Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DHs will - how to handle this situation?!

343 replies

Ope0p · 14/03/2024 19:55

DH has never had a will and wants to start putting one together which is obviously a good thing!

He's been discussing various things with me and one thing cropped up tonight that has thrown me a little.

Basically he's said he wants to put me down as a guardian for his two older DC and I'm unsure how to say no in a way that isn't going to hurt him.

Funnily enough myself and a friend who is also a step parent were talking about this scenario a few months back, what we'd do if both parents weren't around anymore and we both agreed that we didn't think we'd want to take full responsibility for the DC and would likely be with grandparents instead.

How do I say this gently to DH that I'd really rather he didn't put me down as a guardian for his DC?

We do share DC as well so there is that added complication.

OP posts:
VestibuleVirgin · 15/03/2024 06:47

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Oh yes, the perfect tone to tell you husband that you don't want to care for his kids

FlowerBarrow · 15/03/2024 06:43

Or surely he should have been discussing this with their actual mother?? Does she want you to be the guardian of her children?

FlowerBarrow · 15/03/2024 06:42

@Ope0p surely you say nothing? The chances of it happening are miniscule and there’s no obligation on you to follow through just because it’s written into the will. It just means that social services could consider it as an option. Plus presuming they spend more time with their mother, I imagine if she has a named guardian they would also be considered (surely much more likely to be the actual grandparents)

VestibuleVirgin · 15/03/2024 06:38

Wow! So many quesions, @Ope0p
Did you get together with him holding this view? If so, why did you marry him?
Did you tell him that you would not care for those children if anything happened to him?
Have you asked your DH if he would care for your kids if anything happened to you?

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 15/03/2024 06:27

Ope0p · 14/03/2024 19:59

If something were to happen to both parents, I wouldn't want to take on full responsibility for their DC. It would feel beyond me personally.

Yet you married him knowing he had kids!

Why date a man with kods if you're not willing to step up and be a parent to them should anything happen to your DH or their mum?

I find this quite selfish but best to say no as you clearly have no love for them.

Malcom24 · 15/03/2024 06:22

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 15/03/2024 06:21

You haven't even thought this through from your own DC point of view. For this to happen DSC Mum would have to die first. So they'd move in with you all full time. Then your DC father dies and you're going to take your children's siblings away? You're really going to do that to your own children because you don't feel able to do it. How are you going to explain that to them, what will your own DC think of you if you did this?

You're the adult. you're their step mum, crucially your DC are their siblings, you act like an adult and you step up, there aren't other choices at least not ones most people can live with. If I trusted a partner with my kids this much and they felt how you do that would be a deal breaker for me. I couldn't be in a relationship with someone who would do this to my children if I died.

WitsEnd10 · 15/03/2024 06:18

Wow. How incredibly cold.

StarryNightAddict · 15/03/2024 05:51

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 15/03/2024 05:26

I don't think that's what posters are saying. The children, all of them, should get everything. OP can fend for herself.

But the children still need to be provided for while they’re still children.

if I was writing in my will a guardian I would leave them with enough money to provide for said kids. But the OP has to fend for herself?

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 15/03/2024 05:26

StarryNightAddict · 15/03/2024 02:57

Why do people keep making comments like this? Do you think the first two children should be provided for and not the second two?

At the very least, his half would have to be split 4 ways between all his children.

I don't think that's what posters are saying. The children, all of them, should get everything. OP can fend for herself.

ohdamnitjanet · 15/03/2024 04:24

JoshLymanIsHotterThanSam · 14/03/2024 20:00

There is just no humanity anymore.

I think it’s incredibly sad OP that you feel that little for your step children that in the terrible event they suddenly ended up with no parents you would not be interested in being the guardian.

I agree. Happy to palm them off on gp’s without a second’s thought whether that’s even possible. No wonder she doesn’t want to tell dh what she really thinks.

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 15/03/2024 03:44

JoshLymanIsHotterThanSam · 14/03/2024 20:00

There is just no humanity anymore.

I think it’s incredibly sad OP that you feel that little for your step children that in the terrible event they suddenly ended up with no parents you would not be interested in being the guardian.

This is kind of how I feel. I'm not a step parent, and I don't blame you for being daunted at the prospect, but I can't think of any circumstances where I wouldn't be prepared to parent a sibling of my child if there was no biological parent left to do it.

MissTrip82 · 15/03/2024 03:13

Bloody hell. No way would I have entered into my blended family if I weren’t prepared to have my husbands children with us full time if something happened to their mum and with me full time if something happened
to both their parents. Especially now they have a sibling who is my own child. They would need to all be together if they had a devestating loss.

I guess if you can’t you can’t and you need to be honest about it. But it would break my husbands heart if I felt this way so I think you need
to anticipate your husband will be hurt and shocked. He needs to know but it will be difficult.

StarryNightAddict · 15/03/2024 02:57

Mrspopper · 14/03/2024 22:11

So… assuming you don’t want any money left to you in his will either? Or are too happy to take money just not orphans?

Why do people keep making comments like this? Do you think the first two children should be provided for and not the second two?

At the very least, his half would have to be split 4 ways between all his children.

Picklestop · 15/03/2024 02:22

Ope0p · 14/03/2024 20:04

I'm not saying I'd never see them again or want anything to do with them, just I would feel able to assume sole responsibility for them in the unlikely event their parents weren't around.

Truthfully I cannot imagine being solely responsible for children that are not mine either. But I recognised this and never got into a relationship with anybody that had children. I am shocked at your stance regarding children of a man you decided to marry.

I think what you are talking about is a hypothetical situation that is never going (well highly highly unlikely) to happen. In any case what he writes in his will is not legally binding, children are not chattels to be given away after all, it is merely an expression of his preference. If you want your marriage to survive I would let him express his preference in his will.

Tiddlywinks63 · 15/03/2024 02:09

saraclara · 14/03/2024 20:08

Not only would both parents have to die at a very early age in separate incidents, but they'd have to die in the right order. Mum first, then dad. The odds of that are vanishingly small.

Most couples appoint guardians because the risk of an accident involving the couple are much higher, for instance travelling in the same car. Parents who are separated or divorced lengthen the odds of needing a guardian considerably. Then of course, double the already long odds to get it to happen in the right order.

Edited

DH and I were appointed guardians for my sister’s DCs in the event of her and BIL dying. Thankfully it’s never happened and the DCs are adults in their 20’s now. At the time our DCs were in their early teens but it never crossed my mind to refuse.
It’s very sad that you don’t feel you could love and raise your stepchildren, the alternative could be them going into care if their grandparents were unable to step in. What a heartbreaking thought.

anon4net · 15/03/2024 02:04

This is very very sad @Ope0p I don't have many words. They are your child's sibling. You are clearly more involved, with them more than anyone outside of their parents. In the horrific event they were left orphans, you'd want them to leave? What if it was your child. How would you feel if someone said that about them?

Italiangreyhound · 15/03/2024 01:30

IMHO it's very unlikely to happen so in one sense there is no problem with letting him make that will and knowing your feelings may change. If, in those terrible circumstances you were really faced with the reality of losing him and then of the children also losing their mum, you may find you would feel differently.

I agree with Unexpectedlysinglemum you could suggest joint custody with grandparents, and also, talk practically about the money situation in relation to looking after the children.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 15/03/2024 01:11

I would tell him that you could only do it jointly with his parents as equal guardians. Then you can still see them sometimes so they can spend time with their sibling but really the gp will be in change

Skodacool · 15/03/2024 01:05

I believe that, if both parents died and the children were still under age then it would be a court who would decide what would happen. Their father could express a wish but I don’t think it would be legally binding. So OP, you could perhaps express a willingness to care for them but point this out to him.

sykadelic · 15/03/2024 01:02

Honestly, I wouldn't tell him that you won't do it. you're talking about a remote possibility, and you're talking about in the future where your opinion may or may not change.

Personally, I would make sure he assigns a backup if you can't for whatever reason, make sure he has a trust set-up for the kiddos, and then IF he dies before you... make the choice when the time comes.

No need to upset the apple cart for no reason

Stravaig · 15/03/2024 00:58

Ignore the wicked stepmum bunfight. The important thing here is that DH discusses this with his kids Mum, and consults a solicitor, and they jointly draw up a plan, with the agreement of nominated guardians.

With both parents currently alive, and living separately, it's a remote possibility. Having parents in two homes already is the first layer of protection. Wise to prepare for the worst though. It creates space for DH and Ex to have a useful but difficult conversation expressing wishes for the children if the other parent dies. An oft neglected conversation after divorce.

Redirect DH to proper consultation and planning. You'll only have a potentially tricky situation if DH and Ex and kids and grandparents all want you to be primary guardian. Which may not happen.

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 15/03/2024 00:57

concernedchild · 14/03/2024 20:07

I'm sure they would want to. But you're being incredibly callous by saying you'd discard them as soon as he was gone.

You need to tell him. I'd imagine it'll have a huge impact on your marriage.

Yes and what he might put in his will.

changeme4this · 15/03/2024 00:09

Out of interest, how and where is he leaving the rest of his estate? Has he made provision for the children to inherit his share, or does it go directly to you?

Winter2020 · 15/03/2024 00:09

Hi OP,
You could ask your husband to discuss the situation with his ex as they need to be on the same page so the families wouldn't argue over what should happen if both parents did die. If his ex has a sister or brother the children are close to or if either set of grandparents are close to the children and on the younger side that could also work.

Your husband should pay a life insurance policy and specify what is for you and your child/ren and what is for his other children which could be used towards their costs if someone took over their care or for their future.