Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Christening DC if not religious

154 replies

ChoccieEgg49 · 14/03/2024 13:50

Friends of ours seem to Christen their DC although don't go to church. Neither seem religious that I'm aware of anyway.

I just wondered what people's thoughts are on this. Is it grabby for gifts etc, or fine, you don't need to be religious/a churchgoer?

I always assumed it was a religious thing, but maybe I'm wrong or times have changed 💁‍♀️

I'm not being judgy - just genuinely unsure

OP posts:
yourenottgebossoofme · 14/03/2024 18:40

Needmorelego · 14/03/2024 18:36

I curious about people saying that babies shouldn't be Christened because it's taking away their choice to be Christian or not. But I thought you had the Christening as a "promise" to raise them in the faith but if they decide they want to be a fully fledged Christian they have to have their Confirmation ceremony - which is usually done at the age of 12 or so but could be done when older.
Have I got that wrong?

It depends on the denomination- the C of E works as you say,

others do a ‘dedication’ type thing then baptise once they are old enough to believe in their own right,

others don’t do anything until they are older- because they need to have developed their own faith

(they are often the denominations who don’t place so much importance on original sin, so there is no danger to the child by not baptising them asap.

Needmorelego · 14/03/2024 18:36

I curious about people saying that babies shouldn't be Christened because it's taking away their choice to be Christian or not. But I thought you had the Christening as a "promise" to raise them in the faith but if they decide they want to be a fully fledged Christian they have to have their Confirmation ceremony - which is usually done at the age of 12 or so but could be done when older.
Have I got that wrong?

yourenottgebossoofme · 14/03/2024 18:36

Tempnamechng · 14/03/2024 18:15

The thing is the churches own the schools. Religious schools don't receive the same funding as state schools. The church communities / congregations pay towards the upkeep of the schools and provide staff / volunteers to carry out special lessons, Masses and pastoral care. Its wrong to push out Christian children by pretending your dc is Christian ( many faith schools are oversubscribed).

All children are Christian children as far as God is concerned.

For anyone claiming to be a Christian to object to a child being brought into a state of Grace by baptism is utterly absurd.

This is why all children can be baptised, because according to scripture they all should be.

Diamondshmiamond · 14/03/2024 18:23

I don't go to church, but I do have some spiritual belief. Dp is an atheist. We settled on a blessing in church (not a Christening, theres thanks given to God and prayers, but no pledge to bring dc up in christian faith).

I'd prayed to have children, so it felt a suitable way for me to give thanks. That particular church is also a special place to me as dm is buried there, and I was christened there, so I wanted it there rather than somewhere random. I do feel a bit guilty that I don't go to church, just the fun stuff like Carol concerts, but I definitely wanted some service for dc there and a blessing felt like a compromise.

Flyingsquirrelr · 14/03/2024 18:20

To me it’s a religious thing . I was brought up in a religious home but am not religious anymore - DC are not Christened

LlynTegid · 14/03/2024 18:18

I understand why baptism to please grandparents happens. I don't like it being done as the start of trying to get into a good school, to me it is akin to obtaining something by deception.

I supported the law that allowed non-religious venues for weddings.

Mumof2NDers · 14/03/2024 18:17

I’m an atheist so didn’t get married in church or have either of the DC’s christened. I’m actually a little annoyed that my parents had me christened but I guess it was the “done thing” in the 70’s 🤷‍♀️

Noseybookworm · 14/03/2024 18:16

Lots of people don't go to church but that doesn't mean that they don't believe in God. Sometimes it's just family tradition and a nice occasion to celebrate and for everyone to see the baby. Each to their own I think!

Tempnamechng · 14/03/2024 18:15

coureur · 14/03/2024 17:26

@Tempnamechng I don't think its wrong to jump through hoops, even if they are complete nonsense, to get your child into your local school. All these CoE schools and Catholic schools are 90%+ funded by taxpayers - the actual funding provided by the church itself is nominal and sometimes zero as the church just owns the buildings. How would you feel if your taxpayer-funded local hospital, or GP, prioritised patients of a particular religion?

If you live in a rural area chances are your local school is CofE and there is no other choice.

The thing is the churches own the schools. Religious schools don't receive the same funding as state schools. The church communities / congregations pay towards the upkeep of the schools and provide staff / volunteers to carry out special lessons, Masses and pastoral care. Its wrong to push out Christian children by pretending your dc is Christian ( many faith schools are oversubscribed).

CatamaranViper · 14/03/2024 18:05

I was raised Catholic and DH is an atheist. We weren't sure how we were going to raise DS.
We had him baptised. I was still a believer at the time but my faith was massively waning. I'm now agnostic and DS does not go to Catholic school because it feels wrong to push him into a religion that neither of us believe in. I've massively changed my view on religion all together now so DS can make up his own mind.

Tarantella6 · 14/03/2024 18:04

My mum would have been devastated if we hadn't had dc christened. We're not religious (and neither are any of our godparents!) but it was a pretty harmless way of keeping her happy.

AllPrincessAnneshorses · 14/03/2024 18:00

It's hypocritical if you have no faith and dishonest if you have no intention of keeping the promises made. And no, 'teaching them to be good people ' doesn't count.

Gettingonmygoat · 14/03/2024 17:58

All for show, SM, gifts and the party just like baby showers and gender reveal parties.

CutthroatDruTheViolent · 14/03/2024 17:30

I've known people do it because there was a family expectation, they didn't give a shit but admitted it was worth it for the gifts.

And yes, I judge them for that.

Mountainpika · 14/03/2024 17:28

I wasn't christened. My parents said it was my choice when I grew up. I never have been. Never even considered church wedding. Register office wedding, sons not christened. Husband and I both atheists.

coureur · 14/03/2024 17:26

@Tempnamechng I don't think its wrong to jump through hoops, even if they are complete nonsense, to get your child into your local school. All these CoE schools and Catholic schools are 90%+ funded by taxpayers - the actual funding provided by the church itself is nominal and sometimes zero as the church just owns the buildings. How would you feel if your taxpayer-funded local hospital, or GP, prioritised patients of a particular religion?

If you live in a rural area chances are your local school is CofE and there is no other choice.

weegiemum · 14/03/2024 17:22

I didn't have my children christened. I'm a Christian.

It was more important to us that our children chose for themselves. It's up to them if they want to follow the same path.

So we had them "dedicated" when they were small. At age 16 both dd1 and ds opted to be baptised in our church by full immersion. Dh was able to be part of the baptism for dd1 and me for ds.

Dd2 thinks it's all a load of bunk and doesn't want a baptism (she's now 20). Her choice.

I'm so glad our kids were able to decide for themselves!

RaininSummer · 14/03/2024 17:21

If not religious it is an extreme odd and pretty disrespectful thing to do in my mind.

Tempnamechng · 14/03/2024 17:17

Whist I think Christenings and Baptisms are important parts of family cultures, I also think its wrong for someone who declares themselves atheist to Christian or Baptise their children. Its appropriation and 9 times out of 10 there will be a difficult to get into RC school with an outstanding rating as the motivation.

GR8GAL · 14/03/2024 17:15

In the cases I've seen, its to get kids into schools. In Ireland, obviously there aren't enough Educate Together type schools, so kids have to be baptised to get in. I'd rather home school than expose my own to that nonsense.

coureur · 14/03/2024 17:13

We are not religious however if the infants school in our village was oversubscribed we certainly would have christened DCs as it prioritises children christened in the parish over others. So basically, if it ever gets to the point of being oversubscribed, a child who doesn't live in the village but was baptised in the church would get priority over a local child.

Which I find insane - a publicly-funded school, and the only one in the area, can legally prioritise children of one religion over another.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 14/03/2024 17:09

Some people are Agnostic - they don't know for sure in their mind whether there is or isn't a God. So, if there isn't, it doesn't make a difference whether their child is baptised or not, but if there is, it's worthwhile doing it; kind of a Theological Risk Assessment with

no baptism+no God = no problem,
no baptism+God = major problem,
baptism+no God = no problem,
baptism+God = all is good (with the caveat of a few awkward questions to answer at the Pearly Gates about why you only turned up for a baptism and didn't do the rest).

The church pretty subscribes to a similar logic

no baptism+no belief = you're all in trouble
baptism+no belief = you might be in trouble, but your kid is going to be OK
no baptism+belief = you're all in trouble and you know it
baptism+belief = all sorted
baptism as adult = great
baptism as child = better because nobody knows if something's going to go horribly wrong before they reach adulthood

Pickledprawn · 14/03/2024 17:05

It really bugs me when people do that. People use a church near me because it has lovely views 🙄 a couple I know that christened their child there recently were asked by the vicar to attend some church services and when they were telling me about it they took the piss and said "it was really weird" so disrespectful!

RawBloomers · 14/03/2024 17:03

All sorts of reasons why people who don’t seem to be religious get their children Christened.

Some people you’d never think were religious believe, they just don’t do anything public (and often little private) about it, they just sort of assume there is a God, that he is the Christian God and that’s all there is to it. Others are pressured by family. Some are unsure and think there’s no harm in it, just in case. Others are savvy about schools and want to maximise chances in the future (and personally I think it’s more disgusting that tax payer funded schools are allowed to discriminate against people who haven’t been Christened than it is for someone to try and game that system). A few might just like the ceremony and party (much like many people who get married in a church). And others may not have faith, but they do value the social bonds formed or strengthened by rituals like Christenings.

EC22 · 14/03/2024 16:53

I’m not a believer.
My in-laws aren’t. Had I not christened my children my in-laws would have worried about them going to hell, like properly worried, so that’s one reason a non religious person may do it.