Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think perhaps he deserved getting punched??

265 replies

Blouseybiggal · 13/03/2024 11:33

Tricky one as far as I’m concerned - violence bad but this guy was being a homophobic dick so…

Friend’s brother is a bit of an arsehole, winds people up, thinks he’s funny. I have as little to do with him as possible as he’s a right wing type who always thinks he’s right and could start an argument in an empty room.

So, Jeff is in a bar with his girlfriend. A gay couple - one ‘girlie’ one more masc looking ( apparently) - stand near them at the bar ordering drinks, minding their own biz.

Jeff, loud enough for half the bar to hear, says ‘ I don’t get it. If you’re going to go for someone who looks like a man, why not just go out with a man’ at the couple.

The ‘girlie’ woman says ‘what did you say?’ To him, he repeats it, and she punches him in the face. He falls over, his girlfriend is outraged, the gay couple leave.

For what it’s worth, I’m genuinely surprised he doesn’t get thumped more often.

YANBU - he deserved that! Homophobic prick.

YABU - he’s entitled to his opinion, violence is never the answer.

OP posts:
Isitbedtimeyet3 · 13/03/2024 16:01

Both were in the wrong. He doesn’t have to approve of same sex relationships however he didn’t need to give his opinion especially to strangers. The person in the couple shouldn’t have punched him either though. That is assault and had it been a man who had hit a woman all hell would break lose.

Sparklfairy · 13/03/2024 15:59

Hereyoume · 13/03/2024 12:22

And if a woman had said the same about two gay men, and one of the men had punched the woman, would you all be rushing to the man's defence?

I'm a woman and if I'd acted like the guy in the OP and got punched by a bloke, it would have been my own fault. Everyone in my social circle would absolutely tell me I brought it on myself too.

I don't condone violence but if you start with the hate speech, the consequences are your own fault.

Inkyblue123 · 13/03/2024 15:59

Couldn’t have happened to a nicer chap ….

DillDanding · 13/03/2024 15:53

Anyone that lashes out in violence is a dickhead. No amount of fuckwittery deserves a punch and only morons think that’s the answer.

Minymile · 13/03/2024 15:49

He should have been chucked out, if not also banned, from the pub.

Lockpeopleinrooms · 13/03/2024 15:49

The answer is in the middle of your options. He doesn't deserve to voice his homophobic opinions but also punching someone is totally wrong.

Ramalangadingdong · 13/03/2024 15:45

I don't think he's entitled to that opinion, but violence is never the answer. What if he'd been killed?

Ggttl · 13/03/2024 15:45

If everyone punched people who said stupid and insulting comments to them, it would be a total blood bath out there. It would also be a blood bath at home.

PToosher · 13/03/2024 15:42

TeaGinandFags · 13/03/2024 15:33

Provocation is a defence at law.

On the other hand, he'll have to explain to the magistrate exactly how belligerent and abusive he was being and that the 'girlie' one chinned him.

I'd buy tickets for that.

Is someone saying something you find offensive 'provocation'?

You'd need to explain to the court why you felt it was appropriate to assault someone because you didn't like what they said.

PToosher · 13/03/2024 15:37

FOJN · 13/03/2024 15:35

A preemptive punch is not self defence.

He wasn't expressing right wing opinions, he made offensive remarks obviously intended to humiliate the women.

I don't agree with violence but I do feel sorry for the two women, I wonder how much lesbophobia they have put up with from dickheads when they're minding their own business.

A pre-emptive punch is self defence if you believe you are about to be struck. You do not need to wait until you are struck / stabbed / shot to defend yourself.

FOJN · 13/03/2024 15:35

PToosher · 13/03/2024 15:27

He was assaulted.
He could have defended himself before he was struck and decked 'her' first. How would that have gone down with the 'He had it coming', crowd on here?
Or is hurty words a good enough reason to assault someone, so long as the one being assaulted is a bloke or, God forbid, expressing right wing opinions?

A preemptive punch is not self defence.

He wasn't expressing right wing opinions, he made offensive remarks obviously intended to humiliate the women.

I don't agree with violence but I do feel sorry for the two women, I wonder how much lesbophobia they have put up with from dickheads when they're minding their own business.

PToosher · 13/03/2024 15:35

Coconutter24 · 13/03/2024 15:33

It wouldn’t be self defence, if she was repeatedly hitting him then yes he in my eyes has every right to punch her back to defend himself but in this case he would have just been retaliating.

If she approached him and he feared he was about to be struck he would be within his rights to defend himself.

C1N1C · 13/03/2024 15:35

fedupandstuck · 13/03/2024 11:40

You need a third option - he is not entitled to be homophobic towards others, and violence is not the answer.

This.

The guy was a dick, but sticks and stones, assault is still assault.

slore · 13/03/2024 15:34

PToosher · 13/03/2024 15:27

He was assaulted.
He could have defended himself before he was struck and decked 'her' first. How would that have gone down with the 'He had it coming', crowd on here?
Or is hurty words a good enough reason to assault someone, so long as the one being assaulted is a bloke or, God forbid, expressing right wing opinions?

Agreed. No one deserves to be punched for saying hurty words, no matter what.

Also, she put herself massively at risk by punching him. At the end of the day he's a man, and she was very lucky (a) she caught him by surprise, and (b) he didn't decide to retaliate.

Coconutter24 · 13/03/2024 15:33

Midnightrunners · 13/03/2024 11:43

Would it be OK if defended himself and hit her back ?.

It wouldn’t be self defence, if she was repeatedly hitting him then yes he in my eyes has every right to punch her back to defend himself but in this case he would have just been retaliating.

TeaGinandFags · 13/03/2024 15:33

PToosher · 13/03/2024 15:27

He was assaulted.
He could have defended himself before he was struck and decked 'her' first. How would that have gone down with the 'He had it coming', crowd on here?
Or is hurty words a good enough reason to assault someone, so long as the one being assaulted is a bloke or, God forbid, expressing right wing opinions?

Provocation is a defence at law.

On the other hand, he'll have to explain to the magistrate exactly how belligerent and abusive he was being and that the 'girlie' one chinned him.

I'd buy tickets for that.

slore · 13/03/2024 15:32

YABU. An unpleasant bigoted comment is not equal to physical violence.

People should be allowed to speak their minds (even if wrong) without the risk of being assaulted - and as previous posters mentioned, being put at risk of brain damage.

WORDS ARE NEVER JUSTIFICATION FOR VIOLENCE.

TeaGinandFags · 13/03/2024 15:31

ThisGoldHedgehog · 13/03/2024 11:35

What a satisfying tale. I’m delighted he was punched.

Seconded!

IsthisthereallifeIsthisjustfantasy · 13/03/2024 15:28

Did he deserve it? Yes.

Is this going to make him less homophobic and misogynistic in future? Or more hateful? Maybe more hateful inside but less likely to make those kind of comments in public? Probably will just hide away and make them anonymously online instead. Is that better? Maybe a bit? I don't know.

PToosher · 13/03/2024 15:27

He was assaulted.
He could have defended himself before he was struck and decked 'her' first. How would that have gone down with the 'He had it coming', crowd on here?
Or is hurty words a good enough reason to assault someone, so long as the one being assaulted is a bloke or, God forbid, expressing right wing opinions?

PassingStranger · 13/03/2024 15:23

Nope don't agree with the punch. He could have been seriously injured or died from that.

I think the girl could have thought of something else.
Perhaps better if the manager had asked him to leave.

BluntFatball · 13/03/2024 15:20

Another one here who would vote for the third option.

There are people I vehemently disagree with. I find their views repulsive and offensive.

I also would like to think in a civilised society we've moved past violence as a way of dealing with those we don't agree with.

Blouseybiggal · 13/03/2024 15:14

‘You know the saying: if 9 people sit down at a table with 1 Nazi without protest, then there are 10 Nazis at the table.’

what? That’s NOT a saying I’ve ever heard of!

‘They should have recorded the conversation, called the police and had him arrested.’

pretty sure it all happened within 30 seconds or so, no time to whip out phones and start recording even if anyone had thought of it!

Anyway, they’ve left - they don’t live in our town, just visiting - so the chances of anyone tracking anyone down are probably slim.

OP posts:
ntmdino · 13/03/2024 15:13

Caerulea · 13/03/2024 12:06

Isn't there a subreddit you should be skulking around somewhere?

What on earth are you talking about?

Are we not allowed to even ask questions now?

For the avoidance of doubt, I'm in the "violence is just as dumb as the original idiot" camp. Sure, I've wanted to punch people - men and women - in the past, but somehow I've managed to restrain myself and find another way to make them look like absolute morons instead.

anyolddinosaur · 13/03/2024 14:32

They should have recorded the conversation, called the police and had him arrested.

Swipe left for the next trending thread