Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do I get people to stop making unsolicited comments on how I look

237 replies

Beepbeep18 · 13/03/2024 00:44

Recently I posted about an encounter with the guy I’d been seeing for about six weeks where he felt the need to tell me he didn’t find me that physically attractive and I had to physically tell him to leave because I felt physically sick I’d let him sleep with me.

a week ago, I made friends with a woman at a night I do, we went out for drinks and she told me I needed to “own my fatness and plus size identity”. I’m a size 12-14, yes, slightly overweight. There’s nothing wrong with being plus size and owning it but I’d never make claim to that because I don’t have the same experience. I also feel it’s such a personal thing to comment on.

I’ve been called ugly in a bar recently, had almost pitying laughs from a colleague about “what I look like in person” and someone I work with in a professional context said I was weird looking.

I genuinely don’t know what’s wrong with me! Parred back to my physical form of bone structure etc I’m fine and I have a good sense of style etc - can anyone tell me why people keep making these comments? It’s happened on and off all my life.

the recent ones have started to make me really dislike looking in a mirror or going out and being around new groups of people so I’ve booked some therapy to work through this as I don’t want it to become a problem. My friends think some of it happens because people end up feeling comfortable around me and almost word vomiting some of it out (this would make sense in a way from my skill set from my profession)

but seriously has anyone else ever known of this and how do I make it stop?!

OP posts:
ForTonightGodisaDJ · 13/03/2024 12:27

Beepbeep18 · 13/03/2024 12:22

so I don’t use filters etc: I fundamentally don’t believe in them, I don’t have the type of face where it would be realistically enhanced by them and I don’t get validation from people saying I look nice when it’s fake.

my hair: extremely short and extremely blonde

the comments: it’s not from people in my circle, it’s usually strangers or aquantances (apart from the date one which was quite extreme) and no, I hadn’t catfished him, he’d seen me filter free and in all lights of day before this comment

no one - no matter size shape creed colour identity - deserves to feel like the way they look is public property and can just be commentated on. But my issue is what is it about me that makes people do it when my peers do not get it? If we were all getting it I could understand, put it down to weirdos on nights out etc. but it’s consistently me

I think because your hair is "extremely short and extremely blonde".

Beepbeep18 · 13/03/2024 12:22

so I don’t use filters etc: I fundamentally don’t believe in them, I don’t have the type of face where it would be realistically enhanced by them and I don’t get validation from people saying I look nice when it’s fake.

my hair: extremely short and extremely blonde

the comments: it’s not from people in my circle, it’s usually strangers or aquantances (apart from the date one which was quite extreme) and no, I hadn’t catfished him, he’d seen me filter free and in all lights of day before this comment

no one - no matter size shape creed colour identity - deserves to feel like the way they look is public property and can just be commentated on. But my issue is what is it about me that makes people do it when my peers do not get it? If we were all getting it I could understand, put it down to weirdos on nights out etc. but it’s consistently me

OP posts:
LouLaBear23 · 13/03/2024 11:55

The thing is, it most likely isn’t something that’s ‘wrong’ with you; it’s projection on the part of whoever is making these comments.

Tricky part is, what’s causing this projection could be different for each person who’s making these comments so it likely won’t just be one thing (which isn’t in your control anyway). You say that you speak with authority and knowledge on things and perhaps this is intimidating to some and therefore they feel threatened and try to project their insecurities onto you. One of the most insidious human behaviours.

I think the only things you can really do are to not take their comments on board. This is a hard skill to learn and takes massive practice, as it does for all of us and I don’t think anyone really masters not letting other’s opinions in totally, but you can teach yourself that they are background noise. Secondly, keep acknowledging these comments for what they are to the people making them - they’re unwanted and rude. My fave line would be something like a previous poster said - ‘who taught you that it’s OK to make personal comments like that?’. Not aggressive and will likely make the person think.

declutteringdiscipline · 13/03/2024 11:40

What people say, is never a reflection on you, but a reflection on them. I have experienced similar, I try to think about the person and their motive - then disregard their unkind remarks.

For e.g. we are friends with a lovely neighbouring family that have just emigrated from Nigeria. The mum said she thought I was older than my (7-year-older) sister because I was “bigger”. I laughed and disregarded the comment because it’s a cultural difference (in Nigeria, weight is matter of fact and talking about it isn’t offensive) and there was no malice. If that same comment had come from a ‘friend’ of the same culture I would likely have said something (along the lines of ‘who needs enemies when they’ve got friends like you’ or sarcastically ‘that’s very kind of you!’) that would hopefully make them think, then I’d also disregard their comment thinking “wow aren’t they mean/insecure/jealous/tactless/etc”😅

There is nothing wrong with you, hopefully you are surrounded by much nicer people soon Flowers

vickylou78 · 13/03/2024 11:35

Op I'm a size 14-16 UK size and I've very rarely had any comments about my size as round here it's pretty average.

With regards to strangers saying you are ugly... I think that's really weird. Did anything happen to provoke that? Did you accidentally give them a dirty look? Push in in a queue?
Or perhaps I don't mean this unkindly but do you smile a lot or is your resting face not smiling? I feel that sometimes people are a little unlucky in that they appear to be frowning when they are perfectly happy and so unless you know them you think they are grumpy! I always give people benefit of the doubt until I speak to them. Could it be they think you don't like them and so are on the defence (not that it excuses the nasty behaviours you've experienced).

You also mentioned that you have good sense of humour so are people joking with you?

Sceptical123 · 13/03/2024 11:31

ForTonightGodisaDJ · 13/03/2024 11:06

After reading all your posts (people asking are you a lesbian? etc) I'm starting to think your hair could be the big factor (not that it should be at all). A lot of people have an opinion on short hair with a lot of men preferring long hair on women. I personally think short hair is fab if you can get away with it (I definitely couldn't).

Yes it’s really weird how women who ‘appear’ to be lesbians can be triggering for some men - as in very short hair, alternative fashion - stereotypes obv. But to these men it’s almost like giving them 2 fingers bc these women are unavailable to them, which is an insult, are shirking the misogynistic ideal of how women should present themselves, which is threatening, and are confident in their own right, which is offensive. TO THEM.

Also the PP who mentioned if you’re overtly funny and use it in group situations, I agree, ppl may feel you can take it, may even equate you with some well-known female stand-ups who joke about their weight a lot and are alternative themselves - in that regard you may even discern a hidden compliment as they are likening you to them, altho obviously still completely out of order.

Bluegray2 · 13/03/2024 11:29

Do you carry yourself with confidence…..nasty people seek out weak looking people who they think won’t say anything back to them, they rarely pick on confident looking people

tryingtohelp82 · 13/03/2024 11:23

@Gstaad
12-14 is not big in the UK.
18 is where plus size starts. Most women now fall into this category.

Moonlitwalk · 13/03/2024 11:23

Oh my god, I'm not defending it, but could it potentially cause someone to make harmful comments about someone's appearance? Yes

I mean, maybe, but the filter thing doesnt explain the other comments does it? Some people are just arseholes, I don't know why it has to be something OP is doing- there are plenty of dickheads out there. I worked in retail as a student and experienced plenty of rude comments, none of them justified- people were just being dicks

CharlotteBog · 13/03/2024 11:22

Beepbeep18 · 13/03/2024 10:55

to clarify: it’s not my friends making the comments. I mean I can be out with my group of diverse friends and I will get the stranger calling me ugly or someone I’ve just met that evening saying I’ve got weird hair etc etc etc sort of thing. But none of the others get it despite us all being very diverse - just me

In your OP you said you made friends with someone who then went on to say you needed to 'own your fatness'.

A stranger called you ugly? Like a catcall, or standing at the bar? I'm trying to visualise the situation. Catcalls are horrible and made by idiots, but we all know are not to be taken to heart (in the same way such a comment from a friend would be).

baileybrosbuildingandloan · 13/03/2024 11:20

I've been a size 14-16 all my life.

At size 14 I had absolutely no fat on my body at all. I was 9st 10. I have broad hips and my boobs never went below a DD.

I'm not pretty at all, but scrub up ok.

I have NEVER had anyone make an unsolicited comment about my looks. Ever.

I think it must be about the people in your life; they are not very nice.

Rumblingthunder · 13/03/2024 11:19

Turniptracker · 13/03/2024 11:08

Are you a very confident person? Sounds like they are trying to tear you down and put you in your place

I agree with this.

i think it’s your confidence causing this. People feel threatened by confident women and look for ways to bring them back down to earth.

i also think that people think you are only allowed to be confident if you’re ‘perfect’…that’s their own issues.

you describe yourself as being average looking ( taking this from your description) , and you’re an average size ( below average actually) - people are openly questioning why you are so confident.

even though you sound like you’re physically attractive- it’s not enough for some people.

but as you point out, you are funny, outgoing, good company.

basically just ignore it. You can’t change other people’s issues.

slippedonabanana · 13/03/2024 11:19

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 13/03/2024 10:58

Lovely passive aggression and victim blaming there.

What a nasty and unfair interpretation. We are all trying to help the OP figure out why she in particular has been on the receiving end of unwelcome comments.

bonzaitree · 13/03/2024 11:17

If someone doesn’t find you attractive after 6 weeks then it’s game over. Better they tell you now than after 6 years.

The other people it’s inexplicable! You can’t get them to not comment, the only thing you can do is control your reaction.

cooroocoocoo · 13/03/2024 11:16

Sympathies OP. I have no magic bullet, it sounds weird but I noticed in your latest update that you mention that you are funny (have a good sense of humour).

I do wonder if this is somehow the catalyst. That people think "she can take it" or sth like along these lines.

Other than this, are you in UK? Is it a cultural thing? Are you from a straight talking culture and everyone thinks you are abrupt so you can take what you dish out? I am saying this as I have a female Swedish friend who has experienced just this in the UK. People thought she was way more resilient that she was under this "faux cultural understanding" and she got quite upset tbh.

innerdesign · 13/03/2024 11:15

Moonlitwalk · 13/03/2024 11:12

but if I went on an online date and the person had clearly catfished me I'd be really pissed off

I'd be pissed off too but I wouldnt date them for 6 whole weeks and then be suddenly be annoyed about it!! If you choose to date someone you don't find attractive then that is entirely 100% on you. Noone is forcing you to date anyone you don't like.

Oh my god, I'm not defending it, but could it potentially cause someone to make harmful comments about someone's appearance? Yes.

Moonlitwalk · 13/03/2024 11:12

but if I went on an online date and the person had clearly catfished me I'd be really pissed off

I'd be pissed off too but I wouldnt date them for 6 whole weeks and then be suddenly be annoyed about it!! If you choose to date someone you don't find attractive then that is entirely 100% on you. Noone is forcing you to date anyone you don't like.

tryingtohelp82 · 13/03/2024 11:12

12-14 is not plus size, it's lower than the average and at that weight you still look smaller than most (I'm out and about a lot) and certainly won't stand out.
No-one deserves comments at ANY weight but I'm really confused why you keep getting them, and about your looks too.
All I can think of is 1) something about you make them jealous 2) you know a lot of awful people. This is not normal.

cerisepanther73 · 13/03/2024 11:12

@5128gap

Totally right ✅️ 👌 about your emotionally insightful post..

innerdesign · 13/03/2024 11:08

Moonlitwalk · 13/03/2024 10:43

do you use filters and Facetune

Even if she did, thats not an excuse to be rude though is it? loads of people use filters- every insta post I see has very obviously been filtered. Strangers making rude comments wont have seen any filtered pics and family and friends/work colleagues already know what she looks like so it's hardly going to be a shock to them as they see her in real life all the time. With regards to the guy she was dating- he dated her for 6 weeks so he already saw her in real life and knew what she looked like. He would have walked out on their first date if he was so annoyed with the comparison between a filtered photo and her real life image.

There's never really an excuse to be rude, but if I went on an online date and the person had clearly catfished me I'd be really pissed off. If they were nice I'd maybe give it a chance, but then six weeks later when we had a fight maybe I'd bring it up. I find it baffling when people over-filter. I obviously don't know if that's the issue here or not, but OP has asked for potential suggestions for why this happens but still hasn't answered my question, so maybe it is the issue and she doesn't want to face it.

Turniptracker · 13/03/2024 11:08

Are you a very confident person? Sounds like they are trying to tear you down and put you in your place

Beansandneedles · 13/03/2024 11:07

Gstaad · 13/03/2024 09:34

Since vanity sizing became a thing perhaps?

Size 12-14 in some stores is pretty big…

might be worth pointing out that 12-14 UK is different to 12-14 US. Not that it should matter, but can see how one might be viewed as plus size whilst the other is average.

ForTonightGodisaDJ · 13/03/2024 11:06

After reading all your posts (people asking are you a lesbian? etc) I'm starting to think your hair could be the big factor (not that it should be at all). A lot of people have an opinion on short hair with a lot of men preferring long hair on women. I personally think short hair is fab if you can get away with it (I definitely couldn't).

Beepbeep18 · 13/03/2024 11:04

I’d never ever comment on someone’s appearance in a negative way. Also very conscious to comment about my weight, body size, how my arse looks etc because I know it can be triggering. I‘m a good conversationalist and can hold a group but not particularly dominating or braggy. I am very funny though and I’m being honest here because I want honest opinions and there’s no point not being

OP posts:
TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 13/03/2024 10:58

slippedonabanana · 13/03/2024 10:56

No matter what you look like, it's very unusual to have people commenting on your appearance. Not that many of us come across so many rude acquaintances who feel free to voice their thoughts.

It's odd that others seem to want to bring you down. Is there any chance you've made comments that offended their appearance? Or do you present yourself as someone with an overly high opinion of themselves? Otherwise you just seem to be attracting nasty sorts who get a kick out of knocking others. Do you respond appropriately and freeze them out when they make these remarks?

Lovely passive aggression and victim blaming there.