Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For not wanting to pay my therapist when I was sick!!

309 replies

Anonymous2566 · 12/03/2024 23:21

So, I’ve been seeing my therapist for about a year and things are going well. I’ve been very dedicated and always attend my sessions and pay upfront. My issue is, the cancellation policy. The agreement stipulates that I must give 72 hours notice for cancellation, otherwise the full payment is due. I was sick a few weeks back and let my therapist know on the day, she wished me better, advised me to relax and then put something about the cancellation policy, but that she didn’t wish to charge me on this occasion. Again, I have been sick and had to cancel my session on the day. She sent a similar message, wishing me better etc, but this time included something like “I’m afraid this is very short notice to cancel
without charge” and then offered a reschedule, which was online and didn’t suit as I was still feeling poorly.

AIBU to not want to pay this? How could I possibly give 72 hours notice when I woke up sick?!! It’s seem a little inflexible.

OP posts:
Herdinggoats · 13/03/2024 10:30

I’d also imagine that she thinks that because she has given you a free pass once, you then had a bit less respect for he time so the next time you haven’t fancied it so thought that you may as well cancel because there is no penalty. To have no cancellations and then 2 in quick succession is a bit suspicious

dottiedodah · 13/03/2024 10:27

She is running a business .She can't just not charge people if they don't show up! Once is one thing ,but any more and she will be out of pocket.

MrWilyFoxIsBack · 13/03/2024 10:26

Yabvu. She gave you one goodwill free pass when you cancelled with almost no notice once before; so you expect her to keep doing it? I can’t work out if you are being deliberately stupid or obtuse but of course Yabu.

She is a small business, and she isn’t going to be able to replace your session at zero notice - she obviously needs the 72 hours to try and shuffle in a replacement appointment. She clearly set out Ts and Cs which you agreed to. You have no right to feel aggrieved or in anyway diddled. Maybe you can address your reaction in a future therapy session…

HighonCatnip · 13/03/2024 10:23

timeafterrhyme · 13/03/2024 09:31

Sorry meant, DH had to take child to hospital because I was working. Then client didn't turn up. So not only could I not help my child, I didn't really get paid either. It's just the way the cookie crumbles sometimes.

Why didn't you get paid for a DNA?

WatchandWaitorNot · 13/03/2024 10:13

If they had been willing to accept the risk of a last-minute cancellation due to sickness or other unforeseen circumstance they would have carved this out in the Ts and Cs. But you can see why they don’t, people would just lie and it would be a pain trying to get evidence. As you know from the previous time, they always have the discretion to waive the charge.

You saw the 72 hours as being somehow related to your ability to plan in advance. What you did not appreciate was that they chose 72 hours because that is the minimum time they need to fill the slot and not lose money. It was for their benefit, not yours.

ManchesterLu · 13/03/2024 10:11

I think she was very, very kind not to charge you the first time, but you can't take the piss. She has bills to pay just like everyone else. You have a slot booked, it's not her fault you didn't make the slot.

DamnSpots · 13/03/2024 10:11

If you book a hotel and then cancel with24 hour notice you usually have to pay the full price of your stay (because they can't easily fill the room at short notice).
If you cancel your dentist appointment last minute they will often charge you a fee.
My hairdresser charges for last minute cancellations.
If you book a holiday and then can't go because you're sick, the holiday company won't reimburse you or let you off paying (your travel insurance might).
If I cancel my personal trainer at the last minute, I still pay.

It really is standard in all industries. You have booked their time, meaning they are not available for anyone else and so you should be paying for it regardless of whether you are able to make use of it.

tittybumbum · 13/03/2024 10:07

enchantedsquirrelwood · 13/03/2024 09:53

I actually think, and I've posted on here before, that I don't think these cancellation policies are reasonable. And it's not about whether it is in the terms and conditions - they have to be reasonable. We can argue whether they are reasonable, but it's not the case in consumer law that you are bound by something because you agreed to it.

If I cancel an appointment, they want to charge me. But if they cancel, they don't pay me the cost of the appointment. I might have made a loss if I eg needed to pay for childcare or had already bought a train ticket or whatever.

If you don't cancel at all and simply don't turn up, it's fine to charge. If you cancel at short notice, well I think they need to consider if they want you to turn up ill. If you cancel the day before they've time to fill the appointment slot. 72 hours is ludicrous.

Edited

Your position is frankly unworkable.

You are buying their service. Why would they pay you if they cancel? They are not buying your service. What costs you incur are your issue.

If there were not strict cancellation policies people would cancel last minute willy nilly. Totally unworkable. They aren't a charity. YABVU

Anonymous2566 · 13/03/2024 10:05

I get the posts about it impacting income and yes I did ‘agree’ to those t&cs but I seemed to think that 72hrs was for things like planned holiday etc which is easy to give plenty of notice for. I am surprised it’s for illness and as others have pointed out, 72 hours is U.

I agree with a post upthread that therapy is different to other industries and that has made my reaction to this complicated. Btw, I never said “I’m not paying her”, I said I don’t want to - which many have expressed they wouldn’t want to either, even if they eventually do.

And to a previous poster, no I’m not going to use this as evidence against my therapist. I just wanted to know if this was common practice and what others experiences are with their therapist and cancellation.

OP posts:
GG1986 · 13/03/2024 10:03

You are lucky she didn't charge you for the first time you were sick. She is being reasonable and yes you do need to pay her.

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 13/03/2024 10:02

enchantedsquirrelwood · 13/03/2024 09:53

I actually think, and I've posted on here before, that I don't think these cancellation policies are reasonable. And it's not about whether it is in the terms and conditions - they have to be reasonable. We can argue whether they are reasonable, but it's not the case in consumer law that you are bound by something because you agreed to it.

If I cancel an appointment, they want to charge me. But if they cancel, they don't pay me the cost of the appointment. I might have made a loss if I eg needed to pay for childcare or had already bought a train ticket or whatever.

If you don't cancel at all and simply don't turn up, it's fine to charge. If you cancel at short notice, well I think they need to consider if they want you to turn up ill. If you cancel the day before they've time to fill the appointment slot. 72 hours is ludicrous.

Edited

It depends on the modality, I suppose, but there aren't many opportunities for one-session therapy that I can think of. If you're offering 6-12 weekly sessions of therapy, or open-ended therapy, you can't usually just parachute someone into that slot. Most therapists are taught as part of their training that you meet at the same time and place every week and you hold that slot for the client.

Olaeverybody · 13/03/2024 10:01

She's not doing the job out of the kindness of her heart - she's got bills to pay. How is she supposed to operate a business if she can't predict her income? It was very good of her to let you off the once IMO; I don't doubt that you were sick, but if anyone who had something come up could get a session moved on the day simply by claiming they were sick then I don't think it would be viable for her to work as a therapist.

Emotionalsupportviper · 13/03/2024 09:58

Anonymous2566 · 12/03/2024 23:53

No, she isn’t, she’s a private therapist. I get that she has bills to pay and if I was doing it from the start and for no good reason, I can understand the need to charge. It was just unfortunate I had two bouts of illness quite close together. For holidays etc, I’ve always given plenty of notice. I’ve also been very understanding when she has been sick and emailed in the morning.

I’ve also been very understanding when she has been sick and emailed in the morning.

You can afford to be.

It isn't affecting your income.

Usedtobecoolnowiloveairfryers · 13/03/2024 09:56

I think your therapist has been VR in allowing you to cancel without charge once - a second time I agree YABVU to expect her to cancel with no charge

We have similar with DDs riding - cancel with 24 hours notice no charge but if it’s 2 weeks running we have to pay for one of the weeks. And we are only allowed to cancel once within a 6 week period otherwise we forfeit the space (unless we pay for it - which we always do without question) only had this situation once where holidays with both us and Dad took 4 weeks of a 6 week period completely out - so we paid the full 4 weeks she wasn’t there

SoupDragon · 13/03/2024 09:53

katepilar · 13/03/2024 09:51

72 hours before seems a bit long of a notice, around here its usually 48 hours. But its perfectly reasonable of her to charge you within the timeframe you agreed to. Certainly if you cancel of the actual day. Yes, it sucks. But if everyone cancelled on her, she would be out of pocket very soon.
On the first occasion she may have felt generous, or it actually suited her that you cancelled so she felt she is able not to charge you.

The OP cancelled on the day both times

enchantedsquirrelwood · 13/03/2024 09:53

I actually think, and I've posted on here before, that I don't think these cancellation policies are reasonable. And it's not about whether it is in the terms and conditions - they have to be reasonable. We can argue whether they are reasonable, but it's not the case in consumer law that you are bound by something because you agreed to it.

If I cancel an appointment, they want to charge me. But if they cancel, they don't pay me the cost of the appointment. I might have made a loss if I eg needed to pay for childcare or had already bought a train ticket or whatever.

If you don't cancel at all and simply don't turn up, it's fine to charge. If you cancel at short notice, well I think they need to consider if they want you to turn up ill. If you cancel the day before they've time to fill the appointment slot. 72 hours is ludicrous.

BardRelic · 13/03/2024 09:52

OK OP. You've had it explained to you why you're being unreasonable. The vast majority think you are being unreasonable. And even if you've got a point, you've still signed to accept her T&Cs and she still reminded you of them the first time you cancelled. So the question is, what are you going to do now?

You can accept her T&Cs and continue with her. It's hard to find therapists who are a good fit and if you get on with her otherwise, then why not? Or you can seek another therapist, check their T&Cs, and hope you get on better. I don't think either is wrong, there are risks with both. If you stick with your current therapist you may find all of this has upset your relationship with her. Or maybe have another session with her, talk about boundaries, and then decide from there how you feel?

katepilar · 13/03/2024 09:51

72 hours before seems a bit long of a notice, around here its usually 48 hours. But its perfectly reasonable of her to charge you within the timeframe you agreed to. Certainly if you cancel of the actual day. Yes, it sucks. But if everyone cancelled on her, she would be out of pocket very soon.
On the first occasion she may have felt generous, or it actually suited her that you cancelled so she felt she is able not to charge you.

ItsallIeverwanted · 13/03/2024 09:51

I meant whether you show up or not for the session is immaterial, you pay 48 hours in advance and then that's that, unless you cancel more than 48 hours ahead. Once paid, it's up to you to attend, go online or not attend.

Butchyrestingface · 13/03/2024 09:51

YABU. She has already been flexible and not charged you the first time you were ill (some would).

Now she plans to observe her T&Cs going forward. I would too. If you don't like the T&Cs that you voluntarily signed up to, find another therapist.

ItsallIeverwanted · 13/03/2024 09:50

I think a 48 hour policy is fair. I have to pay one therapist 48 hours prior to the session and so whether you cancel or not is immaterial. That person is very strict with boundaries and if you are late, that's your session you are wasting! I appreciate their direct and straightforward way of doing business, it takes the personal out of it.

Moveoverdarlin · 13/03/2024 09:50

Standard practice for this kind of thing. If you give her late notice, she can’t fill that slot. She loses because you’ve got a sore throat? How is that fair? As a gesture of goodwill she let you off last time. But this time you have to pay. This would be the same with personal trainers, childminders, nail techs, hairdressers, piano teachers. It’s obvious!! Otherwise people will cancel all the time just because they can’t be arsed, it’s raining, bit of a cold etc

WhoAteAllTheDinosaurs · 13/03/2024 09:49

The problem with 24 hour cancellation policies is that people leave it until precisely 1 minute before 24 hours before to cancel. Then you're stuck, as you can't charge them, nor can you fill the spot, especially if you are, you know, working, and can't see the cancellation message until later. Which is why my cancellation policy is longer.
But honestly, the number of people who still ask to not pay even though they cancel at late notice is ridiculous.

OssomMummy1 · 13/03/2024 09:49

Anonymous2566 · 12/03/2024 23:21

So, I’ve been seeing my therapist for about a year and things are going well. I’ve been very dedicated and always attend my sessions and pay upfront. My issue is, the cancellation policy. The agreement stipulates that I must give 72 hours notice for cancellation, otherwise the full payment is due. I was sick a few weeks back and let my therapist know on the day, she wished me better, advised me to relax and then put something about the cancellation policy, but that she didn’t wish to charge me on this occasion. Again, I have been sick and had to cancel my session on the day. She sent a similar message, wishing me better etc, but this time included something like “I’m afraid this is very short notice to cancel
without charge” and then offered a reschedule, which was online and didn’t suit as I was still feeling poorly.

AIBU to not want to pay this? How could I possibly give 72 hours notice when I woke up sick?!! It’s seem a little inflexible.

Looks like you think everything in this world works like NHS!!!

rosesinmygarden · 13/03/2024 09:46

Assuming you were made aware of this policy before you booked, I can't see what your issue is.

Why is it that you think that the policy you accepted when you booked, should not apply to you?

I'm self employed and I obviously take the hit for all of my own illness and time off. I cannot afford to pay for all my clients illness and time off too.

I drop clients who don't understand this. Very quickly.

Maybe it's time to look for a new therapist, OP. One who has a policy that suits you better?