Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be exasperated with posters who refer to ‘the terminally offended’?

312 replies

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 14/03/2024 21:11

Been lurking on a couple of threads recently and I just get so frustrated by posters who use these phrases:

”People are offended by EVERYTHING these days.”

”Snowflake”

”The terminally/permanently offended”

etc

It’s just so empty and pointless; you could equally have used these phrases against, say, people objecting to page three photos a few years ago (and, to be fair, some of these posters probably did).

People get so angry when prejudice is pointed out to them. You just know they’re aching to say “This is political correctness gone mad!” but they at least know that’s been discredited, so they pull out one of those other meaningless catchphrases.

AIBU to wish that people could actually articulate a reason that people shouldn’t be offended by insidious prejudice rather than just slinging pointless insults?

OP posts:
WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 20/03/2024 12:08

FourLeggedBuckers · 20/03/2024 11:51

The reason I would be offended by the first example but not the CP ad is that I don’t interpret the CP ad as you do. I don’t read a socially undesirable message into it, whereas I would with the car spares ad

So you have a right to be offended by advertising you don’t like, but others don’t have a right to be offended by different ads?

No, I wouldn’t be offended by the ad you describe. I’d think it was in very poor form, but “offence” is an emotional response, and that isn’t what it would provoke for me. I’m not emotionally moved by poor advertising, I just think people should do their jobs better.

The spurious colourblind argument isn’t accurate: there is an empiric truth about the wavelengths of light involved. The interpretation of the colourblind individual is fine - they can not like it, even if they aren’t seeing it accurately - but correcting the colour is not an ad hominem argument. And that’s the relevant substance of the argument, not that they are personally colour blind.

I’ve never said people don’t have a right to be offended by an ad or anything else. I’m not religious but I can easily understand why those who are religious get offended by jokes or slights about their faith, for example.

People equally do have a right to say that offence expressed is because of over-sensitivity, or its cause completely eludes them.

The point I made was that you can’t duck out of whether you’re properly described as being offended by the CP as simply by moving the goalposts on what the word means.

The colour example was not mine. And I don’t understand it.

CurlewKate · 20/03/2024 12:05

@LancashireTart "It's obvious from this thread alone that there are people who try to find offence where there isn't any."

I disagree. (Well, I would, wouldn't I?) I think that we need to distinguish between "offensive", which the CP advertisement isn't, and mildly misogynist, which it is. Anything which perpetuates a stereotype of women as weak or incompetent or figures of fun is at least mildly misogynist and just better not part of our discourse. There are plenty of other narratives to use.

FourLeggedBuckers · 20/03/2024 11:51

The reason I would be offended by the first example but not the CP ad is that I don’t interpret the CP ad as you do. I don’t read a socially undesirable message into it, whereas I would with the car spares ad

So you have a right to be offended by advertising you don’t like, but others don’t have a right to be offended by different ads?

No, I wouldn’t be offended by the ad you describe. I’d think it was in very poor form, but “offence” is an emotional response, and that isn’t what it would provoke for me. I’m not emotionally moved by poor advertising, I just think people should do their jobs better.

The spurious colourblind argument isn’t accurate: there is an empiric truth about the wavelengths of light involved. The interpretation of the colourblind individual is fine - they can not like it, even if they aren’t seeing it accurately - but correcting the colour is not an ad hominem argument. And that’s the relevant substance of the argument, not that they are personally colour blind.

5128gap · 20/03/2024 11:47

LancashireTart · 20/03/2024 09:12

I really have no agenda whatsoever.

Ironically, it's others who seem to have an agenda to find offence where none exists, the Center Parcs advert being a perfect example of this.

Don't forget, offence isn't given, it's taken, and absolutely nobody has the right to not be offended. It's my view that if someone can find offence in something as innocuous as the CP advert then it's up to them to deal with their own feelings. It's cringey.

Of course people have rights not to be subject to things that cause them to be offended, many of which are rights protected in law, such as those covering anti social behaviour, public decency, hate speech etc. Not to mention the various policies adopted by workplaces, public services and so on that set behavioural standards with the express purpose of protecting one's right not be subjected to offensive behaviour.

LancashireTart · 20/03/2024 11:43

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 20/03/2024 11:28

@LancashireTart

I draw the line where things actually become offensive

But that’s entirely a matter of opinion and will vary hugely depending on perspective. What a silly thing to say.

How is it silly? Society knows what is considered offensive (racism, sexism, for example). It's obvious from this thread alone that there are people who try to find offence where there isn't any. Whether they do that subconsciously or not I don't know, but I do know that it isn't healthy.

Underthinker · 20/03/2024 11:43

Fundamentally, blaming the individual for their argument, rather than engaging with the content of the argument itself, is a logical fallacy.

Is it though? If someone found almost everything offensive (or unhelpful) then that would be relevant in deciding whether their claim that X was offensive was reasonable or not wouldn't it? It doesn't address the substance of their claim, but I'd say it affects its credibility.

"I don't like that shade of red on the wall, can you repaint it?"
"That's green and you know you're colour-blind."
"Logical Fallacy!"

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 20/03/2024 11:42

FourLeggedBuckers · 20/03/2024 11:02

Defending the CP ad is defending minor misogyny in a lot of people’s opinions.

Your points about offence are largely irrelevant as most posters who object to the CP ad are not offended by it, but simply think it is regressive, unhelpful and poor advertising.

You can disagree with that opinion, but calling people “permanently offended” when they aren’t even claiming to be offended by the thing in question isn’t a particularly logical standpoint.

If you see an ad with gratuitous and pointless use of a woman’s body - say, an ad for car spares prominently featuring a woman in a bikini - would you say it offended you? If you did I would agree with you and say it was offensive.

So why is ‘offence’ not the right word to use for those objecting to the CP ad?

The reason I would be offended by the first example but not the CP ad is that I don’t interpret the CP ad as you do. I don’t read a socially undesirable message into it, whereas I would with the car spares ad.

I can see that there can be mild or grave offence, and narrow or widespread offence. But I don’t see how the emotion behind the criticism isn’t one of offence.

If something’s said to be wrong and objectionable I think the right word for the reaction is ‘offence’.

I suspect that people shy away from the word because it conjures up images of angry prudes complaining about Channel 4 programmes. But I’m happy to own it if I object to some message or portrayal for whatever reason.

AllPrincessAnneshorses · 20/03/2024 11:32

Alcyoneus · 14/03/2024 22:21

To be honest, you sound exactly like you are part of the terminally offended crowd. Ranting and raving and finding offence in everything.

Bollocks. You sound like a prejudiced person who can't take a challenge

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 20/03/2024 11:28

@LancashireTart

I draw the line where things actually become offensive

But that’s entirely a matter of opinion and will vary hugely depending on perspective. What a silly thing to say.

OP posts:
LancashireTart · 20/03/2024 11:20

FourLeggedBuckers · 20/03/2024 11:02

Defending the CP ad is defending minor misogyny in a lot of people’s opinions.

Your points about offence are largely irrelevant as most posters who object to the CP ad are not offended by it, but simply think it is regressive, unhelpful and poor advertising.

You can disagree with that opinion, but calling people “permanently offended” when they aren’t even claiming to be offended by the thing in question isn’t a particularly logical standpoint.

"Defending the CP ad is defending minor misogyny in a lot of people’s opinions.

Your points about offence are largely irrelevant as most posters who object to the CP ad are not offended by it, but simply think it is regressive, unhelpful and poor advertising."

Then that goes precisely back to my point about people seeing offence that isn't there. Because there simply isn't and anyone who claims there is is simply wrong and I would question their mindset.

FourLeggedBuckers · 20/03/2024 11:15

It would be slightly more accurate, but it’s still a really lazy way to engage with a discussion.

Fundamentally, blaming the individual for their argument, rather than engaging with the content of the argument itself, is a logical fallacy.

Underthinker · 20/03/2024 11:10

Would "Permanently finding things unhelpful" be better?

FourLeggedBuckers · 20/03/2024 11:02

Defending the CP ad is defending minor misogyny in a lot of people’s opinions.

Your points about offence are largely irrelevant as most posters who object to the CP ad are not offended by it, but simply think it is regressive, unhelpful and poor advertising.

You can disagree with that opinion, but calling people “permanently offended” when they aren’t even claiming to be offended by the thing in question isn’t a particularly logical standpoint.

LancashireTart · 20/03/2024 10:43

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 20/03/2024 10:22

Don't forget, offence isn't given, it's taken, and absolutely nobody has the right to not be offended.

But where do you (as in you personally) draw the line?

Do you think it’s ok to shout racial slurs in the street? Presumably not? So you do think there is a point at which people have a responsibility not to give offence? You wouldn’t (presumably) blame the victim of that racial abuse for taking offence?

In which case, your point about taking not giving offence is rather flimsy.

It just comes down to where you draw the line. Which is kind of obvious I guess.

But even if your line is drawn at a very permissive point (i.e. you’re prepared to defend minor misogyny and refuse to call out any micro-aggressions because some people just need to toughen up), it’s still very lame to call people ‘permanently offended’ just because you can’t see their viewpoint/won’t fully explain yours. It’s just very belligerent and leads to conflict rather than understanding.

I draw the line where things actually become offensive, e.g. racial slurs, blatant sexism (e.g. "women belong in the kitchen", "men are useless so and sos", etc.), rather than things that aren't offensive per se.

And could you please explain where I've defended a minor misogyny?

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 20/03/2024 10:22

Don't forget, offence isn't given, it's taken, and absolutely nobody has the right to not be offended.

But where do you (as in you personally) draw the line?

Do you think it’s ok to shout racial slurs in the street? Presumably not? So you do think there is a point at which people have a responsibility not to give offence? You wouldn’t (presumably) blame the victim of that racial abuse for taking offence?

In which case, your point about taking not giving offence is rather flimsy.

It just comes down to where you draw the line. Which is kind of obvious I guess.

But even if your line is drawn at a very permissive point (i.e. you’re prepared to defend minor misogyny and refuse to call out any micro-aggressions because some people just need to toughen up), it’s still very lame to call people ‘permanently offended’ just because you can’t see their viewpoint/won’t fully explain yours. It’s just very belligerent and leads to conflict rather than understanding.

OP posts:
LancashireTart · 20/03/2024 09:12

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 19/03/2024 17:51

Really curious to know what your agenda is here @LancashireTart
You seem very invested in the idea that people are over-sensitive, as if you just want to defend your right to sort of bulldoze your way through life without considering the feelings of other, potentially disadvantaged, groups. I’m sure it’s not that, but I don’t think you’ve really explained your viewpoint in much detail.

I really have no agenda whatsoever.

Ironically, it's others who seem to have an agenda to find offence where none exists, the Center Parcs advert being a perfect example of this.

Don't forget, offence isn't given, it's taken, and absolutely nobody has the right to not be offended. It's my view that if someone can find offence in something as innocuous as the CP advert then it's up to them to deal with their own feelings. It's cringey.

CurlewKate · 20/03/2024 07:03

And yes, I agree it's lack of social skills! But isn't that rather the point?

CurlewKate · 20/03/2024 07:02

Is it the word "aggression" that's the issue? I do agree it's probably not what I would choose, although I can't think of a better one. I do think that it's a real thing though. And "othering" is a real thing too, subtle things that reinforce a sense of not belonging. "You speak such good English!" "Where are you really from?" -that sort of thing.

TempestTost · 19/03/2024 23:51

CurlewKate · 19/03/2024 19:17

@TempestTost That's one of the things about micro aggressions. There doesn't have to be any ill intent at all. It's just just things that are said to members of minority groups that act like the drip of water wearing away a stone. No ill intent but just a constant reminder of otherness. As Richard Osman said-nobody's been intending to make him feel different- but each individual forgets that they are one of 20 people who have said "Ooh, aren't you tall!" that day.

So not an aggression at all, actually.

"Othering" is doing a lot of heavy lifting here. Things like this are said to everyone at some point or another in life, tedious small talk, often meant to be light and funny, that you've heard 1000 times before and "reminds" you of something that you know very well which you are bored with or would perhaps rather not talk about or highlight.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 19/03/2024 19:27

Is the Richard O example really a micro aggression? It just sounds like people with poor social skills to me. For example, some people’s names tend to generate predictable comment - like quoting lines from songs that feature the name - and often get an eye-roll and a “I’ve never heard that before” in return. I would just say that’s socially inept, not aggressive.

Of course it’s different to shop staff watching black people in a shop more than white people, or ignoring a woman and only talking to her male partner. Those are outright hostility, bigotry or offensive stupidity.

CurlewKate · 19/03/2024 19:17

@TempestTost That's one of the things about micro aggressions. There doesn't have to be any ill intent at all. It's just just things that are said to members of minority groups that act like the drip of water wearing away a stone. No ill intent but just a constant reminder of otherness. As Richard Osman said-nobody's been intending to make him feel different- but each individual forgets that they are one of 20 people who have said "Ooh, aren't you tall!" that day.

TempestTost · 19/03/2024 19:11

Ofcourseshecan · 19/03/2024 11:20

I think the concept of ‘micro aggressions’ is very dangerous. It encourages a sense of victimhood.

Someone looks at you the wrong way, or you think there’s something sneery in their tone, or they turned away when you were approaching them. Any of those could be completely innocent, or by someone who hadn’t even noticed you. But if you want to find fault, they’re micro aggressions.

It's also very often quite wrong.

People bring their own feelings to interactions with others, and can often project their own worries or past experiences into a situation. That person who supposedly is commiting a microaggression may well have some totally differernt set of motivations or thoughts or background that has nothing at all to do with what the supposed victim of the exchange thinks.

The reason I know this is because, like most people, I've experienced it hundreds of times, where I interpreted some interaction as being negative towards me, and only realized later it wasn't. In some cases, the other person's thoughts and feelings and intentions were almost the opposite of what I had thought.

Yes, some people may intend some kind of malice, but mostly they don't, and this focus on our own feelings in these things is usually not the best way forward and nine times out of ten is about our own feelings of inadequacy. The tenth time, it's just an asshole, almost always best dismissed.

It also creates a negative focus on what are often pretty normal interaction, that some people may just not like, and it's ultimately very damaging to normal communications. I knew a woman once who moved into a small town, and was upset people kept asking her who her parents were, because it made her feel like she wasn't accepted when she had to say they were from far away. She wanted people to be more accepting by not asking. It didn't seem to occur to her that maybe she should make people with the fact that she was from away, in a small town where most people could trace a connection, and that no one else minded except her.

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 19/03/2024 17:51

LancashireTart · 19/03/2024 11:06

This is the best post on the whole thread. 👏

Really curious to know what your agenda is here @LancashireTart
You seem very invested in the idea that people are over-sensitive, as if you just want to defend your right to sort of bulldoze your way through life without considering the feelings of other, potentially disadvantaged, groups. I’m sure it’s not that, but I don’t think you’ve really explained your viewpoint in much detail.

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 19/03/2024 13:38

Coincidentally, I heard Richard Osman talking today about how exhausting and belittling it feels to have people comment on his height the whole time, however well intentioned.. The constant reminder of being different, being a minority, and not quite fitting in.

CurlewKate · 19/03/2024 13:34

@WhatsTheUseOfWorrying I've been hunting for a definition of micro aggression I'm happy with- I think I like Derald Wing Sue's
"brief, everyday exchanges that send denigrating messages to certain individuals because of their group membership. The persons making the comments may be otherwise well-intentioned and unaware of the potential impact of their words."