Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you complain about this? (Police behaviour towards a black and potentially vulnerable 16-year-old girl)

259 replies

Readytoplay · 14/03/2024 01:18

TLDR at the end of the post, as this is long but I feel I have to explain the whole situation

Yesterday afternoon I was on a train, departing from a London Terminal. Just after we started moving, a ticket inspection began. The girl (who was black) in front of me didn’t have a ticket. The ticket inspector (White 40s male) was abrupt; and in my opinion rude; with the young lady who claimed she was 16 and homeless. He asked her if she could pay with a debit card, but she told him that she didn’t have one. He then asked her age and she answered 16. He then scoffed “What, you're 16 and don’t have a bank card”. (For what it’s worth I personally didn’t have a bank account until I was 17- and this was only last decade).

He then asked her where she was going. The girl responded with vague answers, such as: “a few stops” or “not far”. He then asked how she got on the train without a ticket and through the barriers. She told him that she ‘just did’. He then asked for a name and address. The first she refused to give and she repeated that she was homeless for the latter, the inspector answered ‘No you're not’, Before asking for some ID. He then left her for a moment after she claimed she didn’t have any, before coming back with an officer from BTP (also a white 40s male).

Now, I always record any encounter I have with the police directly OR if an encounter is happening in my proximity (this was literally the seat in front) so I started filming but with the camera face down so only sound would be recorded. the police officer showed his badge and began to ask for the same information as the ticket inspector. After she repeated what she had already said, he then asked for some ID, before asking what was in her bag and that he was going to search it.

I was about to intervene at this point as I was getting increasingly uncomfortable with the tone and attitude these adult men were having with this young and likely vulnerable lady. Clearly, someone else felt the same and questioned the way the situation was being approached. I then also voiced my concerns and admitted that I was recording this. The other passenger started to tell the men that they thought how they were behaving was disgusting. I commented that if a 16-year-old minor was claiming to be homeless that shouldn’t they be offering them support? They said they would if they had some identification. I tried to explain that she likely doesn’t have anything due to her circumstances and then the part that really annoyed me: “as if she is homeless, dressed in all those brands”. I.E. doubting her circumstances because was wearing a Nike sweatshirt. WTF.

It ended with the other passenger ranting at the cop, before both the guard and cop got off at the next station. And that was that. They didn’t find any ID on the girl, and all that was in her bag were clothes and other personal essentials.

The girl was left visibly shaken and upset. I tried to see if she was alright. She explained to me that she was staying with her BF. I told her of some organisations to contact if she needed any support (Shelter/ Centerpoint). Before she got off I offered to give her a fiver (normally I wouldn’t give money to strangers, but would have in this case) but she declined.

Now, I have no idea if this girl was or wasn’t homeless. But am I wrong in thinking that the behaviour of the cop/train guard was completely inappropriate? There is very little of me who feels this wasn’t racially motivated. The fact that they searched her bag and the fact that both had an abrupt and aggressive attitude toward her really felt like profiling to me. Yes, the girl could have been more cooperative with some of the questions, but the intense questioning, mixed with the dismissive attitude would have likely made most people not want to cooperate.

I am thinking of sending the recording to both the train operator and BTP to express my concerns with what I witnessed, Manly:

  1. The instant refusal to believe that this child could be homeless and the lack of support.
  2. The racial profiling of a young black female
  3. The aggressive attitude that was used throughout the situation.

I would also like to try and get the child checked up on, however, this is likely going to be difficult as I don’t know any details apart from what she told me and where she got off (which I won’t lie, was a bit further than a ‘couple of stops’) as I am worried that she hasn’t got any support. I am also a bit worried that she’s moving in with a bf as well.

TLDR: a young black girl who claimed she was homeless was aggressively Interrogated by a police officer and ticket inspector. They doubted her claims because she was wearing branded clothing. The girl was left viably shaken as a result.

What would you do?
YABU- Don’t report
YANBU- report

OP posts:
Ahugga · 17/03/2024 12:37

lala567 · 17/03/2024 10:22

Nothing really relevant but my sister's husband was accused of being racist at work.

He's white. He practically brought his 3 little sisters up who are mixed race but really dark.
So you can't tell there mum is white.

His mums brother and sister are mixed again quite dark. So he has lots of mixed race cousins who now have their own kids. His sisters also have kids. In fact out around 27 family members only he and his mum are white but obviously by looking at him you wouldn't know.

He has to just ignore this when he's accused of being racist as he would look daft reeling off the story.

Obviously the inspector could be racist but nothing to suggest he was.

Having black or brown friends and family doesn't mean you can't be racist.

lala567 · 17/03/2024 10:22

Nothing really relevant but my sister's husband was accused of being racist at work.

He's white. He practically brought his 3 little sisters up who are mixed race but really dark.
So you can't tell there mum is white.

His mums brother and sister are mixed again quite dark. So he has lots of mixed race cousins who now have their own kids. His sisters also have kids. In fact out around 27 family members only he and his mum are white but obviously by looking at him you wouldn't know.

He has to just ignore this when he's accused of being racist as he would look daft reeling off the story.

Obviously the inspector could be racist but nothing to suggest he was.

AliTheMinx · 17/03/2024 10:15

YABU. Their behaviour doesn't sound unacceptable and if she was on a train without a ticket, the inspector and the police had every right to question her. I can't see any evidence of racism in what you have posted. I imagine they would have done the same with anyone else without a ticket - regardless of age or skin colour

Iwasafool · 17/03/2024 09:42

DdraigGoch · 17/03/2024 00:31

Do you know whether this particular inspector lets off white kids or is that supposition on your part?

The two fare dodgers on my train last week were both white, one male, one female, one probably in their 20s the other probably late 40s or 50s. Both were clearly embarrassed, both immediately got cards out to pay, both were told they must get tickets before travel.

I don't think the big difference was race, I think the difference was the fare dodgers co-operated and paid up.

I have seen clear racism, one particular instance with some junior staff and the manager treated them very differently, I went over his head to report it and it was dealt with. I've also experienced it when I was with my husband, I'm white he isn't, so I see and acknowledge racism. This particular case does not appear to be racism but a 16 year old who was in the wrong and then refused to go through the process set out for the situation.

DdraigGoch · 17/03/2024 00:31

PelicanPopcorn · 16/03/2024 21:08

Did you deliberately ignore the bit in my comment about why it's racist?

Do you know whether this particular inspector lets off white kids or is that supposition on your part?

PelicanPopcorn · 16/03/2024 21:08

ForPinkWasp · 14/03/2024 06:48

What you’re saying is not true. She has been caught in the act of committing an offence and is refusing to give details. There are obvious grounds and legality for a search. They could have just gone ahead and arrested her so how you can say it’s an overreach baffles me. The police have these powers specifically because she is breaking the law. If you don’t want to be told off then either buy a ticket or don’t travel. Maybe we should just not enforce any rules at all and we can all just do what we want, sure that will end well.

Did you deliberately ignore the bit in my comment about why it's racist?

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 16/03/2024 18:00

If she used an Oyster Card to access the barriers then she’d have a ticket unless it was out of credit and she knew this.
Or she tailgated someone

Either was she was travelling without and she knew it .

I’ve had people put an empty plastic cover on the reader and cram themselves through the barrier behind me .And witnessed groups of school pupils in uniform crash their way through barriers. The station staff tend to ignore them though

Ahugga · 16/03/2024 14:47

Hereyoume · 16/03/2024 10:32

There is no expectation of privacy in a public place, so yes, you can record people and you don't need their permission to post it online.

Yes but we should hardly be pushing for videos of potentially vulnerable teenagers to be published without their consent, even if they technically could. Morally repugnant.

Hereyoume · 16/03/2024 10:32

Busbygirl · 14/03/2024 18:09

You can’t make a recording of someone without their permission and share it with a load of random people surely?

There is no expectation of privacy in a public place, so yes, you can record people and you don't need their permission to post it online.

Iwasafool · 15/03/2024 09:22

Readytoplay · 15/03/2024 00:44

I completely agree. This way the chancers/fibbers can receive the appropriate sanction and those generally in need can get the support they need (and yes a sanction if necessary).

She wouldn't give her name, she wouldn't give her address, do you imagine she would have cheerfully said, "OK" and gone with the officer at the next station? She'd have kicked up a fuss, people like you would have joined in and you'd have had something great to film wouldn't you. There is every reason to believe if he'd tried to arrest her she would have refused to move, if he'd laid hands on her he'd be accused of assault. She should have cooperated, given her name, given the address she was going to be staying at. She created this situation and you joined in and supported her behaviour.

Nolongera · 15/03/2024 09:02

DdraigGoch · 15/03/2024 08:50

As she was over 16 the only thing the officer could have done is arrest her under RoRA. How would the OP have reacted then?

Indeed.

As I have said up thread, a white male behaving like this would almost certainly been given the choice of paying a penalty fare, ejected from the train and if they continued to refuse to give details, arrested.

DdraigGoch · 15/03/2024 08:50

Elecrricmaracas · 15/03/2024 05:39

@DdraigGoch

"If a child is running away then the absolute worst thing you can do is to let them carry on (whether that's staff letting them travel or a stranger paying for them). If a child might be a runaway the police should be called to retrive them. This happens a lot (often the same kid every single night), particularly with kids in care."

But the ticket inspector wasn't interested in helping her. Neither was the police. That's my point - the OP said that they were treating her harshly instead of offering her support.

As she was over 16 the only thing the officer could have done is arrest her under RoRA. How would the OP have reacted then?

Londonrach1 · 15/03/2024 08:13

She had no ticket! I bet the guard hears this 1000 times. Yabu.

ilovebreadsauce · 15/03/2024 08:09

She said she was living with her boyfriend. Thomelessness claptrap was to avoid giving an address!!

ilovebreadsauce · 15/03/2024 08:06

She was defrauding the train company! You are very naive!

Tilkyghg6366 · 15/03/2024 05:56

Elecrricmaracas · 15/03/2024 05:39

@DdraigGoch

"If a child is running away then the absolute worst thing you can do is to let them carry on (whether that's staff letting them travel or a stranger paying for them). If a child might be a runaway the police should be called to retrive them. This happens a lot (often the same kid every single night), particularly with kids in care."

But the ticket inspector wasn't interested in helping her. Neither was the police. That's my point - the OP said that they were treating her harshly instead of offering her support.

So anybody without a ticket during that check and other checks can just say they are homeless and expect support instead of the normal course of action for not having a ticket which is plastered all over stations and trains.

Elecrricmaracas · 15/03/2024 05:39

@DdraigGoch

"If a child is running away then the absolute worst thing you can do is to let them carry on (whether that's staff letting them travel or a stranger paying for them). If a child might be a runaway the police should be called to retrive them. This happens a lot (often the same kid every single night), particularly with kids in care."

But the ticket inspector wasn't interested in helping her. Neither was the police. That's my point - the OP said that they were treating her harshly instead of offering her support.

Elecrricmaracas · 15/03/2024 05:37

WhereIsBebèsChambre · 14/03/2024 19:58

Whats teachers role of responsibility to children in their care to do with someone fare dodging?

It's pretty obvious what I meant.

Louisevuitton · 15/03/2024 01:48

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previously banned poster.

Readytoplay · 15/03/2024 00:44

Skodacool · 14/03/2024 07:35

The answer is simple. Anyone without a ticket should be taken off the train at the next station and have their ‘problem’ dealt with.

I completely agree. This way the chancers/fibbers can receive the appropriate sanction and those generally in need can get the support they need (and yes a sanction if necessary).

OP posts:
Iwasafool · 14/03/2024 20:29

I can only imagine what the OP would be saying if the officer had arrested her, say she resisted and he restrained her. She'd have had a great recording then and she could moan about police brutality. You can't win in that situation.

All could have been avoided if she had given them her name and said she was staying at her boyfriends and given his address. No drama needed.

DdraigGoch · 14/03/2024 20:22

Elecrricmaracas · 14/03/2024 19:53

I just hope that the people saying the girl MUST be a fare dodger never needs a stranger to vouch for their child. It's hardly beyond the realms of possibility that a child ran away from home and boarded a train with no money. That's fare dodging. Is it right? No. Should we, as adults, help them? Of course!

If a child is running away then the absolute worst thing you can do is to let them carry on (whether that's staff letting them travel or a stranger paying for them). If a child might be a runaway the police should be called to retrive them. This happens a lot (often the same kid every single night), particularly with kids in care.

Iwasafool · 14/03/2024 20:19

milesmachine · 14/03/2024 02:29

OP I would assume you don't travel by public transport around London regularly?

As someone who gets the train in and out almost daily I can say at least once a week a ticket inspector will find someone (usually young female ime) with some story about forgetting a ticket or a sad situation

I'm afraid they've heard it all before and it sounds like she wasn't homeless but staying with her boyfriend and was a bit obstructive when rightly challenged on her fate dodging

It doesn't seem worthy of reporting, nor profiling to me

I was on a local train last week, I think they've been short staffed or something because for the last couple of months no one seemed to be checking tickets, well last week they checked and in the carriage I was in two people didn't have tickets. They weren't together and both paid up, I think they
ticket guy said it was a penalty fare so they must have paid more than a standard ticket.

My husband is a retired police officer and he arrested a woman for shoplifting. He felt sorry for her kids as they didn't seem to have much. Every year for the next few years he used to drop a bag of presents for her kids on her doorstep on Christmas Eve, ring the bell and leave. I wonder if she ever worked out who was doing it.

DdraigGoch · 14/03/2024 20:15

so nothing to arrest her for
Failing to provide a ticket, payment, and a name & address is grounds for an arrest.

Oh please, I've literally witnessed a group of white teens have a punch-up in the middle of the aisle. On other occasions, the same kids were smoking/vaping, having water fights while spaying other commuters, paying with sparklers and running around with a fire extinguisher. Yet when I tried to report all these to the ticket inspector they told me to ‘just move carriage’. Funny that the white middle-class appearing kids get away with their repeated nuisance, yet a young black girl who claims to be homeless, gets police searching her stuff for not having a ticket.
What exactly is the guard supposed to do if confronted by a gang of teenagers (of any colour) running riot? They're not trained in the use of reasonable force, they do not wear any kind of body armour, they do not carry tasers or PAVA sprays, they are on their own with no back-up if they get stabbed/knocked out. They are expected to keep themselves safe and call the police (who might turn up eventually but BTP often have just one or two officers covering an entire county so you're reliant on them being in the right place at the right time).

Plus, I am pretty sure it's not in a ticket inspector's job description to judge why a 16-year-old hasn't got a bank account and to judge if someone is homeless based on the clothes the person is wearing.
It certainly is not. So why you are blaming the inspector? It's not their job to judge whether the sob story might be genuine, their job is to examine tickets and to take details from passengers who fail to produce. That's all, they're not a branch of social services. My response to "I'm homeless" would be "And? Does this look like a charity?"

Humphhhh · 14/03/2024 20:08

I've met loads of rail staff in my years commuting. They deal with vulnerable people all the time - there is a suicide every week on the railway and an awful lot more who don't go through with it. They have runaways and exploited children.

They'd be fucking horrified that people think that it's none of their business.

Looking out for vulnerable people is absolutely part of their job.