Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To let DD 13 move schools

69 replies

Bonnyswannie · 13/03/2024 09:44

since year 8 dd’s behaviour has deteriorated
it’s a bit of everything she has some traumatic events last year on top of the usual friendships problems etc
for the last 6-8 months she has been desperate to move to another local school as she feels this is a fairer school (her school is very strict) and that she could focus on her learning the way things are going she is getting such a bad rep and her grades are declining.
I am worried about letting my dd dictate about certain things but on the other hand I wonder whether this may help the situation?

OP posts:
KestrelMoon · 13/03/2024 17:22

Bonnyswannie · 13/03/2024 17:20

This was just before I did her screenings. I did refuse for her to do this one because of this reason though. Her lessons are 1.5 hours and she does struggle with the length of them

Good, it warms my heart to read how much you are fighting for your DD. You’re a good mum.

BoohooWoohoo · 13/03/2024 17:21

It’s a gamble because less strict might mean she’s gambling on her bad behaviour being overlooked at the new school but it comes with the major pro that it ends her contact with the older girls. She might change and I would risk it at 13.

Bonnyswannie · 13/03/2024 17:20

KestrelMoon · 13/03/2024 17:19

My dd has had a detention issued for looking out the window and when I questioned this I was told yes this was correct she wasn’t focusing!!!

This is illegal for a child suspected of having ADHD or diagnosed with it. Their disability causes this, and it is illegal, yes illegal for a school to punish a child for a suspected or known disability.

This was just before I did her screenings. I did refuse for her to do this one because of this reason though. Her lessons are 1.5 hours and she does struggle with the length of them

OP posts:
Bonnyswannie · 13/03/2024 17:20

KestrelMoon · 13/03/2024 17:17

I would move her. The advice for a kid that has fallen in with the wrong crowd and self destructive behaviour patterns is to move them even though they usually are defiant and don’t want to. You are lucky that she wants to move. It means she wants to break free from the crowd and self-destructive patterns, so count your blessings and move her to another school.

I see she is being assessed for ADHD, perhaps ask it also include autism? Because questioning fairness and interpretation of rules and having the balls to do it in public to a teacher is a big red flag for an autistic kid that then gets into trouble for pointing out where school rules are contradictory or even stupid.

Yes they have suggested it includes an autism assessment actually

OP posts:
KestrelMoon · 13/03/2024 17:19

My dd has had a detention issued for looking out the window and when I questioned this I was told yes this was correct she wasn’t focusing!!!

This is illegal for a child suspected of having ADHD or diagnosed with it. Their disability causes this, and it is illegal, yes illegal for a school to punish a child for a suspected or known disability.

Foxesandsquirrels · 13/03/2024 17:18

Bonnyswannie · 13/03/2024 17:09

In her school about 15 to people have left due to it being very strict which I used to think wasn’t a bad thing

I'd move her. My DD isn't like this at all, never got in trouble or anything but only now she's moved to a much more relaxed school I can see how anxious it's made her about anything. Those schools are brilliant for some kids, but not for a lot.

KestrelMoon · 13/03/2024 17:17

I would move her. The advice for a kid that has fallen in with the wrong crowd and self destructive behaviour patterns is to move them even though they usually are defiant and don’t want to. You are lucky that she wants to move. It means she wants to break free from the crowd and self-destructive patterns, so count your blessings and move her to another school.

I see she is being assessed for ADHD, perhaps ask it also include autism? Because questioning fairness and interpretation of rules and having the balls to do it in public to a teacher is a big red flag for an autistic kid that then gets into trouble for pointing out where school rules are contradictory or even stupid.

Bonnyswannie · 13/03/2024 17:16

cansu · 13/03/2024 17:12

By the way this is how the very strict schools get good results, calm classrooms and good attitudes to learning. The families and children who don't follow the rules often leave for so called 'fairer' schools where they can get away with poor behaviour.

This is what I used to think however the enforcement of tinier rules can trigger some people if they can’t meet the high standards and this ends up in a volatile atmosphere. Just yesterday there was a serious physical argument in the class room that started off from something quite minute (dd was not involved)
sadly it’s not a one size fits all. My dd has had a detention issued for looking out the window and when I questioned this I was told yes this was correct she wasn’t focusing!!!

OP posts:
XelaM · 13/03/2024 17:15

cansu · 13/03/2024 17:12

By the way this is how the very strict schools get good results, calm classrooms and good attitudes to learning. The families and children who don't follow the rules often leave for so called 'fairer' schools where they can get away with poor behaviour.

Not poor behaviour but not prison-like rules! My daughter is a nice teen who does well at her more relaxed school, whereas she was getting constant detentions for some ridiculously minor things that left her completely disheartened and hating her school/teachers. School is not prison.

Bonnyswannie · 13/03/2024 17:13

cansu · 13/03/2024 17:09

So she has made friends with the wrong crowd. I will be honest kids who like messing around tend to gravitate towards others who mess about.

If she is in lots of trouble in this school chances are she will be similar in another school. She will seek out those kinds of kids in her new environment.

Personally I would be trying instead to back up school at home. So if she doesn't make a full day of lessons because of truanting or being sent out then no phone or Internet when she gets home that day.

Thanks we have been doing this for months on end

OP posts:
XelaM · 13/03/2024 17:13

cansu · 13/03/2024 17:09

So she has made friends with the wrong crowd. I will be honest kids who like messing around tend to gravitate towards others who mess about.

If she is in lots of trouble in this school chances are she will be similar in another school. She will seek out those kinds of kids in her new environment.

Personally I would be trying instead to back up school at home. So if she doesn't make a full day of lessons because of truanting or being sent out then no phone or Internet when she gets home that day.

Sorry but that's terrible advice and a way to ruin your relationship with your teen (and will achieve nothing). Would you stay in a job you hated or try to move for a fresh start?

cansu · 13/03/2024 17:12

By the way this is how the very strict schools get good results, calm classrooms and good attitudes to learning. The families and children who don't follow the rules often leave for so called 'fairer' schools where they can get away with poor behaviour.

doubleshotcappuccino · 13/03/2024 17:10

Yes absolutely - we did- worked out well from a learning point of view but also the positive change in our relationship with our son was huge - he felt heard and empowered and that changed him so much -

Caerulea · 13/03/2024 17:09

I'd move her. The fact she wants to suggests she feels stuck in this behaviour & rut & wants to get out of it. She would have a chance to turn things round before GCSEs.

Just make it a very serious discussion about trust etc etc.

But definitely move her.

cansu · 13/03/2024 17:09

So she has made friends with the wrong crowd. I will be honest kids who like messing around tend to gravitate towards others who mess about.

If she is in lots of trouble in this school chances are she will be similar in another school. She will seek out those kinds of kids in her new environment.

Personally I would be trying instead to back up school at home. So if she doesn't make a full day of lessons because of truanting or being sent out then no phone or Internet when she gets home that day.

Bonnyswannie · 13/03/2024 17:09

In her school about 15 to people have left due to it being very strict which I used to think wasn’t a bad thing

OP posts:
RhubarbGingerJam · 13/03/2024 17:08

I'd try getting her moved - see how likely it is to happen.

One of mine got labelled as trouble not by teachers but support staff end of y10 - it would die down and then flare up all though Y11- causing upset being accused of things couldn't have done. Actual teachers seemed to find them pleasant polite and hardworking entire time there but that and previous year good behavior seemed not to matter to SLT.

Took a lot to keep them on tack to get good GCSE - few time it was what's the point why bother trying - been fine at college very motivated.

Bonnyswannie · 13/03/2024 17:08

VickyEadieofThigh · 13/03/2024 17:06

I'm intrigued to know what her evidence base is for thinking this other school is a "fairer" school, however.

People that attend there have told her experiences

OP posts:
VickyEadieofThigh · 13/03/2024 17:06

I'm intrigued to know what her evidence base is for thinking this other school is a "fairer" school, however.

Bonnyswannie · 13/03/2024 17:03

Prawncow · 13/03/2024 16:56

I’d definitely look at moving her. It sounds like she’d benefit from a fresh start. How do you feel about the school she wants to move to?

I don’t think very strict schools work for every child. Being given detention for forgetting a calculator or rolling up a skirt means many children are a lot more careful about not breaking the rules again. It also means that those who were already unhappy, unsettled or who have organisational issues end up being kicked out of class and put in with children who are completely disengaged with learning. If they make friends there it can make detention a more attractive option than staying in class.

Well it wasn’t my first choice because it’s an old school and has a bit of a rep at times but that’s cos there are a lot of kids there. But to be honest my outlook on schools and education has changed a lot in the last years. I know a lot of kids that went there and are doing well. It’s a lot to do with parenting too. I think she would find the shorter lessons easier to focus and all I want is for her to leave with a good gcse’s and aspirations

that’s what’s happened with DD she honestly never had a call home before this year

OP posts:
Prawncow · 13/03/2024 16:56

I’d definitely look at moving her. It sounds like she’d benefit from a fresh start. How do you feel about the school she wants to move to?

I don’t think very strict schools work for every child. Being given detention for forgetting a calculator or rolling up a skirt means many children are a lot more careful about not breaking the rules again. It also means that those who were already unhappy, unsettled or who have organisational issues end up being kicked out of class and put in with children who are completely disengaged with learning. If they make friends there it can make detention a more attractive option than staying in class.

Bonnyswannie · 13/03/2024 16:56

Icannoteven · 13/03/2024 16:51

Yanbu. Strict schools just do not suit some children, particularly if they are sensitive or clever (often clever children will not respect one-size-fits all or nonsensical rules).

This mirrors my experience at her age almost exactly. I was at a school where everything was very heirarchal and strict (e.g had to stand up when a teacher entered the room, were only allowed to drink at lunchtimes, put in isolation for forgetting your tie etc). I hated it and started to get in trouble because I hated the place. I hated the nasty, oppressive behaviour of the teachers towards students. I hated that there was just so much disruption and shouting in classes due to overly strict enforcement of rules. I hate that it was such an ‘us v them’ crushing attitude from the staff towards the pupils. I told the headmaster how I felt in our exit meeting too (the school were not very happy for me to leave because I was set 1 and top for a lot of subjects in my year).

I later moved to a lovely relaxed all-girl school where there was lots of mutual respect between teachers and students and even, shock, a culture of wanting to learn amongst the students. I don’t think I ever got a detention while I was there.

You are so right she is both sensitive and clever and she gets a lot of detentions for questioning logic in somethings she is seen as defiant. I do think in what world are we teaching our children not to question things.

I think my dd would resonate a lot with what you say. Thank you I needed to hear this. I’m scared I’m letting her get away with things but also at the same time I feel I need to listen to her

OP posts:
Bonnyswannie · 13/03/2024 16:53

Octavia64 · 13/03/2024 16:23

Yes I would move her.

It's very very hard once they are seen as a trouble maker.

Give her a fresh start, and put equipment in her bag!

Trust me I do put equipment in her bag, she loses things a lot. She is being assessed for adhd

OP posts:
Icannoteven · 13/03/2024 16:51

Yanbu. Strict schools just do not suit some children, particularly if they are sensitive or clever (often clever children will not respect one-size-fits all or nonsensical rules).

This mirrors my experience at her age almost exactly. I was at a school where everything was very heirarchal and strict (e.g had to stand up when a teacher entered the room, were only allowed to drink at lunchtimes, put in isolation for forgetting your tie etc). I hated it and started to get in trouble because I hated the place. I hated the nasty, oppressive behaviour of the teachers towards students. I hated that there was just so much disruption and shouting in classes due to overly strict enforcement of rules. I hate that it was such an ‘us v them’ crushing attitude from the staff towards the pupils. I told the headmaster how I felt in our exit meeting too (the school were not very happy for me to leave because I was set 1 and top for a lot of subjects in my year).

I later moved to a lovely relaxed all-girl school where there was lots of mutual respect between teachers and students and even, shock, a culture of wanting to learn amongst the students. I don’t think I ever got a detention while I was there.

itsgettingweird · 13/03/2024 16:45

Have a look at managed moves.

You may be able to just move her if space.

But reading about managed moves will reassure you that a fresh start can be the best thing for some pupils.