Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think perhaps he deserved getting punched??

265 replies

Blouseybiggal · 13/03/2024 11:33

Tricky one as far as I’m concerned - violence bad but this guy was being a homophobic dick so…

Friend’s brother is a bit of an arsehole, winds people up, thinks he’s funny. I have as little to do with him as possible as he’s a right wing type who always thinks he’s right and could start an argument in an empty room.

So, Jeff is in a bar with his girlfriend. A gay couple - one ‘girlie’ one more masc looking ( apparently) - stand near them at the bar ordering drinks, minding their own biz.

Jeff, loud enough for half the bar to hear, says ‘ I don’t get it. If you’re going to go for someone who looks like a man, why not just go out with a man’ at the couple.

The ‘girlie’ woman says ‘what did you say?’ To him, he repeats it, and she punches him in the face. He falls over, his girlfriend is outraged, the gay couple leave.

For what it’s worth, I’m genuinely surprised he doesn’t get thumped more often.

YANBU - he deserved that! Homophobic prick.

YABU - he’s entitled to his opinion, violence is never the answer.

OP posts:
yourenottgebossoofme · 14/03/2024 07:31

SoreAndTired1 · 14/03/2024 05:00

I'm a bit confused by your post. You say gay couple (which means men) but then use 'she'. So was it a gay couple or lesbian couple? And I can't imagine a woman just punching a male stranger in the face like that, as women tend not to hit men knowing they are stronger, taller and pack more power than us. But either way, if your friend's brother was being homophobic and directly to their face, then he deserved the punch.

Edited

Gay means attracted to the same sex- men or women.

Plenty of women are boxers/weightlifters/kick-boxers etc.

Clearly this woman had a good idea of her capabilities since she took him out.

Itsallfunngamesuntil · 14/03/2024 07:21

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 13/03/2024 19:19

I would hope the bar staff have now banned the woman who assaulted the (homophobic) man

I agree

I was referring to the events before he was punched though

VestibuleVirgin · 14/03/2024 07:06

Does your friend realise that she has such an unpleasant person as a brother?

Blouseybiggal · 14/03/2024 07:01

SoreAndTired1 · 14/03/2024 05:00

I'm a bit confused by your post. You say gay couple (which means men) but then use 'she'. So was it a gay couple or lesbian couple? And I can't imagine a woman just punching a male stranger in the face like that, as women tend not to hit men knowing they are stronger, taller and pack more power than us. But either way, if your friend's brother was being homophobic and directly to their face, then he deserved the punch.

Edited

I’m gay as in a gay woman. I say gay, lots of women say gay. Sometimes I say lesbian.
I thought the other details in the post made it clear it was a female couple.

OP posts:
Blouseybiggal · 14/03/2024 06:58

‘And had he retaliated, punched her back, in self defence,

he didn’t though! Perhaps we just judge on the facts! Although I’m swayed by the fact that I know how smug and obnoxious he can be.

OP posts:
JudgeJ · 14/03/2024 06:49

ThisGoldHedgehog · 13/03/2024 11:35

What a satisfying tale. I’m delighted he was punched.

And had he retaliated, punched her back, in self defence, you would expedition him to be arrested no doubt! He was wrong, utterly crass, but she landed the first physical blow.

Maray1967 · 14/03/2024 06:44

LakieLady · 13/03/2024 13:34

Now that would be a shocking waste of a perfectly good drink.

Throwing his drink in his face, on the other hand ...

Yes - great point!

I’m sure it would still be considered an assault, but something dramatic needs to happen to him. He needs a lesson which being asked to leave the bar doesn’t really provide.

ntmdino · 14/03/2024 06:39

Blouseybiggal · 13/03/2024 21:43

‘Imagine if had been the other way around.’

it wasn’t. Circumstances matter, no? Like ‘what if it was 3 people punching him…’ it wasn’t. Nor two gay men nor the man hitting the woman… etc etc

As noted...circumstances only matter in regard to mitigation, not guilt. What she did was illegal, regardless of what he said; the only circumstance in which her behaviour was justified (legally-speaking) would've been if she was acting in self-defence, which she wasn't.

Freakinfraser · 14/03/2024 06:39

SoreAndTired1 · 14/03/2024 05:00

I'm a bit confused by your post. You say gay couple (which means men) but then use 'she'. So was it a gay couple or lesbian couple? And I can't imagine a woman just punching a male stranger in the face like that, as women tend not to hit men knowing they are stronger, taller and pack more power than us. But either way, if your friend's brother was being homophobic and directly to their face, then he deserved the punch.

Edited

My daughter is gay and happy for the term gay couple. Gay means attracted to same sex, yes particularly of men, but can be used for women. It is absolutely not exclusively men and you can’t make up your own definition and decide every one needs to abide.

SoreAndTired1 · 14/03/2024 05:00

I'm a bit confused by your post. You say gay couple (which means men) but then use 'she'. So was it a gay couple or lesbian couple? And I can't imagine a woman just punching a male stranger in the face like that, as women tend not to hit men knowing they are stronger, taller and pack more power than us. But either way, if your friend's brother was being homophobic and directly to their face, then he deserved the punch.

PickAChew · 13/03/2024 23:35

While I don't condone violence, I think he was lucky that a sore nose and bruised dignity was all he got for mouthing off. There are plenty of people out there who don't give a shit about the ethics of a violent response and might punch him harder or even pull a knife on him.

WingsofRain · 13/03/2024 23:19

fedupandstuck · 13/03/2024 11:40

You need a third option - he is not entitled to be homophobic towards others, and violence is not the answer.

Yes, I agree.

Rainynight09 · 13/03/2024 23:15

So OP, do you think it is okay to punch someone for saying something you disagree with? Why don’t you do it then? See how far that attitude gets you. Inside a prison cell that’s where.

Willyoujustbequiet · 13/03/2024 23:12

No. Violence isn't the answer.

One punch can kill.

Rainynight09 · 13/03/2024 22:59

Blouseybiggal · 13/03/2024 21:43

‘Imagine if had been the other way around.’

it wasn’t. Circumstances matter, no? Like ‘what if it was 3 people punching him…’ it wasn’t. Nor two gay men nor the man hitting the woman… etc etc

That’s why I said imagine. I know how it was. I can read. I was highlighting double standards. Wouldn’t the punch have been caught on CCTV? No?

ApartFromAllThat · 13/03/2024 22:05

I'm very glad he didn't die and I'm very glad he got punched.

He asked why she wasn't dating an actual man, she obviously attempted to demonstrate in terms understandable to him, that she felt didn't need a man's protection.
"Oh, explanation accepted", he said, as he slide down to the floor.

The gf outraged? Was she there for all of it I wonder? Did she wonder if it was any of his fucking business?

EarringsandLipstick · 13/03/2024 21:52

Blouseybiggal · 13/03/2024 21:43

‘Imagine if had been the other way around.’

it wasn’t. Circumstances matter, no? Like ‘what if it was 3 people punching him…’ it wasn’t. Nor two gay men nor the man hitting the woman… etc etc

Hence the 'imagine' bit!

I think it's valid. The point being, punching someone won't resolve anything, will not change this man's homophobic views, and could have led to a more serious situation.

Kpo58 · 13/03/2024 21:51

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 13/03/2024 19:26

Or

They should have videoed the assault, called the police and had Punchy Woman arrested

How would they have had videoed either the abusive language or the punch? They probably wouldn't have had time to get their phone out and start filming before it had finished.

I'm not sure what words would have worked on the man (apart from 'you no longer have your job'). He would have played the victim if he got banned from the bar or asked to leave. Something along the lines of I was only speaking the truth/this country is going to the.../they can't take a joke, etc etc.

Blouseybiggal · 13/03/2024 21:43

‘Imagine if had been the other way around.’

it wasn’t. Circumstances matter, no? Like ‘what if it was 3 people punching him…’ it wasn’t. Nor two gay men nor the man hitting the woman… etc etc

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 13/03/2024 21:41

Starspangledrodeopony · 13/03/2024 18:41

I hope she broke his fucking jaw.

That's an appalling thing to post. 😳

WalkingThroughTreacle · 13/03/2024 20:57

BlackForestCake · 13/03/2024 19:07

I saw a documentary once on how one well placed punch can kill or brain damage.

This can happen if a man is doing the punching. But I would be very surprised if there was any recorded case of a woman killing a man with one punch.

Most one punch killings are not a direct result of the punch itself but more usually from the victim hitting their head hard on the ground when they go down. If a woman can punch well enough to knock a man down, and it doesn't take a lot of force if it lands in the right place, then she is just as capable of causing him to suffer a fatal head injury on contact with the pavement or floor.

All that said, that didn't happen in this case and frankly the level of contrived whataboutery on this thread is staggering and the motivation for it highly suspicious.

Rainynight09 · 13/03/2024 20:55

A single punch can kill someone. Imagine if had been the other way around. A member of the couple made a nasty comment towards him and his girlfriend, and then he punched one of the women. That would not be ok, would it? Put the shoe on the other foot and then see what you think.

yourenottgebossoofme · 13/03/2024 20:35

DrJoanAllenby · 13/03/2024 19:31

The offended person could have engaged in a debate or robust discussion without the need for violence.

A single punch can kill as can a blow to the head on the ground when felled.

Hurty words are hurty words and whilst he may be a duck, the person who punched him is a violent thug who does not have any communication skills or the ability to turn the other cheek when faced with a fool.

If only it were that simple.

yourenottgebossoofme · 13/03/2024 20:34

I wouldn’t have punched him- a friend of mine did this to a racist guy who had been harassing her for about 10 minutes and she ended up in court… but I entirely understand the urge!

Blouseybiggal · 13/03/2024 20:28

Well, no-one was killed with this punch so that’s that.

OP posts: