Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Work trying to make me do the work without promoting me- AIBU to say no?

59 replies

ThatsNotMyJob · 14/03/2024 10:50

I’ve worked at my job for 5 years. I love it, I feel like I’m actively doing something good, my boss is great and it’s really flexible around family/kids. The only issue is it’s not the best paid, I could get more if I was willing to change, but I like the company and I’m happy to be paid less and have a happier life.
a few months ago my manager told me she’s leaving. Not the most shocking news, pay isn’t great so lots of people leave to increase their wages. I spoke to my manager and her manager and we agreed that I would like to have her role, and that we could look at doing it as a quick internal vacancy. Did the interview and was told they’d like me to take on the role! Great! Then this week, the senior manager has told me that there’s a recruitment freeze and they’re not able to replace my manager. She’s asked me to take on the responsibilities of the role, without the title/promotion or pay increase. The company has form for doing this and then not replacing the person because the work is being done.

I’m so upset. Would I be unreasonable to refuse to take on any of her work at all? Or am I just cutting my nose off to spite my face and I should suck it up and take on the extra work with the theory that it’ll put me in good stead for when they can do pay rises? I like my job and don’t want to leave, but I don’t want them to take advantage of me

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Unexpectedlysinglemum · 16/03/2024 23:00

Then you can use this experience and interim title on your applications for jobs elsewhere

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 16/03/2024 23:00

They could probably pay an honorarium little bit extra and give you an 'interim' role - can you ask for that? And some of your current work to be reduced?

Bluegray2 · 16/03/2024 22:44

If they at least gave you the title you would then have that on your CV so in a few months you could apply for a better job and then be able to get a big pay rise…..or would that be even possible?

ThatsNotMyJob · 16/03/2024 22:32

Thanks everyone. I’ll get my shit together and have a proper discussion with them on Monday and make it clear that I either get the job with it’s duties, title and pay. Or I don’t and I won’t be doing it if I don’t get it.

OP posts:
SleepyRich · 15/03/2024 18:01

How cheeky! I would just express that you're still interested in the role, that you're disappointed to hear the company has suddenly frozen promotions/recruitment after you were interviewed and offered the promotion. Please let know when you're able to promote me as discussed but for now I'm happy to continue in my current role....

susansaucepan · 15/03/2024 17:40

As someone who by the sound of it works in similar industry and has been working several years with gaps in my teams (with me doing all the work ) , I say DONT DO IT . The whole point of recruitment freezing is a financial decision. If you demonstrate that you can effectively do both jobs for your current rate , you will make the post redundant and there will be no reason to recruit to it .

Forewarned is forearmed and all that .

Crumpleton · 15/03/2024 17:27

Then this week, the senior manager has told me that there’s a recruitment freeze and they’re not able to replace my manager.

I'd just reply that you totally understand and are happy staying in and continuing to do the work of your present role.

EmmaInScotland · 15/03/2024 17:22

enchantedsquirrelwood · 14/03/2024 12:25

Where I work, that is the norm - you apply for a promotion, based on demonstrating that you are already performing above your corporate title/role

Surely it should be on the potential to perform above, not doing it already? Maybe in some aspects, but a promotions should allow room to grow as well.

I think it depends on a number of things. I work in Higher Education, in the professional services. It's very rare that higher graded jobs come up, however, you can apply centrally if you have been working consistently above the expected responsibilities, due to either someone leaving, or the way we work changing. Due to the pandemic, a lot of our work changed significantly (and we had staff leaving), so I was able to apply on both aspects. It wasn't easy, but it gave me the pay raise for what I' was already doing - when the Uni just didn't have the vacancies in the field in which I work.
I fully get that in other companies it's your potential to do something that can (and probably should in all fields) get you the promotion opportunity.

Spinet · 15/03/2024 15:54

I think I would tell them you're not doing it as an open question. Sort of 'what's in it for me?' Partly because you don't then have to just say out and out no. You can say whatever answer they give (experience? Goodwill?) is not enough of an incentive for you and you never know they might come back with an actual pay offer.

mathanxiety · 15/03/2024 15:50

ThatsNotMyJob · 14/03/2024 11:34

@IncompleteSenten no, last year someone left and we amalgamated her role into my team’s’ responsibilities. They haven’t even mentioned replacing her since, that’s why I’m so hesitant about this

for those asking- I’d be happy to do the role for the pay increase, I just don’t want to do it for free? Sounds like I’m being reasonable in that decision though. I wasn’t sure if this was how things were done and I was being naive but it looks like they’re taking the piss and seeing if I’ll let them

You're being reasonable.

You need to document the situation so they won't let you go/ edge you out in the short term or long term on 'business interests' grounds.

Compose a memo outlining the chronology and what you understand of the 'offer' you've had. Ask for confirmation/ acknowledgement of your understanding of the situation.

They may be flexible, and you may feel they're 'nice', but they're actually trading on that to an extent that can be described as taking the piss.

I'd be looking for another job if I were you. You know you're capable of the managerial responsibilities, and your current employer is surely not the only one offering a degree of flexibility?

Bluegray2 · 15/03/2024 15:35

So basically more work and responsibilities without extra pay, no, I wouldn’t do it, I would possibly do it for six months if I at least got the title / promotion without the extra pay but with no change at all, no I wouldnt

how much extra pay would the promotion have meant?

Donzybugs · 15/03/2024 14:32

I was in this situation a few years ago in a public sector organisation, did the additional duties for a couple of years with no additional pay and formal recognition. Told informally that it would put me in a good position when they could create a higher scale post. When they finally did get authorisation for the higher post they told me they had to advertise and someone else told me they had been promised the job as they threatened to leave. I was fuming at this as they trusted my loyalty and thought I wouldn't leave.

I left before the interviews for the promotion as I was offered a few other roles in the private sector. Better paid and far more flexible than I imagined. No regrets, wish I'd left sooner!

Bookkeepermum · 15/03/2024 14:12

How do you know you wouldn't be as happy if not happier somewhere else where you'll be paid a better wage? Most places are flexible with family now. I would seriously look elsewhere.
Know your worth! Then add tax ;)

ColleenDonaghy · 15/03/2024 14:11

The only way I'd even remotely consider this is if they'll give the job to someone else who you know will be awful and make your life a misery. If there's no one like that on the team, then I'd say you're not willing to take on extra responsibility at your current salary level, but that you'd be very happy to if they matched your manager's pay.

Outofideas79 · 15/03/2024 13:59

Depends what sector you're in. If it was private sector I'd be more inclined to 'help out', but set out strict parameters in timings. But I think private sector, you have no chance of getting that promotion or wage uplift. There are key role being left gapped due to the public sector pay freeze. Its the stupidest, arbitrary way of saving money, and just puts pressure on the remaining staff. Meaning they leave as well. I don't see this recruitment freeze being lifted any time soon.

EmmaInScotland · 15/03/2024 13:28

Did they formally offer & have you accepted? If yes & you're in a Union I'd contact them

poetryandwine · 14/03/2024 13:38

If you would still be interested in the higher role, properly compensated, I think@Mikkismum has suggested a good way forward.

But I might want to leave

CaramelMac · 14/03/2024 13:32

Nope, I wouldn’t do it.

If she hadn’t handed her notice in the money would be there to keep paying her and you, so now they get to keep her salary and still get the same amount of work done.

MrWilyFoxIsBack · 14/03/2024 13:30

yanbu.

It is really common, sneaky behaviour by employers .

Happened to me a few years ago - My boss quit due to overwork/stress imposed by his new manager (my manager told them the job wasn’t worth the aggro and pitiful bonus). I had joined the team as a more first-level supervisor because it was less stress than the management jobs I’d had prior to having kids. But as it was clear I was capable of stepping up, I was offered a promotion - not my old manager’s role, but a new mid-management made-up job which was all the crap bits of my manager’s job but without the power to be able to make things happen PLUS all the things in my current job too. They didn’t disclose what the new salary would be.

When I pointed out this was a very shitty job offer and said no thank you, I’m happy in my current role, the company went ahead with their plan of not replacing my manager and hired someone a level above (a very senior “won’t get hands dirty” manager on about £150k whose approach was depressingly all about “mobilising people” and “lean change management”.

It was immediately clear that the employer decided just to dump all the work on me regardless I had said no, several times. I pointed this out to HR, and to this new manager and to their manager. I could probably have argued harder that they had been totally unreasonable but actually I just wanted to get the hell out of there by that stage.

Management were “disappointed” when I quit.

I don’t really understand why employers think we are such dumb suckers really!

Yellowroseblooms · 14/03/2024 13:26

I think @Eleganz is utterly right. They want you to do extra work and take on extra responsibility without the title or any more money. Only a mug would agree to this.

Eleganz · 14/03/2024 13:19

You have two options here depending on whether you want to stay or not.

If you want to stay long term then refuse the role without any pay rise because you simply will never get it. Say you are interested but that as the previous role holder was at grade/pay band X then it is only fair that you are offered similar remuneration for doing the same role.

If you want to leave accept the opportunity with 2 conditions: you can use the title "Acting" while doing it and that the situation will be reviewed in 6 months (this last one won't happen, but it suggests you aren't a pushover). You then start looking for new roles outside the using your new title and hopefully leverage a better salary elsewhere as a result. Hopefully you'll be on your way before the 6 months elapses.

I'd suggest the second option - I wouldn't want to work for an organisation that acts like this.

DancesWithBadgers · 14/03/2024 13:19

Something similar to this happened to me in my last role. A hell of a lot of internal changes and churn meant I was consistently asked to step in to complete tasks and projects that were technically a grade higher - but for no extra pay or the actual role (messy internal politics and roles not dissimilar to your recruitment freeze meant they never actually put me into the role). All with so many compliments on how capable I am and what a great development opportunity all this extra work was. left for a job that actually wanted to pay me properly and with a job title that reflected my skills. When I left my manager was STILL going on about all the great development opportunities I could have and what a fab employee I was blah blah.

Taught me that talk is very cheap in these situations, my finances and progression prospects cannot improve with compliments. In some situations you’re valued because they can get the same work out of you cheaper and so why would they change it? Don’t get backed into this.

Blanketpolicy · 14/03/2024 13:18

How will you feel if someone else in your department takes the opportunity and you end up reporting to them and they get promoted later once the freeze is over?

I would discuss it as a temporary acting up role for X months with the expectation it is made permanent/salary discussed at that point. Make sure what ever you agreement is documented with HR.

StBernie · 14/03/2024 13:15

YANBU and I’ve been put in a very similar situation. I was offered the pay rise and promotion but then a couple of weeks later they said they couldn’t offer the pay rise after all but still wanted me to take on the extra responsibilities. I refused it. Those companies are trying to take advantage and we are worth more than that.