Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So confused by percentiles

38 replies

Growthexpectations · 13/03/2024 13:35

My pre schooler got measured today. Just gone four and is 108 cm. Since two he was on upper percentiles (80+) but last two measurements has been quoted as 25th and 30th percentile. He's really tall compared to some of his friends and the same size as others, not many taller so I queried how he could be on the lower range and was told it was because of calculating months. Fair enough. I them went on the internet and can only really find things that say he's closer to my original estimation of 80%.

Am I wrong here? Every time I bring it up they just dismiss it, but I'd like to know as it'll obviously effect if he is a healthy weight or not. Again, not worried as such but just to monitor.

Can someone explain to me?!

So confused by percentiles
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
KestrelMoon · 13/03/2024 17:08

Growthexpectations · 13/03/2024 13:58

Yeah I mean I that's the thing, I want to know I'm not missing anything huge as growth can obviously be an indicator of something else. It's just that his height, our experience of comparison all tally with his previous percentile and not current. The doctor said as long as he was going along fine but he's dropped from 30 to 25 according to them over six months so given the huge drop you'd think they'd be interested.

WHO is worldwide so will include children genetically or nutritionally destined to be shorter. They are likely using more local indecies.

Dropping 5 centiles is very minor.

I would not worry.

SneakySnakeEx · 13/03/2024 17:04

One of my dcs on their 4th birthday was 110cm. On 6th birthday was 129cm. Wears age 10 clothes as tall.
They were born on 9th centile. I haven't charted it for ages though.

Yet my now 4. 3m old Is just 101cm. Born on same centile as other dc.
Their birth weight and lengths were half an oz different and 1 cm different.

Bumply · 13/03/2024 16:47

The centiles shouldn't change with change in age bands.
That's the whole point of them.
To be able to pinpoint failure to thrive or excessive weight gain if a child changes from their usual percentile in a relatively short period of time.

Ds2 was 95th percentile for height and weight up to 1 year old. Then got ill and dropped to 50th percentile, but because it was being charted on the next page of his red book (1-5 year) it took ages to get his illness taken seriously and investigated. "He's perfectly normal". Not for him he wasn't.

FraterculaArctica · 13/03/2024 16:42

Almost every single doctor and HV I have met (across 3DC) has shown a staggering inability to plot or interpret centile charts correctly so I wouldn't worry.
Yes, 108 cm at 4.1 is tall. DC3 is 4.4 and 99 cm (he is tiny - sits on 9th centile line).

Namechangedagain20 · 13/03/2024 16:36

This happened with DD once, she went from being over the 75th centile to 25th at the appointment. The health visitor was sat there saying ‘but she seems so tall it’s odd’. When I got home and looked at the red book she’d plotted it as 10cm smaller than she’d measured DD, her actual centile was still 75th. I’d get the red book out and have a look yourself

hummmmm · 13/03/2024 16:32

Have you got the nhs app set up to give you access to his records? (you need to fill in a form at your GP surgery if you haven't already done it) - the measurement they took may show up in that somewhere so you could check what it says?

ECPCR2 · 13/03/2024 16:21

DS is same age and same height as yours. Definitely high centile, taller than average. The doctor who told you he's around 30th centile must have read the chart wrong.

Iknowiknow21 · 13/03/2024 16:06

You keep going back to his taller than all his friends. They use the same charts as the red book.
he is on the 88th centile .. the doctor has for his height wrong somehow
which is a pretty easy fix.
4 year old here ( 4 and 5 months ) is 104 cm
what actually is more important is what their height Vs weight is
as long as there is not 2 centiles better these you are fine.

TeaGinandFags · 13/03/2024 15:58

Centiles are easy, but appear confusing.

A centile is 1% of the population being measured, eg kids at age x. Things like height follow a normal distribution pattern known as the bell curve. It's called a bell curve because it's shaped like a bell with most of the kids at the same height in the middle while very few kids (outer centiles) are really small or really tall or at the edge of the bell.

Height can be affected by things like genetics, so really tall parents and grandparents are unlikely to have small kids and vice versa. Alternatively if mum was starving whilst pregnant or the kid is mal nourished then they won't grow up to their full potential height, which is calculated with mum and dad's heights. It could also be there's a shorty in the family woodwork but has been hidden in recent generations.

Health visitors love every kid on 50% which is the standard average, but health visitors are nazis. I had trouble because my lad started out bang on 505 to shoot over to the max centile for height and weight. He's now a strapping 6'4". in the same room I saw a teeny tiny lady being berated because her baby was tiny and therefore 'failing to thrive.' It was fine, but the health visitor was being a bitch.

if you know your kid to he happy and healthy ignore that nonsense. It's an admin thing for populations not individuals.

Does this help?

KarmaCaramello · 13/03/2024 15:31

I had DD measured and they started talking to me about childhood obesity. I wtf'd as she has always been in or under the 25th centile.

Turns out they'd somehow recorded her measurements as 5th centile for height and 95th for weight...redid the meaurements and she was 25th for both.

LeanIntoChaos · 13/03/2024 14:52

There is an app you can download. Search growth charts who-uk on the play store.

I am a pediatrician and use it all the time.

You put in date of birth and measurements. If he is 4yrs and 1 months, he plots on 88th centile.

The doctor just made a mistake. I used to make mistakes on growth charts all the time.... It's all the lines. Hence why I always check with my app now. I have to check several times even i have to plot.... Don't know why it is so difficult for me, I have a medical degree ffs

Growthexpectations · 13/03/2024 14:23

I honestly have no idea. Anecdotally, he is taller than all his other friends. He has only just turned four. I'd be less surprised at say 50 percentile than 25/30th though as it's less dramatic than 90th to 25th.

OP posts:
heartbrokenof · 13/03/2024 14:20

Is 108cm that tall though? I have a 4 year old, he is 4 years and 6 months and is 115cm tall, he has been tall for his age since his 10 week check but he is heads and shoulders over the rest of the boys in his class so 108 would be average. But I can see how it's confusing if the who chart says otherwise for your son, maybe the school use one adapted for race and demographics?

Bigcoatlady · 13/03/2024 14:19

HV usually record at the age 3 developmental check. GPs don't routinely record BUT often need to assess if prescribing meds which might be the reason - e.g. my child had their height and weight calculated frequently to prescribe steroids for asthma when young as the dose is weight dependant. In these circs the relationship to the child's overall devt is irrelevant and GPs are not child health specialists which may be why they filled in the chart wrong.

Growthexpectations · 13/03/2024 14:18

Bearbookagainandagain · 13/03/2024 14:17

Ah fair enough! I was wondering if I had missed something!

You and me both. Starting to doubt myself and thinking have I lost a year? Is he really five?!

OP posts:
Bearbookagainandagain · 13/03/2024 14:17

Growthexpectations · 13/03/2024 14:16

No we had a medical reason I'd rather not disclose which is why he is being monitored. I would just prefer them to be accurate as obviously height and weight effect all sorts of medical things.

Ah fair enough! I was wondering if I had missed something!

Growthexpectations · 13/03/2024 14:16

No we had a medical reason I'd rather not disclose which is why he is being monitored. I would just prefer them to be accurate as obviously height and weight effect all sorts of medical things.

OP posts:
Bearbookagainandagain · 13/03/2024 14:14

Sorry if I'm a bit off topic, but is it common for GPs to actively follow children measurements still when they are 4yo?

I'm just wondering why/how those measurements came about, my eldest is 2 and his height has never been measured since they don't always do it at birth, and his last weighting was at a 12 weeks I think.

We did opt out of HV appointments so that might be the part of the reason, but our GP has never asked to follow-up on these either.

Growthexpectations · 13/03/2024 14:09

I think he may have been recorded as five years old not four, as that would put him around the 30th

Obviously I will have to double check but it's a shame no one double checked when I queried it. 🙄

OP posts:
Growthexpectations · 13/03/2024 14:04

Bigcoatlady · 13/03/2024 14:01

Whilst it seems likely you are right and for whatever reason the dr reading was wrong I doubt there is much to worry about. My three all treated centile charts as trampolines. The eldest managed to swerve btw 0.04th and 91st for weight over the course of her infancy! She's a normal sized adult now.

Haha that made me laugh. Thank you!

OP posts:
Growthexpectations · 13/03/2024 14:04

Tandora · 13/03/2024 14:01

I just checked in my red book at 108 cm at 4yrs 1 month is def tall. I think this must be an administrative error by the doctor. Very out of order that they dismissed you and made you feel silly. I’d go back and query what they have recorded his height as, as I’m betting it’s wrong.

Thanks I will dig out the previous paperwork as well and check it against our own height records. Yes, it just seems odd and I just want to make sure he is ok for weight too as they reckoned the 50th but again, who knows if accurate.

OP posts:
Tandora · 13/03/2024 14:01

I just checked in my red book at 108 cm at 4yrs 1 month is def tall. I think this must be an administrative error by the doctor. Very out of order that they dismissed you and made you feel silly. I’d go back and query what they have recorded his height as, as I’m betting it’s wrong.

Bigcoatlady · 13/03/2024 14:01

Whilst it seems likely you are right and for whatever reason the dr reading was wrong I doubt there is much to worry about. My three all treated centile charts as trampolines. The eldest managed to swerve btw 0.04th and 91st for weight over the course of her infancy! She's a normal sized adult now.

Growthexpectations · 13/03/2024 14:01

Bigcoatlady · 13/03/2024 13:58

If he's 4+1m (i.e. 49m old) and 108cm he is definitely btw 75-91st centile for height. A good table is here: https://www.rcpch.ac.uk/sites/default/files/Boys_2-18_years_growth_chart.pdf

It is possible that the dr underestimated his height or you overestimated it by a cm or too. And if both those things happened i.e. his true height is 105 cm, you overestimated it and the dr got it at 103 that would get you down to the 50th centile line. BUT that's still not as low as 25-30th centile.

I doubt you could have made an error as big as 8cm which is what you'd need to make him that short! So hard to guess what went wrong here.

If it is worrying you call the HV and ask for advice and possibly a remeasure. Don't worry too much about calculating BMI now unless you are already concerned he is over or underweight for his height. BMI is not an especially helpful measure in children under 5 who can get chubby then thin out as they grow quite dramatically in the space of a few weeks. Its only if he seems very slim or large for an extended period of time and you have additional worries about his diet that calculating his BMI may be helpful.

Thanks. I watched her take the measurement and if anything she underestimated, but like you say it wouldn't have come up that low. I'm wondering if it is something as simple as they think he is five not four maybe?

It's also just weird I queried it both times and both times told I was wrong.

OP posts:
Growthexpectations · 13/03/2024 13:58

NailedIt1 · 13/03/2024 13:54

That does seem a big drop, even accounting for the fact they all have growth spurts at different times. I wonder if they're using a different reference to what they were before. Or someone's typed something in wrong somewhere. The doctors obviously aren't bothered if they're dismissing you but I'd want to know what's going on too!

Yeah I mean I that's the thing, I want to know I'm not missing anything huge as growth can obviously be an indicator of something else. It's just that his height, our experience of comparison all tally with his previous percentile and not current. The doctor said as long as he was going along fine but he's dropped from 30 to 25 according to them over six months so given the huge drop you'd think they'd be interested.

OP posts: