Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop opening door for sister

89 replies

thegroundskeeper · 14/03/2024 09:54

My younger sister (22) and I live with my mum.

Sister can be unbelievably rude, unreasonable and aggressive so we don't have much to do with each right now to keep the peace. However, she keeps misplacing her front door keys!

I always let her in, but she is so rude I don't feel inclined to keep doing it. This is what happened last night:

Bell rings, I open door
Sister stomps past me and slams her bedroom door

Me, quietly: Are you going to say thank you?
Sister, screaming: OMG I just got home. FUCK OFF!!!

AIBU to go on strike and stop letting her in? That will just get me in massive trouble though. Putting a key under a plant pot or welcome mat doesn't work as that goes missing in a day or so as well. Mum won't do anything. FWIW yes I suspect she's neurodiverse but that's no excuse for the really personal insults and aggression. She doesn't reflect/apologise later.

OP posts:
usernother · 14/03/2024 12:29

Picklestop · 14/03/2024 10:13

I really couldn’t leave my 22 year old sister standing outside, what if she wanders off and something happens. But I suspect she has her key and is just too lazy to get it out of her bag. I would maybe take my time getting to the door.

She's 22, not a child. She's unlikely to just wander off.

I'd ignore her OP and give headphones as reason. She sounds absolutely horrible.

moonfacer · 14/03/2024 12:26

Gettingonmygoat · 14/03/2024 12:20

People can just be rude, arrogant and entitled. Not everything is a mental health issue. In this case the sister may just be a bitch.

Exactly!

CactusClaire · 14/03/2024 12:24

Pop your earphones in when shes due home and turn that music up!

Gettingonmygoat · 14/03/2024 12:20

WatchandWaitorNot · 14/03/2024 09:58

I kind of think YANBU but that level of unprovoked rudeness is off the scale for someone that age, so I doubt it would even change her behaviour as it must be some form of mental health issue. Stop doing it if you want to avoid being shouted at, but don’t think of it as a way to change things.

Have you and your Mum talked to her or each other about getting her help?

Is she similarly rude to your Mum?

People can just be rude, arrogant and entitled. Not everything is a mental health issue. In this case the sister may just be a bitch.

exexpat · 14/03/2024 12:15

There are obviously more major issues going on here, but just on the losing keys thing - when DD was a teenager she used to keep losing/forgetting/being unable to find her keys at the bottom of the tote bag full of crap she always carried around. What worked for her was putting the keys on a carabiner ring attached to the strap of her bag, or to the loop of her jeans if she went out without the bag - she could open the door without taking the keys off the ring and she always knew where they were. Something like this might work well: https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/386731211301?itmmeta=01HRYE35YG1YDYZC77A35H975A&hash=item5a0af9fa25:g:PbEAAOSwMKhlu0Zj&itmprp=enc%3AAQAJAAAA8EByjsTq87%2BAK0PHQXk04cWZ2IsrTCQvIHMkqGTU3tCptEPoWFLCEoyAwmU8by2%2BJ0UF7ef%2F8prxNc0tI7b7%2FX3BgGLi8TZwnGVPA7e8mA9w%2FA4NNm7goZaRd8jVjSD7Mum8hbGQFiNDng%2FpDlauf5W8gd60G4SrnchkoYN2bvr9sN4WxfCXtqWN1B5OQb42VO8F2Mh2Y6Z9HtHdXejhWJ6dDmy2qVg%2Bn3brFnwrTU5cCe18ApkdFWS2jN5tD2BlxCSALrwmEBqS5uDfj742QYi6ayQIFbjXmILvUsjqgO4uvnTxxYRhUtTCrKSaN1JWlA%3D%3D%7Ctkp%3ABFBM1N-Mzsdj

But if part of her neurodiversity is some form of pathological demand avoidance, she will probably just reject all practical suggestions.

2PCS Retractable Extendable Reel Stretch Pull Cord Spring Keyring Key Chain Clip | eBay

Very strong and durable pull back recoil. 1 x 1/2/4 Pcs Silver Recoil Key Ring. When you do not use it, let it go, it will be automatically rebound to the waist, in case of avoidingkeys lost because of frequent using.

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/386731211301?itmmeta=01HRYE35YG1YDYZC77A35H975A&hash=item5a0af9fa25:g:PbEAAOSwMKhlu0Zj&itmprp=enc%3AAQAJAAAA8EByjsTq87%2BAK0PHQXk04cWZ2IsrTCQvIHMkqGTU3tCptEPoWFLCEoyAwmU8by2%2BJ0UF7ef%2F8prxNc0tI7b7%2FX3BgGLi8TZwnGVPA7e8mA9w%2FA4NNm7goZaRd8jVjSD7Mum8hbGQFiNDng%2FpDlauf5W8gd60G4SrnchkoYN2bvr9sN4WxfCXtqWN1B5OQb42VO8F2Mh2Y6Z9HtHdXejhWJ6dDmy2qVg%2Bn3brFnwrTU5cCe18ApkdFWS2jN5tD2BlxCSALrwmEBqS5uDfj742QYi6ayQIFbjXmILvUsjqgO4uvnTxxYRhUtTCrKSaN1JWlA%3D%3D%7Ctkp%3ABFBM1N-Mzsdj

theothercatpurred · 14/03/2024 12:06

A key safe is a good idea, only she'll probably forget to put the key in it.

Worth a try if not too expensive.

theothercatpurred · 14/03/2024 12:06

I don't carry keys anymore as I lose so many of them, it's a security risk.

I have ADHD.

No amount of leaving me locked out is going to change the fact that I have poor executive function, a shit memory and lose things all the time. Those on this thread who are suggesting locking her out to teach her a lesson - trust me, more frustrating than living with someone who loses things all the time is actually BEING someone who loses keys, wallets, important documents, bags etc etc all the time. I cannot trust myself to hold on to anything.

As to her being so rude to you, no that's not acceptable, of course not. It may be general young person selfishness, or it could be she's masking when out in the world, and it all comes out when she gets home. My mum's on the spectrum, and she would work all day in a professional environment where she was well respected for being a supportive boss.

Then she'd come home and the first thing she'd say to us kids was to have a go at us.

Years later, I now understand that it was to do with the stress of masking all day, and that it all came out when she got home, plus her lack of empathy meant she didn't understand the impact it had on us. That doesn't take away how it felt to be on the receiving end of it, but I understand better that she couldn't help it, to an extent.

I would avoid challenging your DSis when she'd just got in. If you want to discuss it with her, do it another time.

Manage your own expectations e.g. don't expect her to come say hi like an NT person would, let her decompress when she gets in, without judgement. Tell her you plan to do this from now on, but in return she needs to understand it's not on to shout at you.

thegroundskeeper · 14/03/2024 12:03

Dontblameitonsunshine · 14/03/2024 11:55

Why don’t you move out? It would reduce pressure on your poor mother

We actually quite like living together!

OP posts:
Abouttimeforanamechange · 14/03/2024 12:00

Just open the door,

It's not 'just' opening the door, is it. OP has to interrupt whatever she's doing, go from wherever she is in the house to the front door.

OP, what does your sister do if both you and your mother are out when she gets home?

Dontblameitonsunshine · 14/03/2024 11:55

Why don’t you move out? It would reduce pressure on your poor mother

TheSnowyOwl · 14/03/2024 11:52

Being nd doesn’t excuse her for being rude although it could account for endlessly losing her keys.

I would say to your mum that she needs to get a key safe and then stop answering the door.

Allfur · 14/03/2024 11:52

I would move out, find your own place, your rules

Peekaboobo · 14/03/2024 11:48

I wouldn't answer it.

No need to lie and pretend you didn't hear. Lyings wrong. Just don't answer it and if she asks you tell her why.

LookItsMeAgain · 14/03/2024 11:46

I would sit Sister down at dinner time (assuming you eat together) and simply say to both Sister and Mother -

"Going forwards, due to the horrible attitude and manners I am on the receiving end with Sister, I am no longer going to be opening the front door or any door to her. She has her own key, she will have to take more care of it so that she can let herself in now. Also, this is not an opening to a discussion about this. I'm simply letting you both know what I will and will not do any more."

Should take about 2 minutes to state clearly. Then don't open the door any more. The first few times, it'll be hard to ignore the banging so if you're at home, I'd recommend getting noise cancelling headphones to block out the noise, or better yet, be out yourself. I guarantee that on the first day when it's raining, if she gets stuck outside, she will not forget her key any more.

moonfacer · 14/03/2024 11:42

SpringSprungALeak · 14/03/2024 11:24

@moonfacer

i didn't say it was did I?

I just asked you if you could stop calling her a twat. There's just no need for it.

I wasn't conflating the two.

But she does sound like a twat.

Couldyounot · 14/03/2024 11:31

Don't put any keys out. Let her screech and bang all she likes. Repeat as required.

TempleOfBloom · 14/03/2024 11:30

Just open the door

Don’t interact or demand thanks.

It will take up less of your energy.

And take less energy than listening to her banging and yelling til your Mum does it.

Just open the door, don’t give it head space. Focus on saving to become independent and move out.

SpringSprungALeak · 14/03/2024 11:24

moonfacer · 14/03/2024 11:15

Her sister’s mean behaviour is not a symptom of neurodiversity.

YABU for conflating the two.

@moonfacer

i didn't say it was did I?

I just asked you if you could stop calling her a twat. There's just no need for it.

I wasn't conflating the two.

Alwaysdieting · 14/03/2024 11:21

She sounds a nightmare to be honest and as some have said she is 22 not 2. She must know right from wrong she works and has lots of friends. I think she is just taking the mick out of OP and is a nasty women who has been left to be so.
What happens if OP isnt in?
Does the mum answer the door then. The mum isnt nice either leaving Op to answer the door alm the time.

veryawkwardohno · 14/03/2024 11:19

moonfacer · 14/03/2024 11:15

Her sister’s mean behaviour is not a symptom of neurodiversity.

YABU for conflating the two.

It's literally impossible to know what. Without knowing exactly what the mean behaviour is, what's going on in general, how the people around her react to her when she is struggling etc but people don't always struggle in ways that are healthy and people with a social communication difficulty are very likely to... struggle with social communication. And struggling with emotional regulation is very common.
It's literally seems like people only think it's ok to be ND if the difficulties as a result of that are palatable.

moonfacer · 14/03/2024 11:15

SpringSprungALeak · 14/03/2024 11:13

@moonfacer

the OP's sister is suspected of being ND.

could you please stop calling her a twat.

Her sister’s mean behaviour is not a symptom of neurodiversity.

YABU for conflating the two.

SpringSprungALeak · 14/03/2024 11:13

moonfacer · 14/03/2024 10:17

The most logical thing would be for Op to ignore the twat.

@moonfacer

the OP's sister is suspected of being ND.

could you please stop calling her a twat.

thegroundskeeper · 14/03/2024 11:08

veryawkwardohno · 14/03/2024 11:03

If you think she is autistic I think you should just leave her alone when she comes in instead of passive agressively saying "are you going to say thankyou"
I get so overwhelmed a lot of the time I easily and just need to be alone and not spoken to or have to try to think of the things I am supposed to say I could and have forgotten to say thank you to someone opening the door.
obviously she shouldn't be rude. But when you're incredibly overwhelmed and someone criticises you it really can feel like a much bigger deal at that time and feels like an attack and just way too much.
i think people like to think they are accepting of autistic people until really basic things happen like autistic people struggling with social communication- which is literally the main thing about autism, and they they get offended.

It's constant meanness though and not limited to stressful moments. I understand what you're saying but I don't think being autistic is a reason to be as mean as she is.

OP posts:
thegroundskeeper · 14/03/2024 11:03

Lindy2 · 14/03/2024 10:56

How does your sister cope with other life demands? Does she work, have qualifications, go out with friends?

I'm trying to gauge if it's rudness or if the level of neurodiversity means that your sister is on high alert and in fight or flight mode a lot of the time which is causing the volatile temper.

If she coping with everything else and just useless with the key, then the rudeness and carelessness is unacceptable.

If she's not coping with life and her day is constant chaos and stress and this is just one more element of her struggles.

My ND child is younger and if she arrived home and panicked because she couldn't get in she would probably either try to break in or call the police. To her it would be a major emergency (and nothing would persuade her otherwise).

We have a keybox. I make sure that the key is put back every time it's used. She doesn't have her own keys at all. That could be a solution.

Moving out is also a solution. If she's your younger sister then you're at least mid 20s. If the dynamics in your mother's house don't work for you then you have other options. I don't think it's inappropriate to suggest that.

You can't make your mum or sister change but you can express your own independence and decide not to be part of it.

It's in between. She's working, has lots of friends and goes out a lot.

However wasn't able to complete her qualifications.

OP posts:
veryawkwardohno · 14/03/2024 11:03

If you think she is autistic I think you should just leave her alone when she comes in instead of passive agressively saying "are you going to say thankyou"
I get so overwhelmed a lot of the time I easily and just need to be alone and not spoken to or have to try to think of the things I am supposed to say I could and have forgotten to say thank you to someone opening the door.
obviously she shouldn't be rude. But when you're incredibly overwhelmed and someone criticises you it really can feel like a much bigger deal at that time and feels like an attack and just way too much.
i think people like to think they are accepting of autistic people until really basic things happen like autistic people struggling with social communication- which is literally the main thing about autism, and they they get offended.