Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you complain about this? (Police behaviour towards a black and potentially vulnerable 16-year-old girl)

259 replies

Readytoplay · 14/03/2024 01:18

TLDR at the end of the post, as this is long but I feel I have to explain the whole situation

Yesterday afternoon I was on a train, departing from a London Terminal. Just after we started moving, a ticket inspection began. The girl (who was black) in front of me didn’t have a ticket. The ticket inspector (White 40s male) was abrupt; and in my opinion rude; with the young lady who claimed she was 16 and homeless. He asked her if she could pay with a debit card, but she told him that she didn’t have one. He then asked her age and she answered 16. He then scoffed “What, you're 16 and don’t have a bank card”. (For what it’s worth I personally didn’t have a bank account until I was 17- and this was only last decade).

He then asked her where she was going. The girl responded with vague answers, such as: “a few stops” or “not far”. He then asked how she got on the train without a ticket and through the barriers. She told him that she ‘just did’. He then asked for a name and address. The first she refused to give and she repeated that she was homeless for the latter, the inspector answered ‘No you're not’, Before asking for some ID. He then left her for a moment after she claimed she didn’t have any, before coming back with an officer from BTP (also a white 40s male).

Now, I always record any encounter I have with the police directly OR if an encounter is happening in my proximity (this was literally the seat in front) so I started filming but with the camera face down so only sound would be recorded. the police officer showed his badge and began to ask for the same information as the ticket inspector. After she repeated what she had already said, he then asked for some ID, before asking what was in her bag and that he was going to search it.

I was about to intervene at this point as I was getting increasingly uncomfortable with the tone and attitude these adult men were having with this young and likely vulnerable lady. Clearly, someone else felt the same and questioned the way the situation was being approached. I then also voiced my concerns and admitted that I was recording this. The other passenger started to tell the men that they thought how they were behaving was disgusting. I commented that if a 16-year-old minor was claiming to be homeless that shouldn’t they be offering them support? They said they would if they had some identification. I tried to explain that she likely doesn’t have anything due to her circumstances and then the part that really annoyed me: “as if she is homeless, dressed in all those brands”. I.E. doubting her circumstances because was wearing a Nike sweatshirt. WTF.

It ended with the other passenger ranting at the cop, before both the guard and cop got off at the next station. And that was that. They didn’t find any ID on the girl, and all that was in her bag were clothes and other personal essentials.

The girl was left visibly shaken and upset. I tried to see if she was alright. She explained to me that she was staying with her BF. I told her of some organisations to contact if she needed any support (Shelter/ Centerpoint). Before she got off I offered to give her a fiver (normally I wouldn’t give money to strangers, but would have in this case) but she declined.

Now, I have no idea if this girl was or wasn’t homeless. But am I wrong in thinking that the behaviour of the cop/train guard was completely inappropriate? There is very little of me who feels this wasn’t racially motivated. The fact that they searched her bag and the fact that both had an abrupt and aggressive attitude toward her really felt like profiling to me. Yes, the girl could have been more cooperative with some of the questions, but the intense questioning, mixed with the dismissive attitude would have likely made most people not want to cooperate.

I am thinking of sending the recording to both the train operator and BTP to express my concerns with what I witnessed, Manly:

  1. The instant refusal to believe that this child could be homeless and the lack of support.
  2. The racial profiling of a young black female
  3. The aggressive attitude that was used throughout the situation.

I would also like to try and get the child checked up on, however, this is likely going to be difficult as I don’t know any details apart from what she told me and where she got off (which I won’t lie, was a bit further than a ‘couple of stops’) as I am worried that she hasn’t got any support. I am also a bit worried that she’s moving in with a bf as well.

TLDR: a young black girl who claimed she was homeless was aggressively Interrogated by a police officer and ticket inspector. They doubted her claims because she was wearing branded clothing. The girl was left viably shaken as a result.

What would you do?
YABU- Don’t report
YANBU- report

OP posts:
WhereIsBebèsChambre · 14/03/2024 19:58

Whats teachers role of responsibility to children in their care to do with someone fare dodging?

Elecrricmaracas · 14/03/2024 19:55

Oh and fuck all this "she's 16, she can change her name and get married etc etc" - she's still technically a child and should be safeguarded as such. Do you think in year 11 at school, once they have their 16th birthday, teachers just say "nah we don't need to help you anymore" ??

Elecrricmaracas · 14/03/2024 19:53

I just hope that the people saying the girl MUST be a fare dodger never needs a stranger to vouch for their child. It's hardly beyond the realms of possibility that a child ran away from home and boarded a train with no money. That's fare dodging. Is it right? No. Should we, as adults, help them? Of course!

Creatureofhabit87 · 14/03/2024 19:47

Why is her colour relevant? It doesn’t sound like any of this is about race. It’s about the fact she hasn’t got a ticket. She shouldn’t have got on a train without one. It isn’t the job of the ticket inspector to find homes for homeless people! I think she was just trying to avoid paying.

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · 14/03/2024 19:42

Tourmalines · 14/03/2024 09:25

Oh let’s just all get on the train , no ticket, give smart smug answers when questioned, just basically give the finger to all in authority. Let’s just rip off the system and rip off all other passengers because we can . You always record any encounter you have with the police directly or in close proximity to you.? So how many police encounters have you personally had ? I think you have it in for them . At no time was that ever racist. It was them doing their job and probably a young woman (not child) scamming the system .

This. Does it only work on trains? Can I go to the airport and find a flight to Maui? 'A ticket?! Ahem! Safeguarding 101! You can't ask me for a ticket! Take me to Maui and provide me with accommodation! I'm saying I'm 16!'

DdraigGoch · 14/03/2024 19:39

Tummytroubles22 · 14/03/2024 09:22

Rather than recording the situation and thinking of intervening you could have stopped the situation by paying for her ticket at the start. If you were willing to give her £5 then you could afford it.

I’m not surprised the ticket inspector summoned BTP, a bus driver local to me was stabbed to death last month by a 15 year old.

I'm more surprised that BTP showed up. They're known as "Be There Presently" for a reason

bows101 · 14/03/2024 18:20

Nothing you've said about their approach appeared to be of a racist nature.
It seems you are the only one concerned about her skin colour.
They will ask anyone for the ticket and if she really did need help, she could have given them her name and information.
How the hell do you expect them to refer her to SS when she is not giving information?
Unfortunately, rail fare dodgers are an every day occurrence. And even people who do it everyday can appear 'shaken'.

MCOut · 14/03/2024 18:15

You just have to laugh. Never in decades of living in London or even outside have I ever seen strangers intercede on behalf of someone who hadn’t paid. Not once.

If two people felt the need to bestir themselves and intervene with murmurs of agreement from others, then the behaviour of the ticketing officer and BTP was disproportionate. Most of the time racism is not slurs.

lemonmeringueno3 · 14/03/2024 18:13

Hey op, I know a Nigerian prince who's trying to move millions out of the country. Something tells me you'd be interested.

Busbygirl · 14/03/2024 18:09

Hereyoume · 14/03/2024 17:46

OP. unless you are prepared to upload the audio you recorded, then I call BS on this whole thread.

If you need instructions on how to link it, let me know, and I will talk you through it.

You can’t make a recording of someone without their permission and share it with a load of random people surely?

Busbygirl · 14/03/2024 18:07

Honestly I think you’re being naive. Not sure what the girl’s colour has to do with it either.
About 6 months ago I witnessed similar on a train. Young man got on the train, had a ticket for one stop and no railcard to show.
He gave the poor. young ticket collector such a hard time. Man opposite me pulled out £100 cash to give to the young man to help him out. He refused to take the cash but I couldn’t believe the older man had swallowed his story. I’m guessing people try and get away with not paying the full fare more frequently than you think.
Why report someone who is trying to do their job? Doesn’t sound like they were being horrible to the girl to me.

Hereyoume · 14/03/2024 17:46

OP. unless you are prepared to upload the audio you recorded, then I call BS on this whole thread.

If you need instructions on how to link it, let me know, and I will talk you through it.

YouDidntEvenAskIfSheWasThereMoriarty · 14/03/2024 17:20

DrJoanAllenby · 14/03/2024 17:18

What a load of nonsense.

You have made it a racial issue when there wasn't any.

They were just doing their job and dealing with a person who hadn't paid for their ticket.

You've chosen to call her vulnerable when she could just as easily be a persistent offender.

The outrage at such a non event which has been escalated in your mind to all sorts of crap is completely misplaced

Do you actually know whether this girl was vulnerable or not? Or do you prefer to assume everyone is lying?

Because I'd rather assume everyone was telling the truth, rather than fail to support someone who was in genuine need.

DrJoanAllenby · 14/03/2024 17:18

What a load of nonsense.

You have made it a racial issue when there wasn't any.

They were just doing their job and dealing with a person who hadn't paid for their ticket.

You've chosen to call her vulnerable when she could just as easily be a persistent offender.

The outrage at such a non event which has been escalated in your mind to all sorts of crap is completely misplaced

Scott1eh · 14/03/2024 17:16

So.... let's try and look at this objectively, recognising that only you were there.

  1. The level of people without a/ correct ticket is significant in terms of the numbers of people who do it, in turn, that puts up your fare.
  2. Not having a ticket is an offence, and it sounds like a revenue inspector, not just a routine train manager/ ticket checker. They are obliged to request personal details as an offence has been committed, and if this was a revenue protection officer, they have the same powers as the Police in these matters.
  3. Personal details are required to send a fine, regardless of circumstances. This isn't a case of "go on then, never mind" situation.
  4. Where the individual refused to provide personal details, it is common for the Police to be called, the main reason is to check who the person is, and to check for any previous offences of a similar nature, or in these cases often can be missing persons or are wanted - especially for young vulnerable people.
  5. The BTP officer may have been assertive, however if the Police hold up a train, they can be fined by the train operator - so when someone is not cooperating, this delays travel for everyone - who then complain.
  6. Without these details, no one can offer help - and if the person could be proven to be this age, they would be regarded as potentially a vulnerable person, and either referred to an agency or in many BTP cases, taken somewhere.
  7. I would say... if you were that concerned, you could have offered to pay the individuals fare? You also go on to say the person did in fact go further than the "few stops".

At least one, if not both staff would have a body worn video, and recording - so that's not a problem to report, as that can be checked, as can the video footage that is on every carriage.

I would also say that the way in which people handle situations is subjective, what might be aggressive to you, might be less so to another.

What concerned me was your automatic assumption that somehow this was racial, and the fact that the two staff were male vs. a black female is in my view, irrelevant. BTP in fact, is a very caring Force that focusses on safety and well-being of vulnerable travellers, regardless of age or race.

I'm not doubting you, or your interpretation, however a BTP officer and rail staff are not here to give their side of the story, and who are heavily regulated and scrutinised. I would have preferred that you report it to both the rail operator and BTP for them to investigate, rather than possibly trying to paint a picture that was your interpretation.

penjil · 14/03/2024 17:11

Look, OP, nothing racial was actually said!

What do you want them to do? Not ever check black people's tickets?!?

missmollygreen · 14/03/2024 17:10

Readytoplay · 14/03/2024 01:55

It's not that she was challenged for not having a ticket. But more the attitude of both the inspector and the policeman and (the main one for me), refusing to believe her situation. Safeguarding 101: you always believe a person's claims until if and when you have evidence to suggest otherwise.

You dont think the police hear people telling lies to get off the hook ALL THE TIME?

If the inspectors and police let people off with every sob story they heard no one would bother buying a ticket.

Not really sure why you felt the need to bring any of their race into this. Maybe its your bias

penjil · 14/03/2024 17:08

Readytoplay · 14/03/2024 01:55

It's not that she was challenged for not having a ticket. But more the attitude of both the inspector and the policeman and (the main one for me), refusing to believe her situation. Safeguarding 101: you always believe a person's claims until if and when you have evidence to suggest otherwise.

The fact she's homeless isn't their problem.

Their problem is that she didn't have a ticket.

Why would they be concerned about anything else? They are not social workers.

They must see countless chancers and people who try it on every day, and engaging in polite chat just drags the matter out.

That asked for the facts. They may have been abrupt, but they didn't actually say anything about he race, did they?!

Starspangledrodeopony · 14/03/2024 17:05

I’d report. But don’t expect support on here, there’s a very unpleasant undercurrent here whereby any prejudice, especially towards people of colour and disabled people, is minimised or flat-out denied. It’s pretty horrific.

DdraigGoch · 14/03/2024 16:54

ASighMadeOfStone · 14/03/2024 06:17

Do you not travel on trains often @Readytoplay ?

I don't think I've been on any busy train recently where someone hasn't tried to get away without paying. The most recent was a (white) man in his twenties supposedly on his way to visit his sick mother in hospital. He was asked to leave at the next station.

You shouldn't be filming minors btw. Safeguarding 101.

Did the whole train stand up and cheer?

Edited

Funny how it's always their mother or their grandmother who is in hospital. Almost as if they think that it will attract more sympathy compared with claiming that their father is in hospital.

teatimeplease · 14/03/2024 15:46

Interested to know how you think the police or anyone else can offer support if the girl refused details?

Rosecoffeecup · 14/03/2024 15:36

Now, I always record any encounter I have with the police directly OR if an encounter is happening in my proximity

how often is this happening to you?!

You sound insufferable and probably quite gullible

Everanewbie · 14/03/2024 15:35

Hi OP. These threads rely on people posting in good faith, and therefore I don't want to suggest that this is fabricated. But how come you seem to end up having so many dealings with the police? I mean, I've spoken to them a few times, maybe seen them attending an incident a few times, but don't find myself dealing with them on such a frequent basis that I have a 'policy' on dealing with them such as filming etc. What is going on here? Are you unlucky? Do you sniff out trouble?

Resilience · 14/03/2024 15:34

Oh please, I've literally witnessed a group of white teens have a punch-up in the middle of the aisle. On other occasions, the same kids were smoking/vaping, having water fights while spaying other commuters, paying with sparklers and running around with a fire extinguisher. Yet when I tried to report all these to the ticket inspector they told me to ‘just move carriage’. Funny that the white middle-class appearing kids get away with their repeated nuisance, yet a young black girl who claims to be homeless, gets police searching her stuff for not having a ticket.

Not having a go because it's not acceptable either way, but how do you know it's about race and not about numbers/sex/level of conflict?

2023NEWMUM2023 · 14/03/2024 15:33

On the train yesterday the passenger sat next to me had bought a ticket online with a railcard but didn't have the railcard. The ticket inspector asked for ID and I thought this was to check he was under 25 but they took a photo and said a letter will be sent with a fine and how they could explain/appeal it. The passenger was black but I don't think this was racial profiling etc, the ticket inspector was polite but firm. Sounds like they get people without tickets/trying it on daily and they are really clamping down on it

Swipe left for the next trending thread