Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do I get people to stop making unsolicited comments on how I look

237 replies

Beepbeep18 · 13/03/2024 00:44

Recently I posted about an encounter with the guy I’d been seeing for about six weeks where he felt the need to tell me he didn’t find me that physically attractive and I had to physically tell him to leave because I felt physically sick I’d let him sleep with me.

a week ago, I made friends with a woman at a night I do, we went out for drinks and she told me I needed to “own my fatness and plus size identity”. I’m a size 12-14, yes, slightly overweight. There’s nothing wrong with being plus size and owning it but I’d never make claim to that because I don’t have the same experience. I also feel it’s such a personal thing to comment on.

I’ve been called ugly in a bar recently, had almost pitying laughs from a colleague about “what I look like in person” and someone I work with in a professional context said I was weird looking.

I genuinely don’t know what’s wrong with me! Parred back to my physical form of bone structure etc I’m fine and I have a good sense of style etc - can anyone tell me why people keep making these comments? It’s happened on and off all my life.

the recent ones have started to make me really dislike looking in a mirror or going out and being around new groups of people so I’ve booked some therapy to work through this as I don’t want it to become a problem. My friends think some of it happens because people end up feeling comfortable around me and almost word vomiting some of it out (this would make sense in a way from my skill set from my profession)

but seriously has anyone else ever known of this and how do I make it stop?!

OP posts:
nadine90 · 13/03/2024 09:54

What I do when someone says something out of line, and I’m not feeling brave enough to flat out confront them, is to pretend I don’t understand. Keep repeating what they are saying but as a question. Keep saying “I don’t get it?”. Forces them to explain themselves and think about what they’ve said. Or you could just straight up tell them they’re rude/what a horrible thing to say to someone etc. I’m often not brave enough for that irl so thats why I do the first option.
It’s irrelevant what you look like, it’s never ok to put someone’s looks down. As someone who’s gone from a size 8 to a 16-18, I am all too aware of the difference in how people treat you when you’re on the larger side. From not being able to get served at the bar to people commenting on what I’m eating (normal food!) or telling me I need to walk more (I don’t drive, I walk bloody loads!) it’s horrible how shallow so many people are.

AccountantMum · 13/03/2024 09:52

I'm a clothes size 14-16 and have not experienced anyone being this rude to me - I don't think it's a reflection of your size or what you look like there must be something making people feel comfortable enough to make these kids of comments to you, or you have been unlucky and met multiple people who say inappropriate things.

YouDidntEvenAskIfSheWasThereMoriarty · 13/03/2024 09:52

Beepbeep18 · 13/03/2024 08:49

I think quite the opposite of making them uncomfortable; I think I make people too comfortable in the conversation and they sort of end up talking to me without the airs and graces you’d normally put on.

i am also very confident when speaking to strangers, i speak on topics with authority and knowledge and I know I’m very sharp and quick. But that doesn’t account for the people who haven’t seen / spoken to me making these weird comments! I have a unique but not outlandish sense of style, have always had very short hair etc.

im 30 and the comments come from a range of ages (older women seem to have always been extremely proactively kind about the way I look which is another facet of strangeness)

Are you alternative, by any chance?

I have found that, if you are, people seem to see that as a green light to make personal comments.

billybear · 13/03/2024 09:51

how rude are they.evan if you weighed 20 stone which you dont it would be no ones business, ignore have a snappy reply ready, please dont think its true, i wish i could get in a size 12 - 14 clothes,.i walk my dog in an old blue coat this little girl recently asked if i worked at tesco i asked why she said i always have that old blue coat on, very rude,i just replied im walking my dog its a regetta make, im not going to a party,

Pookerrod · 13/03/2024 09:47

I agree with your friend that it has nothing to do with the way you look but something about your profession or demeanour that makes dicks think they can say this to you.

My cousin is a model. She has a quite unusual androgynous look. She is very tall and very skinny with very short hair and an angular face. Her look is perfect for both runway and campaigns and she is very successful. But the number of times she has been called ugly when we’re on a night out, shouted horrible things by blokes when walking down the street. It’s just awful.

I have no advice on how to make it stop I’m afraid. I have a resting bitch face so have never been in your situation but you need to try and keep your head held high and remember it says more about them than it does you 💐

Gstaad · 13/03/2024 09:34

Ilovesunshine22 · 13/03/2024 09:32

Since when is a size 12-14 plus size! ☹️

Since vanity sizing became a thing perhaps?

Size 12-14 in some stores is pretty big…

Ilovesunshine22 · 13/03/2024 09:32

Since when is a size 12-14 plus size! ☹️

Moonlitwalk · 13/03/2024 09:31

Anniegetyourgun · 13/03/2024 09:17

Not on purpose to be hurtful, in my defence, well for the most part (maybe did at school with someone I really disliked, don't remember but expect I did). Sometimes a compliment that didn't work, sometimes thoughtlessness, most often I think a failed attempt at light-hearted teasing. Because I never thought much of my own looks it didn't really occur to me that others could be sensitive about theirs. Also, my dad was a terrible tease and very judgemental on others' looks and character, so I had to un-learn his example. It was a lesson painfully learned when I went out into the world of work that you can't just do that with someone who doesn't know you REALLY well! I cringe when I remember, but I have to forgive myself, as I would forgive a friend who truly repented of being an asshole. Still have to guard my tongue nowadays and I'm in my 60s. It doesn't come naturally. But I try. The problem this thread is about is that many people (nowadays?) don't seem to have any idea that they SHOULD even try to guard their tongues.

Thank you for answering! Yeah, I agree about light hearted teasing- I only do this with people I know very, very well and fully know what subjects to avoid as it could hit a sore spot for them. Interesting that your dad was like this too- just shows how important it is to model kindness and sensitivity to kids.

We've all done things we regret and none of us are perfect, but I agree that when you know that its hurting someone, you should absolutely stop and edit what you say.

Devilshands · 13/03/2024 09:28

Beepbeep18 · 13/03/2024 08:52

Also just to add when things have been said to me recently I have pulled the person up various times because I’m sick of being nice about it, but just wondered if anyone else had experience of why it happens and how to stop it more generally from the off

I am size 12-14 (depending on brand etc). The last time someone told me I could do with 'losing a bit of weight, because then you'd be very pretty' I politely pointed out I had just completed Ironman. When they then persisted, I very (unpolitely) pointed out that they could barely walk up the stairs without getting out of breath and they should focus on their own health woes before coming at me.

People who are rude enough to comment on weight/appearance don't deserve any politeness. Eventually, they realise that you're not an easy target to tear down in an attempt to make themselves feel good and they go and bother someone else.

Things like this are increasing because people are seeing 'perfect bodies' on social media and think everyone should be like that. But they can't do it themselves (for whatever reason) and feel insecure and take it out on other people. It's really sad.

Gstaad · 13/03/2024 09:26

blCkmagic · 13/03/2024 01:40

You’re mistaken. The trend was to have a small waist with flat stomach/abs with wide hips/bum. Your legs and arms were still supposed to be slim/toned. The look is an exaggerated slim pear/hourglass figure like Kylie Jenner - a quite rare figure in most people. The trend was definitely not to be a bigger woman all over. Hence why BBL surgery was so popular.

Plus that beauty trend is dying now, being slim is already trending again.

Thanks for the update, lol

Beansandneedles · 13/03/2024 09:23

OP I'm so so sorry you've had this happen even once let alone multiple times. I have no idea what's wrong with people that they think they have the right to talk to people like that.

I would previously have called them out on it. Probably in a way that I'd regret later, and then spend weeks thinking of what I should have said instead. In the last year or two I've come to realise moments like this say far more about the person saying them rather than about me. Ultimately you cannot stop people saying whatever they want to say, it's outside your zone of influence, but you can work on how you feel about yourself and then ultimately how things like this make you feel. You can also say something like 'I don't want/have to listen to this.' and leave. I'm hoping the therapy helps you to be confident and empowered in who you are so comments like this have no bearing on your mood or self-esteem. It helped me a lot with a similar issue (only personality traits rather than physical ones).

(edited to fix a typo)

Anniegetyourgun · 13/03/2024 09:17

Moonlitwalk · 13/03/2024 09:01

p.s. I used to comment on people's looks when I was younger, to my shame. As with many social graces I wasn't born with, eventually I learned better. My heartfelt apologies to anyone I hurt with unnecessary remarks. You'll be pleased to hear I'm getting it back tenfold these days!

Very honest of you to admit that- can I ask, what was the reason you did it?- was it insecurity do you think?

Not on purpose to be hurtful, in my defence, well for the most part (maybe did at school with someone I really disliked, don't remember but expect I did). Sometimes a compliment that didn't work, sometimes thoughtlessness, most often I think a failed attempt at light-hearted teasing. Because I never thought much of my own looks it didn't really occur to me that others could be sensitive about theirs. Also, my dad was a terrible tease and very judgemental on others' looks and character, so I had to un-learn his example. It was a lesson painfully learned when I went out into the world of work that you can't just do that with someone who doesn't know you REALLY well! I cringe when I remember, but I have to forgive myself, as I would forgive a friend who truly repented of being an asshole. Still have to guard my tongue nowadays and I'm in my 60s. It doesn't come naturally. But I try. The problem this thread is about is that many people (nowadays?) don't seem to have any idea that they SHOULD even try to guard their tongues.

EmmaEmerald · 13/03/2024 09:14

Is anyone else reading this and thinking, WTF?

There's an occasional arsehole commenter out there, sure, but many posters are talking about this as if it happens a lot.

OP I'm really sorry you're experiencing this. I find if people get too comfortable they overshare, I haven't found they make comments about me.

I'm middle aged but I notice other posters have said it goes on a lot, one poster said it's more frequent now. Couple of recent threads have made me wonder WTAF is going on in terms of appearance, expectation, criticisms.

I suppose if it's happening you need to have comebacks but....I'm really sorry it's happening. If it's part of a wider thing then how has that come about?

SortUKproblemsfirst · 13/03/2024 09:13

innerdesign · 13/03/2024 01:11

The comment about what you look like 'in person' makes me wonder if you use a lot of filters and Photoshop or Facetune online? Most people get very few rude and personal comments like this, so it seems unusual. But if you're (intentionally or inadvertently) catfishing people it makes more sense.

I wondered this too.

I'm pretty ugly but people don't comment. I've seen people who look 20 years younger on social media out and about and barely recognise them. So maybe that might make people comment 🤔 who knows.

Edwoodparkfootie · 13/03/2024 09:10

Crikey OP, I wish I was a 12-14, I think you’re right to keep calling them out, I’d definitely, use some of the suggested comments above and develop a fabulous stare to go with it.

graceinspace999 · 13/03/2024 09:09

Beepbeep18 · 13/03/2024 08:52

Also just to add when things have been said to me recently I have pulled the person up various times because I’m sick of being nice about it, but just wondered if anyone else had experience of why it happens and how to stop it more generally from the off

I think certain types of people (arseholes) sense vulnerability.
I am not victim blaming here but it’s something I have sensed and observed in myself and friends.
This ‘predatory sense’ makes them feel confident in insulting/abusing you.
These people are not like us. They don’t expect to be called out for their bad behaviour and are not sorry.
Still call them out by saying something like ‘is it insecurity or jealousy that makes you so rude.’

Then walk off with a huge smile to let them know they haven’t bothered you.

Never stay as that gives them time to say more stupid stuff and your smiling departure will speak volumes.

They are bullies looking to pick on somebody. Stay away from them and drop any ‘friends’ who are disrespectful towards you.

The root cause will be jealousy because they know you are better than them.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 13/03/2024 09:06

BeardyButton · 13/03/2024 08:45

People are assholes OP. I think you have to come up with a few one liners (loads of them on this thread) and then wheel them out.

My mother comments on appearance all the time. All three daughters have had eating disorders. She’s constantly rambling about strangers and their appearance. I’ve now figured out it comes from a massive place of inadequacy in her. Recently she did it to me in front of my 20 yr old niece. I immediately fell into trauma mode… my niece meanwhile said “ Gran, are you trying to fat shame Beardy? You’re a feminist right?! You know better than that”. My mother literally fell over herself and completely stopped in her tracks. I’m so proud sometimes of the generation of women coming after me.

so ya- it’s probably from a deeply unhappy place in these people… but that doesn’t make it ok.

My friend’s teenage son did that when his grandmother commented on his weight. ‘Are you trying to fat shame me?’ Brilliant.

Kittynoodle · 13/03/2024 09:04

I would stare at them and say

“fortunately your opinion isn’t of the slightest importance to me “

Soñando25 · 13/03/2024 09:04

I would also love to know how to stop these comments from the outset, but have absolutely no idea how to do that, unfortunately. Maybe it's about giving out a more distant vibe, I don't know, but I don't see why I should change how I am.

Moonlitwalk · 13/03/2024 09:01

p.s. I used to comment on people's looks when I was younger, to my shame. As with many social graces I wasn't born with, eventually I learned better. My heartfelt apologies to anyone I hurt with unnecessary remarks. You'll be pleased to hear I'm getting it back tenfold these days!

Very honest of you to admit that- can I ask, what was the reason you did it?- was it insecurity do you think?

Anniegetyourgun · 13/03/2024 08:59

People comment on my looks a fair bit, not because they're remarkable in any way but because I work in a local government public facing role. Low level, but to the client I represent the Council, by extension all government and every rule they don't like, and all they can do about it is insult the agent of it who's in front of them at the time. And obviously, being A Woman Of A Certain Age, they assume comments about my appearance will get to me. I take it as a kind of inverse compliment, because I'm obviously getting to them, otherwise they wouldn't bother.

I amuse myself with various responses such as "have a nice day", "thank you for your input", "oh you don't find me attractive then? good", "you should have gone to SpecSavers", "you're no oil painting yourself, Sunshine" (make sure no senior colleagues are in earshot when using that one), and "what on earth makes you think I'm interested in your opinion?". I guess it's trickier if it's someone you have to work with on a regular basis, or worse, someone you (used to) think of as a friend. As for poking you in the stomach to see if it was really part of you - I'd want to poke them right back, but probably wouldn't. It's technically assault even if it doesn't hurt. It's also disgusting manners.

p.s. I used to comment on people's looks when I was younger, to my shame. As with many social graces I wasn't born with, eventually I learned better. My heartfelt apologies to anyone I hurt with unnecessary remarks. You'll be pleased to hear I'm getting it back tenfold these days!

TR888 · 13/03/2024 08:58

OP, you sound confident, intelligent and have good self-esteem despite the way some people relate to you. I think you should call them up every single time this happens, but avoid being sarcastic in your response and go for deadpan literal. If you say: "I find your comment hurtful" - or similar short, clear sentence which leaves no room to interpretation- then people will be embarrassed. Watch them frantically backpedaling while you make no further comment 😉,

Fraaahnces · 13/03/2024 08:53

I can’t stand people like this… It’s becoming more and more common. It could be because you being okay in their own skin is intimidating or discomforting to them and they want to bring you down to their own level. It could simply be that they are competitive fuckwits who are attempting to bring attention to your perceived faults because they feel that you are getting attention they feel entitled to (deliberate or not.) On the whole, because there are just so many more people bloody everywhere, we encounter more of these mannerless twonks.

Beepbeep18 · 13/03/2024 08:52

Also just to add when things have been said to me recently I have pulled the person up various times because I’m sick of being nice about it, but just wondered if anyone else had experience of why it happens and how to stop it more generally from the off

OP posts:
Beepbeep18 · 13/03/2024 08:49

I think quite the opposite of making them uncomfortable; I think I make people too comfortable in the conversation and they sort of end up talking to me without the airs and graces you’d normally put on.

i am also very confident when speaking to strangers, i speak on topics with authority and knowledge and I know I’m very sharp and quick. But that doesn’t account for the people who haven’t seen / spoken to me making these weird comments! I have a unique but not outlandish sense of style, have always had very short hair etc.

im 30 and the comments come from a range of ages (older women seem to have always been extremely proactively kind about the way I look which is another facet of strangeness)

OP posts: