Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be exasperated with posters who refer to ‘the terminally offended’?

312 replies

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 14/03/2024 21:11

Been lurking on a couple of threads recently and I just get so frustrated by posters who use these phrases:

”People are offended by EVERYTHING these days.”

”Snowflake”

”The terminally/permanently offended”

etc

It’s just so empty and pointless; you could equally have used these phrases against, say, people objecting to page three photos a few years ago (and, to be fair, some of these posters probably did).

People get so angry when prejudice is pointed out to them. You just know they’re aching to say “This is political correctness gone mad!” but they at least know that’s been discredited, so they pull out one of those other meaningless catchphrases.

AIBU to wish that people could actually articulate a reason that people shouldn’t be offended by insidious prejudice rather than just slinging pointless insults?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 20/03/2024 20:41

pikkumyy77 · 20/03/2024 18:28

Against stupidity the gods themselves contend in vain.

@BernardBlacksBreakfastWine is doing yeoman service here but there is no point engaging in a reasoned debate with LT. They either can’t grasp the issues on an intellectual level or they won’t grasp the issues because they can’t afford to lose the argument. So dear Bernard, don’t cast your pearls before LT.

I really have enjoyed getting to read the many thoughtful posts on this thread, though.

Thanks @pikkumyy77

The fact that she thinks she’s engaging but is just making silly little put-downs tells us a great deal.

Never mind 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
LancashireTart · 20/03/2024 18:35

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 20/03/2024 17:15

Yay! Knew you’d be back 😂

I get that you’re trying to be clever/condescending etc, but you’re single/handedly proving the exasperating nature of the “Oh you’re you’re permanently offended” crowd by not engaging.

That’s what’s exasperating! Not the fact that you don’t agree with everything I think has a measure of offence!

My very first post was about how exasperating it is when people don’t argue their case but just blurt out “snowflake” instead. That’s what you’re doing 🤷‍♀️

I’m very ready to admit that boundaries around what is deemed offensive shift according to era and perspective. I’m only asking that people engage with this and argue their point.

You, instead, state that there’s an accepted body of material that just IS offensive! And you don’t think that’s absurd?

You can carry on with the ad hominem attacks if it makes you feel better. But you’d do better in the actual discussion if you, you know, put forward an argument.

How am I not engaging? I've given you examples and I've explained how and why you're wrong. Yet you aren't engaging in the points I've made.

You're getting yourself in such a muddle to the point where you're not making any sense and making claims about me that are actually only relevant to yourself.

Perhaps you should have a break from Mumsnet for a while because it obviously isn't doing your coherency any good.

Love and hugs. 😘

pikkumyy77 · 20/03/2024 18:28

Against stupidity the gods themselves contend in vain.

@BernardBlacksBreakfastWine is doing yeoman service here but there is no point engaging in a reasoned debate with LT. They either can’t grasp the issues on an intellectual level or they won’t grasp the issues because they can’t afford to lose the argument. So dear Bernard, don’t cast your pearls before LT.

I really have enjoyed getting to read the many thoughtful posts on this thread, though.

Underthinker · 20/03/2024 17:50

Yeah I thought LT was just saying there are some things that we know are offensive without long drawn out debates (and presumably they also think there are also things that are grey areas and things that are clearly inoffensive).

I'm not wading back through to double check that though.

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 20/03/2024 17:29

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 15/03/2024 19:43

The thing is, we can have examples forever. It won’t really help.

Some things are offensive. Some are not, even by the most creative stretch of the imagination.

Many are in a sort of grey area.

So there will always be a level of disagreement about those categories. The people who are defending the term ‘permanently offended’ will find some things offensive (presumably!) so even they might be called ‘permanently offended’ if their boundary for ‘offensive’ is in a different place from someone else’s.

So we can’t really come to a conclusion on that unless we run through every single example of everything potentially offensive.

But my point was more that, in a disagreement over those ‘grey area’ examples, one of the most stupid, unintelligent things someone can say is “urghh - you’re permanently offended” - because it brings literally nothing to the discussion. It shows a lack of thinking, and I think if you’re going to usefully participate in a discussion about what is and isn’t acceptable or prejudiced, you should be prepared to use your brain.

Quoting myself here, but this is the post I was just referring to.

OP posts:
BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 20/03/2024 17:24

Underthinker · 20/03/2024 17:20

You, instead, state that there’s an accepted body of material that just IS offensive! And you don’t think that’s absurd?

I think there's a difference here between "a body of material that just is offensive", which implies we know exactly where the boundary lies and we can easily see what falls either side of that boundary, and the claim I believe LT is making that there are some things that are clearly within that boundary and everyone agrees are offensive.

Well, of course. With respect, I made this point many pages back. The existence of this key area of offensiveness on which everyone agrees sort of, logically, implies that there must be some grey areas around its edge? Unless it goes ‘inoffensive… inoffensive… inoffensive’ and then suddenly there’s a hard, undeniable boundary that marks where ‘offensive’ starts?
It's really the grey areas we’re discussing, surely?

OP posts:
Underthinker · 20/03/2024 17:20

You, instead, state that there’s an accepted body of material that just IS offensive! And you don’t think that’s absurd?

I think there's a difference here between "a body of material that just is offensive", which implies we know exactly where the boundary lies and we can easily see what falls either side of that boundary, and the claim I believe LT is making that there are some things that are clearly within that boundary and everyone agrees are offensive.

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 20/03/2024 17:15

LancashireTart · 20/03/2024 17:05

Are you seriously suggesting the majority of society doesn't know that blatant racism and sexism is offensive?! You really are the gift that keeps on giving. 😂

I know you're very easily offended but you really should calm down. You're getting yourself worked up about nothing (yet again) and it isn't good for your blood pressure.

Yay! Knew you’d be back 😂

I get that you’re trying to be clever/condescending etc, but you’re single/handedly proving the exasperating nature of the “Oh you’re you’re permanently offended” crowd by not engaging.

That’s what’s exasperating! Not the fact that you don’t agree with everything I think has a measure of offence!

My very first post was about how exasperating it is when people don’t argue their case but just blurt out “snowflake” instead. That’s what you’re doing 🤷‍♀️

I’m very ready to admit that boundaries around what is deemed offensive shift according to era and perspective. I’m only asking that people engage with this and argue their point.

You, instead, state that there’s an accepted body of material that just IS offensive! And you don’t think that’s absurd?

You can carry on with the ad hominem attacks if it makes you feel better. But you’d do better in the actual discussion if you, you know, put forward an argument.

OP posts:
LancashireTart · 20/03/2024 17:05

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 20/03/2024 16:23

@LancashireTart

The fact that you regard my opinion as absurd says more about you than anything else

Explain how it’s not absurd to assert that ‘society knows what’s offensive’ as if it’s an objective fact that everyone agrees with when this whole thread is predicated on the basis that there is disagreement about what is offensive and what isn’t !

That’s what’s absurd. I dare say you won’t respond because you don’t actually have an argument, so happy flouncing!

Are you seriously suggesting the majority of society doesn't know that blatant racism and sexism is offensive?! You really are the gift that keeps on giving. 😂

I know you're very easily offended but you really should calm down. You're getting yourself worked up about nothing (yet again) and it isn't good for your blood pressure.

FourLeggedBuckers · 20/03/2024 17:03

Societal views about what is (and isn’t) offensive are constantly changing though. Different sectors of society will have different ideas about what is “obviously” offensive and what is debatable. It is through conversation, debate and argument that ideas about what is acceptable become mainstream. It isn’t so long ago that racial or homophobic slurs were in common usage, and were widely accepted (despite the offence to those they were aimed at). Those who took offence at, or just called out, that sort of behaviour were also once in a minority. (And, for balance, there are also examples the other way of things once seen as offensive, now accepted.)

To suggest there is a hard and fast rule, from which those who deviate are “just looking for offence” is absurd. And to dismiss the OP as looking for negativity, depressing others and like a flat earther, is both inaccurate and unnecessary.

Underthinker · 20/03/2024 16:51

I think that's a bit harsh.
There are some things that no one disputes are offensive. There are some things that very few people think are offensive.
With the "minor" offences like the CP advert, no matter how many pages of MN we debate them for, they're never going to be in the same category as shouting racist abuse in the street. I'm happy to debate stuff endlessly (clearly) but I'm not surprised or concerned that many people will just say "this is BS I'm out".

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 20/03/2024 16:23

@LancashireTart

The fact that you regard my opinion as absurd says more about you than anything else

Explain how it’s not absurd to assert that ‘society knows what’s offensive’ as if it’s an objective fact that everyone agrees with when this whole thread is predicated on the basis that there is disagreement about what is offensive and what isn’t !

That’s what’s absurd. I dare say you won’t respond because you don’t actually have an argument, so happy flouncing!

OP posts:
LancashireTart · 20/03/2024 15:27

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 20/03/2024 14:55

It’s interesting that you throw a little wobbly when people reveal the absurdity of your position.

I’m intrigued by the way you refer to the rest of us too, as if anyone else in the thread has been as intractable and unresponsive to actual arguments as you! Others have certainly disagreed with me, but they’ve tended to use reason…

"The absurdity of your position."

The fact that you regard my opinion as absurd says more about you than anything else and only serves to confirm what I've been saying all along.

And, by the way, I've given my reasoning further up the thread.

Anyway, I really am getting bored now. No offence!

Please try to enjoy life more, wasting so much of your energy looking for offence in everything every day is futile. 😘

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 20/03/2024 14:55

LancashireTart · 20/03/2024 14:49

I'll tell you what, you carry on with your offended life and looking for oppression in everything but please keep your negativity to yourself, you're depressing the rest of us.

It's like debating with a flat Earther.

It’s interesting that you throw a little wobbly when people reveal the absurdity of your position.

I’m intrigued by the way you refer to the rest of us too, as if anyone else in the thread has been as intractable and unresponsive to actual arguments as you! Others have certainly disagreed with me, but they’ve tended to use reason…

OP posts:
LancashireTart · 20/03/2024 14:49

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 20/03/2024 14:19

@LancashireTart

Society knows what is considered offensive (racism, sexism, for example). It's obvious from this thread alone that there are people who try to find offence where there isn't any.

You are joking? You think there’s an accepted canon of stuff that objectively Is Offensive ?? And does this pre-approved body of material mysteriously coincide with what you personally find offensive? Wow! What a fascinating coincidence! 😂

I'll tell you what, you carry on with your offended life and looking for oppression in everything but please keep your negativity to yourself, you're depressing the rest of us.

It's like debating with a flat Earther.

Underthinker · 20/03/2024 14:46

@BernardBlacksBreakfastWine
OK, but I would have said the analogy would be more like - if you're a teacher who is known to say "stop yelling" every time someone whispers in class, then when you tell a colleague that you gave a kid detention for shouting, they may not believe or support you.

I do see the sense in your analogy too however.

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 20/03/2024 14:22

Underthinker · 20/03/2024 13:09

Is there a risk that, when claiming something is offensive that relatively few people see a problem with (such as the CP ad) you undermine efforts to tackle things that more people found offensive/unhelpful (e.g. the bikini car ad).

Is there a "crying wolf" effect here?

So people who could have been persuaded that the bikini car ads were an issue dismiss your argument because your credibility is diminished by also believing that many seemingly innocuous things are also a problem.

I can sort of see your logic here but, no, I don’t believe that’s how it goes.

Zero tolerance gets results.

If I’m a teacher and I object to low-level distraction in class, although it’s only someone whispering to the next person about the work in hand, is my credibility damaged when I try to correct the big stuff, like swearing and fighting? No. It’s the opposite.

OP posts:
BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 20/03/2024 14:19

@LancashireTart

Society knows what is considered offensive (racism, sexism, for example). It's obvious from this thread alone that there are people who try to find offence where there isn't any.

You are joking? You think there’s an accepted canon of stuff that objectively Is Offensive ?? And does this pre-approved body of material mysteriously coincide with what you personally find offensive? Wow! What a fascinating coincidence! 😂

OP posts:
Underthinker · 20/03/2024 13:13

@WhatsTheUseOfWorrying The colour example was not mine. And I don’t understand it.

That was mine, I just meant if someone thought all colours were red, you wouldn't trust their opinion on colour, and if someone thought almost everything was offensive you wouldn't trust their opinion on what was offensive.

Underthinker · 20/03/2024 13:09

Is there a risk that, when claiming something is offensive that relatively few people see a problem with (such as the CP ad) you undermine efforts to tackle things that more people found offensive/unhelpful (e.g. the bikini car ad).

Is there a "crying wolf" effect here?

So people who could have been persuaded that the bikini car ads were an issue dismiss your argument because your credibility is diminished by also believing that many seemingly innocuous things are also a problem.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 20/03/2024 13:07

I don’t disagree about the emotional basis of offence. But offence is expressed (when it’s expressed) in words and actions. That’s how observers know when people are offended.

If someone wrote to CP and said “I object to your ad because the mum is depicted as physically inferior”, CP could quite reasonably write back saying “We do regret the offence you felt at the ad, but…”

Anyway, I’ll leave it there.

FourLeggedBuckers · 20/03/2024 12:59

It really isn’t what the word means. Offence is an emotional response, by definition. You don’t get to decide if I’m having an emotional response to an advert or not - only I can judge that.

You seem very keen to tell people they feel, or how they should feel, about things.

You say I am over-sensitive, because I am “offended” by an advert (which I am not), because you do not seem able, in this context, to conceive that it is possible to have a different opinion to you, without it being a personal fault.

I don’t think you’re wrong to be offended by the hypothetical car spares advert, or not by the CP advert - even though I disagree with your interpretations or the importance you place on different aspects of each advert.

I do think you are wrong to tell other people they are “over-sensitive” for having different opinions to you.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 20/03/2024 12:47

I’m not projecting offence on to you. I’m saying that’s what the word means. Whether you reject the word for what you feel is your business. It’s still offence.

You don’t object to the CP ad because it’s ugly or clutters up your screen. You object to the message you say it conveys and its effect.

I really don’t get this ‘what gives you the right?’ stuff. Does everyone have to accept the opinions and motives of others? Is everyone required to accept expressions of offence however vehemently expressed, however contrived or however persistent?

The issue ultimately is how many people take your side. I bet more would be offended by the hypothetical car spares ad than the CP ad, for lots of reasons.

As to “permanently offended”, I said upthread - more than once - that I dislike ‘snowflake’ and the like.

If you read back, my point was the, IMO, unjustified outrage at the ad on the original thread, for which the OP said CP should be “ashamed”. Yes, I’ll happily say that’s oversensitivity.

LancashireTart · 20/03/2024 12:28

CurlewKate · 20/03/2024 12:05

@LancashireTart "It's obvious from this thread alone that there are people who try to find offence where there isn't any."

I disagree. (Well, I would, wouldn't I?) I think that we need to distinguish between "offensive", which the CP advertisement isn't, and mildly misogynist, which it is. Anything which perpetuates a stereotype of women as weak or incompetent or figures of fun is at least mildly misogynist and just better not part of our discourse. There are plenty of other narratives to use.

You've just proved my point, entirely.

The CP advert isn't remotely misogynistic. You have literally taken a completely innocent, innocuous comment from an obviously excited child and twisted it to suit your mindset.

FourLeggedBuckers · 20/03/2024 12:17

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 20/03/2024 12:08

I’ve never said people don’t have a right to be offended by an ad or anything else. I’m not religious but I can easily understand why those who are religious get offended by jokes or slights about their faith, for example.

People equally do have a right to say that offence expressed is because of over-sensitivity, or its cause completely eludes them.

The point I made was that you can’t duck out of whether you’re properly described as being offended by the CP as simply by moving the goalposts on what the word means.

The colour example was not mine. And I don’t understand it.

Edited

My point is that if you are offended by the car spares ad, and someone else is not, but is offended by the CP ad - what gives you the right to call them over-sensitive, but not the reverse? Why is your definition of what’s offensive the only correct one? Or are you happy to be called permanently offended, or over-sensitive, for your views on the hypothetical car spares ad?

There is a huge difference between saying “I don’t believe there is anything offensive in that advert” and “you’re one of the permanently offended”. The former is a valid expression of your opinion. The latter is a lazy dismissal of the other person’s opinion.

I’m not moving any goal posts 🙄 You don’t get to project offence onto me - that’s batshit. I’m not offended by it - it is entirely possible to think something is a bit rubbish without being offended by it.

If your definition of offence is that broad (and inaccurate), I’m not surprised you think a lot of people are permanently offended.