Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That puberty blockers should not be promoted for children by any charities or celebrities for children.

282 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 13/03/2024 00:04

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-68549091.amp

https://archive.ph/hmIvY

Loads of news today about the NHS stopping puberty blockers being given to children who think they are trans. Puberty blockers are sometimes prescribed for children who have precocious puberty, however a narrative that has been pushed by Mermaids, Stonewall and celebrities like India Willoughby and Emma Watson (who gave a large donation to Mermaids) - that puberty blockers are safe and "lifesaving"

WPATH guidelines in the USA which the UK NHS have followed in procedure have had leaked documents and videos showing that they knew that children didn't have the ability to understand the long term effects.

https://amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/mar/09/disturbing-leaks-from-us-gender-group-wpath-ring-alarm-bells-in-nhs

https://archive.ph/h0BtF

And a new Finnish Study debunks the idea that children who say they are trans are more suicidal https://archive.ph/h0BtF

However Mermaids, Stonewall and India Willoughby are pushing puberty blockers as safe.

https://x.com/stonewalluk/status/1767603259932361036?s=

https://www.tiktok.com/@mermaidsgenderr*/photo/7345520902936726816?isfrommwebapp=1&senderdevice=mobile&senderrweb_id=7345629783211378209

https://x.com/indiawilloughby/status/1767595379921404151?s=46

AIBU to think that anyone pushing puberty blockers at this point is unethical? And that they should never have been allowed to be given to children who did not need them for precocious puberty where the risks are weighed up against the side effects and they are only used short term?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Iam4eels · 13/03/2024 20:53

I saw a post elsewhere on SM saying it's unfair that "cis" children will still have access to these drugs and implying that this is somehow discriminatory.

I have a child who was on puberty blockers for CPP (precocious puberty). There were medical assessments beforehand and the consultant had to write off for permission to prescribe the drugs (triptorelin), treatment was strictly limited to a set number of doses to be given spaced six months apart. During this time DC was monitored and regularly reviewed and I had an open route into the department if I had any concerns or any problems came up. DC did continue to develop while on treatment albeit much more slowly than before as they were on the minimum necessary dose of the blockers. As it was, DC's puberty overtook the blockers and rather than increase the dose we (and their team) decided that they were now old enough to stop treatment and let nature take it's course without significant risk of future problems as the short period on blockers (two years/four doses) had been successful at achieving the aims of the treatment.

I believe the blockers given for treatment of gender identity is at a higher dose and for a longer period and therefore carries a significantly higher risk of health effects.

While I'm very much live and let live and think transpeople have the right to live their lives in safety, free from hate and with the same human rights as the rest of us, I don't think children should be allowed to take these drugs simply because they're too young to give proper consent and puberty itself is a transitional life stage (no pun intended) where the brain is literally rewiring itself. If a child wants to wear gendered clothing typical of the opposite sex, use a different name, use different pronouns, cut/grow their hair then that's up to them and their parents and all of those things can be reversed/refined as they grow. Anything more permanent such as taking hormones or reassignment surgery should have to wait until adulthood when they can make informed choices about their own care.

WeMeetInFairIthilien · 13/03/2024 20:09

Cold, hard evidence seems to be the kryptonite of the affirmation only world.

Children can't give informed consent about things such as fertility, bone density and sterility.

Heavens, grown women are refused tubal ligations, because they are not old enough and they might want children one day.

If my primary school child chose to go down the PB/cross sex hormone/surgery route, it is likely that I would outlive them.

Kucinghitam · 13/03/2024 19:40

Poinsettiasarevile · 13/03/2024 19:08

I find it fascinating when you get an insight into the inner workings of the brains of people who hold views you simply cannot fathom. It is a good reminder that for some, no evidence will be enough, no expert will be expert enough, no common sense will be sensible enough.

Because they're high on their own Righteous BeeeeeKind farts, would be my guess.

Poinsettiasarevile · 13/03/2024 19:08

I find it fascinating when you get an insight into the inner workings of the brains of people who hold views you simply cannot fathom. It is a good reminder that for some, no evidence will be enough, no expert will be expert enough, no common sense will be sensible enough.

HardyCrow · 13/03/2024 17:58

Btw I am actually a scientist but frankly my status as a mother is sufficient insight to make a decision on this subject.

HardyCrow · 13/03/2024 17:55

ChatBFP · 13/03/2024 16:13

@newyorker74

I think you're clearly struggling with this as you've been told that accommodating trans people is the "kind" way to be.

The point is that adults make decisions to protect children all the time. We don't let them get tattoos and there are age related restrictions to a lot of things. We also don't just hand them drugs to experiment with.

And we shouldn't allow medical experiments with drugs that are proven to be harmful on them, even if said children think it is best for them.

Point is that many enlightened societies are rowing back from puberty blockers because they stunt brain, bone and sexual development, which is a high price to pay and very hard for a child to consent to. You're clearly in the US and have been told what the "enlightened" view is to have, but we don't share it because the medical evidence is quite frightening.

Yes all of this BFP. @New Yorker. There is a lot of information on this thread if you care to go back and read through it. Early on you suggested it should be left to the children themselves to make the decision. This isn’t how parenting works and can see some folks kids bringing law suits against their parents for not stopping them when the many harms were clearly and unambiguously in the public domain.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 13/03/2024 17:20

I am not a scientist but I can understand the principle of informed consent. If experts like the NHS and the Karolinska Institute are saying there is insufficient evidence for the benefits of puberty blockers in addressing gender dysphoria and growing evidence of potential irreversible harms how can a pre-pubescent child make an informed decision? An adult can voluntarily accept a risk of an experimental treatment even if the information is scant but I don’t see why anyone would consider asking a child to do the same for a condition that can be addressed through other safer interventions.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 13/03/2024 17:20

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 13/03/2024 17:01

Leave the experts to expert is my general rule.

Eh, isn't that what's happened here?

Possibly NewYorker thinks they are the wrong kind of experts? 🤔

TheMarzipanDildo · 13/03/2024 17:18

TheKeatingFive · 13/03/2024 15:57

Or maybe Jameela Jamil?

Could have been both in fairness

I think JJ had it confused with going on the pill for bad periods. She kept saying that loads of girls she went to school with had taken them…

TheKeatingFive · 13/03/2024 17:16

WelcomeMarch · 13/03/2024 16:15

How are you reconciling 'I guess my point is that it's extremely difficult for any lay person to fully understand these studies' with 'maybe this is one of those decisions that should be left to the young person in conjunction with their doctors and guardians'?

How is the young person meant to understand what the average adult cannot?

On reflection, this is the most extraordinary point made on the thread.

blubberyboo · 13/03/2024 17:14

YANBU

every generation lives through a health scandal and this will be ours

shame on us all as a society for allowing this to happen to our kids.

celebrities should not have the power to direct drugs to children’s bodies

we need to stop being afraid to speak out against this

TheMarzipanDildo · 13/03/2024 17:09

Tandora · 13/03/2024 10:25

YABU. Puberty blockers are are safe, important component of healthcare for trans children.
All children deserve access to health care.

Insane

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 13/03/2024 17:01

Leave the experts to expert is my general rule.

Eh, isn't that what's happened here?

LittleGreenDuck · 13/03/2024 16:51

@newyorker74 I'm a bit confused here. You keep stating that this decision should be made by experts. It has been made by experts.

So, what exactly is your argument?

You also seem to be suggesting that nobody on MN has the ability to accurately analyse the reports. I think you might be surprised.

TheKeatingFive · 13/03/2024 16:28

Anyway. I'm immensely relieved to see this from the NHS. I am also very intrigued as to what's in the full Cass report.

Karensalright · 13/03/2024 16:26

anyolddinosaur i think you are correct

anyolddinosaur · 13/03/2024 16:22

I'm afraid I dont understand why you think that the NHS would not appoint its brightest and best to conduct a wide ranging review of a contentious issue and then take a decision to ban. Who do you think is more qualified to take a decision - those making a lot of money from prescribing, those selling the drugs, yourself?

Children can consent to medical decisions when they are old enough to understand the implications. That isnt a fixed age but they cant give informed consent to something they havent been fully informed about and where they cant appreciate the consequences. Puberty blockers are not prescribed after puberty, it's not likely to be past 18. Would you support an anorexic starving themself, even if they were 17? Perhaps you have a child taking puberty blockers already and need to justify the child continuing to harm themselves?

StephanieSuperpowers · 13/03/2024 16:16

I don't think I'll ever be the better of seeing that middle aged man pontificating about the prospect of menopause in a nine year old. You don't need to have any special qualifications to know that that is insane stuff.

WelcomeMarch · 13/03/2024 16:15

How are you reconciling 'I guess my point is that it's extremely difficult for any lay person to fully understand these studies' with 'maybe this is one of those decisions that should be left to the young person in conjunction with their doctors and guardians'?

How is the young person meant to understand what the average adult cannot?

WelcomeMarch · 13/03/2024 16:13

TheKeatingFive · 13/03/2024 15:57

Or maybe Jameela Jamil?

Could have been both in fairness

I think Jameela Jamil rather wildly claimed that half her class had been on puberty blockers for heavy periods.

The contraceptive pill was probably identifying as a puberty blocker. It's all drugs, innit.

ChatBFP · 13/03/2024 16:13

@newyorker74

I think you're clearly struggling with this as you've been told that accommodating trans people is the "kind" way to be.

The point is that adults make decisions to protect children all the time. We don't let them get tattoos and there are age related restrictions to a lot of things. We also don't just hand them drugs to experiment with.

And we shouldn't allow medical experiments with drugs that are proven to be harmful on them, even if said children think it is best for them.

Point is that many enlightened societies are rowing back from puberty blockers because they stunt brain, bone and sexual development, which is a high price to pay and very hard for a child to consent to. You're clearly in the US and have been told what the "enlightened" view is to have, but we don't share it because the medical evidence is quite frightening.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 13/03/2024 16:10

Luckily experts made this decision 🤷‍♀️

Helleofabore · 13/03/2024 16:09

newyorker74 · 13/03/2024 13:05

I'm not a doctor or health care researcher who studies data from medical treatments but I know a large number due to my job. In order to get a job in my firm to interpret scientific studies, you have to have a PhD to even get an interview. I guess my point is that it's extremely difficult for any lay person to fully understand these studies and whether they are all agreeing or disagreeing, whether the study was well done or badly written (read anything by Ben goldacre to scare you about how badly medical studies can be set up, run and documented) and therefore come to any conclusions about what the long term impact may be. So maybe this is one of those decisions that should be left to the young person in conjunction with their doctors and guardians. Rather than a lot of people online deciding that it should be stopped across the board with, and I include myself in this group, no qualifications to make that decision. Leave the experts to expert is my general rule.

I suspect that someone has done a number on newyorker where they have made their staff without specific qualifications feel that they can never be able to 'understand' the stuff that those with the qualifications understand. So therefore, non-experts should not bother.

I could be wrong, but that is how this interaction has come across over the pages.

ArabellaScott · 13/03/2024 16:06

I was genuinely hoping that others would be able to give me pointers to try and understand what appears to be the overwhelming point of view on these kind of threads that this treatment

Helle, and others, have patiently posted plenty of links for you to evidence, from experts, to help you understand.

SabrinaThwaite · 13/03/2024 16:06

newyorker74 · 13/03/2024 15:58

So this has been an interesting conversation but I'm going to leave this thread. I was genuinely hoping that others would be able to give me pointers to try and understand what appears to be the overwhelming point of view on these kind of threads that this treatment = bad thing. I have never once displayed a view that says I disagree with that only that I don't have the knowledge to say either way so want to leave it up to others to choose and would suggest people on this thread do the same or decide to opt in or out if they or a loved one needs treatment. Whilst many posters have been respectful and, I think, tried to provide that clarity others have been called me childish, said I have said I can read medical reports when I clearly said I can't, and mocked the fact that I'm not an expert. Something I clearly said in my first post. I'm no further forward in my understanding of why people on this thread think the way that they do so if you are trying to convert people to your viewpoint this has been a not huge success. Which kind of tracks with my experience of having read these threads before where anyone with a different view is metaphorically shouted at. Thank you to those who did try to engage in what I was trying to get across. Better luck next time I hope.

Gosh, that’s some DARVO.