Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For not wanting to pay my therapist when I was sick!!

309 replies

Anonymous2566 · 12/03/2024 23:21

So, I’ve been seeing my therapist for about a year and things are going well. I’ve been very dedicated and always attend my sessions and pay upfront. My issue is, the cancellation policy. The agreement stipulates that I must give 72 hours notice for cancellation, otherwise the full payment is due. I was sick a few weeks back and let my therapist know on the day, she wished me better, advised me to relax and then put something about the cancellation policy, but that she didn’t wish to charge me on this occasion. Again, I have been sick and had to cancel my session on the day. She sent a similar message, wishing me better etc, but this time included something like “I’m afraid this is very short notice to cancel
without charge” and then offered a reschedule, which was online and didn’t suit as I was still feeling poorly.

AIBU to not want to pay this? How could I possibly give 72 hours notice when I woke up sick?!! It’s seem a little inflexible.

OP posts:
changergranger · 13/03/2024 08:26

YABVU. As others have mentioned it's like you're paying for a ticket for a show. A shame you can't make it but you can't expect to not pay.

I actually think it's nice that most therapists let you cancel with any amount of notice without paying. Surely you're really paying for a weekly slot?

If they have a full caseload and you cancel your next Tuesdays session then what can they actually use it for? I know they could use it as an introductory session with a new client but if they don't have capacity for anyone new then they can't really. And if they did have capacity, there were other slots free they could have used so they're still not gaining anything.

OP, please answer the question about if you'd be ok if your work told you that morning not to come in and they wouldn't pay you.

Ginnnny · 13/03/2024 08:19

She has the cancellation policy in place for a reason. You should pay her.

ntmdino · 13/03/2024 08:18

Anonymous2566 · 12/03/2024 23:53

No, she isn’t, she’s a private therapist. I get that she has bills to pay and if I was doing it from the start and for no good reason, I can understand the need to charge. It was just unfortunate I had two bouts of illness quite close together. For holidays etc, I’ve always given plenty of notice. I’ve also been very understanding when she has been sick and emailed in the morning.

So, consider this: there's a nasty virus going round, and six of her clients are ill. If she was to do it your way, that's 20% of her income gone for the week.

NaomhPadraigin · 13/03/2024 08:16

ilovesooty · 13/03/2024 08:14

Yes, I've already charged for the cancelled one.

Ah thanks, that makes more sense.

ilovesooty · 13/03/2024 08:14

NaomhPadraigin · 13/03/2024 08:10

While I commend your approach as kind I don't agree it's necessarily fair.
The therapist will lose money if a client cancels short notice, but the client won't lose anything if therapist cancels that morning (provided they don't charge for them cancelling). I can see offering a free session is a good will gesture, but not charging for the cancelled session is OK - unless of course you've charged for the cancelled one?

Edited

Yes, I've already charged for the cancelled one.

Wirelessbird · 13/03/2024 08:13

I’m a psychotherapist in training and in my opinion this is a very lenient policy. Aside from the financial implications for the therapist, which are important. Being able to cancel short notice communicates that the session is unimportant or the work is avoidable. In my experience with therapy when we hit on difficult moments I begin to come up with a million reasons why I don’t need to attend. Some of them I consciously know I am avoiding the work, some of them manifest in very unconscious ways such as fatigue. Perhaps worth bringing this to your therapist so you can explore it together.

katsusando · 13/03/2024 08:13

It does not matter one jot that you have never cancelled before these two sudden bouts of illness.

Your therapist has a very clear cancellation policy which she waived the first time you were unwell and had to cancel at short notice. That was goodwill on her part and something she did not have to do given her clear cancellation policy.

To use a much loved phrase on here, you're a cheeky fucker to expect her to waive the cancellation fee a second time.

NaomhPadraigin · 13/03/2024 08:10

ilovesooty · 13/03/2024 00:33

Well it's only fair to put myself under the same T&Cs as I expect from the clients.

While I commend your approach as kind I don't agree it's necessarily fair.
The therapist will lose money if a client cancels short notice, but the client won't lose anything if therapist cancels that morning (provided they don't charge for them cancelling). I can see offering a free session is a good will gesture, but not charging for the cancelled session is OK - unless of course you've charged for the cancelled one?

Itloggedmeoutagain · 13/03/2024 08:01

You can't say I get that she has bills to pay then in the same breath say you don't think you should pay. What does she pay those bills with?
I'm a tutor. I've had 4 cancellations in the last week. 1 was rearranged online as parent had no car. 1 i waived the cancellation fee as it was the first time they had ever canceled . 1 I also waived the cancellation fee as it was unavoidable and this teenager usually comes all through the holidays instead of taking them off. But i made it clear to both it was a goodwill gesture.The last one I declined to continue working with them as they caused me so much hassle.
You are just one client. You won't be the only cancellation. Cancellations this week cost me over £100

ilovesooty · 13/03/2024 08:00

menohnopausal · 13/03/2024 07:56

Her only mistake was waiving the fee the first time. I'm a therapist, and I have a 48 hour cancellation policy. I'm completely "inflexible" about that. It's obviously partly to do with me having to pay my bills, but also because it's therapeutically helpful to hold a boundary. My clients know exactly where they stand in this regard, and being clear about this sort of thing (money, timings etc) actually builds trust and safety.

FWIW I sometimes would rather waive the fee, because I know it can feel shitty for them to stump up for a therapy session when they've been a "dedicated" client, and they've had to late cancel because for a horrible reason. I care deeply about my clients and waiving the fee would feel like a "nice" way of showing that care, but it's ultimately quite a shallow and self-serving version of care.

What would be great though is if you could talk about this with your therapist. It can often be a very fruitful conversation, and can deepen the therapeutic connection. Depending on the situation and the client, I sometimes actively invite a check-in about feelings around paying the fee. Maybe your therapist will "open the door" for you in this way, but if not, I do encourage you to raise the issue.

I agree with you there. That's why I only ever make the exception on rare occasions for long standing supervisees.
ETA by that I mean supervisees with whom I've worked for years who are qualified themselves. The waiver I offered recently was for a supervisee I'd worked with for four years, who had never cancelled and whose child had been suddenly hospitalised. In fact I had a trainee who'd cancelled on the day due to illness and I enforced the charge. It would have been poor modelling to do otherwise. She was upset but we worked through the rupture and she stayed with me.

abeeabeeisafterme · 13/03/2024 07:59

Yabu and ungrateful. How lousy of you to feel entitled to special treatment rather than realise she lost money because you cancelled before.

Abeona · 13/03/2024 07:59

I think she's behaved eminently reasonably and probably like all professional therapists. You are buying her time and cancelling at short notice leaves her with no way of filling your slot.

You've been seeing her for nearly a year and she was flexible with the first cancellation to show good will. Now, not much later, comes a second cancellation and so she's intervening by requesting payment, as per your contract, to focus you on whether her time is valuable to you or not.

She knows how valuable her time is and she's holding her boundaries with you — which may be really, really important if your issues are around boundaries. I've known people who've reached difficult, gritty patches in their therapy and started missing sessions because there's stuff they don't want to have to deal with. I've also known people who, once they start having a week off here or there start regarding therapy as an option, if they're in the mood. By holding you to the contract the therapist protects herself but also you. I think a lot of people go through a stage of expecting the therapist to be a nice indulgent mummy or daddy or friend and let them off their responsibilities. Your therapist is making a point: she's not an indulgent parent or friend, she's a professional woman earning a living. I think it's a sign of a good therapist.

BeaRF75 · 13/03/2024 07:57

This is the contract you made. Of course you have to pay.

menohnopausal · 13/03/2024 07:56

Her only mistake was waiving the fee the first time. I'm a therapist, and I have a 48 hour cancellation policy. I'm completely "inflexible" about that. It's obviously partly to do with me having to pay my bills, but also because it's therapeutically helpful to hold a boundary. My clients know exactly where they stand in this regard, and being clear about this sort of thing (money, timings etc) actually builds trust and safety.

FWIW I sometimes would rather waive the fee, because I know it can feel shitty for them to stump up for a therapy session when they've been a "dedicated" client, and they've had to late cancel because for a horrible reason. I care deeply about my clients and waiving the fee would feel like a "nice" way of showing that care, but it's ultimately quite a shallow and self-serving version of care.

What would be great though is if you could talk about this with your therapist. It can often be a very fruitful conversation, and can deepen the therapeutic connection. Depending on the situation and the client, I sometimes actively invite a check-in about feelings around paying the fee. Maybe your therapist will "open the door" for you in this way, but if not, I do encourage you to raise the issue.

Craftycorvid · 13/03/2024 07:54

The cancellation policy isn’t about the validity of your reasons, OP., it’s just business and your therapist’s need to earn a living. She can’t usually fill an on the day cancellation. Yes, I agree it stings a bit when you feel poorly and have the expense as well. Fees and the issue of paying them is quite thorny in therapy. I would encourage you to tell your therapist how you feel next time you see them. Any good therapist will talk this issue through with you as things like this almost always say something beyond the surface level frustration of the moment.

Jc2001 · 13/03/2024 07:51

Anonymous2566 · 12/03/2024 23:21

So, I’ve been seeing my therapist for about a year and things are going well. I’ve been very dedicated and always attend my sessions and pay upfront. My issue is, the cancellation policy. The agreement stipulates that I must give 72 hours notice for cancellation, otherwise the full payment is due. I was sick a few weeks back and let my therapist know on the day, she wished me better, advised me to relax and then put something about the cancellation policy, but that she didn’t wish to charge me on this occasion. Again, I have been sick and had to cancel my session on the day. She sent a similar message, wishing me better etc, but this time included something like “I’m afraid this is very short notice to cancel
without charge” and then offered a reschedule, which was online and didn’t suit as I was still feeling poorly.

AIBU to not want to pay this? How could I possibly give 72 hours notice when I woke up sick?!! It’s seem a little inflexible.

Would you be happy to not get paid if you call in sick on the day where you work?

ilovesooty · 13/03/2024 07:50

Myopicglass · 13/03/2024 06:10

@ilovesooty

you say you charge the client at the time of booking for the next session. So in effect clients pre pay.

Then you said if you are sick on the day of the next session you give them a free session.

Is that on top of the prepaid session? So they get the next slot with you as the pre paid session then the following slot free?

If so that is very generous.

No, the first session only is payable on booking. That's because we haven't yet met and I can't put an unknown person in my diary a week in advance and have them cancel the day before when I could have given the slot to another person who enquired. Once they become a client they pay a minimum of 24 hours before the session.

If I'm then sick they've already paid so I obviously don't charge for the session next time they attend. The one time it happened the payment just rolled over to the following week. I don't charge for the weeks they're on holiday so if I'd had to cancel due to my illness and they were due to be on holiday and not attend for a couple of weeks and they asked me for a refund for the cancelled session I'd refund them.

Candl3Stix · 13/03/2024 07:50

My therapist works from home and has always been very understanding if I need to cancel as I have a lot on hence needing therapy. I tend to do time and a half the following week so it works out roughly the same.

YetAnotherSpottyDress · 13/03/2024 07:50

The 72 hours is to enable her to fill thenslot so she can meet her financial obligations that month.

She's not giving you therapy as a favour to you and you knew the T&Cs when you entered into a relationship with her.

AliceToTheWitchElm · 13/03/2024 07:48

I'm a therapist. If every client cancelled and I didn't charge them, am I supposed to starve/not pay my mortgage? Would the bank understand?
The cancellation policy is there for a reason and it sounds as if she's been flexible. I'm tbe same, I do make allowances for certain circumstances. But most appointments for private health related matters are like this. If you cancel at short notice, someone else could have used that slot and now cannot.

Rainbowstripes · 13/03/2024 07:48

When you're self employed you very quickly realize if you're not strict on your cancellation policy people can and will take advantage and it can make a huge difference to your income. On the day there's no chance of her filling your space with another client so you are def being unreasonable and I think you'd struggle to find a therapist who wouldn't charge in that situation.

yourenottgebossoofme · 13/03/2024 07:47

@Anonymous2566you will find this is the case pretty much all appointment based services- as long as she isn’t charging you when she cancels it’s perfectly fair.

Otherwise if you cancel on the day, and 5 other clients do the same that week and every week, she is never going to have a reliable income.

Would you be happy and financially stable if you never knew if you were going to loose 10/20/50% of your income that month?

She gave you one chance where you didn’t pay, she gave you the chance to reschedule- she has been more than fair.

Itisverycomplicated · 13/03/2024 07:40

She was generous to give you one off. I know therapists that do that, I don’t. It is not just room hire, the space cannot be filled at that short notice so its loss of income. You have committed to the space.
Speak to your therapist about your feelings. That’s what she’s there for.

NamelessNancy · 13/03/2024 07:39

Anonymous2566 · 12/03/2024 23:53

No, she isn’t, she’s a private therapist. I get that she has bills to pay and if I was doing it from the start and for no good reason, I can understand the need to charge. It was just unfortunate I had two bouts of illness quite close together. For holidays etc, I’ve always given plenty of notice. I’ve also been very understanding when she has been sick and emailed in the morning.

Hang on a minute, so you acknowledge that she has bills to pay but simultaneously say that you shouldn't be charged because you have a good reason? That only makes sense if she doesn't have pay her bills if she has a (in your view) good reason.

Somehowgirl · 13/03/2024 07:33

I'm amazed that you don't understand why it's right and proper for her to have those T&Cs and abide by them. She was generous waiving the first cancellation fee.

I work in an industry where it's 100% cancellation fee on the day or day before. Anything before that up to a week is still 50% cancellation fee. I have cleared my diary for a client and if they cancel, sickness or otherwise, they are charged. Now, like your therapist I will use my discretion as to when I waive this: first time cancelling due to illness, family emergency etc.

But I have bills to pay and I provide professional services. I won't be mucked around and I have T&Cs for a reason.

Swipe left for the next trending thread