Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That puberty blockers should not be promoted for children by any charities or celebrities for children.

282 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 13/03/2024 00:04

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-68549091.amp

https://archive.ph/hmIvY

Loads of news today about the NHS stopping puberty blockers being given to children who think they are trans. Puberty blockers are sometimes prescribed for children who have precocious puberty, however a narrative that has been pushed by Mermaids, Stonewall and celebrities like India Willoughby and Emma Watson (who gave a large donation to Mermaids) - that puberty blockers are safe and "lifesaving"

WPATH guidelines in the USA which the UK NHS have followed in procedure have had leaked documents and videos showing that they knew that children didn't have the ability to understand the long term effects.

https://amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/mar/09/disturbing-leaks-from-us-gender-group-wpath-ring-alarm-bells-in-nhs

https://archive.ph/h0BtF

And a new Finnish Study debunks the idea that children who say they are trans are more suicidal https://archive.ph/h0BtF

However Mermaids, Stonewall and India Willoughby are pushing puberty blockers as safe.

https://x.com/stonewalluk/status/1767603259932361036?s=

https://www.tiktok.com/@mermaidsgenderr*/photo/7345520902936726816?isfrommwebapp=1&senderdevice=mobile&senderrweb_id=7345629783211378209

https://x.com/indiawilloughby/status/1767595379921404151?s=46

AIBU to think that anyone pushing puberty blockers at this point is unethical? And that they should never have been allowed to be given to children who did not need them for precocious puberty where the risks are weighed up against the side effects and they are only used short term?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
ArabellaScott · 14/03/2024 07:38

redalex261 · 13/03/2024 21:07

I’m sorry @newyorker74, this is not “an emerging medical area” at best it’s administration of an untested experimental treatment on a vulnerable group who lack the emotional maturity to grasp the actual and potential impacts of these treatments. At worst it’s unethical doctors exploiting vulnerable people for financial gain or, well, just to see what happens.

There is no unbiased data on efficacy or outcomes. There is no proper research. The overwhelming majority of youth presenting at these clinics have co-morbidities including ASD, OCD, anxiety, eating disorders. Many have suffered trauma or abuse. These kids need counselling and talking therapies - they are not getting their other issues resolved but instead having brief appointments, diagnosis then hormones. The personal and financial costs will be huge for each patient, regardless if they feel it’s a failure or a success.

As for comparisons with pregnancy risks - well, lets agree there is plenty of data, research and longitudinal studies on how that pans out….

this is not “an emerging medical area” at best it’s administration of an untested experimental treatment on a vulnerable group who lack the emotional maturity to grasp the actual and potential impacts of these treatments. At worst it’s unethical doctors exploiting vulnerable people for financial gain or, well, just to see what happens.

There is no unbiased data on efficacy or outcomes. There is no proper research. The overwhelming majority of youth presenting at these clinics have co-morbidities including ASD, OCD, anxiety, eating disorders. Many have suffered trauma or abuse. These kids need counselling and talking therapies - they are not getting their other issues resolved but instead having brief appointments, diagnosis then hormones. The personal and financial costs will be huge for each patient, regardless if they feel it’s a failure or a success.

All of that. It's a fucking outrage. These poor kids. I'm also very concerned for the kids once they turn 17, who are then thrown to the wolves. This is a vulnerable cohort who doesnt suddenly become not-vulnerable aged 17. They certainly need support and care.

This care should be evidence based, not predicated on the deluded idea that anyone can change sex and that a solution to the mental illness of body dysphoria is extreme plastic surgery.

EasternStandard · 14/03/2024 07:33

People did post links and information so that claim isn’t the case

But there wasn’t an answer on why NHS didn’t involve experts which didn’t make sense really

RedToothBrush · 14/03/2024 07:33

NefertitiV · 14/03/2024 05:32

@RedToothBrush

When your best argument to give kids significant very strong drug which have life-changing implications and no evidence to support the argument that they have clinical benefit in a climate where the activists supporting this have tried for years to actively STOP research and undermine standard clinic safeguarding measures. To the point that the NHS has now said there's an ethical and clinical problem with continuing on this pathway:
To reiterate, I was addressing the other poster, not you, about the posting style of people on this thread rather than the content of this thread. Earlier in the thread, I did say that the medicine had other uses than blocking puberty in older children (ie. precocious puberty). I don't necessarily agree with it being used it other circumstances, no.

The failure to engage with concerns about why so many children identifying as trans are either autistic, gay, have experienced sexual trauma of some kind or have activist parents (or have multiples of these) is a massive red flag. Until we have established why this is happening and what it is that is shaping these patterns there is a massive question about comorbidity and ethically it's a none starter.
A red flag on whose part? Who are you talking to here?

You have 'zero sum bias thinking'.This is just word salad bollocks to try and intimidate and look clever. it is an argument which has absolutely no substance to it whatsoever.
Not at all. If you were aware of the meaning of zero sum bias, you'd recognise it instantly as a common conversational tool, particularly on this board.

See what I mean about this post not actually having anything of substance to add to the conversation.

RedToothBrush · 14/03/2024 07:31

AutumnCrow · 14/03/2024 05:54

“If you were aware of the meaning of zero sum bias, you'd recognise it instantly as a common conversational tool, particularly on this board.”

I don’t understand if you mean mean the actual doing of this postulated thing; or people literally posting the words ‘zero sum bias’.

But it is early.

To be honest, I think it's just someone trying to look clever but is totally blind to their own idiocy and their total lack of knowledge and understanding of good medical practice and different practical applications of drugs to achieve a different medical outcome.

Must be my bias towards actually having medical ethics talking. Rather than thinking that Mengele did brilliant work that is worthy of accolades due to advances in medicine that he pioneered.

Shrug.

Helleofabore · 14/03/2024 07:25

I think someone attempting to portray the frustration at communicating with a poster that actually made no effort to engage beyond their own decision to not read content because that discussion is best left to the experts as a ‘zero sum bias’ is perhaps displaying their own bias here. Offering sympathy to a poster who came to offer an opinion of ‘the experts know best’ while ignoring the experts who are pointing to the issues seems to be rather downplaying the actions of that poster. That is absolutely fine, but that does need to be acknowledged.

I believe the treatment for precocious puberty with these drugs still has potential significant side effects but so much has been learned in women’s voices being heard about the damage to their bodies long term to shape the treatment standards used today. As a pp kindly explained up thread. Treating precocious puberty though, is nothing like what is happening to stop puberty from happening in this cohort. One is slowing down bodies natural process that was happening too early, the other is preventing that process to happen altogether or preventing it from progressing.

Why has a group in society been allowed to be experimented on removing the bodies maturing process, in a completely healthy body, when fundamentally this has been done for appearance? It is a form of extreme body modification that then results in a lifetime medical patient.

What other group of people would this kind of treatment be viewed as acceptable? or ethical? And yet, there are many ways to dismiss what is happening. One is to assert that there will be rare cases where this should happen. This is a position considered one of moderation, positioning any other position as extreme.

And yet, it is unworkable completely. Because who decides which rare case will benefit here, what defines that rare case to be a worthy recipient vs others? Or is the issue as many of us has been pointing to wildly, that the system is broken and those very same experts considered expert enough to listen to who state these drugs are safe, are a major part of the issue in the first place?

So, why do some people use those terms of ‘rare cases’? To make themselves feel like they are the kind ones, the ones who are, to them, not extreme or intolerant.

When the reality is, it is not a ‘kind’ position for the children left open to these treatments supported by some people either unable or unwilling to read and to analyse the information before casting their opinion about ‘being moderate’. Talking about the ‘rare cases’ is an empty platitude when you are discussing the treatment of children with healthy bodies.

Alcyoneus · 14/03/2024 06:28

Puberty blockers? You mean chemical castration for children?

AutumnCrow · 14/03/2024 05:54

“If you were aware of the meaning of zero sum bias, you'd recognise it instantly as a common conversational tool, particularly on this board.”

I don’t understand if you mean mean the actual doing of this postulated thing; or people literally posting the words ‘zero sum bias’.

But it is early.

NefertitiV · 14/03/2024 05:32

@RedToothBrush

When your best argument to give kids significant very strong drug which have life-changing implications and no evidence to support the argument that they have clinical benefit in a climate where the activists supporting this have tried for years to actively STOP research and undermine standard clinic safeguarding measures. To the point that the NHS has now said there's an ethical and clinical problem with continuing on this pathway:
To reiterate, I was addressing the other poster, not you, about the posting style of people on this thread rather than the content of this thread. Earlier in the thread, I did say that the medicine had other uses than blocking puberty in older children (ie. precocious puberty). I don't necessarily agree with it being used it other circumstances, no.

The failure to engage with concerns about why so many children identifying as trans are either autistic, gay, have experienced sexual trauma of some kind or have activist parents (or have multiples of these) is a massive red flag. Until we have established why this is happening and what it is that is shaping these patterns there is a massive question about comorbidity and ethically it's a none starter.
A red flag on whose part? Who are you talking to here?

You have 'zero sum bias thinking'.This is just word salad bollocks to try and intimidate and look clever. it is an argument which has absolutely no substance to it whatsoever.
Not at all. If you were aware of the meaning of zero sum bias, you'd recognise it instantly as a common conversational tool, particularly on this board.

RedToothBrush · 14/03/2024 04:45

NefertitiV · 14/03/2024 00:17

@newyorker74

So this has been an interesting conversation but I'm going to leave this thread. I was genuinely hoping that others would be able to give me pointers to try and understand what appears to be the overwhelming point of view on these kind of threads that this treatment = bad thing. I have never once displayed a view that says I disagree with that only that I don't have the knowledge to say either way so want to leave it up to others to choose and would suggest people on this thread do the same or decide to opt in or out if they or a loved one needs treatment. Whilst many posters have been respectful and, I think, tried to provide that clarity others have been called me childish, said I have said I can read medical reports when I clearly said I can't, and mocked the fact that I'm not an expert. Something I clearly said in my first post. I'm no further forward in my understanding of why people on this thread think the way that they do so if you are trying to convert people to your viewpoint this has been a not huge success. Which kind of tracks with my experience of having read these threads before where anyone with a different view is metaphorically shouted at. Thank you to those who did try to engage in what I was trying to get across. Better luck next time I hope.

You tried. I honestly don't think they want to convert anyone to their viewpoint, though. Like you, I've noticed this treatment of any alternative voice before. It's immediately jumped on by multiple posters who use zero-sum bias and logical fallacies to shut down the conversation all the time. It's enormously frustrating - so take heart.

When your best argument to give kids significant very strong drug which have life-changing implications and no evidence to support the argument that they have clinical benefit in a climate where the activists supporting this have tried for years to actively STOP research and undermine standard clinic safeguarding measures. To the point that the NHS has now said there's an ethical and clinical problem with continuing on this pathway:

You have 'zero sum bias thinking'.

This is just word salad bollocks to try and intimidate and look clever.

However it is an argument which has absolutely no substance to it whatsoever.

None.

The failure to engage with concerns about why so many children identifying as trans are either autistic, gay, have experienced sexual trauma of some kind or have activist parents (or have multiples of these) is a massive red flag. Until we have established why this is happening and what it is that is shaping these patterns there is a massive question about comorbidity and ethically it's a none starter.

We should not make exceptions to medical ethics because it's inconvenient for anyones beliefs or even justified medical concerns. Ever. And this applies even more so when children, especially vulnerable children are concerned.

It is totally irrelevant what the medical condition is. These children deserve better.

RedToothBrush · 14/03/2024 04:33

Tandora · 13/03/2024 10:25

YABU. Puberty blockers are are safe, important component of healthcare for trans children.
All children deserve access to health care.

So why EXACTLY are the NHS (amongst other western European nations) saying there's both ethical issues and physical issues relating to the level of harm related to puberty blockers, and no evidence that they actually improve the quality of life for these kids?

In the face of significant pressure to keep prescribing them.

Why do you know better than clinical researchers and those who have worked in the field and have whistleblown /conducted a serious review into services and clinical practices?

Or did you just read some shite on social media that you see fit to parrot without thought? Cos 'be kind'.

SoreAndTired1 · 14/03/2024 04:23

mitogoshi · 13/03/2024 13:12

@VickyEadieofThigh

Puberty doesn't cure it for all. We have a trans relative who displayed dysphoria from a toddler - not expressed in a direct way at first, refusing to wear dresses, insisting on playing "boys" sports, pulling heads off dolls - only learned the concept of trans in their teens which was before the current explosion of cases. They are 29 now and very happily transitioned.

Personally I want to see far better support for young people struggling with mental health issues which may include trans. Medication arguements are simply a distraction, we need to start working out why it's become so common compared to before! I personally don't agree with medication under 18 unless in exceptional circumstances, but I think we should allow young people to be individuals rather than conforming to gender stereotypes without medical interventions.

@mitogoshi So they were a tomboy. A girl not wanting to wear a dress and wanting to play with boys doesn't mean they are a boy. You are using regressive stereotypes. Girl doesn't = wearing dresses and playing with dolls, you know. The whole point of the 70s, 80s and 90s was to teach girls and boys there is no right way to be a girl or boy. That boys can like pink and play with dolls, and girls can like blue and play with cars. Your relative has bought into ancient stereotypes. This is a regressive, sexist ideology that says if you don't 'girl' the right way, then there is something wrong with you. It undoes all the effort the previous two generations went through to break down gender stereotypes.

SoreAndTired1 · 14/03/2024 04:01

Tandora · 13/03/2024 10:25

YABU. Puberty blockers are are safe, important component of healthcare for trans children.
All children deserve access to health care.

You obviously haven't read the WPATH files. Puberty blockers are incredibly dangerous and cause cancer, osteoporosis, stunted growth just for starters.

NefertitiV · 14/03/2024 03:16

@WandaWomblesaurus

So engage then. Talk about the issues raised. Let's hear your alternative voice. The previous poster refused to read the links and evidence and then got upset and FLOUNCED off.

Are they a woman? I don't know. Can you define a woman anymore? Are you calling women names here. Yes you are.

Can you hold more than one thought in your head? I would hope so. In which case you can read the links.

I was addressing the other poster, not you, about the posting style of people on this thread rather than the content of this thread. Can you see the difference?

Where am I calling women names? Are you okay?

maddening · 14/03/2024 02:09

NefertitiV · 13/03/2024 00:18

They still can be prescribed by individual practitioners. It must be remembered, too, that there is more than one use for these medicines. For example, should a child start developing breasts at the age of 2, this is the type of medicine that curbs that process.

It's uses for appropriate treatment is fine (precocious puberty and prostate cancer) ( apparently also for chemical castration of pedophiles but that would not be an nhs concern

WandaWomblesaurus · 14/03/2024 00:57

archive.ph/MRVmd

Call to close loopholes on private clinics prescribing puberty blockers

OP posts:
Karensalright · 14/03/2024 00:49

@NefertitiV Simple question, do you think that as a society we should administer puberty blockers for children, and if so why?

WandaWomblesaurus · 14/03/2024 00:45

"You tried. I honestly don't think they want to convert anyone to their viewpoint, though. Like you, I've noticed this treatment of any alternative voice before. It's immediately jumped on by multiple posters who use zero-sum bias and logical fallacies to shut down the conversation all the time. It's enormously frustrating - so take heart."

So engage then. Talk about the issues raised. Let's hear your alternative voice. The previous poster refused to read the links and evidence and then got upset and FLOUNCED off.

Are they a woman? I don't know. Can you define a woman anymore? Are you calling women names here. Yes you are.

Can you hold more than one thought in your head? I would hope so. In which case you can read the links.

OP posts:
WandaWomblesaurus · 14/03/2024 00:38

Wait you're just here to tell us we are mean Terfy Terfs!

So have you read the links?

OP posts:
NefertitiV · 14/03/2024 00:36

@WandaWomblesaurus

Are you at all concerned about children not being able to consent to being rendered sterilised and asking for amputations before they have even had their first kiss. Are you slightly concerned that many of these children are autistic or come from challenging family circumstances?

Aaand here we go with the zero sum bias thinking. If I support this poster, I must not be concerned about the children! Try to think about one thing at a time, Wanda.

NefertitiV · 14/03/2024 00:32

WandaWomblesaurus · 14/03/2024 00:24

Deflector Bingo

  1. Feigned Openness
  2. "I'm not an expert" I'm not to blame for anything I say
  3. I'm the victim of you being mean to me
  4. Can't have a conversation because you are mean
  5. Thanks for the experience - flounce

"Read the links"
"Oh no I couldn't possibly do that."

TERF bingo:

Insult all others who do not conform to our mode of thinking
Act like a bully schoolgirl gang
Use the word 'flounce' against another woman

WandaWomblesaurus · 14/03/2024 00:32

NefertitiV · 14/03/2024 00:17

@newyorker74

So this has been an interesting conversation but I'm going to leave this thread. I was genuinely hoping that others would be able to give me pointers to try and understand what appears to be the overwhelming point of view on these kind of threads that this treatment = bad thing. I have never once displayed a view that says I disagree with that only that I don't have the knowledge to say either way so want to leave it up to others to choose and would suggest people on this thread do the same or decide to opt in or out if they or a loved one needs treatment. Whilst many posters have been respectful and, I think, tried to provide that clarity others have been called me childish, said I have said I can read medical reports when I clearly said I can't, and mocked the fact that I'm not an expert. Something I clearly said in my first post. I'm no further forward in my understanding of why people on this thread think the way that they do so if you are trying to convert people to your viewpoint this has been a not huge success. Which kind of tracks with my experience of having read these threads before where anyone with a different view is metaphorically shouted at. Thank you to those who did try to engage in what I was trying to get across. Better luck next time I hope.

You tried. I honestly don't think they want to convert anyone to their viewpoint, though. Like you, I've noticed this treatment of any alternative voice before. It's immediately jumped on by multiple posters who use zero-sum bias and logical fallacies to shut down the conversation all the time. It's enormously frustrating - so take heart.

Have you read the links @NefertitiV or are you going to rinse and repeat the ignorance of the previous poster?

Maybe you could comment on the links and not on whether you think the concerned women of Mumsnet are some kind of mean hydra.

Are you at all concerned about children not being able to consent to being rendered sterilised and asking for amputations before they have even had their first kiss. Are you slightly concerned that many of these children are autistic or come from challenging family circumstances?

Or are you just here to tell us to BeKind?

OP posts:
WandaWomblesaurus · 14/03/2024 00:24

Deflector Bingo

  1. Feigned Openness
  2. "I'm not an expert" I'm not to blame for anything I say
  3. I'm the victim of you being mean to me
  4. Can't have a conversation because you are mean
  5. Thanks for the experience - flounce

"Read the links"
"Oh no I couldn't possibly do that."

OP posts:
NefertitiV · 14/03/2024 00:17

@newyorker74

So this has been an interesting conversation but I'm going to leave this thread. I was genuinely hoping that others would be able to give me pointers to try and understand what appears to be the overwhelming point of view on these kind of threads that this treatment = bad thing. I have never once displayed a view that says I disagree with that only that I don't have the knowledge to say either way so want to leave it up to others to choose and would suggest people on this thread do the same or decide to opt in or out if they or a loved one needs treatment. Whilst many posters have been respectful and, I think, tried to provide that clarity others have been called me childish, said I have said I can read medical reports when I clearly said I can't, and mocked the fact that I'm not an expert. Something I clearly said in my first post. I'm no further forward in my understanding of why people on this thread think the way that they do so if you are trying to convert people to your viewpoint this has been a not huge success. Which kind of tracks with my experience of having read these threads before where anyone with a different view is metaphorically shouted at. Thank you to those who did try to engage in what I was trying to get across. Better luck next time I hope.

You tried. I honestly don't think they want to convert anyone to their viewpoint, though. Like you, I've noticed this treatment of any alternative voice before. It's immediately jumped on by multiple posters who use zero-sum bias and logical fallacies to shut down the conversation all the time. It's enormously frustrating - so take heart.

cherish123 · 13/03/2024 22:29

YADNBU

redalex261 · 13/03/2024 21:07

newyorker74 · 13/03/2024 12:39

I read these threads which seem to be a daily occurrence on mumsnet and have been trying to articulate why it bothers me that people are advocating for safe treatment for young people. And then I realized that these conversations aren't always confined to that idea. The conversations tend to always end up in "don't do it" land as opposed to "do it but let's make sure it's safe and regulated and that we are ensuring that the young people involved have full capacity and understanding of what they are doing and the potential long terms impacts." You know, in the same way that we haven't made pregnancy illegal even though we know that some women will die and others have long term impacts from pregnancy and child birth. But we do ensure that women have access to care and are protected to minimize those risks. I'm fine with regulating this emerging medical area but that shouldn't mean stop it. Just ensure it's safe, access is through well regulated and trained providers and that everyone involved has time and space to consider the choice they are making.

I’m sorry @newyorker74, this is not “an emerging medical area” at best it’s administration of an untested experimental treatment on a vulnerable group who lack the emotional maturity to grasp the actual and potential impacts of these treatments. At worst it’s unethical doctors exploiting vulnerable people for financial gain or, well, just to see what happens.

There is no unbiased data on efficacy or outcomes. There is no proper research. The overwhelming majority of youth presenting at these clinics have co-morbidities including ASD, OCD, anxiety, eating disorders. Many have suffered trauma or abuse. These kids need counselling and talking therapies - they are not getting their other issues resolved but instead having brief appointments, diagnosis then hormones. The personal and financial costs will be huge for each patient, regardless if they feel it’s a failure or a success.

As for comparisons with pregnancy risks - well, lets agree there is plenty of data, research and longitudinal studies on how that pans out….