Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That puberty blockers should not be promoted for children by any charities or celebrities for children.

282 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 13/03/2024 00:04

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-68549091.amp

https://archive.ph/hmIvY

Loads of news today about the NHS stopping puberty blockers being given to children who think they are trans. Puberty blockers are sometimes prescribed for children who have precocious puberty, however a narrative that has been pushed by Mermaids, Stonewall and celebrities like India Willoughby and Emma Watson (who gave a large donation to Mermaids) - that puberty blockers are safe and "lifesaving"

WPATH guidelines in the USA which the UK NHS have followed in procedure have had leaked documents and videos showing that they knew that children didn't have the ability to understand the long term effects.

https://amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/mar/09/disturbing-leaks-from-us-gender-group-wpath-ring-alarm-bells-in-nhs

https://archive.ph/h0BtF

And a new Finnish Study debunks the idea that children who say they are trans are more suicidal https://archive.ph/h0BtF

However Mermaids, Stonewall and India Willoughby are pushing puberty blockers as safe.

https://x.com/stonewalluk/status/1767603259932361036?s=

https://www.tiktok.com/@mermaidsgenderr*/photo/7345520902936726816?isfrommwebapp=1&senderdevice=mobile&senderrweb_id=7345629783211378209

https://x.com/indiawilloughby/status/1767595379921404151?s=46

AIBU to think that anyone pushing puberty blockers at this point is unethical? And that they should never have been allowed to be given to children who did not need them for precocious puberty where the risks are weighed up against the side effects and they are only used short term?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
NefertitiV · 14/03/2024 11:19

@RedToothBrush

Yes. TERF is a slur. Which you well know and it's why you used the term.

Don't try and pull the innocent on that one.

Actually, no, I didn't. When I first starting reading this board, someone told I was a TERF due to my stated beliefs. (I didn't think so.) Thanks for letting me know that. (That person is on this thread, BTW - don't bother asking who it is, though.)

Leah5678 · 14/03/2024 11:18

VivienneDelacroix · 13/03/2024 09:11

Hhmm the page you quote has been removed. It's 83 children in the last year - from NHS data, not a very bias newspaper. Puberty blockers are not being dished out like sweeties. It's astonishingly rare for them to be prescribed (as it should be).
All this will do is push people to private clinics, and (as has been the case for neurodevelopmental pathways) then we'll have a dangerous situation where if you pay enough you'll get the prescription, without the much more transparent systems of the NHS.

I find it hard to believe it was only 83 last year, unless the trend is dieing out (I hope so) I'm 22 and when I finished school in 2017 there was about 3 children in my secondary school alone using puberty blockers.

Poinsettiasarevile · 14/03/2024 11:16

NefertitiV · 14/03/2024 11:13

@Poinsettiasarevile

I think posters like @newyorker74 and @NefertitiV demonstrate some of the reasons why we have ended up in a position with vulnerable, complex, distressed children have been given puberty blockers despite there being no robust evidence of benefit and growing evidence of harm. The whataboutery, ignoring the expert opinions offered up, taking offence at the tone of the discourse and adopting victimhood.

Nonsensical. Few of my posts even addressed puberty blockers, and when they did, they agreed that they do cause harm to older children. Perhaps work on your comprehension.

No, as you say you have added precisely nothing to the discussion on puberty blockers, which begs the question, why exactly are you posting?

NefertitiV · 14/03/2024 11:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I did answer that question.

Kucinghitam · 14/03/2024 11:13

I think posters presenting The Right Side of History with such brave clarity are to be much admired and encouraged. We really need mascots such as these, with their beautifully evidenced and straightforwardly written posts, to educate the undecided lurkers.

NefertitiV · 14/03/2024 11:13

@Poinsettiasarevile

I think posters like @newyorker74 and @NefertitiV demonstrate some of the reasons why we have ended up in a position with vulnerable, complex, distressed children have been given puberty blockers despite there being no robust evidence of benefit and growing evidence of harm. The whataboutery, ignoring the expert opinions offered up, taking offence at the tone of the discourse and adopting victimhood.

Nonsensical. Few of my posts even addressed puberty blockers, and when they did, they agreed that they do cause harm to older children. Perhaps work on your comprehension.

RedToothBrush · 14/03/2024 11:12

NefertitiV · 14/03/2024 11:07

@RedToothBrush @SabrinaThwaite @anyolddinosaur

Amazing.

Sorry, is TERF an insult to you? I don't think you have any cause to be amazed, anyway, given you are fairly good at dishing out insults yourself - like this one, calling me "totally blind to their own idiocy and their total lack of knowledge and understanding of good medical practice". Amazing.

Why are you here, other than to be insulting?
Because I'm allowed to be, and I was responding to someone specific, as I've said ad nauseum.

Yawn

Yes. TERF is a slur. Which you well know and it's why you used the term.

Don't try and pull the innocent on that one.

Karensalright · 14/03/2024 11:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

NefertitiV · 14/03/2024 11:07

@RedToothBrush @SabrinaThwaite @anyolddinosaur

Amazing.

Sorry, is TERF an insult to you? I don't think you have any cause to be amazed, anyway, given you are fairly good at dishing out insults yourself - like this one, calling me "totally blind to their own idiocy and their total lack of knowledge and understanding of good medical practice". Amazing.

Why are you here, other than to be insulting?
Because I'm allowed to be, and I was responding to someone specific, as I've said ad nauseum.

anyolddinosaur · 14/03/2024 10:36

@NefertitiV Why are you here, other than to be insulting?

RedToothBrush · 14/03/2024 10:29

SabrinaThwaite · 14/03/2024 10:26

This is you right @NefertitiV ?

Calling women TERFs on this thread just a few hours ago?

Amazing.

SabrinaThwaite · 14/03/2024 10:26

This is you right @NefertitiV ?

Calling women TERFs on this thread just a few hours ago?

That puberty blockers should not be promoted for children by any charities or celebrities for children.
That puberty blockers should not be promoted for children by any charities or celebrities for children.
EasternStandard · 14/03/2024 10:11

@Poinsettiasarevile great post

HardyCrow · 14/03/2024 10:10

@Poinsettiasarevile I heartily agree.

Poinsettiasarevile · 14/03/2024 09:56

I think posters like @newyorker74 and @NefertitiV demonstrate some of the reasons why we have ended up in a position with vulnerable, complex, distressed children have been given puberty blockers despite there being no robust evidence of benefit and growing evidence of harm. The whataboutery, ignoring the expert opinions offered up, taking offence at the tone of the discourse and adopting victimhood.

But you are right, discussing this topic on Mumsnet is not for the faint hearted. It is full of people, some with relevant expertise, many who have had to become experts. There are many parents on here who have had to battle to try and keep their kids safe. Some unfortunately have not been able to do this.

So, yes, if you want to defend the use of puberty blockers in children, you will need to come armed with something more than 'be kind' or 'what about suicide rates' or 'this should be between patient and doctor". This is dangerous and you will be called on it. The stakes are too high for niceties.

NefertitiV · 14/03/2024 09:37

anyolddinosaur · 14/03/2024 08:43

@NefertitiV There has been a lot of explanation on this thread about why a long term enquiry staffed by highly respected NHS people has recommended banning puberty blockers when there is no proven gain. If someone wants to dispute why that is necessary then they need to explain where the evidence of gain comes from and why the enquiry didnt hear it.

Puberty blockers are being treated as no different to any other medication, the NHS doesnt prescribe it unless there is a benefit that outweighs the harm. Why do you want to argue against that?

Where have I argued against it?

anyolddinosaur · 14/03/2024 08:43

@NefertitiV There has been a lot of explanation on this thread about why a long term enquiry staffed by highly respected NHS people has recommended banning puberty blockers when there is no proven gain. If someone wants to dispute why that is necessary then they need to explain where the evidence of gain comes from and why the enquiry didnt hear it.

Puberty blockers are being treated as no different to any other medication, the NHS doesnt prescribe it unless there is a benefit that outweighs the harm. Why do you want to argue against that?

Helleofabore · 14/03/2024 08:36

NefertitiV · 14/03/2024 08:20

@RedToothBrush

See what I mean about this post not actually having anything of substance to add to the conversation.

I wasn't attempting to add to the conversation. I was talking to one poster in particular.

Of course, people can see you were posting for the benefit of one single poster. It doesn’t mean that no one else should interact with what you said.

By posting on the thread, however, you were ‘adding to the conversation’.

NefertitiV · 14/03/2024 08:22

@RedToothBrush

To be honest, I think it's just someone trying to look clever but is totally blind to their own idiocy and their total lack of knowledge and understanding of good medical practice and different practical applications of drugs to achieve a different medical outcome.

Excuse me? That's a bit uncalled for. I don't see how you could possibly extrapolate that from my posts.

Kucinghitam · 14/03/2024 08:22

I for one am extremely grateful to the few Brave Stunning Righteous voices on this thread. Please, in all seriousness, keep posting.

NefertitiV · 14/03/2024 08:20

@RedToothBrush

See what I mean about this post not actually having anything of substance to add to the conversation.

I wasn't attempting to add to the conversation. I was talking to one poster in particular.

Helleofabore · 14/03/2024 08:17

The dissonance is clanging very loudly now Alison. There is apparently evidence out there that proves ‘some’ posters claims of being ‘safe’ that world health agencies cannot find AND that WPATH cannot produce to refute the report written about just how little evidence WPATH has.

AlisonDonut · 14/03/2024 07:56

The 'evidence' was that they surveyed people after giving them treatment and compared them to after the treatment.

However what they did was base this survey on their actual sex prior to treatment and after treatment, based their survey on the 'changed gender'.

So to 'prove' it was 'successful', they asked girls prior to treatment about their feelings based on being a girl, and after, based on feelings on being a boy.

So no actual comparison could ever be made.

No control group was ever looked at or surveyed or assessed.

No long term follow ups were made.

No assessments of detransitioners were ever made. They were dropped from their books the moment they detransitioned.

Helleofabore · 14/03/2024 07:39

The question is, and it always has been, where is the evidence that this treatment improves the lives of those who are receiving treatment for this purpose?

And if numerous world health organisations, filled with ‘experts’ are saying the evidence does reach the bar needed to continue this treatment standard, why are those with high personal investment simply offering mantra like phrases to refute those world health agencies? There has been absolutely nothing released by WPATH to show the evidence they declare is there.

And even posters on this thread have declared the usage “safe” without ever providing any evidence to support this. So it is not a MN phenomenon. It is one though that very evident in all the interactions of this group demanding that the care is ‘safe’ in desperation that if enough people say it, society will put pressure on those experts to reverse the decision.

Once you recognise the emotional manipulation aspect used, it is impossible to unsee it.

That is why you get some posters who will use what could be described as appeals to authority such as ‘they are experts so they must know best’ to try to shape the discussion they find uncomfortable.

That is why you will get some posters who will leverage victimisation that has been exaggerated to portray those attempting to interact as extreme. Catastrophisation and polarisation are cognitive distortions being used to emotionally manipulate readers in an attempt to discredit what others are saying.

When support relies on emotional manipulation rather than presenting facts, evidence and interrogated, coherent and logically consistent thoughts, people should be aware of that emotional manipulation for what it is. A lack of evidence to support what then is exposed to be a belief.