Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell my daughter she goes on too many holidays?

293 replies

Salltee · 14/03/2024 19:36

I have a daughter, aged 26. She has an addiction to holidays abroad. She spends every moment of her annual leave on a beach in a foreign land.

She should be saving the money instead. She rents and doesn’t have a huge amount of savings. She earns a lot of money for her age and does work hard to be fair to the girl.

But it’s hard to see her rentin, when she could save for a deposit on a house.

She’s just told me she’s booked flights again for £500 to go to mexico for a week in December. Heaven forbid another holiday. I reckon she probably spends about 20-30% of her income on holidays.

OP posts:
PurpleOodie · 17/03/2024 16:05

Life is for living and that is exactly what she’s doing. It’s none of your business whatsoever. She’s an adult. Wind your neck in.

beanii · 17/03/2024 16:02

She's 26 - she can spend her hard earned money however she wants!

No1toldmeaboutit · 17/03/2024 16:01

Is this for real???

Lurkingonmn · 17/03/2024 15:56

Do you discuss finances with your daughter? Do you know that she isn't saving/investing as well as spending money on travelling?
Renting is not always a bad option as it can save money on maintaining, buying/selling costs, etc.
A lot of people would choose to spend their disposable income on travel and a lot of people eho retire early do the same thing but time, good health and old age is not guaranteed.
I think a sensible mix of making sure all bills are paid, saving/investing and enjoying life is the best combination.

TrustyRusty68 · 17/03/2024 15:52

She’s 26 - not really any of your business as she’s an adult earning her own money. Sure - you can suggest but & guide but that’s it! Way too controlling!!

Victoriancat · 17/03/2024 15:51

I think someone's jealous!

AnnieSnap · 17/03/2024 15:49

Is this a joke @Salltee ? She’s 26. Unless you are supporting her financially by letting her live at home without ‘paying her way’, it’s none of your business! Even then, you are only in a position to insist she pays her way. Other than that, they in which she spends her money is her own affair. I understand your concerns, but it’s just not up to you to decide.

Musiclover234 · 15/03/2024 15:33

Those judging the daughter to be irresponsible don’t actually know that she is not saving just because she has holidays doesn’t mean she isn’t saving too or paying towards a pension. Plenty of people older can’t afford either (or mortgages or holidays) Also op hasn’t come back so……

Also I never regretted spending and living life in my twenties! I still paid into my NHS pension from 26. I didn’t save much ( low earner) but I have a house and ok savings now. Life is a balance. Also with wars, climate change and the worries of life we should be encouraging young people to have some enjoyment on whatever they choose!

Itloggedmeoutagain · 15/03/2024 12:48

Given that you're not paying for them, it's nothing to do with you.

Fupoffyagrasshole · 15/03/2024 12:48

lolz! leave her alone - I am like this I need to have trips to look forward to and chose to spend most of my spare money on travel! I'm mid 30s now did actually manage to buy a flat eventually 2 years ago - just took me a few years longer to save than it would have if I didn't travel so much !

I have a 3 year old and a baby on the way and I haven't changed at all - we are away all the time - 3 year olds been on i think 40 trips so far in her little life and we are spending 6 months of my next maternity leave travelling too!!

life is for living and this is how some people want to spend their money !

JamSandle · 15/03/2024 12:39

I sense a lot of jealousy on this thread.

Who is to say the daughter will even want kids or all of these things?

My own mum died young. You can enjoy the moment and still prepare for the future.

So many people amass things for a future than never comes.

NeedToChangeName · 15/03/2024 12:24

If they end up old aged with no property - they government will pay for their care@Scarletttulips

I would think that's even more reason to save......... In future, I fear that -

assisted dying will be introduced
people who can afford it will pay for quality care when they are frail and elderly
people who can't afford it - some - by no means all - will be deemed to have such poor quality of life that assisted dying is the best solution for them

It terrifies me and I don't think it's hyperbole

Riverlee · 15/03/2024 12:03

It’ll be interesting in four year’s time when op’s daughter hits thirty to see her situation then. Will she regret all the holidays, or at least regret not beginning to save? Even having one fewer holiday a year, and saving a thousand pounds each time, will mean she’ll have a few thousand pounds to put towards a deposit, car etc.

RiderofRohan · 15/03/2024 11:41

Menomeno · 15/03/2024 11:22

You’re assuming everyone is in London/South East. My DS bought a 3 bed house with a garden for £200K. OP says her DD is spending 20-30% of her salary on holidays, so £5-10K a year? A deposit on a starter home could be saved in 4 years at £5K a year in most of the country. Of course it’s not easy, but nor is it impossible.

Exactly this. Even outskirts of London and South East will be doable for my sister in 5-6 years if she sticks to her plan. It will be a flat not a house, but she'll be going into her 30s with her foot on the ladder.

I'm not saying this is great. My generation have it tough and Gen Z's have it tougher. But that doesn't give us an excuse to constantly give in to instant gratification with the attitude of 'oh well, it's too hard to try'.

RiderofRohan · 15/03/2024 11:34

@Scarletttulips I'm a millennial in my 30s, so I'm not looking down on the younger generation and giving outdated advice. I'm looking at my generation and Gen Z's.

Fully aware previous generations had it much easier than us. This doesn't give us an excuse to not try.

I'm not saying every young person can afford to buy a home. It might be impossible for those on low incomes. But the OPs daughter earns well and is spending thousands of £ a year on holidays. This is a young person who could save a deposit if she wanted to. Yes, she wouldn't have it in one or even two years, but she could make a five to ten year plan.

My sister is younger than the OPs daughter and we've done just that. She'll still be able to go on holiday once a year but conscientiously saving will mean she'll have a deposit before she's 30. I only wish I'd had someone do this for me in my 20s.

I doubt 20-30 % of the OPs daughter's income is £2000 if she earns well.

KreedKafer · 15/03/2024 11:25

She's 26, ffs. Mind your own business. It's absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with you.

Menomeno · 15/03/2024 11:22

Scarletttulips · 15/03/2024 11:05

This thread is depressing in that it reflects our current society's obsession with spending on constantly having a good time and miseducation about saving.

When I was young I brought a house on my own X3 of my salary:

Since them I married and me and DH brought a house less than X3 joint salaries.

The young now have to save 10% deposit so £36K plus moving costs, increase %rate which will only go up - they can afford to hop on the ladder or move up it. New builds are getting smaller and smaller to be ‘affordable’

If they end up old aged with no property - they government will pay for their care.

Debts are passed on that die with the person.

You can’t blame them for living to the current climate - they are adjusting -

Spending £2,000 a year on trips isn’t going to put a dent in a housing deposit:

Wr were luckily - my kids will still be at home at 30 years old because they can’t afford to move out - why is this mess their problem?

You’re assuming everyone is in London/South East. My DS bought a 3 bed house with a garden for £200K. OP says her DD is spending 20-30% of her salary on holidays, so £5-10K a year? A deposit on a starter home could be saved in 4 years at £5K a year in most of the country. Of course it’s not easy, but nor is it impossible.

Scarletttulips · 15/03/2024 11:05

This thread is depressing in that it reflects our current society's obsession with spending on constantly having a good time and miseducation about saving.

When I was young I brought a house on my own X3 of my salary:

Since them I married and me and DH brought a house less than X3 joint salaries.

The young now have to save 10% deposit so £36K plus moving costs, increase %rate which will only go up - they can afford to hop on the ladder or move up it. New builds are getting smaller and smaller to be ‘affordable’

If they end up old aged with no property - they government will pay for their care.

Debts are passed on that die with the person.

You can’t blame them for living to the current climate - they are adjusting -

Spending £2,000 a year on trips isn’t going to put a dent in a housing deposit:

Wr were luckily - my kids will still be at home at 30 years old because they can’t afford to move out - why is this mess their problem?

x2boys · 15/03/2024 10:58

Good for her I wish I had ,had more holidays when I was her age and able to afford it.

NeedToChangeName · 15/03/2024 10:30

I respect it's her choice but I'd worry too OP

Yes it's fun to travel, enjoy holidays etc but if you want financial stability, you need to be responsible too

Menomeno · 15/03/2024 10:22

RiderofRohan · 15/03/2024 10:07

This thread is depressing in that it reflects our current society's obsession with spending on constantly having a good time and miseducation about saving.

Suggesting that a mum should not advise her young, adult daughter on financial matters. Suggesting this girl can spend absolute bank on holidays each year yet it would somehow be impossible to save for a house in the next 5-10 years. Saying 'you only live once', as if she's expected to die imminently, so why invest in her financial future?

Many of us will have to work until we are very old, stooped over and grey. Many of us will die in debt which we will pass on to our kids. Many of us will rely on our kids to financially support us in old age, thus taking away from them and our grandkids.

This thread demonstrates why.

Absolutely this.

Our children probably won’t get a state pension. They will work until they die without a decent workplace/private pension. I can’t understand why blowing all your income and not making plans for the future is so encouraged.

An interesting statistic: A person who pays a set amount into a pension between the ages of 21 and 30, and then pays nothing for the rest of their life can retire with a bigger pension pot than a person who starts paying the same amount at 30 and continues to pay until the day they retire. Early contributions are absolutely crucial.

I’d much rather my DCs had the chance to retire in their 50s than pull their tripes out till the day they die. Their happy holiday memories won’t keep them housed and fed in their old age. Making them aware of this isn’t jealousy, it’s wanting what’s best for them.

RiderofRohan · 15/03/2024 10:07

This thread is depressing in that it reflects our current society's obsession with spending on constantly having a good time and miseducation about saving.

Suggesting that a mum should not advise her young, adult daughter on financial matters. Suggesting this girl can spend absolute bank on holidays each year yet it would somehow be impossible to save for a house in the next 5-10 years. Saying 'you only live once', as if she's expected to die imminently, so why invest in her financial future?

Many of us will have to work until we are very old, stooped over and grey. Many of us will die in debt which we will pass on to our kids. Many of us will rely on our kids to financially support us in old age, thus taking away from them and our grandkids.

This thread demonstrates why.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 15/03/2024 09:17

It's none of your business OP and you should not be expressing opinions on what she spends unless you are paying. I say that as a person with adult dc myself.

YOU like to save; she doesn't. Different people.

JamSandle · 15/03/2024 09:08

This is the absolute best way to spend your 20s tbh. You're young once.

HungryBeagle · 15/03/2024 08:54

Spectre8 · 15/03/2024 08:43

It's not just all about a mortgage, saving for rainy day if u lose ur job in another financial crash, saving for a retirement cos if u fall ill early u need back up money if unfind u csnt work to retirement age. Saving money if u want to have kids.

Noone is saying don't go on holiday and don't live your life and have every penny you have more that maybe she should balance it more

Maybe that won’t matter if the daughter decides to go and live her life on a commune in the outer Hebrides though. The point is that everyone is assuming the daughter wants to buy a house, settle down, get married, have kids and work until retirement… this might be the furthest thing from her plans. Who knows?