Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Two kids looks harder than one, but is it?

137 replies

oneortwokids · 14/03/2024 20:15

Mulling this over with DH.

Everyone we know with two (especially if both parents work FT) is stressed to the max with hardly any time for themselves or their spouse and these are the people we hear complaining the most. However, I suppose you can’t take away from the fact the two children have each other forever and that is a really valuable thing.

On paper one looks easier. More energy, for yourself and them. More time to yourself, for work or personal reasons. More time to spend with DH. But, the biggest reason being, the cost of one is so much more manageable. The cost of living is so expensive, I don’t think we could provide the same for a second without compromise and less experiences and fun stuff for the three of us. I always imagined having lots of children - I’m really maternal and I just love babies. Babies grow up though and my biggest desire is to provide any support DC needs until and beyond them being an adult. We’d adapt no doubt to a larger family, but not be able to give them the same. And I’m not talking about private school and hefty deposits, I’m talking about affording to help with driving lessons, uni accommodation, pay childcare and such.

I thought I would ask on here. Parents of older kids, younger kids, objectively would one have been ‘easier’ or ‘harder’ for you? If this was your choice are you glad?

OP posts:
mitogoshi · 14/03/2024 22:18

2 mean they can play together.

Dd1 has add and now they are adults Dd2 if pretty helpful including dishing out tough love. But every family is different.

jelliebelly · 14/03/2024 22:15

Definitely easier with one but if you wanted an easy life you’d wouldn’t have any! I have 2 older teens and I love the somewhat chaotic family interaction which their friends without siblings just don’t have.

iverpickle · 14/03/2024 22:05

2 is harder than 1, no question.
I'd have never ever had just 1 by choice, but that's because I am close to my siblings and have raised my children to be close, and they are and always have been.

Although I think the relationship between only child and parent can be really close and beautiful and obviously the financial benefits are clear, I'd personally rather gift my children the chance of a lifelong relationship with each other, which is priceless.
I know not all siblings get on, and it's not a certainty, but I'd always choose the possibility for them to have that chance, rather than the impossibility.

elliejjtiny · 14/03/2024 22:04

I have 5, all with SEN. I had awful pnd with my first so having 1 didn't seem that easy. I remember thinking that I was responsible for this tiny human and if I got it wrong he would be scarred for life. I remember asking the health visitor every time I saw her if I was dressing him in the right clothes because I was always worrying that he was too hot or too cold. He also liked to feed a lot so I have find memories of watching endless box sets while feeding him on the sofa.

Dc2 was born when dc1 was a toddler. There were some lovely times but also the hardest times. Dc1 was displaying autistic traits but all the professionals said he didn't have it (he was later diagnosed aged 9). I really struggled to manage dc1's behaviour and there was no support available. I couldn't even look up how to manage autistic behaviour and how to handle it on the internet because the professionals all said that he wasn't and I thought they must be right. Dc1 was poorly too and I really struggled in that first year and a half. The bright side was the bond between dc1 and dc2. Dc1 always involved Dc2 in his play. There was often plastic food etc on dc2's play mat and in his moses basket that dc1 had given to newborn Dc2 with a request to help with the pretend cooking. Dc1 would take them back with a "thank you for peeling the potatoes" or whatever it was he'd ask dc2 to do.

Dc3 was born when dc1 was 4 and dc2 was nearly 3. It was probably the easiest transition, although I found it hard to get us all out of the house in time for school. Dc3 always wanted to feed or poo when we were supposed to be leaving the house.

Dc4 was born 2.5 years later and Dc5 12 months after that. They mostly just slotted in although dc4 spent a lot of time in hospital and doing that with a baby as well was hard.

Tintackedsea · 14/03/2024 21:56

Ach, I suppose it was harder when they were really wee. I had 3 in under 4 years so there was an intense period of breastfeeding and nappies and weaning. It's tons easier now though. They're a team and I don't need to entertain them much because they have each other. The kid next door spends a lot of time here because he's an only child and I think he's quite bored. During the lockdowns it was a wee shame for him.

PumpkinPie2016 · 14/03/2024 21:50

We only have 1 (he is 10 - he is definitely an only!). Part of the reason we didn't have another was because we felt we couldn't stretch to two in so many ways. Time and money being big ones.

I absolutely love having one and don't regret my decision at all.

I can imagine, looking at others with 2+ children, that it is a lot more work than having one.

thecatsthecats · 14/03/2024 21:48

Lots of people commenting here from the perspective of having a second soon after.

The only friend I have who makes having a second look appealing had hers four years apart. The eldest can manage bedtime partially herself, handle waiting for the baby to be sorted, and generally is more of a help than a hindrance.

Whereas five minutes with my friends with two under two makes my eyes bleed.

If we make the leap, it will be with a minimum three year gap.

ChampagneSuperDrinker · 14/03/2024 21:45

When the youngest was a baby it was easy. Now at 2.5 & 4.5 it's really tough, it's just constant fighting, jealousy and bickering. Wayyyy more than double the work, on their own they're both mostly easy children. I am starting to see snippets of them playing together so I'm hoping things will improve and long term it will be easier.

heartbroken22 · 14/03/2024 21:41

I've found it easier with three 🤣

Tisfortired · 14/03/2024 21:40

I’ve not found 2 that much more difficult but we have a big age gap (10 and 1.) Bigger than we wanted, but we only felt mentally ready for another when he started school. Unfortunately we had some difficulties along the way.

But the eldest is able to look after himself to an extent and is also a help with the baby sometimes. I think having two who are entirely dependent on you would be so difficult and I know myself and my own limits I personally would really struggle with that. One of my best friends is about to have her second and her first is 18 months, I’m scared on her behalf!

Alalalalalongalalalalalonglonglilong · 14/03/2024 21:38

This 100% depends on the child. I found having an only child for almost 6 years considerably harder than having premature twins. DS1 was an incredibly difficult baby and toddler, the others were normal enough, we had bad phases and some problems but all average infant stuff. Breastfeeding two and getting two down for naps was so hard but nothing like their hyper active insomniac brother. So it's all relative.

Oohooh · 14/03/2024 21:37

Supertayto · 14/03/2024 20:26

Easier with one. I look back on how stressful I found having one and just think ‘twat’. I am in the trenches of them both being little though.

Same. 4 and 1 year olds here and it’s been MORE than twice the work. You can’t leave them alone together (rough or overly excitable play), 2 lots of every task, conflicting pick up times for school/nursery, when the youngest wakes at night he wakes up his sister who then also wants attention, getting them both out the door is a nightmare… I feel a bit lied to tbh; everyone was all ‘oh it’s so much easier, you know what you’re doing blah blah’. Nope.

MummySam2017 · 14/03/2024 21:31

MummySam2017 · 14/03/2024 21:28

I think ‘twat’ when I look back at not savouring the newborn stage enough. Sitting on my couch, breastfeeding and watching Netflix. More of that please!

OP, I found the transition really tough, but as they get older, I think it has a lot of perks. They both always have someone to play with, when they laugh together it’s honestly the best feeling ever…. Actually, that’s all I’ve got. It’s hard 😕….

….But worth it 😙. I’d do it a million times over.

Sorry, I was actually supposed to quote @Supertayto’s post lol.

MummySam2017 · 14/03/2024 21:28

paristotokyo · 14/03/2024 20:27

Definitely easier with one. We have two now and I sometimes reminisce how much easier we had it then! Not that I'd change it now.. but it was easier for sure.

I think ‘twat’ when I look back at not savouring the newborn stage enough. Sitting on my couch, breastfeeding and watching Netflix. More of that please!

OP, I found the transition really tough, but as they get older, I think it has a lot of perks. They both always have someone to play with, when they laugh together it’s honestly the best feeling ever…. Actually, that’s all I’ve got. It’s hard 😕….

….But worth it 😙. I’d do it a million times over.

RosePetals86 · 14/03/2024 21:21

One is one, two is twenty… or so it feels some days! No doubt one is easier but like you say, as they get older they have one another. No regrets having two but definitely think I’m done!

Londonrach1 · 14/03/2024 21:20

Yes judging by friends.. easier when their babies or toddlers.. school age they fight fight fight..but worse than having three ..but I'm sure amazing when they grow ups... honestly op if you want another have one for you and dh..

Xanders · 14/03/2024 21:18

I have three dc. Two (even less than 3 years apart) was an absolute breeze. Yet my third dc broke me lol. Don’t get me wrong he’s funny and amazing young man now that’s he’s grown up (pre teen) but from the ages of 2-10 he was hard work. Two kids under the age of 3 was a walk in the park in comparison lol.

Crazycatlady79 · 14/03/2024 21:16

I have twin girls, now 6. Bit different in that I've raised them alone (left the Father when they were 5 months, although our marriage was clearly over during the early stages of pregnancy!) and both have SEN and complex needs.
The first few years felt like absolute hell and passed in a blur. Had no one to one time with either until they were 5.
During the past few months, things have got SO much better and I love being a parent these days (always loved them, just not always been in love with parenting) and I am SO glad I had 2.

Jesusmaryjosephandtheweedon · 14/03/2024 21:15

Of course two is harder than one. You have double the workload, double the attention, you can't divide and conquer, one do bed time while other tidies up as then who puts no. 2 to bed.

I have 3 dd's lots of hard work, lots of running about, you have to completely take a back seat for a few years but I wouldn't change it.

ShiftySquirrel · 14/03/2024 21:14

0-1 was definitely harder and a huge shock compared to 1-2 for me.

In terms of on going effort 1 child is always going to be easier.
Mine were under 18 months apart so the preschool years were a blur, most stages over fairly swiftly.

The DC always have someone to play and argue with that's not just you. And there's already lots of the clothes, baby equipment and toys so little need to buy much else.

I don't regret having two DC ever. Mine are both teens now, and we still have the most expensive years ahead but I couldn't imagine it any other way.

Calamitousness · 14/03/2024 21:14

I found going from zero to one incredibly tough. Going from one to two was super easy and actually a really lovely time in our lives. No more loss of my previous life. I’d mourned that with no. 1 so it was just full of love. I’d have had another if I hadn’t been sterilised during elective section.

dottypencilcase · 14/03/2024 21:10

DreadPirateRobots · 14/03/2024 21:02

The one thing I ABSOLUTELY HATE with two is both of them going "mummy mummy mummy" to me over each other at the same time. It makes me want to scream.

On the other hand, last night I caught them after bedtime curled up in the same armchair while the big one read to the small one because the small one was scared. 😍

Omg- the "mummmmmmy" on loop! And the "look at this"for every. Single. Bloody. Thing.

midtownmum · 14/03/2024 21:10

Two is harder but worth it because they love each other when not trying to kill each other and I'm so glad I didn't miss out on having DD. She's my younger one and she's just a joy. Mostly. When she's not intentionally winding up her brother. I think it's just about how you see your family, really. I wanted two, it's harder, took longer to get through the tunnel, but I'm so glad we did it.

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 14/03/2024 21:09

If I could go back I wouldn't have any at all.
I have two and it is soooo hard!

dottypencilcase · 14/03/2024 21:08

15 month difference between mine- I'm much poorer, knackered, overstimulated by the noise and fed up of breaking up fights, etc. but I wouldn't change a thing- both DC have complete opposite personalities and bring so much joy to my life (mostly)!