Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell my daughter she goes on too many holidays?

293 replies

Salltee · 14/03/2024 19:36

I have a daughter, aged 26. She has an addiction to holidays abroad. She spends every moment of her annual leave on a beach in a foreign land.

She should be saving the money instead. She rents and doesn’t have a huge amount of savings. She earns a lot of money for her age and does work hard to be fair to the girl.

But it’s hard to see her rentin, when she could save for a deposit on a house.

She’s just told me she’s booked flights again for £500 to go to mexico for a week in December. Heaven forbid another holiday. I reckon she probably spends about 20-30% of her income on holidays.

OP posts:
MsRosley · 14/03/2024 22:57

There's a fine line as a parent between guidance and being seen as criticising and interfering. In your shoes I think I would gently steer her towards thinking about buying a home and pointing out how much money that will save her in the longer term, while not actively criticising the holiday spending. You could sell it to her that she could rent out the property while she travels to offset some of her holiday costs.

Shadowonasun · 14/03/2024 22:56

Mind your own business.

Scarletttulips · 14/03/2024 22:54

That £500 single holiday will soon turn into a family of 2 adults and 3 kids costing £3,000!

Best see the world single before the kids arrive.

I would love to be that independent again.

tachetastic · 14/03/2024 22:54

Salltee · 14/03/2024 19:36

I have a daughter, aged 26. She has an addiction to holidays abroad. She spends every moment of her annual leave on a beach in a foreign land.

She should be saving the money instead. She rents and doesn’t have a huge amount of savings. She earns a lot of money for her age and does work hard to be fair to the girl.

But it’s hard to see her rentin, when she could save for a deposit on a house.

She’s just told me she’s booked flights again for £500 to go to mexico for a week in December. Heaven forbid another holiday. I reckon she probably spends about 20-30% of her income on holidays.

I regret a lot of the money I spent on crap when I was in my twenties and thirties (I would get hooked on collecting things and spend a fortune), but I don't regret a penny spent on seeing the world.

Let her enjoy her holidays while she can. In ten years time with a mortgage and three kids she will enjoy having the memories.

sunights · 14/03/2024 22:52

I'd suggest thinking in terms of long term outcomes for both your daughters future and your shared relationship.

E.g. she may resent you blocking her from taking holidays once she has children and can't.

A healthy compromise could be to suggest she starts saving 5 or 10% of her income and offer to maybe match this with some sort of reward or favour when she reaches a savings goal.

And/or to offer to come on a holiday with her - may as the reward/favour once she hits a savings goal.

If this feels too twee, maybe setting it up as a bet could be more fun?

MsRosley · 14/03/2024 22:51

WinterMorn · 14/03/2024 19:39

It’s absolutely nothing to do with you, and to be honest, you sound envious.

No she doesn't. She sounds concerned.

Elphamouche · 14/03/2024 22:50

You’re being completely unreasonable! Leave her alone 😂.

beAsensible1 · 14/03/2024 22:20

£500 for Mexico is so cheap, let me go and book for myself !

Alconleigh · 14/03/2024 22:18

GetWhatYouWant · 14/03/2024 19:54

I'd be of the same opinion as you OP. It would be better if she saved now for a deposit and mortgage, then she can spend money on holidays when she's sorted that out, the different countries are not going anywhere.

My son and his now wife saved for a deposit and put extra money in pensions more or less from starting work after university. They had weekends away and an annual reasonably priced holiday but saving meant they could buy at 25 and now at 30 they have a large 4 bed house in a desirable area, pay extra into pensions so they can retire at 50 and now have more expensive holidays and trips.

Maybe suggest to your daughter that there's a happy medium between spending and saving for the future. I find it strange how many people on here seemingly never speak to their adult children about sensible financial management.

This makes me feel absolutely suffocated and conjures up the sort of fifty at twenty people who have want nothing more than to spend every weekend with their parents, live round the corner and start having babies at 25. But that could be massively unfair. Much as it's unfair to judge OP's daughter as a flibbertigibbet spendthrift.

FWIW, I pissed away all my money in my twenties, paid no attention to my career until my thirties, didn't buy a flat until I was 40 and now earn £100k and live in a 4 bed detached so.....you never know. And there is nothing better than seeing the world.

Spectre8 · 14/03/2024 22:16

At 26 though OP is right to have a few concerns why does she have to throw majority of her money on travel instead dod I dunno 6 holidya why not just 4 a d save at the same time.

As we have seem so many times on here suddenly the thirties hit and people complain why they can't afford a house, children and then retirement yet everyone is so stuck with this archaic view of just spend all your w0s partying, travelling and worry about it later.

It's like noone can be sensible and do both, travel and save 🙄

minthybobs · 14/03/2024 22:11

myhardluckstory · 14/03/2024 21:46

I agree. While it's none of the OP's business if daughter is funding herself (and OP shouldn't let her move back home either if she hasn't saved to fund a job loss for example)... the attitude towards, erm, 'travel' is very different to takeaways or luxury goods.
People see the former as superior, the latter as mindless consumption.
They're all the same to me.

Especially if you're just going to these places to lie on a beach. It doesn't make you more worldly/open-minded/resilient whatever.

I also agree. It’s definitely not OPs business to comment on her choices and it’s her money, her decision.
That said, I am so glad I saved for a house as lots of people my age now cannot afford them and where I live, renting is almost double the cost of mortgage repayments. Holidays are wonderful but when you consider how much time you actually spend at home to how much time you spend on holiday it was a no brainer to me to spend money on where I spend the majority of my time.

CaterhamReconstituted · 14/03/2024 22:10

You only get one life. The idea that the priority is to hoard all your resources into owning a pile of bricks is one point of view. But it is only one point of view, a middle-class, suburban one that knows the price of everything and the value of nothing. Your way is not the only way.

Alconleigh · 14/03/2024 22:08

Reverse?

BeauSignoles · 14/03/2024 22:07

I spent my 20s travelling too. Didn’t get my first “proper” job until 29. Now I’m mid 40s, with kids, a decent job and a manageable mortgage. No regrets!

3luckystars · 14/03/2024 22:07

EasterIssland · 14/03/2024 21:36

you sound like my parents. Think they got happy when I bought the house cuz they thought I’d stop traveling as much. It didn’t happen. I did a small wedding cuz I wanted to spend more on my honeymoon than on a wedding. Then I got a pregnant and had a child. They thought maybe we’d travel less. My son is not 6 and has been on 47 airplanes and traveling to Asia for the first time.
ahe might not want a mortgage. She might be happy renting and it’s fine as long as you’re not paying her bills. If she looses her job I’m sure one way or another they’ll find a job. She’s not your little girl anymore. She can take decisions for herself

I love your attitude and I hate when people pick apart posts but can you tell me how he was on an odd number of flights? Have you not come home or did you get two flights on one leg and only one flight on the other leg? How is it 47?

As for the op, your daughter will have responsibility and bills long enough, let her enjoy her youth.

onawave · 14/03/2024 22:04

I travelled and holidayed every chance I got in my 20s. Didn't save a penny. Every bit of cash and time I had went on getting away even if it was only a short trip to Europe. Now I'm middle aged and tied down by a mortgage and 2 kids (that I wouldn't give up for anything) I treasure those memories. I constantly feel the itch to get away but commitments keep me in one place so I am so glad I did it all when I had the chance.

myhardluckstory · 14/03/2024 22:01

ButterflyTable · 14/03/2024 21:56

I was the hard working person in my 20s I can’t believe by the age of 28 I’d saved over £70k as a deposit for a house and spend £20k on my wedding too in the same year!

However my friends travelled and did amazing things I missed out! I wish I’d used some of that hard earned cash to travel.

one thing I also regret I was offered a post in Canada by my company and then a post in Dubai and then a post in Oz!! I turned them all down!! Maybe your DD could move abroad? Somewhere like Australia? That may quench her thirst for travel a bit?

Well if your salary is really good, you can do both! Especially as the daughter's working FT, doesn't sound like she has a lot of A/L. Not sure if what OP thinks is a 'good salary' might have been 20 years ago and isn't really.

Up until 1.5 years ago a mortgage was cheaper than rent in most desirable areas. I had so much more free spending money after buying (with then partner, but I had enough on my own even without him anyway). I have friends who rented their property out and travelled, airBnb'ed it, all sorts.

I like my bed too much to travel lots althought I do at least 2 holidays a year, but love restaurant food. IL's complain we have too many takeaways and they sound like the OP! Unlike the OP however they don't know the extent of our very healthy savings.

Irishmumofboys · 14/03/2024 22:01

A 26h year old living independently by the sound of things, working hard, using her annual leave to travel… what a loser!
Im joking OP your daughter actually sounds amazing and fair play to her for enjoying her life and spending her money as she pleases.
I would stop judging her if I was you, house is not everything!! Would you be happier is she bought a house and just sat in it?

Whattheduck · 14/03/2024 22:00

Let her travel and see the world
My dd would have my full support she’s 19 and I know she has started saving to go to Greece for a month in the summer and I’m excited for her.
She has plenty of time to commit to buying a house let her have adventures while she can.

SuperstarDeejay · 14/03/2024 21:59

Some people are just wired this way. We get restless and want to move around, see more, do more. Most of us have commitments that tie us to one place, so we need to break away occasionally to get our fix. If you're not like this OP, you won't understand how miserable life gets if you can't go. The pandemic was torture.

fleurneige · 14/03/2024 21:57

BakedTattie · 14/03/2024 19:40

Good for her!

Well yes. But it is hard then to hear her and others like her- complain how hard this generation has it, etc. As long as she doesn't come complaining and asking parents to sacrifice their savings and own very hard won holidays, at last ... to pay for her deposit when she needs one. OK.

ButterflyTable · 14/03/2024 21:56

I was the hard working person in my 20s I can’t believe by the age of 28 I’d saved over £70k as a deposit for a house and spend £20k on my wedding too in the same year!

However my friends travelled and did amazing things I missed out! I wish I’d used some of that hard earned cash to travel.

one thing I also regret I was offered a post in Canada by my company and then a post in Dubai and then a post in Oz!! I turned them all down!! Maybe your DD could move abroad? Somewhere like Australia? That may quench her thirst for travel a bit?

AngelQuartz · 14/03/2024 21:55

Jealous much???

Let her live. She obviously earns her own money and lives independently it’s up to her how she spends it. Good for her and hope she enjoys her next trip.

Yazzado · 14/03/2024 21:53

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

jupiterhigh · 14/03/2024 21:52

Ellie525 · 14/03/2024 19:42

Agree with other posters in that its hers to spend as she likes and good on her.

For a reality check also - even if she spends say £5k a year on holidays, putting that towards a house deposit its going to take her TEN YEARS to get a half decent deposit and by then £50k wont even be a half decent deposit anymore unless house prices totally crash... so shes probably thinking why have ten years of zero fun or experiences just to be in same position

This completely.
OP, have a real look at mortgage affordability, we tend to put our own life experiences on others, but mortgages are completely different experience now.