Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Two kids looks harder than one, but is it?

137 replies

oneortwokids · 14/03/2024 20:15

Mulling this over with DH.

Everyone we know with two (especially if both parents work FT) is stressed to the max with hardly any time for themselves or their spouse and these are the people we hear complaining the most. However, I suppose you can’t take away from the fact the two children have each other forever and that is a really valuable thing.

On paper one looks easier. More energy, for yourself and them. More time to yourself, for work or personal reasons. More time to spend with DH. But, the biggest reason being, the cost of one is so much more manageable. The cost of living is so expensive, I don’t think we could provide the same for a second without compromise and less experiences and fun stuff for the three of us. I always imagined having lots of children - I’m really maternal and I just love babies. Babies grow up though and my biggest desire is to provide any support DC needs until and beyond them being an adult. We’d adapt no doubt to a larger family, but not be able to give them the same. And I’m not talking about private school and hefty deposits, I’m talking about affording to help with driving lessons, uni accommodation, pay childcare and such.

I thought I would ask on here. Parents of older kids, younger kids, objectively would one have been ‘easier’ or ‘harder’ for you? If this was your choice are you glad?

OP posts:
Mum2jenny · 14/03/2024 21:08

For me it didn’t really matter. I found there were pluses and minuses with 2 over 1. Wouldn’t have changed my approach even now as they are both over 18 now

LameBorzoi · 14/03/2024 21:07

I found two much easier than one. I don't mind the logistics, but both my kids want full on non stop social interaction. Even from babyhood, they provided that for each other.

SummerSazz · 14/03/2024 21:07

I had less than 2 years with only one, only a year before pregnant so don't really remember it!! Love two now they are 17 and 15.
Being close in age we've had it easier with similar interests, only one school year apart so from 3-17 I've only had one year in different schools (so much easier for logistics!)
They bounce off each other, argue sometimes, and dance round the kitchen with each other which is just fab

Backintothewoods · 14/03/2024 21:06

It’s harder with two in a way but I found it easier going from 1-2 than from 0-1.

I do find it hard never having a moment to myself but it’s not forever. I feel a bit bad for Ds as my DD is quite needy at the moment. But I cook for one I cook for two, I’m going to a group, both get dragged along, it’s fine. I love DD so much, I am so so glad I had her. I did hesitate about trying for a second because of my age but I’m so glad I did.

minipie · 14/03/2024 21:06

For us, going from 0-1 was so flipping hard that 1-2 felt pretty straightforward. Our second is also a much easier child.

Having said that, it would still be a lot easier with one child, even though our eldest generates 80% of the stress. Just avoiding the squabbling would be a lot easier in itself. And then there’s the competing demands on time, different interests, trying to make sure things are “equal” as regards playdates and presents and activities… did I mention the squabbling??

Concestor · 14/03/2024 21:05

We are an ND household and have two kids, five year age gap and different sexes. They don't do anything together, seemingly dislike each other, and it's hard work.

I love them but I wish I had stopped at one. Life would be so much less stressful. I can't see it getting easier to one of them leaves home, and that will be years. It's quite depressing to be honest. It makes me so sad that they don't get on at all.

Mintearo7 · 14/03/2024 21:04

Harder with two but not twice as hard. But I think circumstances dictate this -DH will automatically deal with one while I’m dealing with the other, we both work from home, eldest is a great sleeper, we can afford childcare. Also lucky that they mostly get on.

NCJD · 14/03/2024 21:04

I found the jump from 0-1 DC much harder than the jump from 1-2.

But practically and physically, 2 is much harder than 1, despite my youngest being a very easy child. DH and I both work 4 days per week. I have no idea how working parents manage with more than 2 children unless they have a nanny or lots of grandparent help

Katela18 · 14/03/2024 21:03

I actually found the transition from 1-2 harder than from 0-1!

I think two is really hard. Mine are 4 and nearly 2.

It's expensive (both in nursery), and we never get time for ourselves or as a couple.

Mine are also very different personalities / needs too which also adds to the difficulty.

DreadPirateRobots · 14/03/2024 21:02

The one thing I ABSOLUTELY HATE with two is both of them going "mummy mummy mummy" to me over each other at the same time. It makes me want to scream.

On the other hand, last night I caught them after bedtime curled up in the same armchair while the big one read to the small one because the small one was scared. 😍

GettingStuffed · 14/03/2024 21:02

It depends on the child, my DS2 was a really easy child, if exhausting, so it definitely wasn't twice the work and the third didn't really make a difference

Flippingflamingo · 14/03/2024 21:02

2 kids are at least 5 times harder than one!

Between my 2 I have 8 different activities to get them separately to. And they fight, constantly!

MrsFarmerTom · 14/03/2024 21:00

Mine are 4.5 and 1.5.

Things that (IME) are harder with two:
Managing when they both need something from you at the same time.
Never being able to give your second child the same attention that you gave your first - and the guilt that comes with that.
Childcare is so expensive 😫
So little time to yourself
Childcare is so expensive!
If the elder one isn't a good sleeper it can be hard to juggle all the night wakings.
If there's a whiff of neurodivergence about you, the noise and chaos and overstumulation of two can be overwhelming / rage-inducing.
The bickering (and mine actually get on relatively well, but stil, the bickering when it happens is infuriating).
Did I mention the cost of childcare?? 😭
Trying to get them both in bed and asleep, especially if there are nights when only one parent is there.
Finding ways to engage with them both at the same time, if they have very different interests/abilities.

Things that are better with two:
Twice as many cuddles
When they play together, or make each other laugh
When the eldest gently helps the younger one with something
When they comfort each other
When they entertain each other and you can catch a break

I'm currently in bed with one child wedged up against either side of me, and I wouldn't change my life for the world.

DreadPirateRobots · 14/03/2024 20:59

Two was way harder in the early days. Newborn plus toddler pretty much brought us to our knees.

However, since the small one turned 3 or so, two is less work since they spend so much time playing together. I actually kind of dread DH going off and doing something solo with the older one because the small one is so mopey, demanding and high-maintenance when they're without their sibling for a bit. However, if we'd only ever had 1 that wouldn't have been an issue.

FrenchFairytale · 14/03/2024 20:58

Mine is now 6. I could not go back. I was also a single parent doing 80 PC custody. My 1 is quite easy now but I don't feel like a natural parent. I think 2 would kill me off.

TeaPleaseX · 14/03/2024 20:57

I have four soon to be five and I found it harder with just one. Not sure why to be honest just felt like some thing was missing.
but I love having a lot of them.
They are all quite bonded and do things together. I find days out more fun with a group rather than just one.
I think the stressful parts of it all for me is the school runs as they go to 3 different schools. As two have Sen needs and ones only 4 so still part time. Other than that it's great.
I have 8,7,4,1 and then it'll newborn.

freespirit333 · 14/03/2024 20:56

One is so much easier! But I don’t think it’s possible to realise that until you have two.

I have two DC, one is definitely ND. But if we only had him, not his sibling too, my god our lives would be easy. He wouldn’t argue with anyone at home (well, except DP and I!), he’s just very very easy when he’s on his own. My other DC is hard work generally (deeply feeling!) but again, on his own, so easy!

thesugarbumfairy · 14/03/2024 20:56

There are no crystal balls unfortunately. DC1 was a difficult child and resented his sibling from day 1, so they have never 'played together'.
DC2 has a very different personality and has always been easier to parent.

From my point of view it was hard work raising one and harder raising two. There was no way I would have had more.

ColleenDonaghy · 14/03/2024 20:54

Someone once told me that one is one, but two is twenty, and there's a lot of truth in that.

Ours are 5 and 3, eldest has a couple of friends without siblings and the parents can carve out so much more alone time. Easier to just work around one set of needs too. Not to mention the squabbling. Jesus Christ the squabbling.

I wouldn't change it though. Our youngest is our little ray of sunshine, and second time round you have more perspective that everything is a phase. They mostly play nicely together and that is the loveliest thing in the world.

MeanLeanRunnerbean · 14/03/2024 20:54

In the short term 1-2 was a big adjustment and of course harder as juggling a baby and a toddler was more complicated than just focussing all my attention on one. Once they turned 1&2 it was easier than having one child (I imagine) as they palled along together and still very much do as pre teens, so definitely an investment! On the other hand adding in the next one wasn't much bother, probably as I was more experienced/had lower standards but now the 3rd is a bit out on their own and not tight like the older 2 (slightly larger age gap though there is only a 4 year age gap between the 1st & 3rd) so I imagine ease depends a great deal on how the kids get along.

MiddleParking · 14/03/2024 20:54

No one really goes into it for ease or affordability though, do they? Otherwise we’d all have none. Of course I recognise that sticking at one would have been easier and cheaper, having none even more so. Doesn’t mean having two wasn’t my preference and exactly the right choice.

Abitlosttoday · 14/03/2024 20:53

Likemyjealouseel · 14/03/2024 20:32

Easier with two from about 4 or 5. I know a lot of people with one child and they spend a lot of effort entertaining them or seeking out opportunities for them to be with other kids. Mine play together all day at the weekend.

Yes, this is my experience. Mine are 6 and 4 and play together nicely (sometimes). When they were 3 and 1 and I was losing my MIND. A friend with just a 6 year old found early years easier -two parents to one toddler. Now, her child is bored and needs lots of interaction. Although, my friend only has half the child life-admin that I do.

TDIAP · 14/03/2024 20:50

Easier with one. Before I had 2 I thought I was a natural born mother 😂, 2 was a shock to the system and is by far harder. Although they have each other the arguments they have with each other can be awful. On the very rare occasion I have just one with me (it doesn’t matter which one), it feels so much easier to manage and is how I remember parenting being when I just had one! Those were the days! I love them both equally though and wouldn’t be without them now.

flashmcdoodle · 14/03/2024 20:50

There is an expression; the difference between 1child & 2 is like the difference between a pet and a zoo.

I agree with this and I have 4. The change from 1 to 2 was harder. After 2 you have submit 😭

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 14/03/2024 20:50

Find 2 easier now they are at an age they play together- leaves me a lot of time to crack on with chores rather than feeling guilty leaving one alone.