Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister thinks she’s so hard done by

28 replies

Kwasi · 13/03/2024 20:51

I think I rally just need to vent!

I moved from my hometown 24 years ago and currently live 300 miles away. I have DS5, and DH and I own a shop as well as being employed elsewhere. I attend college one day a week. I also have a chronic illness as well as having a difficult time with DS at school and a marriage that only still exists because I can’t afford to leave.

Brother and sister still live in our hometown. For years, sis lived next door to our mum, who did 100% of the childcare for my sister’s two kids so her and her DH could continue doing things people in their 20s do, such as weekends out, weekends away, even an annual week in Ibiza. Heck, my sister never even had to take her kids to the supermarket. I don’t begrudge her this at all; she just lacks a little empathy because she’s never had to worry about school holidays or sick days, etc.

In recent years, our mum has become a hoarder and let the house go to wrack and ruin. Four months ago, she had an accident, which meant she needed some rehab and a suitable place to stay afterwards. She’s been at my sister’s house for two months and my sister is getting annoyed, saying she’s our responsibility too. While Mum was still in rehab, my sister asked me to go up and help sort the house because she was getting someone in for a house clearance the following week. I arrived on the Saturday and was told my sister wouldn’t be free until 2pm on Sunday with no way to get the keys to me. Turns out, she just wanted some things moving upstairs so she could get a price for the house clearance. I felt this was a wasted trip.

My sister is complaining that I am not doing more. I have offered to go up and dismantle the old kitchen but my April availability doesn’t suit. I have offered to pay someone to do it but my sister has refused to give her day off to be there. Any suggestion I make is met with a problem and my sister always has an idea of what she wants to happen but never actually says what she wants; instead, she just tries to steer me into saying what she wants to happen.

I have told her I can’t be there on weekdays as every single day of my annual leave is required for school holidays. It’s a 10-hour round trip and costs £100 in fuel, which is a lot when no one will actually firm up a plan and I’m waiting around half the time. If she would actually let me take the reins instead of playing the martyr, it would have all been sorted in January.

My brother is pretty useless and has zero DIY knowledge. He only lives 10 minutes from our mum but hasn’t really contributed much more than me.

Full disclosure: I am not close to my mum because we are too different. She doesn’t bother with DS and just sends him £20 at birthdays and Christmas.

YABU: Get your arse up there and shelve your own problems and do as you’re told
YANBU: She either needs to come up with a plan or let you be in charge

OP posts:
TeaKitten · 13/03/2024 21:00

Sounds like you both think you are done by, when actually you are both busy and doing your best. Maybe cut each other some slack.

Lazypeopledrivemecrazy · 13/03/2024 20:57

It sounds like your DS wants to play the role of martyr OP. She wants to make you feel guilty about not being there to help, but actually enjoys being in that position. Quite honestly, in your shoes, and bearing in mind the distance that you live from your DM's, and the fact that you've not been around for 24 years, and in that time haven't been close to your DM, then I would tell your DS, that you've offered all the help you're going to. She's going out of her way to make things awkward, and you don't have the time or inclination to play silly games just because she can't get her act together.

Mummame222 · 13/03/2024 20:56

I don’t think YBU but it does seem like a bit of a competition of who has it hardest.

When adult DC decide to look after their parents I think they don’t actually consider how hard it will truly be. Just because one DC wants to do it doesn’t mean that the other DC owe them anything or have to help them.

I won’t be looking after my DP in their older age. They neglected me when I was young, I owe them nothing.

Obviously your circumstances mean you cannot help either. Set out a couple options for your DSis and if nothing is good enough that’s her choice.