Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Christening DC if not religious

154 replies

ChoccieEgg49 · 14/03/2024 13:50

Friends of ours seem to Christen their DC although don't go to church. Neither seem religious that I'm aware of anyway.

I just wondered what people's thoughts are on this. Is it grabby for gifts etc, or fine, you don't need to be religious/a churchgoer?

I always assumed it was a religious thing, but maybe I'm wrong or times have changed 💁‍♀️

I'm not being judgy - just genuinely unsure

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tengreenbottles2 · 18/03/2024 09:52

puzzledout · 15/03/2024 06:36

Oh year everyone wants 20 silver money boxes! How would it be grabby?

People may believe but not attend church, if you feel strongly don't attend. 🤷‍♀️

Haha just what I was thinking! I cherish the christening gifts my children received because they were kind and have meaning due to who gifted them, but I certainly don't feel our lives would have been in any way enhanced by receiving even more chrome-plated hairbrushes in a box, a fourth and fifth "Illustrated Children's Bible", or yet more stuffed animals😂I find it very hard to believe that gifts are the primary reason for anyone to hold a christening!

In my experience, people who christen their children despite not being religious do so mainly because "it's tradition", they want some sort of ceremony to welcome their baby (and why not? Most cultures all over the world have these sorts of rites to mark various stages of life), or they simply want an excuse for a family get-together. But not the card-shop gifts.

Reugny · 15/03/2024 13:45

Bellatrixxx · 14/03/2024 20:37

SCHOOLS SCHOOLS SCHOOLS

Depends where you are.

To get into my DD's CofE primary school it is done on EHCP, children with siblings, children of staff, and then distance from home or small business premises. The school is over subscribed and still taking children of their waiting list.

I checked and only one CofE primary school within 10 miles uses a religious requirement for some of it's places. Don't know if it is over subscribed.

The catholic primary schools take anyone.

For secondary there are some that are more religious so if you can't prove that you spent the last 5 years going to Church regularly whether the school is Catholic or just Christian (the CofE's fall under that), then you ain't getting in. There as there are others that just rely on the primary school criteria.

RaraRachael · 15/03/2024 13:26

My MiL never attended church yet got all 3 children christened en masse so that they could go to a CofE primary school. Never went near a church again.

thecrispfiend · 15/03/2024 11:08

I go to church and my son was dedicated as a baby - very low key, no god parents / party etc just a welcome to the church family with tea and cake after . My friend is not religious and they had a naming ceremony for her son at the town hall which was really lovely and a nice party afterwards. Incidentally when I started looking at primary schools it turns out the decent ones require a baptism/dedication certificate so it did come in handy!

pimplebum · 15/03/2024 10:55

I am not a church goer but my partner is so our kiddos were christened

Growing up lots of my friends and family had weddings and christenings in church but are non attendees

now there are nice alternatives to church dos using a church for such events has massively dwindled

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 15/03/2024 10:12

PaperDoIIs · 15/03/2024 07:07

There isn't just one way to be a Christian.

Yes, thank you. I am a Christian. I wasn't baptised as a baby, but as an adult (just to illustrate your point). But my point is that if you're going to do the CofE baptism thing, which presumably this refers to, then you should be prepared to follow it through. Otherwise it's like - I dunno - walking into a birthday party, picking a cherry off the cake, and walking out. Anyway, I don't really care. People are free to choose to behave in a way that aligns with their conscience. At least it gets them through the church doors, I suppose.

WickerMam · 15/03/2024 08:14

I am an atheist, and would never have had a church wedding or wanted a church funeral.

There was a little bit of prejudice in me that baulked a bit at not christening my DC though. I didn't do it, as it would be completely irrational. But it still felt a bit wrong

Deep down, I definitely had ingrained sub-conscious bias based on the observations I made as a child, that classmates who were christened had working parents, and classmates who weren't had chaotic home situations.

Abracadabra12345 · 15/03/2024 07:58

My husband- very much a nominal Christian- was keen to get our DC christened as that was his tradition. I was reluctant but as it was important to him, it was done. We had to an attend preparation class and were offered a naming ceremony if we knew we couldn't say the words in faith and I was thrilled. But then it made me start thinking about if there was a God or not and I went on to experience a wonderful encounter with Him. I became a Christian. My DH's faith has increased and we are both involved in our lovely church community. That gives us a lot of joy.

So it can work the other way round sometimes!

vdbfamily · 15/03/2024 07:53

Nevermindtheteacaps · 14/03/2024 14:27

I don't understand how anyone can know their DC are Christian when they're so young and this get them christened!!

Having your child baptised does not make them a Christian. It welcomes them into God's family formally and those present( parents, Godparents and congregation and friends) make promises to nurture them and teach them about Christian things.
If they later decide they believe this, they are' confirmed'. So they confirm that they actually want to continue along the path their parents have chosen for them .
Some Christian parents choose to wait for their children to decide they want to be baptized themselves but as baptism is symbolic, personally I don't think it matters when it happens.
In my experience, most families coming to the church for baptism have a pretty good reason. One of the parents may have a strong faith but stopped going to church as partner dies not go. Some families have a strong tradition of baptism at local parish church where all the family have been Christened for hundreds of years. I think it would be quite unusual for a couple who were both atheists or even agnostic to ask for their child to be baptised.

yourenottgebossoofme · 15/03/2024 07:18

RawBloomers · 15/03/2024 06:18

This is the parents of the children paying, not the church. Most schools encourage parents to donate money to the school to enhance provision, often in ways that make parents think it’s pretty much mandatory. Schools with better off intakes tend to ask for and receive more money from parents. That church schools often do it to a greater extent is just another example of their abuse of their ability to discriminate and manipulate their intake in a way that hoards provision for the better off.

Edited

The money goes to the parish, not the school- the parish is asking for the money, not the school.

So the church is paying X amount for the schools, and trying to recoup some of that from the parents.

PaperDoIIs · 15/03/2024 07:07

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 14/03/2024 23:13

I think if you're not prepared to bring your dch up as Christians then it's hypocritical to get them baptised - along the lines of taking your marriage vows with no intention of being faithful. I went to my first CofE baptism recently and found what they were expected to promise a bit alarming! Personally, I wouldn't be able to agree to all that if I wasn't prepared to see it through, and go to church etc.

There isn't just one way to be a Christian.

MsSquiz · 15/03/2024 06:47

DH and I aren't religious but have christened DD1 and DD2 will be christened at Easter.
His family are religious (sister is a vicar) so we do the church ceremony for them and the get together afterwards for us.
It's a nice occasion for both families to come together.

puzzledout · 15/03/2024 06:36

ChoccieEgg49 · 14/03/2024 13:50

Friends of ours seem to Christen their DC although don't go to church. Neither seem religious that I'm aware of anyway.

I just wondered what people's thoughts are on this. Is it grabby for gifts etc, or fine, you don't need to be religious/a churchgoer?

I always assumed it was a religious thing, but maybe I'm wrong or times have changed 💁‍♀️

I'm not being judgy - just genuinely unsure

Oh year everyone wants 20 silver money boxes! How would it be grabby?

People may believe but not attend church, if you feel strongly don't attend. 🤷‍♀️

RawBloomers · 15/03/2024 06:35

@yourenottgebossoofme & @IngridPrice Sorry, I’ve directed that post at the wrong people.

RawBloomers · 15/03/2024 06:18

yourenottgebossoofme · 14/03/2024 21:46

@IngridPrice has somewhat of a point- The RC church does expect parents to pay towards ‘land costs’ or ‘building funds’ for schools-

at DS school it was £40 per child (can’t remember if it was termly or what)- given to the school to be handed on to the parish.

It isn’t forced, just one of those things they ask for, like food donations or collection money.

This is the parents of the children paying, not the church. Most schools encourage parents to donate money to the school to enhance provision, often in ways that make parents think it’s pretty much mandatory. Schools with better off intakes tend to ask for and receive more money from parents. That church schools often do it to a greater extent is just another example of their abuse of their ability to discriminate and manipulate their intake in a way that hoards provision for the better off.

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 14/03/2024 23:13

I think if you're not prepared to bring your dch up as Christians then it's hypocritical to get them baptised - along the lines of taking your marriage vows with no intention of being faithful. I went to my first CofE baptism recently and found what they were expected to promise a bit alarming! Personally, I wouldn't be able to agree to all that if I wasn't prepared to see it through, and go to church etc.

IngridPrice · 14/03/2024 22:57

I don’t remember in some cases these so called donations being resquests at times but more like demands from the RC schools, especially if you gave one child one week the donation one week and not the other child till the following some teachers tried putting them in detention for forgetting 😡

USaYwHatNow · 14/03/2024 22:02

So I never went to Church as a child however my brother and I were both christened. My brother grew up atheist and I grew up believing in 'something' but not sure what. My sister was not and still had not been christened, yet attended church regularly! My mother is a firm believer that God created the world, Dad not so much. Mum believes that God only gives us what we can handle, Dad believes there can be no God when there's so much suffering in the world.

My parents were married in a church, I was later christened in that church and my husband and I were married there. To me, it was really important that my marriage was a religious ceremony. My husband is atheist.

When our son was born, I reconnected with my faith in God and started to go to church as I wanted to explore having my son christened. It felt like the right thing to do and my husband supported it. He was happy to come to church with me but I wanted to go on my own to explore my faith again and we had meetings with our local vicar and agreed to have our son christened.

I think different people have different journeys and just because you don't 'think' they're Christian, doesn't mean they're not.

ILoveSalmonSpread · 14/03/2024 21:57

We didn't christen our children.
Religion means nothing to us. However, I find it bizarre that people want Christenings when they never set foot inside a church.

Yes, each to their own but to me it sounds like an Insta moment or a present grabbing moment.

Religious families may wish to ignore what I've said.

NannyR · 14/03/2024 21:55

yourenottgebossoofme · 14/03/2024 21:39

Yes- there is variation in interpretation. Some definitely argue that infant baptism is good, but not necessary (based on a move away from Catholic tradition at the reformation I think).

To my reading the ‘good but not necessary’ interpretation seems correct- but that isn’t the one I’ve ever heard expressed by clergy.

Personally I think ‘good (ish) people go to Heaven whatever they do or don’t believe religion wise’, and I don’t think I really believe in hell as an actual entity at all…

I think we are on the same page then!
In my experience, many Anglican clergy don't agree with infant baptism being necessary though.

yourenottgebossoofme · 14/03/2024 21:53

PaperDoIIs · 14/03/2024 21:51

@yourenottgebossoofme I don't disagree on that point. DD's primary asked for it (went up to £60 a term-from £60 a year when she started which we always paid- ..yeah right!) and her high school also asks for it. However, that's for the 10% or extras, not the whole thing.

Yes exactly, sorry I thought you were saying they never asked for any money.

yourenottgebossoofme · 14/03/2024 21:52

Clearinguptheclutter · 14/03/2024 21:08

This.
I’m Christian and wanted my kids christened.
my (somewhat annoyingly principled, atheist) DH couldn’t promise to bring them up in the Christian faith. So we didn’t.

My atheist wife said she wasn’t bothered because it was all made up and meaningless- she said the only meaning to her was in the fact it was important to me, so she would do it to honour that.

PaperDoIIs · 14/03/2024 21:51

@yourenottgebossoofme I don't disagree on that point. DD's primary asked for it (went up to £60 a term-from £60 a year when she started which we always paid- ..yeah right!) and her high school also asks for it. However, that's for the 10% or extras, not the whole thing.

PaperDoIIs · 14/03/2024 21:48

@IngridPrice ,interesting since cofunding of catholic schools started in 1944. Unless you're not in England, in which case I apologise.

Surroundedbyfools · 14/03/2024 21:46

I think a lot of ppl that I know Just do it for

  1. a party
  2. they were christened themselves
  3. to get into a Catholic school

my DH is Catholic but not practicing. I myself do not believe so neither of my kids have been christened. Should they choose to join a faith as an adult/teenager then I will support their choice but I feel it’s their choice to make.

Swipe left for the next trending thread