Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DHs will - how to handle this situation?!

343 replies

Ope0p · 14/03/2024 19:55

DH has never had a will and wants to start putting one together which is obviously a good thing!

He's been discussing various things with me and one thing cropped up tonight that has thrown me a little.

Basically he's said he wants to put me down as a guardian for his two older DC and I'm unsure how to say no in a way that isn't going to hurt him.

Funnily enough myself and a friend who is also a step parent were talking about this scenario a few months back, what we'd do if both parents weren't around anymore and we both agreed that we didn't think we'd want to take full responsibility for the DC and would likely be with grandparents instead.

How do I say this gently to DH that I'd really rather he didn't put me down as a guardian for his DC?

We do share DC as well so there is that added complication.

OP posts:
Floofball99 · 15/03/2024 11:28

Scarletttulips · 15/03/2024 11:12

You don’t deserve them. They’d be better off in a loving home with their grandparents. Shame on you

Wow - she doesn’t deserve them? They aren’t here’s the deserve - they aren’t a prize - they are young children who will have their own thoughts on who to live with should the worse happen.

OP recognizes they have other blood relatives that could do a better job of looking after them - that isn’t a failure - that’s a strength.

Where did I say that they were a prize? All I’m saying is they deserve to be in a loving home with someone who actually wants them. The op has said she doesn’t want them. I find this not only cold and heartless but rather shocking.

PoppingTomorrow · 15/03/2024 11:18

How Dickensian

Willyoujustbequiet · 15/03/2024 11:16

JoshLymanIsHotterThanSam · 14/03/2024 20:00

There is just no humanity anymore.

I think it’s incredibly sad OP that you feel that little for your step children that in the terrible event they suddenly ended up with no parents you would not be interested in being the guardian.

This

It would be the end of my marriage if I knew my husband felt like this.

Scarletttulips · 15/03/2024 11:12

You don’t deserve them. They’d be better off in a loving home with their grandparents. Shame on you

Wow - she doesn’t deserve them? They aren’t here’s the deserve - they aren’t a prize - they are young children who will have their own thoughts on who to live with should the worse happen.

OP recognizes they have other blood relatives that could do a better job of looking after them - that isn’t a failure - that’s a strength.

OneTC · 15/03/2024 11:10

I know it's an anon forum but you're just taking an opportunity to look especially heartless on a situation that's not likely to ever come around.

Their parents are separated, there's very very very little chance of both of them getting knocked off any time soon. Say you'll do it, gather the kudos, safe in the knowledge that it's never going to happen. And if it does happen then the person you seem to worry about offending will be dead and you can just drop em round the grandparents

Floofball99 · 15/03/2024 10:58

You don’t deserve them. They’d be better off in a loving home with their grandparents. Shame on you

mammaCh · 15/03/2024 10:50

If my partner said they were not willing to bring up my kids if they became orphaned that would a huge red flag and I would be out of there fast!
His kids are an extension of him.

TeaGinandFags · 15/03/2024 10:39

One way of wriggling out of this is to ask him to discuss the situation with his ex as she's interested in their future care.

If this doesn't work then agree and pray they become adults before he kicks the bucket. If the worst happens, you will need to thrash it out with all interested parties - including the children if old enough.

There are too many variables at play here to make a hard decision and being made guardian isn't a compulsion. None of us can dictate what happens after we're gone.

gannett · 15/03/2024 10:25

InterIgnis · 15/03/2024 10:02

No, but she would need to be signing up for taking on his children to raise alone (or indeed to raise). Which she didn’t do, and clearly isn’t going to.

The point is that in this unlikely scenario of immense tragedy there isn't anyone who's directly "signed up" to raise the children, as both parents are dead. And in life it's sometimes incumbent on people to step up to do things they haven't signed up to. And I'd say the stepmother has signed up to raise the children more actively than the grandparents, or any aunts/uncles (who might not exist anyway). She's already in a household with them.

mrshoho · 15/03/2024 10:22

You need to tell him so he can write specifically in his will regarding the proportion of his property and assets that he wishes his previous children to inherit. Your wishes make it clear that you do not feel you have any obligation towards them and he will want reassurance they will be looked after. Hopefully their Mother has suitable guardians she can nominate.

OrlandointheWilderness · 15/03/2024 10:16

God above. I'd be very, VERY careful how you tell him that OP as quite frankly I'd be rethinking the relationship if my DP said that.

Jamesblema · 15/03/2024 10:15

Maybe suggest he consults his ex about this. If they are both dead and she has appointed a guardian too then who gets the kids? Of course they are vanishingly unlikely to die at the same time so you only really need to worry about this if his ex dies.

tara66 · 15/03/2024 10:13

OP has left the building.

GoofyGoldie · 15/03/2024 10:09

If their mum died first they'd be living with you & your family. If their dad then died too would you pass them on to grandparents?

It's unlikely both parents will die in the next 10 years, but not impossible.

It would depend on who died first. If it was dad, then the children would most likely go to whatever mum has in place.

While I find it hard to understand why you wouldn't want to take on your child's siblings (although I get it's a massive responsibility & could be hard financially) I think it's something you need to talk through with your DH, & be honest. Someone upthread said don't tell him, he won't know once he's dead, but the children may have been told they will come to you.

My stepson lives with us as his mum died when he was 5. Before we all lived together I knew I'd take him on if his dad died. I did worry about finances but DH has life insurance. Now, it's actually me that's dying & DH is taking on my DD cos she doesn't want to live with her dad.

If you really feel you can't do it, you do need to say as it would be awful for the children to lose both parents, then have to live with someone who didn't want them.

InterIgnis · 15/03/2024 10:06

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 15/03/2024 09:48

OP wanted someone to have kids with, didn't care about his kids then and clearly doesn't now.

OP knew he had kids, why date him if you can't accept his kids?

Would be same if it was a woman saying her DH won't be a guardian to her kids if anything happened to her.

It's quite selfish to date a man with kids yet not want anything to do with them.

Worst case, OP's dh dies, she remarries, asks her new husband to be a guardian and he refuses.

Since when did accepting someone mean willing to raise them as a single parent’? Or ‘not willing to raise them a single parent’ mean ‘wants nothing to do with them’?.

MarmaladeOrangey · 15/03/2024 10:04

Frogggie · 15/03/2024 09:55

Considering the likelihood of this ever actually happening is so slim, I honestly would not say anything. Regardless of what he writes in a will it isn’t possible to legally force someone to be a guardian for anyone. It’s only really in there as a preference. Seems unnecessary to make this into a whole conversation when it’s most likely never going to happen, and if it does, then you can just say no at the time if you really still feel that way.

Agree, also OP may feel differently if the worst were to actually happen.

InterIgnis · 15/03/2024 10:02

gannett · 15/03/2024 08:23

No one ever actively signs up for tragedy and trauma, do they? But yes, when we choose to enter relationships with people - in this case a man and his children - we sign up to potentially having to deal with the worst life can throw at us as well as the best.

No, but she would need to be signing up for taking on his children to raise alone (or indeed to raise). Which she didn’t do, and clearly isn’t going to.

SKG231 · 15/03/2024 09:58

BranchGold · 14/03/2024 19:59

Do you dislike them?

It’s strange you married and had a child with a man when you can’t bring yourself to tolerate the children he has, your child’s siblings, if they were orphaned.

I take it you don’t have stepchildren yourself from this post.

Frogggie · 15/03/2024 09:55

Considering the likelihood of this ever actually happening is so slim, I honestly would not say anything. Regardless of what he writes in a will it isn’t possible to legally force someone to be a guardian for anyone. It’s only really in there as a preference. Seems unnecessary to make this into a whole conversation when it’s most likely never going to happen, and if it does, then you can just say no at the time if you really still feel that way.

Emotionalsupportviper · 15/03/2024 09:54

TiaraBoo · 15/03/2024 09:00

I’d phrase it as also wanting their mothers input into who would raise the children if neither parent was there. That you don’t want to step on any toes and would want their grandparents involvement etc, it’s not just something you add a note in the will about and tell them, it needs to be discussed.

That is an excellent suggestion.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 15/03/2024 09:50

Naunet · 15/03/2024 09:11

Ahh, the problem you have here is that you don’t seem to understand that step mothers aren’t a hive mind, they are all individuals with their own morals, thoughts, desires and standards etc. You won’t get a woman posting on here to boast how she’s picking up her step kids from cricket, because why would she? Step mothers also tend to take on a hell of a lot more than step dads do, so maybe add that into your analysis.

Expecting someone else to take on your kids full time, single handedly is a HUGE, HUGE ask, parents should be aware of this when asking anyone to be their childrens guardians in this sort of event.

Except she married him knowing he had kids.
She wants a unit with him excluding his kids, that's not ok.

BetterWithPockets · 15/03/2024 09:49

Stravaig · 15/03/2024 09:32

OP, by far the more important and tangible protection is what financial arrangements DH is making to ensure you and all his children are materially supported in the event of his death alone. And vice versa ofc. If he hasn't even got that covered, then sole guardian of step-children is very much a secondary issue.

And also this.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 15/03/2024 09:48

OP wanted someone to have kids with, didn't care about his kids then and clearly doesn't now.

OP knew he had kids, why date him if you can't accept his kids?

Would be same if it was a woman saying her DH won't be a guardian to her kids if anything happened to her.

It's quite selfish to date a man with kids yet not want anything to do with them.

Worst case, OP's dh dies, she remarries, asks her new husband to be a guardian and he refuses.

BetterWithPockets · 15/03/2024 09:47

AnnaMagnani · 14/03/2024 20:06

I honestly would not fall out with my DH over this.

If he dies, the children have a loving mother who would have them.

Chances of them both dying - incredibly small

The children are old enough that their wishes would be taken into account in that incredibly rare situation, especially as they will be getting older, regardless of who is appointed guardian.

I'd be delighted my DH thought I was the best person, and then file that info under 'never going to happen'.

This.

Stravaig · 15/03/2024 09:32

OP, by far the more important and tangible protection is what financial arrangements DH is making to ensure you and all his children are materially supported in the event of his death alone. And vice versa ofc. If he hasn't even got that covered, then sole guardian of step-children is very much a secondary issue.

Swipe left for the next trending thread