Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do I get people to stop making unsolicited comments on how I look

237 replies

Beepbeep18 · 13/03/2024 00:44

Recently I posted about an encounter with the guy I’d been seeing for about six weeks where he felt the need to tell me he didn’t find me that physically attractive and I had to physically tell him to leave because I felt physically sick I’d let him sleep with me.

a week ago, I made friends with a woman at a night I do, we went out for drinks and she told me I needed to “own my fatness and plus size identity”. I’m a size 12-14, yes, slightly overweight. There’s nothing wrong with being plus size and owning it but I’d never make claim to that because I don’t have the same experience. I also feel it’s such a personal thing to comment on.

I’ve been called ugly in a bar recently, had almost pitying laughs from a colleague about “what I look like in person” and someone I work with in a professional context said I was weird looking.

I genuinely don’t know what’s wrong with me! Parred back to my physical form of bone structure etc I’m fine and I have a good sense of style etc - can anyone tell me why people keep making these comments? It’s happened on and off all my life.

the recent ones have started to make me really dislike looking in a mirror or going out and being around new groups of people so I’ve booked some therapy to work through this as I don’t want it to become a problem. My friends think some of it happens because people end up feeling comfortable around me and almost word vomiting some of it out (this would make sense in a way from my skill set from my profession)

but seriously has anyone else ever known of this and how do I make it stop?!

OP posts:
FrenchFairytale · 13/03/2024 08:47

Also why are people obsessed with height??

Toomuchclothess · 13/03/2024 08:46

I had this my entire child hood, I was called ugly and disgusting by my school peers since being about 5 years old..
I still remember once my school mate looked at me in the class and said: Jane why are so much ugly?
it was so hurtful,I never forget this.
It knocked my confidence so much that later when I was a teen a walked everywhere with my head down and I never looked at people, always had my head down, literally bending down.

VampireWeekday · 13/03/2024 08:46

Agree with practicing a comeback. Even an incredulous "you what?" should do it. Anything to make them realise that you won't be bullied into laughing along.

I am (and always have been) a size 8. I went through a period of time where people felt the need to comment on my appearance, weird things like I have a small head, bad hair, looked frumpy. Lasted about a year. I think they were sensing insecurity and lack of availability, and it made them think they could say these things to me. So I guess the solution is make them realise that actually, they can't say these things to you.

FrenchFairytale · 13/03/2024 08:46

curiousasacat · 13/03/2024 08:43

No one who said this to me was a stunner so they can fuck off

Yup- in my experience, its never really genuinely attractive people who say this, its often people who look rough AF themselves. Therefore, I wonder if it's some kind of jealousy/insecurity playing out by having to take you down a peg to make themselves feel better about themselves. Pathetic really.

Definitely. I had to laugh when a very large lady said I was too slim. Imagine if I commented on her weight.

BeardyButton · 13/03/2024 08:45

People are assholes OP. I think you have to come up with a few one liners (loads of them on this thread) and then wheel them out.

My mother comments on appearance all the time. All three daughters have had eating disorders. She’s constantly rambling about strangers and their appearance. I’ve now figured out it comes from a massive place of inadequacy in her. Recently she did it to me in front of my 20 yr old niece. I immediately fell into trauma mode… my niece meanwhile said “ Gran, are you trying to fat shame Beardy? You’re a feminist right?! You know better than that”. My mother literally fell over herself and completely stopped in her tracks. I’m so proud sometimes of the generation of women coming after me.

so ya- it’s probably from a deeply unhappy place in these people… but that doesn’t make it ok.

curiousasacat · 13/03/2024 08:43

No one who said this to me was a stunner so they can fuck off

Yup- in my experience, its never really genuinely attractive people who say this, its often people who look rough AF themselves. Therefore, I wonder if it's some kind of jealousy/insecurity playing out by having to take you down a peg to make themselves feel better about themselves. Pathetic really.

FrenchFairytale · 13/03/2024 08:39

Yeah people are dicks
I've been told I'm short (5 foot 3)
Pale (English rose )
Scary eyes (ice blue)
No one who said this to me was a stunner so they can fuck off

ZebraD · 13/03/2024 08:37

That is just awful! I really feel for you. Bonnie deserves those comments and shame on them for saying them!

WoodBurningStov · 13/03/2024 08:36

I don't know how you make it stop, these people sound unbelievably rude. I think I'd brush up on my cutting remarks back and start to be equally rude back. Maybe use the words 'fuck off, you rude cunt' more liberally in the future.

Quorny · 13/03/2024 08:31

Wow how do you know so many rude people? Not just rude but absolutely horrible and mean with no social awareness whatsoever? Your problem is not how you look. Your problem is that somehow you are surrounded by too many arseholes.

Please don't question your looks. Normal people would not say stuff like this even to quasimodo. And if I was a size 12-14 I'd consider myself skinny. The average size in the UK for women is apparently a 16 and I've seen stunning women who are clearly much larger than that. Not that it matters because as I said no matter what you looked like normal people don't make comments like that to anyone.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 13/03/2024 08:27

I had a woman at a hobby group I went to who was always telling me I looked like I had a cold. I decided one day I had had enough and when as usual she pitched in with her unwanted comment I just said, ‘Can you not comment on my personal appearance please because I really hate it and it is starting to make me not look forward to coming to this group.’
There was a bit of an atmosphere for the rest of the meeting but she hasn’t done it since and we are fine now.

Honestly just say it, clearly, no game playing: ‘please don’t make comments about my personal appearance, I don’t like it’ and if relevant add ‘it’s not appropriate in the workplace.’

PrincessOfPreschool · 13/03/2024 08:17

I never get comments like this! I think it's because I'm overweight, old AND unstylish! (And really can't be bothered). They wouldn't know where to start. OP, if your only flaw is a little extra weight, I would take that.

curiousasacat · 13/03/2024 08:12

Foxyaus · 13/03/2024 03:24

Stare directory at them and say "Please repeat that." Don't break eye contact while they stutter and squirm. When they stop speaking, still maintain eye contact and silence. The silence speaks volumes and you maintain your dignity while they show themselves to be the shit humans they are.

I actually love this. Say, "what did you say?" with a stare and ask them to repeat it. Then, I'd act faux confused and say "I don't understand- what exactly are you saying?"- then get them to repeat it again, then when they do say, "so what does this actually mean- can you explain?" and keep this up for as long as they keep answering.

Most people wont have the balls to actually spell it out as forcing them to repeat it over and over will make them cringe at their own rudeness. If they do have the balls to explain what they mean then I'd say "oooooh I see- it's meant to be an insult, I get it now!- ok, well if we're doing that then I think your haircut is awful, makes you look a complete frump and ages you 20 years". Then give a big smile. I guarantee they wont be doing that again.

Elephantsareace · 13/03/2024 08:09

I think the old amused ''have YOU looked in a mirror lately?' come-back works perfectly for any comment on appearance and means you don't have to think on the spot

haveacat · 13/03/2024 08:09

You are a 12-14? That is not plus size!

So sorry that people have been mean to you.

IncompleteSenten · 13/03/2024 08:00

You could say wow, that was really rude/hurtful. What made you think it was ok to say that to me?

And then you wait for an answer. Let them be uncomfortable!

When they inevitably say it was a joke you say oh, was it? Why was it funny? Maybe I just didn't get it.

And again, wait for an answer.

Oh, so the joke is that I'm ugly, that's the joke is it?

Really make them squirm. People don't expect they'll be asked to explain themselves because most people bend over and take it up the arse because they feel they shouldn't make a fuss or they'll be making things awkward if they say anything. Fuck that. Make it awkward!

I'm not a fan of the whole did you mean to be so rude thing because I think being more direct works better.

I once told a bloke who decided I needed the benefit of his wisdom "I don't care what you think about anything".
He was a bit surprised.

I feel like you're not at the point you feel able to fire shots back but if you get to that point then when someone comments about your weight you can tell them in your best sad voice that people keep coming to you to moan about what a twat they are and they always bring cake.

HazelBite · 13/03/2024 07:59

The problem with this type of comment is that they take you by surprise so completely often out of the blue that you are temporarily lost for words. I have in the past been on the receiving end of unsolicited comments from family members and their sheer rudeness has rendered me temporarily speechless so there was no clever or admonishing retort from me as I was so taken aback at the time.
I am no pushover, and I wonder at the mentality of those who make personal comments, thinking it is okay to do so.

Startingagainandagain · 13/03/2024 07:53

Two things:

  • online dating is full of creeps including men who delight in making women feel bad about themselves. It not about you, it is about them and their 'issues'
  • comments on your appearance at work are completely inappropriate. I would give a stern reply: 'I don't appreciate you making comments about my body, especially not in a professional setting.'' Then report to HR.

You have to call people out and show that you won't put up with this nonsense.

CharlotteBog · 13/03/2024 07:51

I’m asking how to make the comments stop lol.

Keep it simple - "please don't make comments on my appearance, it's rude".
Then walk away if you can.

Sceptical123 · 13/03/2024 07:45

I agree with PP’s who say this response is usually from ppl who want to take you down a peg bc they feel you’re too big for your boots. There are a lot of them around sadly. They’d never say it to someone they found attractive who they also thought they’d have a chance with. Always ppl they think won’t do them harm if they cut them down to size (to give themselves an ego boost), or ppl who are out of their league, so they have nothing to lose and can vent their anger at presuming they’ll be viewed as not good enough by them etc. Sad.

HesterPrincess · 13/03/2024 07:43

I've been overweight most of my life and have had the worst comments imaginable. Now I've lost weight, all I get is "Gosh, what an improvement, you look so much better" and it's a really back handed compliment imo. Why not just say "god you used to look horrendous".

I think the MN mantra of "Did you mean to be so rude" may help us both, OP.

Moonlitwalk · 13/03/2024 07:40

Unfortunately in life 😕 you will come across arseholes in life male and females ones

I think it's a case of building up your resilience your cofindence levels on continuously levels

So when you come across arseholes like this you have got the confidence to stand up for yourself and not to let these kinds of comments get too

This is very sage advice. I'm tall (5'10") and have had people point it out to me and go on about it. I never understood why as it's not freakishly tall and I am fully aware of my height so I don't really understand the need to inform me about it as if I don't know. I think often we remember the insults we receive and easily forget the compliments - its confirmation bias.

You have to build up a very strong resilience and call it out every single time you hear it. Not only will that put them in their place but it will build your own confidence at the same time. I am never rude to people BUT, if they make a rude comment to me, I wont hesitate to comment back on their appearance. The majority of people arent supermodels so they have their own flaws of their own and I will happily point theirs out if they choose to be rude first. If you give out rudeness then you should expect to get it back I'm afraid. It's not difficult not to make rude personal comments so if you do it to me, then expect it back. It really does work and I think you need to start doing this- defend yourself as if someone insulted your best friend. Think of it like that. Whenever I have done this- they shut up remarkably quickly so it absolutely does work.

I'll give you an example- I was in a shop queue and some rough looking man behind me said "you're tall for a woman arent you?" I turned and looked him up and down (he was short and scruffy) and said "yes, and you're short for a man arent you?". Funnily enough, he shut up then. Strange how that works 😜people don't like it when it's directed back towards them!

5128gap · 13/03/2024 07:28

I can't imagine a conversation where 'owning your plus size' would come up apropos of nothing. I mean, how would she think you didn't? Sounds to me like a conversation where you expressed that you didn't think you were fat/liked your figure and she wanted to put you in your place.

Deathraystare · 13/03/2024 07:15

@Foxyaus

Yes! That is great! The silence for them will be embarrassing!

If they want the person to comment ask if they want applause!

Or when you ask them to repeat it, sigh and mockingly say "That wasn't worth saying really, was it?"

Northernsouloldies · 13/03/2024 07:13

My retort is ,I can do something about being fat but you will always be stupid...this is usually met with only joking,no need to be like that.yes there is .