his undercrackers in the Parc Market?

Swipe left for the next trending thread