Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Two kids looks harder than one, but is it?

137 replies

oneortwokids · 14/03/2024 20:15

Mulling this over with DH.

Everyone we know with two (especially if both parents work FT) is stressed to the max with hardly any time for themselves or their spouse and these are the people we hear complaining the most. However, I suppose you can’t take away from the fact the two children have each other forever and that is a really valuable thing.

On paper one looks easier. More energy, for yourself and them. More time to yourself, for work or personal reasons. More time to spend with DH. But, the biggest reason being, the cost of one is so much more manageable. The cost of living is so expensive, I don’t think we could provide the same for a second without compromise and less experiences and fun stuff for the three of us. I always imagined having lots of children - I’m really maternal and I just love babies. Babies grow up though and my biggest desire is to provide any support DC needs until and beyond them being an adult. We’d adapt no doubt to a larger family, but not be able to give them the same. And I’m not talking about private school and hefty deposits, I’m talking about affording to help with driving lessons, uni accommodation, pay childcare and such.

I thought I would ask on here. Parents of older kids, younger kids, objectively would one have been ‘easier’ or ‘harder’ for you? If this was your choice are you glad?

OP posts:
HighCortisolIsMyName · 15/03/2024 06:25

Supertayto · 14/03/2024 20:26

Easier with one. I look back on how stressful I found having one and just think ‘twat’. I am in the trenches of them both being little though.

Same 🤣 but mine are a little older now ( 7 and 9 ) When they were younger I used to ask myself why I had done this 😂

When their really dependent on you it is really difficult with more than 1. Especially if their both dependant on you. But, as they get older it really does get a lot easier

DuskyEvenings · 15/03/2024 06:20

FAR EASIER with TWO! But I was lucky. They adored each other until they hit 11ish.

WithACatLikeTread · 15/03/2024 06:16

Harder because you are pulled in two different directions. Easier if you can have a bigger gap though. We have nearly five years between them.

WithACatLikeTread · 15/03/2024 06:15

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previously banned poster.

So?

Zanatdy · 15/03/2024 01:47

I have 3 children but manageable age gaps. But that doesn’t affect overall cost

32degrees · 15/03/2024 01:38

Easier with two once the smaller one can play.

So easy I went for a third.

Louisevuitton · 15/03/2024 01:32

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previously banned poster.

elliejjtiny · 15/03/2024 00:24

A 5 year age gap can be quite emotional as you are pregnant when eldest starts school and then you have eldest leaving secondary school when youngest leaves primary. I managed to do this twice, once with dc1 and dc3 and again with dc2 and dc4.

BelindaOkra · 14/03/2024 23:38

Easier with 1. I have 3 - every additional child made things harder 😂

cherish123 · 14/03/2024 23:36

Age/stage is more the issue. Teenage years much more tiring/emotionally demanding. The easiest years were preschool and then early primary.

cherish123 · 14/03/2024 23:34

No. No different with two.

WhatWouldTheDoctorDo · 14/03/2024 23:33

We have one. Not by choice, and my views on it have changed over the years.

Much easier in the baby/toddler years. Which is why I put off a second. Turns out I left it too late, but I don't think I'd have coped with two.

Primary school years were tough. I had pangs of envy for those that had two or more, the sibling bond, playing with each other etc. We had to work harder at play dates and encouraging friendships. DS struggled with friendships, but I think that was down to a range of factors, not being an only child. I did find other people's children quite stressful though - noisier and more chaotic than our lives.

Teen years - having one is a dream. Easier to fund great experiences and holidays (DS is well travelled in a way we couldn't have afforded with more), we can give him the attention he needs during the exam years, and looking to the future we can more easily afford support at uni etc. We have our life back in way that would be a few years off if we had more - don't need to worry about babysitters and have raised an independent child that can happily entertain himself.

I worry about him in the future, when we're old (if we're lucky) and what that might mean for him going through those years without a sibling.

On balance, we have a nice life as three. Financially it has been much easier, we have great holidays, have a close bond.

Do I wish I'd had more? Sometimes. Is my life easier because I didn't? Most of the time. What has been MUCH easier with one is my career. I was retraining when I was pregnant with DS. I'm now in a very senior role in my company, I don't think I could have risen through the ranks in the same way with more. Not because of sexism or discrimination, I just wouldn't have had the bandwidth. And that career advancement significantly contributes to the nice life we have, and with a bit of luck and good health, my retirement.

Sorry, that is much longer than I intended!

mondaytosunday · 14/03/2024 23:31

Are you kidding? In what world is two easier than one?
Twice the amount of work, twice the cost of childcare, twice the ferrying to this sport and that activity, twice the laundry, and when older twice the heartache/alcohol/partying/grade worries/friendship trauma/uni costs...
Plus the kids themselves may not get along. They might not be interested in the same things. They might not even go to the same schools.

CountryMumof4 · 14/03/2024 23:29

2 is definitely harder than 1 - BUT they become lovely companions as they get older. I have 4... But I do have a big age gap between the 1st and 2nd (9 years). While it is expensive and stressful at times, watching them so happy together makes it absolutely worth it. We just pull together and make it work. Do what's best for you though. I have lots of friends with one child and they're lovely, happy kids.

MermaidGin · 14/03/2024 23:21

Of course one is easier!

jennemin · 14/03/2024 23:14

I have 2 with a 3 year gap and I'm definitely finding it harder and more limiting with 2. Our parenting style has always been geared to entertaining the dc, so having them entertain each other to make less work for us doesn't appeal. But it means that the places we take them are limited because of age restrictions/suitability, or DH and I end up taking one child each so I don't end up spending much time with one of the dcs sometimes. I miss having more one to one time with my eldest in particular (but I get lots of one to one time with the youngest while eldest is in school). I don't find it hard work to entertain my dc and I enjoy it, but I work better focused on one child (or 2 parents with one child, which we did when we just had one).

Sometimes I've felt bad for having to limit extracurriculars for the the eldest because it's a hassle to bring along the toddler as well, whereas her friends who are onlies can be ferried around with no issues. There are things she misses out on or we only do activities on her school site so I don't have to ferry her about. And keeping up with primary school duties (spellings, music practice, homework etc) is harder work with a toddler to deal with. Hard to do other focused activities like detailed Lego or crafts with a whirlwind toddler. I expect it will be easier when the toddler gets older, but then they'll be at school and we'll have 2 lots of after school clubs and homework to deal with. I'm sure the exam years would be easier with just one dc as well.

BridieLand · 14/03/2024 23:04

I think having one is the best compromise between being childfree and having kids, in that it's a lot easier for each parent to get alone time, and generally there is less admin and chores needing done.

1984Winston · 14/03/2024 22:57

I think everyone will have a different answer, for me going from 0-1 was horrendous, going into having 1-2 was absolutely fine, I knew what I was doing by then. Did have a 4 year gap between them though

pambeesleyhalpert · 14/03/2024 22:48

MamaBearHealer · 14/03/2024 20:43

My 2year old sons toys seem to have taken over and although my 5 year old daughter still enjoys playing with some of them I would like to find a toy she could have and use for herself. She’s very Hypo-sensory and generally gravitates towards more physical play or ‘messy play’ activities but does also enjoy playing with kitchens, play food and soft toys. Any suggestions would be appreciated.

Have a look at inspire my play. Some great ideas on there!

pambeesleyhalpert · 14/03/2024 22:46

3 weeks away from having my second and wishing I never opened this thread 😂

TheOneWithUnagi · 14/03/2024 22:36

I don't find 2 massively harder at the moment. We have a just over 3 year age gap which I think helps as the older one is more self sufficient and understanding than she was at 2. And she sleeps!

Saying that I'm still on mat leave with baby 2 so will probably be harder when I'm back full time.

BreakingAndBroke · 14/03/2024 22:32

I think 2 is easier than having an only child would be. Yes, there are difficulties, but with one, you have to give them all of your attention. With two, they can entertain each other while you get on with the cooking or whatever.

Thegiantofillinois · 14/03/2024 22:31

2 is harder. Especially if 1 completely ignores 2 and 2 deliberately sets out to be different to 1. Mine have never played with each other. They both prefer me. I had 2 kids so that they would play with each other.
They have absolutely nothing in common, other than their address. 2 years apart. Dc1 would prefer to be an only. D 2 wishes dc1 would be a proper sibling. I was v close to my sibling growing up. It makes me sad that my two don't have that.

Firebird83 · 14/03/2024 22:22

Two is much harder than one. I don’t regret having DC2 though.

jelliebelly · 14/03/2024 22:19

thecatsthecats · 14/03/2024 21:48

Lots of people commenting here from the perspective of having a second soon after.

The only friend I have who makes having a second look appealing had hers four years apart. The eldest can manage bedtime partially herself, handle waiting for the baby to be sorted, and generally is more of a help than a hindrance.

Whereas five minutes with my friends with two under two makes my eyes bleed.

If we make the leap, it will be with a minimum three year gap.

This also becomes a factor as they get older - I have 3.5 yrs between my two (yr13 and yr10) and school much less stressful when exams come around if they aren’t both sitting exams at the same time - easier to give attention and support appropriately and much less competitive around school generally in our experience.

Swipe left for the next trending thread