Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you complain about this? (Police behaviour towards a black and potentially vulnerable 16-year-old girl)

259 replies

Readytoplay · 14/03/2024 01:18

TLDR at the end of the post, as this is long but I feel I have to explain the whole situation

Yesterday afternoon I was on a train, departing from a London Terminal. Just after we started moving, a ticket inspection began. The girl (who was black) in front of me didn’t have a ticket. The ticket inspector (White 40s male) was abrupt; and in my opinion rude; with the young lady who claimed she was 16 and homeless. He asked her if she could pay with a debit card, but she told him that she didn’t have one. He then asked her age and she answered 16. He then scoffed “What, you're 16 and don’t have a bank card”. (For what it’s worth I personally didn’t have a bank account until I was 17- and this was only last decade).

He then asked her where she was going. The girl responded with vague answers, such as: “a few stops” or “not far”. He then asked how she got on the train without a ticket and through the barriers. She told him that she ‘just did’. He then asked for a name and address. The first she refused to give and she repeated that she was homeless for the latter, the inspector answered ‘No you're not’, Before asking for some ID. He then left her for a moment after she claimed she didn’t have any, before coming back with an officer from BTP (also a white 40s male).

Now, I always record any encounter I have with the police directly OR if an encounter is happening in my proximity (this was literally the seat in front) so I started filming but with the camera face down so only sound would be recorded. the police officer showed his badge and began to ask for the same information as the ticket inspector. After she repeated what she had already said, he then asked for some ID, before asking what was in her bag and that he was going to search it.

I was about to intervene at this point as I was getting increasingly uncomfortable with the tone and attitude these adult men were having with this young and likely vulnerable lady. Clearly, someone else felt the same and questioned the way the situation was being approached. I then also voiced my concerns and admitted that I was recording this. The other passenger started to tell the men that they thought how they were behaving was disgusting. I commented that if a 16-year-old minor was claiming to be homeless that shouldn’t they be offering them support? They said they would if they had some identification. I tried to explain that she likely doesn’t have anything due to her circumstances and then the part that really annoyed me: “as if she is homeless, dressed in all those brands”. I.E. doubting her circumstances because was wearing a Nike sweatshirt. WTF.

It ended with the other passenger ranting at the cop, before both the guard and cop got off at the next station. And that was that. They didn’t find any ID on the girl, and all that was in her bag were clothes and other personal essentials.

The girl was left visibly shaken and upset. I tried to see if she was alright. She explained to me that she was staying with her BF. I told her of some organisations to contact if she needed any support (Shelter/ Centerpoint). Before she got off I offered to give her a fiver (normally I wouldn’t give money to strangers, but would have in this case) but she declined.

Now, I have no idea if this girl was or wasn’t homeless. But am I wrong in thinking that the behaviour of the cop/train guard was completely inappropriate? There is very little of me who feels this wasn’t racially motivated. The fact that they searched her bag and the fact that both had an abrupt and aggressive attitude toward her really felt like profiling to me. Yes, the girl could have been more cooperative with some of the questions, but the intense questioning, mixed with the dismissive attitude would have likely made most people not want to cooperate.

I am thinking of sending the recording to both the train operator and BTP to express my concerns with what I witnessed, Manly:

  1. The instant refusal to believe that this child could be homeless and the lack of support.
  2. The racial profiling of a young black female
  3. The aggressive attitude that was used throughout the situation.

I would also like to try and get the child checked up on, however, this is likely going to be difficult as I don’t know any details apart from what she told me and where she got off (which I won’t lie, was a bit further than a ‘couple of stops’) as I am worried that she hasn’t got any support. I am also a bit worried that she’s moving in with a bf as well.

TLDR: a young black girl who claimed she was homeless was aggressively Interrogated by a police officer and ticket inspector. They doubted her claims because she was wearing branded clothing. The girl was left viably shaken as a result.

What would you do?
YABU- Don’t report
YANBU- report

OP posts:
MCOut · 14/03/2024 09:00

I don’t think anybody suggesting that it was acceptable for her not to pay her fare but in my experience Londoners don’t usually have sympathy for people who get themselves into this position. If multiple people intervened, their behaviour must’ve been shocking.

I would also have been concerned about her age and would have assumed she lied and could be younger than 16. The BTP should have had a card with contact details for organisations that could provide assistance. I’d be wary of any black, mixed race or female child being removed from the train for safeguarding so I don’t think the police could’ve done that.

MariaVT65 · 14/03/2024 08:57

ChildsPosition · 14/03/2024 07:22

I have not read the thread yet, but I presume it is full of people saying there is no way this is racist, or that you are playing the ‘race card’. MN does not believe racism exists unless it involves the use of overt verbal racial slurs.

My parents (non-white) were treated appallingly by Eurostar staff once. They had boarded a carriage at the wrong end, even though a white couple had just got on the same way without censure. The guard was so rude to my parents. To me, it was obvious because they looked ‘foreign’, my mum had a head scarf on etc. But there is no way of proving this. Sometimes racism is expressed by a dirty look or a shift in tone and it is impossible to prove and nobody will believe it.

I will read the thread now and I might be pleasantly surprised, but I’m sure it will be a litany of racism denial.

No one here is saying racism doesn’t exist. Of course it does.

The situation here is that the person is question was also deliberately fare evading and should have been pulled up on it regardless of skin colour.

I once forgot to get a ticket stamped on a train in France and got pulled up on it. But I gave my name and address for the fine because I’m a genuine person. This girl’s story doesn’t add up, she said she was moving in with her boyfriend, so she could have given that address. No reason not to give her name.

She could have also been lying about her age. I used to lie about my age to charity workers in the street and say I was 16 so they’d leave me alone.

Hereyoume · 14/03/2024 08:50

So just because someone doesn't want to pay for something, you think they should get it for free.

Wow OP, you are so naive. Top tip OP, check the fingernails, guessing this "homeless" and "helpless" "child" had a manicure and clean clothes.

Why do you think every interaction between a black person and an the police is racially motivated?

How about a rude, entitled teenager fancied a free ride on a train and knew if challenged that some deluded woman would come to her "rescue" from the bad men.

How about you upload the audio on here for us to listen to. That way we have more context.

MoWiIIs · 14/03/2024 08:35

Just trying to understand how a white man, 40s, same story, would have been treated any differently?

Bunked on train
No ticket
Vague with inspector when asked
No means to pay

I'm struggling to see the age, sex and race reference.

I am a black woman.

ThePoshUns · 14/03/2024 08:32

How do you know she was actually 16? She had no ID. She could be lying about her age.
Fun fact - people lie to the police all the time.

Rosieleerose · 14/03/2024 08:20

BobbyBiscuits · 14/03/2024 07:35

If they had done nothing wrong why didn't they detain her, rather than leaving when everyone said they were being dicks?
I'd say it's more likely than not she wasn't homeless and said that to stop them sending her a fine etc. But it's not right what they did. As people say, they should signpost her to services and offer support if she said she was.

Because they didn't want the problem to escalate. Sometimes police/ticket inspectors don't have the resources to deal with extra issues that may arise and it's easier just to let it go.

Whatafustercluck · 14/03/2024 08:16

I'm fairly certain they see so much of this behaviour that it gets irritating, which probably explains their attitudes more than anything - but then, I'm a 40-something white woman living in an affluent area who has never experienced racial profling personally.

But putting all of that aside for a moment, I absolutely would report the BTP officer due to his failure to report possible safeguarding issues. Wasn't this the problem with the various grooming gangs? Police and social services failures to intervene, because young vulnerable girls were just completely written off as hopeless causes who most likely deserved what they got and knew what they were doing. This girl stated she was 'moving in with her boyfriend'. She stated she had no money and was homeless. She was travelling some distance to be with this 'boyfriend'. This 'boyfriend' could in fact be a 35 year old pimp. That's more than enough red flags for safeguarding concerns and the BTP officer has a duty of care to that girl.

Normal, happy, settled 16 year old girls don't just climb aboard a train without a ticket, without money, to travel a number of miles to move in with their boyfriend of undetermined age. She's still a minor and her vulnerability should have been clear to a police officer.

Towerofsong · 14/03/2024 08:09

I'm struggling to understand why you thought there was racial profiling?
If they didn't check anyone else's tickets and zoomed in on the black passengers that would be racial profiling. But you have said that they were checking everyone's tickets.

Or that you think they would have let a white kid off - which you cannot prove unless you saw them let a white kid off.

The inspectors attitude may have been shitty and sarcastic, but you'd be hard pressed to say it was racist.

There are enough real problems in society without inventing them, and crying racism whenever a non-white person gets into legal trouble just creates a 'cry wolf' situation which undermines the real issues.

Abeona · 14/03/2024 08:05

ThePerfectDog · 14/03/2024 07:00

If you were worried about her, you could have paid for her ticket. Not sure why if you believed her, you left her to deal with that and your only response was to start filming.

This. All these social justice warriors and their phone cameras — but ask them to pay for a homeless person's train ticket and they go strangely silent. Why didn't you jump in with your bank card, OP, and sort this poor young woman out?

LakeTiticaca · 14/03/2024 08:05

Why didn't u just pay for her ticket.then?

ApiratesaysYarrr · 14/03/2024 08:03

Of course, when she claimed to be homeless the police should have got off the train with her at the next stop and directed her to the appropriate service (or even taken her), but I would bet a reasonable amount of money that the ticket-dodger would have been extremely unhappy about that.

IWFH · 14/03/2024 07:54

I used to commute into London daily. My experience was that ticket staff used to get a fair amount of abuse from fare dodgers who lied regularly.

I don't believe their behaviour was either racist or sexist from your description. This sounds typical of transactions I've seen when the fare dodger did not co-operate and would not pay regardless of the colour or sex or age of the fare dodger. The only difference is that she was left on the train to her destination wheras in my experience they would be ejected from the train at the next station.
You helped her get away with it.

PrinnyPree · 14/03/2024 07:52

Elvis1956 · 14/03/2024 07:47

What I find odd in all this is the op records any interaction with the police or anything the police do near them.
I've been arrested several times, detained without arrest , been attacked by police officers , been kettled, been prevented from walking down certain streets without good reason,seen people seriously injured by the police and I don't record interactions with them.
You sound like the type of person who goes looking for issues and provoking trouble

Edited

You've had all this happen to you from police and you don't think all police interactions should be recorded whenever humanly possible... 🤨

hotpotlover · 14/03/2024 07:50

I think the only mistake the police did was to not escort her off the train.

PrinnyPree · 14/03/2024 07:49

Skodacool · 14/03/2024 07:32

Anyone can claim to be homeless. It’s the ticket inspector’s job to ensure everyone has paid their fare.

When did I mention it was the ticket inspectors duty? There was a police officer who was called to intervene, when they were informed she was homeless they should have treated her like a vulnerable homeless teen at that point. Do you think the police officers response to a young girl saying she's homeless was adequate?

Elvis1956 · 14/03/2024 07:47

What I find odd in all this is the op records any interaction with the police or anything the police do near them.
I've been arrested several times, detained without arrest , been attacked by police officers , been kettled, been prevented from walking down certain streets without good reason,seen people seriously injured by the police and I don't record interactions with them.
You sound like the type of person who goes looking for issues and provoking trouble

FatFemale · 14/03/2024 07:44

I dnt think the colour of her skin is relevant here.

i would have intervened, paid for her ticket and tried to offer support

i did a soup kitchen last night and a lot of the street homeless were wearing branded adidas/nike clothing

16 is extremely young. If she is homeless, she wont have bank cards etc. keep an eye out for her if you travel that route again

NotQuiteNorma · 14/03/2024 07:42

Readytoplay · 14/03/2024 02:13

I don't as I say in my OP. but I found the lack of safeguarding that a police officer refused to believe a childs claim to be homeless worrying.

I think you've got a misguided idea of what a child is.

At 16 You can give consent and have sex.
You can be prosecuted for having sex with someone who is under 16.
You can apply for your own passport with a parent’s consent.
You can change your name.
You can be prosecuted for neglecting a child in your care.

You can also be prosecuted for fare evasion.

ApiratesaysYarrr · 14/03/2024 07:38

I commute on a 1hr train journey daily, and regularly overhear conversations like this when the ticket inspectors come round - similar stories with vagueness about where they got on/where they will get off, that they don't have money on them etc. They have these conversations with men and women of all ages and ethnicities.

SevenSeasOfRhye · 14/03/2024 07:38

There are two parts to this, really.

Ticket inspector - he was just doing his job. The young woman had boarded the train without a ticket and with no plans/means to buy one on the train. She must have known there'd be a risk of her being challenged for this. He is not a social worker, he is a low-paid customer service worker; his remit in this aspect of his role is simply to ensure everyone on the train is paying for the right to be there. I travel on the train a lot and the ticket inspectors will challenge anyone without a ticket, or even without the correct ticket, regardless of race.

Police - this is where there should have been proactive intervention if the woman appeared to be vulnerable. They shouldn't have searched her bag in the middle of a train carriage. He was being unreasonable and it does sound as though racism was in play.

Anameisaname · 14/03/2024 07:37

I think you report it OP because it sounds like this girl was vulnerable and needed support which was not forthcoming. Sounds like a county lines or something.
But I can't tell how much race played into this but I am worried about the welfare of this child.

takemeonnnn · 14/03/2024 07:37

YABU and if I you had a spare fiver to give away you should have just bought her ticket to save everyone, including us, the hassle of this non event.

You admit yourself that she lied about where she was going to so why is it ok for you to doubt her story but not the people whose job it is to ask questions?

Skodacool · 14/03/2024 07:35

The answer is simple. Anyone without a ticket should be taken off the train at the next station and have their ‘problem’ dealt with.

BobbyBiscuits · 14/03/2024 07:35

If they had done nothing wrong why didn't they detain her, rather than leaving when everyone said they were being dicks?
I'd say it's more likely than not she wasn't homeless and said that to stop them sending her a fine etc. But it's not right what they did. As people say, they should signpost her to services and offer support if she said she was.

Dontforgetthesalamander · 14/03/2024 07:32

Its only racial profiling if they only asked her if she had a ticket because she was black. They always ask everyone for their ticket.

Swipe left for the next trending thread