Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Two kids looks harder than one, but is it?

137 replies

oneortwokids · 14/03/2024 20:15

Mulling this over with DH.

Everyone we know with two (especially if both parents work FT) is stressed to the max with hardly any time for themselves or their spouse and these are the people we hear complaining the most. However, I suppose you can’t take away from the fact the two children have each other forever and that is a really valuable thing.

On paper one looks easier. More energy, for yourself and them. More time to yourself, for work or personal reasons. More time to spend with DH. But, the biggest reason being, the cost of one is so much more manageable. The cost of living is so expensive, I don’t think we could provide the same for a second without compromise and less experiences and fun stuff for the three of us. I always imagined having lots of children - I’m really maternal and I just love babies. Babies grow up though and my biggest desire is to provide any support DC needs until and beyond them being an adult. We’d adapt no doubt to a larger family, but not be able to give them the same. And I’m not talking about private school and hefty deposits, I’m talking about affording to help with driving lessons, uni accommodation, pay childcare and such.

I thought I would ask on here. Parents of older kids, younger kids, objectively would one have been ‘easier’ or ‘harder’ for you? If this was your choice are you glad?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PoochiesPinkEars · 15/03/2024 17:05

True enough, on paper, you'd probably never have kids at all if you just weighed up the effort and expense. 😁

BobbysSox · 15/03/2024 15:54

You're overthinking things. Of course on paper, working it out clinically we would all stick with one.
My second child is my sunshine, I adore him and never regretted going from 1 to 2 for even a second. Going from 0-1 was far harder!

thecatsthecats · 15/03/2024 14:39

jelliebelly · 14/03/2024 22:19

This also becomes a factor as they get older - I have 3.5 yrs between my two (yr13 and yr10) and school much less stressful when exams come around if they aren’t both sitting exams at the same time - easier to give attention and support appropriately and much less competitive around school generally in our experience.

Haha, I didn't even say that I had a two school year gap withy own sister and she was a bloody nightmare around exams. Hers were always oh so important and stressful compared to mine...

NeedtostopusingMNsomuch · 15/03/2024 08:48

I think the age gap when the second is born is crucial. If it had been 3.5 plus years it would have been infinitely easier than a 2 year old and newborn. Hardest time of my life. But now we’re rewarded with a small age gap, they are best friends, play together (argue of course), only 2 schools years apart. It’s exhausting but fun. So worth it further down the line. Oldest has some friends with siblings with a much bigger gap and having a 1 year old to hang out with when you are 6 just isn’t the same

mirror245 · 15/03/2024 08:16

I only have one but find it very easy. My friends with 2 just have more stress, less money and more time dealing with sibling rivalry. Of my 3 close friends the younger one is a different sex from the older and there's a bit of a gap (4 year plus). The younger ones all have additional needs to which adds to stress. The kids don't play together.

My child is very self sufficient and I didn't need to spend lots of additional time playing with them. We have a super close relationship and our house is calm. Dc does lots of sports so it's always busy and can devote our time to that. They also have cousins of same sex and similar age that they see often and weekends are spent taking turns at sleepovers. When dc is away for a sleepover or an activity dh and I have time to go out for the time or chill at home and watch a movie. One wasn't our plan but that's the way it was but I'm extremely grateful and love the family we've created.

MotherofChaosandDestruction · 15/03/2024 08:03

Yes when they are small it's hard, there is 16 months difference between mine. However, now I think it's easier and during COVID it was a god send. They play together and although they fight, they have each other and don't rely on me to constantly play with them etc.

I love having two!!

PrincessHoneysuckle · 15/03/2024 07:57

Im forever thankful that I stuck at one.Ds 10 is everything I need I never had an urge to have another,dh felt the same.

Crunchymum · 15/03/2024 07:56

Of course managing two nervous systems is going to be harder than one. I think a lot of it depends on the temperament and nature of the children though.

You might be lucky and have two good eaters / sleepers who are content and easy going and have a sunny disposition. You might be "unlucky" and end up with the opposite or as with most people you'll land somewhere in the middle.

Going from 0-1 was the hardest as literally nothing prepares you but my first DC was one of those really easy babies (and he still is easy 11 years later). DC2 was very high needs, cried all the time, couldn't be put down, didn't sleep (co-slept and breast fed until aged almost 3!). If she'd been the first who knows if there'd have been a second.

lolacherricoke · 15/03/2024 07:47

I have 2 and they entertain each other 99% of the time. Not sure I would have wanted just one as that sibling connection is undeniable. So I think 2 is easier xx

kikisparks · 15/03/2024 07:39

I have one and personally I’m sure I’d find it harder with two. More drudgery, beds to strip and make, more sheets to wash, clothes to wash, towels to wash, dishes to wash, nappies to change etc etc. I’m barely on top of what needs done for the three of us (DH does other household stuff and some of his own washing). Add more sleeplessness, less time to myself, refereeing arguments, ferrying to multiple activities, double childcare costs, having to work with competing interests, less space in the house, more pressure on our marriage and so on and it sounds exhausting and a bit miserable (for me, I know lots love having multiples).

I love giving lots of my time to my daughter, being able to quickly pack up and go off on an adventure, being able to do activities based on her age and abilities, and that we can manage things that are already a bit tricky like swimming and eating out because we can give her our attention. Just my personal feelings on it.

Samlewis96 · 15/03/2024 07:21

3.5 years between my first 2. Definitely much much easier with one. Not so much the financial stuff that was an issue but the years and years of constant bickering, fighting,tale telling in each other constantly . So draining. Couldn't take them anywhere without them fighting and arguing. BTW they are now 32 and 28. They are able to tolerate and be polite to each other where they have to meet up (. Funerals mainly) but no relationship otherwise.

Never have a second child to " give," the first one a sibling

Purpleturtle45 · 15/03/2024 07:13

Easier with one when they are younger and rely on you for everything but easier with 2 when they get older and can entertain/play with each other, assuming they get along.

DutchCowgirl · 15/03/2024 07:05

when they are babies/toddlers yes they are twice the work. But my when they get older it gets easier. I have 2 boys, 3 years age gap. They play together, do things together. The youngest does things/learns things because he sees his older brother doing this. Older brother now helps with his homework when we are working. There was a time they could bike to school together (now the oldest is in secondary)
Yeah things like laundry and lunch packing is still twice the work ofcourse. But people with 1 kid are always looking for activities and playdates…

JC89 · 15/03/2024 07:03

One is easier but that doesn't necessarily mean better! Zero is even easier, but not better if you want kids.

lala567 · 15/03/2024 07:03

Mine are nearly 12 and 14. It's still so much easier when one is out. They argue and fight over everything. It's actually ridiculous!!!

Desecratedcoconut · 15/03/2024 06:56

Harder when they are little and very dependent and then easier once they can entertain one another. Three took a little longer to feel like everything was easily manageable again but, the logistics of getting everyone where they need to be for friends and clubs aside, you do get there and then the looming university costs are the only reason that stop you wishing you had four 😁

iLovee · 15/03/2024 06:56

When I had 1, i thought it was the hardest thing in the world. Now I have 2, going out with 1 feels like a little holiday

Globules · 15/03/2024 06:53

I have two, 2 years apart. Close friend has one, same age as my youngest. They're all approaching adulthood now.

I definitely had it more intensely in the early years. 2 nappies to change, 2 bedtimes, 2 meals.

When my youngest hit 3, things felt easier for me. My 5 year old was my 3 year old's best friend. I watched my friend run herself ragged constantly playing with her child, teaching her child, modelling eating to her child. My youngest learned so much from my eldest, which meant I didn't need to do that. My eldest even taught youngest to read. They really enjoyed teaching them.

Their friendship continued. If people came round, they'd amuse themselves. When I went to friends, her child always had to be part of everything, as she could only amuse herself for short periods.

Teen years have been much of a muchness for both families.

So I'd say two is easier than one long term.

mrssunshinexxx · 15/03/2024 06:46

1 is 1 , 2 is 100
But I am pregnant with third so probs not the best person to ask 😂

curiousasacat · 15/03/2024 06:44

PrincessesRUs · 14/03/2024 20:36

I disagree - easier with two as they play together and there are less requests for me to play!

I agree with this!! I mean, of course having one more child technically means more school drop offs, activities etc but for me, mine are close together in age and I felt so much more relaxed with the second one as I knew how to parent by then so it wasn't so stressful. The fact they played together was a huge bonus as it meant I didnt have constant requests to play- it was great!

lala567 · 15/03/2024 06:42

Of course. Why would it not be?

Heatherbell1978 · 15/03/2024 06:41

Mine are 7 and 9 now. Without a doubt having one would be easier especially when I look back. Now they can be fairly self sufficient around the house but with multiple activities, two FT jobs and one car, life is mainly about planning logistics. Eldest going to private school this year which wasn't planned. We're not sure if youngest will do the same but we need to plan for it and it's a lot of money. If we'd stayed at one we probably would have privately educated from the start. I don't regret our choice but especially where money is involved, it's clearly different.

Loopytiles · 15/03/2024 06:40

‘two children have each other forever’ isn’t a fact, it’s a wish!

Sibling rivalry / issues can be rough.

LurkingAndVenting · 15/03/2024 06:35

I was actually shocked at the number of folks saying that 1 was easier. I remember so many times feeling so sorry during lockdown for parents of 1.

I did make the very conscious decision of having my younger two close together in age. We were already elbow deep in nappies and no sleep anyways, so why not?

I think that decision has paid me back in spades for so many of the reasons other parents above have explained.

Would I do 3? No. No way. Shop was closed after #2. Done! So done! =)

NoraLuka · 15/03/2024 06:32

I have two with a 15 month age gap. It wasn’t easy when they were babies/toddlers, but now they are teenagers one good thing is that they have each other to talk to about any problems they might be having with friends or at school etc. They can talk to me too of course but that’s different because I’m old and don’t understand anything! I always get the impression that they have each other’s backs.

On the downside, two teenagers being difficult at the same time is not fun to deal with.