Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DHs will - how to handle this situation?!

343 replies

Ope0p · 14/03/2024 19:55

DH has never had a will and wants to start putting one together which is obviously a good thing!

He's been discussing various things with me and one thing cropped up tonight that has thrown me a little.

Basically he's said he wants to put me down as a guardian for his two older DC and I'm unsure how to say no in a way that isn't going to hurt him.

Funnily enough myself and a friend who is also a step parent were talking about this scenario a few months back, what we'd do if both parents weren't around anymore and we both agreed that we didn't think we'd want to take full responsibility for the DC and would likely be with grandparents instead.

How do I say this gently to DH that I'd really rather he didn't put me down as a guardian for his DC?

We do share DC as well so there is that added complication.

OP posts:
Xylophonics · 14/03/2024 20:30

Agree best for your dh to discuss it with his ex. She may have thoughts on who she'd want her dc to be with - could be grandparents, one of her or your dhs siblings, even a family friend.

I couldn't think of anyone suitable to name as a guardian for the dc, so we never made a will. DC are now both young adults, so not an issue anymore.

flyinghen · 14/03/2024 20:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Papillon23 · 14/03/2024 20:27

Honestly, I probably just wouldn't talk about it. Suggest he puts you jointly with his parents.

The likelihood of it happening is incredibly low. The likelihood of you still feeling the way you do if it did happen is even lower. And if that did happen you could have a discussion with the GPs etc and then not have them live with you full time.

If you say you don't want to take it on I don't think there's any way it won't be massively hurtful.

Humphhhh · 14/03/2024 20:23

Ope0p · 14/03/2024 20:00

No I don't dislike them. But I wouldn't feel able or capable of taking them on full time without either parent around.

The fall out from you not doing this will be huge so be very sure you want to make a big deal of it.

It isn't legally binding, you don't know what his ex-wife wants and it's very very unlikely to be needed.

Propertylover · 14/03/2024 20:23

@Ope0p I have seen it pointed out on other threads that if your step children were orphaned, guardianship would not solely be determined by the parents wills. SS would be involved and would consider what was best interests of the children and for everyone.

Has your DH asked their mum who she would want to be their guardian? I see this as a joint decision for them as their Mum may not want you to be named. I would start with this tack first.

Redglitter · 14/03/2024 20:23

I'd get him to discuss it with his ex & see her thoughts. If she's happy for you to be named then to be honest I'd just go with it. The chances of his ex dying then him dying in the next 10 years are slim. It's more a paper exercise. You say no & it could end your marriage. But as pp said even if it did all happen its not legally binding

RandomMess · 14/03/2024 20:21

Being their guardian doesn't mean they come and live with you it means you take on responsibility for sorting things out and advocating for them.

Didimum · 14/03/2024 20:21

Just say yes. They are hardly both going to die before the kids turn 18. This isn’t worth the hassle.

NoTouch · 14/03/2024 20:20

I asked my dbro/SIL to be guardian for ds.

To me guardian was I would make them trustees for our estate and put in my will I would like them to have a say in what happened to ds and how the money from our estate would be used. I asked them, if it was possible, for them to make decisions for ds that would be in his best interests with no pressure on them to "take him in". That might be live with them if they agreed/wanted to or live with another sibling/elsewhere if that was what they deemed best for ds.

What would be in ds's best interests would change depending on whether he was 3 years old and could easily move across to the other side of the country or 16 years old and sitting exams and I didn't want to be rewriting my will every 10 minutes.

As far as I know, you cannot "leave" a child in your will to anyone, only express a wish, social services would get involved. Personally I would let your dh put it in his will and tell him in the unlikelihood of it ever happening you will make sure his children are taken care of and keep in close contact with their siblings, but not necessarily live with you if it is not in their best interests at the time (which it wouldn't be if you couldn't cope).

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 14/03/2024 20:18

It's very important your dh speaks to the mother of the children !

as she may have a sister or a brother or someone that she would wish to be the children's guardians.

HappyDaze23 · 14/03/2024 20:18

There’s not wanting to be fully responsible for your step children, and then there’s not wanting to be responsible for your step children in the unlikely event they end up orphaned in tragic circumstances. The former, understandable, the latter, heartless!

We are named in a family will to be guardians for two DC if anything should happen to their parents. I certainly wouldn't chose to raise two more children BUT I wouldn’t hesitate to do it if the need arose.

Starfish1021 · 14/03/2024 20:17

I’m kind of shocked by your coldness. I would do this for a friend if the absolute worst thing happened and someone needed to step in. There is such a remote possibility of this happening. But your partner should know your position.

fairymary87 · 14/03/2024 20:16

Wow imagine being raised but someone then to have them not be around if a parent dies....

Ketzele · 14/03/2024 20:16

I would say yes with loving enthusiasm, banking on the odds of both your dh and his ex dying in the next few years are incredibly slim.

I also don't think that being guardian means you have to have the children living with you. It gives you responsibility for making the best arrangements for the children's care, which may mean living with grandparents.

The chance of this happening is SO small - I wouldn't throw this hand grenade into my marriage, if I were you.

Motheranddaughter · 14/03/2024 20:13

It would not be legally binding on you
Maybe go along with it and in the very unlikely vent that it came to pass see how you feel

DisforDarkChocolate · 14/03/2024 20:12

If I liked his children I'd say yes, it would be the best for them and probably my own children.

LisaD1 · 14/03/2024 20:12

My eldest was 4 when I met my DH, we’ve been together 20 Years now. my will made him guardian of my eldest and my exh agreed that if I died she would remain with my DH and our child together.

honestly, if my DH had said no it would have been a relationship ender for me.

hes never treated my eldest like anything other than his own daughter.

TheSnowyOwl · 14/03/2024 20:12

You can say no and once he gets over that he will probably leave you or you could suggest that he says both grandparents, so they are still involved, and that you will continue to have a role in their lives along with their half sibling/s.

Soontobe60 · 14/03/2024 20:09

Ope0p · 14/03/2024 20:01

No I don't think I could no.

How do you think your joint children - who are half siblings to DHs Childers - may react to the fact that you wouldn’t want to look after their siblings?

User364837 · 14/03/2024 20:09

I think the chances of both parents plus grandparents dying before the kids are grown up is pretty miniscule especially if they’re not together so not travelling together eg. And in a car accident.

it’s a horrible thing to think about but just say yes to give him peace of mind. How horrid to think no one would want his kids if the worst happened. How could you see them go into care if they were to suffer that triple tragedy?!

saraclara · 14/03/2024 20:08

Not only would both parents have to die at a very early age in separate incidents, but they'd have to die in the right order. Mum first, then dad. The odds of that are vanishingly small.

Most couples appoint guardians because the risk of an accident involving the couple are much higher, for instance travelling in the same car. Parents who are separated or divorced lengthen the odds of needing a guardian considerably. Then of course, double the already long odds to get it to happen in the right order.

FacingTheWall · 14/03/2024 20:08

I think it’s really unlikely you’ll ever be in that position, but I don’t understand how you could not want them to be with you and their sibling(s) in the event of their parents deaths! I’ve read a lot of cold hearted things on here but that beats most of them. You think they would be better off being brought up by aging grandparents than in a family with you?!

Soontobe60 · 14/03/2024 20:08

JoshLymanIsHotterThanSam · 14/03/2024 20:00

There is just no humanity anymore.

I think it’s incredibly sad OP that you feel that little for your step children that in the terrible event they suddenly ended up with no parents you would not be interested in being the guardian.

I totally agree with this.
However, I’d be completely honest with your Dh as he will likely need to make sure his Dc are left financially secure if he and their mother were both to die.

concernedchild · 14/03/2024 20:07

I'm sure they would want to. But you're being incredibly callous by saying you'd discard them as soon as he was gone.

You need to tell him. I'd imagine it'll have a huge impact on your marriage.

JennyMule · 14/03/2024 20:07

OP a testamentary guardianship only comes into effect if both parents (and anyone else with parental responsibility) is dead.
If you did agree to be TG for his offspring you would only be called upon if the children's mother also died.
A way of avoiding hurting your DH's feelings could be to suggest that Maternal and Paternal Grandparents (if still alive and compos mentis) act as TG to allow children to maintain legal as well as social links with both sides of their birth family.
Alternatively you could suggest that you share the TG role with a grandparent (but risk is they predecease or leave you to carry out the bulk of the role )
TGs are not obliged to have wards live with them, btw, the decision making about their lives is vested in the TG, (not an absolute obligation to care for directly but you'd have to establish what the testator expects.)