Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DHs will - how to handle this situation?!

343 replies

Ope0p · 14/03/2024 19:55

DH has never had a will and wants to start putting one together which is obviously a good thing!

He's been discussing various things with me and one thing cropped up tonight that has thrown me a little.

Basically he's said he wants to put me down as a guardian for his two older DC and I'm unsure how to say no in a way that isn't going to hurt him.

Funnily enough myself and a friend who is also a step parent were talking about this scenario a few months back, what we'd do if both parents weren't around anymore and we both agreed that we didn't think we'd want to take full responsibility for the DC and would likely be with grandparents instead.

How do I say this gently to DH that I'd really rather he didn't put me down as a guardian for his DC?

We do share DC as well so there is that added complication.

OP posts:
Cazpar · 15/03/2024 00:06

Marchitectmummy · 14/03/2024 23:55

Don't think there is a way to break that news in an unoffensive way.

Darling no I am unable o look after your children if you die or god no I won't be having anything to do with those two if you die will sound the same to someone who loves them.

Or, giving it five seconds thought and the slightest bit of brain power:

"I'm genuinely honoured you would want me to do that, but I have X/Y/Z concerns - how can we address those? What do you think the children / grandparents would want? Should we discuss it with anyone else?"

Cazpar · 15/03/2024 00:04

It's easy to say "but of COURSE I would do that" when you've got no realistic prospect of ever being asked. It's a very big thing to ask someone to take on parental responsibility of your children should the worst happen. It is not the same as agreeing to babysitting them on the odd weekend.

Taking on two (orphaned, grieving, possibly traumatised) children is not as simple as saying "yes I'll do it" and someone signing a will and then all is rosy with the world.

Social services will be involved in placing them. The children's wishes will be taken into account. There may be other family members who want to raise them.

There are also serious financial considerations. Could OP afford to raise four children?

Try, for a moment, to imagine how difficult that is at the best of times, let alone when you're recently widowed and dealing with grieving children.

OP you need a serious, genuine, conversation with your H about your concerns. It would be best if your H and his ex also took legal advice about their children's guardianship and how best they can go about it.

Marchitectmummy · 14/03/2024 23:55

Don't think there is a way to break that news in an unoffensive way.

Darling no I am unable o look after your children if you die or god no I won't be having anything to do with those two if you die will sound the same to someone who loves them.

Changeusernameseeusernamehistory · 14/03/2024 23:53

Bob Geldof is a fucking saint in my opinion. Poor Tiger Lily

Ulysees · 14/03/2024 23:46

JoshLymanIsHotterThanSam · 14/03/2024 20:00

There is just no humanity anymore.

I think it’s incredibly sad OP that you feel that little for your step children that in the terrible event they suddenly ended up with no parents you would not be interested in being the guardian.

Exactly. How very sad.

Pacificisolated · 14/03/2024 23:44

It’s incredibly unlikely that your DH and his ex wife will both die while their kids are young enough to need a guardian. If they did, and you were named as a guardian of the kids it does not mean you are compelled to care for them.
You smile and say ‘yes of course’, for the sake of family unity.

Mustreadabook · 14/03/2024 23:43

Ope0p · 14/03/2024 19:59

Mid 60s approx.

Its more likely the grandparents will die than DH snd the mother. But if they were alive I’m sure they would continue to provide a grandparent role of advice. But they wont necessarily be fit enough to parent

TempleOfBloom · 14/03/2024 23:43

But if he died before his ex, his ex would be their parent - and it would be up to her to say in her will who the guardians would be on her demise.

If the ex died before your DH then he would have the kids f/t, surely, and any question of you being guardian would only occur if he then also died. In this unlikely series of events wouldn't you consider having them?

MrsPerfect12 · 14/03/2024 23:32

I would just do it. It's so unlikely to happen. This could seriously harm your marriage if you said no.

duckydoo234 · 14/03/2024 23:27

I wouldn't. Taking on someone else's kids as your own is not just a straightforward "but you've had the same partner". I had my first child when step-daughter was 9. She has a heart of gold, but no way on earth I would have taken her on in the event of both her parents dying. She has been brought up totally differently to how I'm raising my children, and in a way that I could no way have had her in my home as someone other than a visitor. She's turned out okay, but that's kinda by chance, and in hindsight there's still no way I would have taken her on. I really like her now, but parenting someone and liking them are completely separate things.

Quartz2208 · 14/03/2024 23:25

Rather than saying no I think you need to gently point out that they also have a mother and that any decision made as to what happens if both of them go needs to be more of a joint co parenting decision rather than step mother with no blood ties gets them and a discussion and look at grandparents might be a better option but that you will of course want to keep the ties between the siblings (because your children are related to them) going

FunnysInLaJardin · 14/03/2024 23:24

that's is bizarre OP. We put my childless elder sister as guardian who was 65 at the time. She was happy to take the risk and would have loved them as her own if we had both died.

Sad for the DC that you can't do that

LiveLaughCryalot · 14/03/2024 23:19

Dibbydoos · 14/03/2024 22:40

You are married to him so they are your kids too. What's so difficult to.understand?

Seriously hate this step child isn't mine rubbish. They're your childrens siblings, so theyre yours end of.

If they are OP's kids then I hope they call her mum, that would be ok wouldn't it? Infact, if they are indeed OP's children then they should be calling her mum. I hope they were encouraged to do so.
I think many people would agree with you OP. I have indeed taken on two extra children for a few months not that long ago and it was HARD. It was hard on me, my OH AND my children. My youngest is still nervous about it happening again. I wouldn't do it again. I couldn't.
However, in your case it is very unlikely to happen so I would agree but ensure there are things in place just incase. Your DH needs to ensure that you would be very comfortable financially. I received nothing, again, it was very hard. Does he have life insurance etc? It would NOT be fair to burden you financially. It crippled us.

CarrotsAndCheese · 14/03/2024 23:18

Natty13 · 14/03/2024 21:24

I would agree, with the intention and full knowledge that if it came to it, I'd give the DSC to their grandparents or an aunt/uncle.

Reason being: it is EXTEMELY unlikely that both parents will die and leave tthem orphaned (at least while they are dependant children), saying no will cause hurt and damage to your husband but potentially also the DSC if they knew, and lastly because if your DH died and you went against his wishes for you to take on his kids - well, dead people can't have their feelings hurt so better to do it then.

dead people can't have their feelings hurt

JFC, well, that's ok then! 🙄

What the hell is wrong with all of these posters saying to just say yes to DH now with no intention to uphold that commitment if DSC were orphaned?

Quite apart from the lack of compassion for those children, where is your integrity, your respect for the dead and their wishes? Would you all ignore a dead person's will too if you were made the executor? Ignore their wishes to donate or not donate their organs? What a disgraceful, selfish attitude to take!

The dead should be able to trust the loved ones they have left behind.

godmum56 · 14/03/2024 23:12

OP, who do the children live with now?

Lockpeopleinrooms · 14/03/2024 23:12

Honestly, you don’t deserve to be a step parent and I hope to god my daughter’s doesn’t think as you do (I know she doesn’t, she’s lovely). I would take any of my best friends kids on if push came to shove - let alone my bloody husbands’ kids.

And I don’t even like other people’s kids!

easylikeasundaymorn · 14/03/2024 23:08

was just coming to say what @samarrange said. The will doesn't place any legal obligation on you - if worst comes to the worst you could just say 'I can't look after them.' Presumably the grandparents would be supportive of this as well.

Just say to him you'd prefer it if a) he discussed with his ex-partner and b) put something less prescriptive on there, like, 'I would like OP and grandparents (on both sides, plus any siblings?) to discuss the best living situation for my older children based on their circumstances.' What if, for example, (obviously knock wood!) he died in a car crash and you were seriously injured in the same crash and were either temporarily or long term unable to care for them?

The needs of a 17 year old could be a lot different to a 15 year old - one could have left school, be able to drive, and be doing an apprenticeship so could live with grandparents, the other might be better to stay in their school to finish their GCSEs so would be better to live with you for at least a few months, etc.

Having a less prescriptive expression of preference would be better all around.

Realistically it's more likely that you and DH would die at the same time, than his ex-wife would die and then him, both within the next 10 years.

You also never know how you might feel - you might get a lot closer with the kids in the next 10 years and want them to live with you. Losing your DH might make you want to keep the relationship with them as close as possible. Who knows?

cadburyegg · 14/03/2024 23:08

Elphamouche · 14/03/2024 22:52

I just don’t get this. Me and my friend were talking about this, if something happened to them we would bring up each others kids no questions asked.

Yet people wouldn’t take on their own step kids? Get out of the marriage.

I feel the same way. I'd take on my best friend's kids if necessary and I'm a single mum of two already!

YABU. Massively.

theduchessofspork · 14/03/2024 23:03

JoshLymanIsHotterThanSam · 14/03/2024 20:00

There is just no humanity anymore.

I think it’s incredibly sad OP that you feel that little for your step children that in the terrible event they suddenly ended up with no parents you would not be interested in being the guardian.

Yes… I mean the thought doesn’t need to fill you with joy, but unless there are other factors, it’s fairly shit not to be able to put yourself out for a couple of years in the incredibly unlikely event both your partner and x total themselves, especially as there are grandparents around to help out. I am a stepparent and it does come with SOME responsibilities.

crockofshite · 14/03/2024 23:03

Just say yes. It'll never happen.

lanadelgrey · 14/03/2024 22:59

Haven’t rtft but you and your DH need to discuss likelihood of you being last one standing and also once that has been broached gently suggest that he has conversation with his ex and also his parents re what would be best/possible for stepkids were he to die. He can’t stipulate what adults will do about kids after he dies - a good solicitor will explain this to him. A will is about money ie the estate and simpler the better all round. The important thing is that the children have a chance to maintain relationship with each other. If he leaves money and they are underage, who might be trustee of any money until it goes to them.
Thinking about making wills is emotive but they are a source of mess, pain and chaos if too much emotion goes into their actual stipulations. You should take chance to do yours at same time. And when he begins the process you can gently steer him away from rash stipulations. Realistically you and he are more likely to meet an untimely end together than he and his ex as you are more likely to be in the same place at the same time.

SuperstarDeejay · 14/03/2024 22:57

I wouldn't poke the bear on this one! The chances of them both dying (her first) in what's left of these kids' childhood is so ridiculously remote. And even if it did happen, once they were gone you could choose differently. Nobody can force you to do something just because someone willed it.

samarrange · 14/03/2024 22:55

Apologies is this is crass, but if push actually came to shove in this situation, it wouldn't matter too much what was in his will. Nobody can force you to become their guardian, DH can't "bequeath" that onto you, he can only say that that's what he would like. You could back out, pleading whatever reasoning you are currently using, or something else. He and his ex won't be around to be disappointed that you let them down.

So you could just say yes and cross that bridge (or not) if by some very unlikely chance you come to it. If it did happen you might find that you did want to take up the guardianship (your own DC might not need/want the extra upheaval otherwise), at which point you would be glad he did name you in the will.

Also let's say one of them does die, bringing the clause a step closer. At that point the world will look very different. If DH dies first then his ex will presumably become a sole parent (or if she has a new DP, they may adopt the kids). If the ex dies first then DH will become the sole parent and he might suggest that you adopt his kids. None of that will be easy, but it will bring DH to revise his will anyway.

Putting it another way, if you say no you are pretty much guaranteeing that you will create all kinds of doubt in DH's mind about your relationship with his DC. If you say yes you are taking a very small risk about having to have some difficult conversations at some future point.

Dullardmullard · 14/03/2024 22:55

Dibbydoos · 14/03/2024 22:40

You are married to him so they are your kids too. What's so difficult to.understand?

Seriously hate this step child isn't mine rubbish. They're your childrens siblings, so theyre yours end of.

Your first part isn’t true unless she’s adopted them.

MumblesParty · 14/03/2024 22:55

This is a very strange thread, because really OP, it’s not his sole decision to make. His ex may have siblings, parents, aunts/uncles, cousins etc who know and love the kids, and would definitely want to look after them. Why is your DH assuming they’ll just relinquish care of the children to their stepmother?

So to answer your question, I don’t think you need to break it to your DH that you’re not keen. You just need to tell him that he needs to have a conversation with his ex about it.