Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For not wanting to pay my therapist when I was sick!!

309 replies

Anonymous2566 · 12/03/2024 23:21

So, I’ve been seeing my therapist for about a year and things are going well. I’ve been very dedicated and always attend my sessions and pay upfront. My issue is, the cancellation policy. The agreement stipulates that I must give 72 hours notice for cancellation, otherwise the full payment is due. I was sick a few weeks back and let my therapist know on the day, she wished me better, advised me to relax and then put something about the cancellation policy, but that she didn’t wish to charge me on this occasion. Again, I have been sick and had to cancel my session on the day. She sent a similar message, wishing me better etc, but this time included something like “I’m afraid this is very short notice to cancel
without charge” and then offered a reschedule, which was online and didn’t suit as I was still feeling poorly.

AIBU to not want to pay this? How could I possibly give 72 hours notice when I woke up sick?!! It’s seem a little inflexible.

OP posts:
LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 13/03/2024 11:28

Anonymous2566 · 13/03/2024 10:05

I get the posts about it impacting income and yes I did ‘agree’ to those t&cs but I seemed to think that 72hrs was for things like planned holiday etc which is easy to give plenty of notice for. I am surprised it’s for illness and as others have pointed out, 72 hours is U.

I agree with a post upthread that therapy is different to other industries and that has made my reaction to this complicated. Btw, I never said “I’m not paying her”, I said I don’t want to - which many have expressed they wouldn’t want to either, even if they eventually do.

And to a previous poster, no I’m not going to use this as evidence against my therapist. I just wanted to know if this was common practice and what others experiences are with their therapist and cancellation.

Edited

But what is reasonable for illness - it sounds like 24 hours wouldn’t have been enough and you can’t just make an exception for illness otherwise that will always be used as an excuse.
what is they all cancelled on the day due to illness, she would make nothing

Scirocco · 13/03/2024 11:26

PinkIcedCream · 13/03/2024 11:23

I’d be more bothered about paying the therapist regularly for over a year with no obvious end point.

Rather than worry about one unattended session, maybe you could think about looking towards a clear end date and/or find a new therapist who focuses on helping you to get on with your life.

The only time I used therapy was with a hypnotherapist who sorted me out in one session. That was money well spent!

There are different types of therapy for different people and different issues.

Some therapies are short, time-limited interventions.

Some are longer-term and can take years, due to the complexity of what needs to be explored and how it needs to be explored in order to help the patient most appropriately.

It's not unusual to see a therapist for long-term work. It's just maybe something people don't talk about that much when we live in a rather 'instant fix' society.

CandidaAlbicans2 · 13/03/2024 11:23

No-one wants to pay for a service that they are unable to use due to illness. You are no different to anyone else on that, it’s not unreasonable to feel a bit annoyed about that. But you should be annoyed that you got ill, not at the person providing the service you were unable to use.

That's exactly what I was going to say @Causewerethespecialtwo

@Anonymous2566 I get that it stings to have to pay for a service you couldn't attend through no fault of your own. YANBU to feel that way. But your therapist isn't being unreasonable in having those Ts&Cs (and enforcing them) for reasons already given. Also, unfortunately, there are so many people who will make the "I'm ill" excuse when they aren't actually ill, they just don't feel like doing something (not implying that's you BTW). As service providers have no way of knowing who's genuine and who isn't they simply have to have a blanket policy for dealing with cancellations. Plus they can't afford to subsidise missed appointments. I hope you feel better soon and that you're finding the therapy helpful Flowers

PinkIcedCream · 13/03/2024 11:23

I’d be more bothered about paying the therapist regularly for over a year with no obvious end point.

Rather than worry about one unattended session, maybe you could think about looking towards a clear end date and/or find a new therapist who focuses on helping you to get on with your life.

The only time I used therapy was with a hypnotherapist who sorted me out in one session. That was money well spent!

katepilar · 13/03/2024 11:14

WinterDeWinter · 13/03/2024 10:56

In my experience this is a sign that the type of therapy offered is not a 'depth' one, so less able to offer lasting change at a systemic level. It will address the symptoms but not the cause, and is best thought of as emotional coaching or mentoring. It can be helpful, but the fundamental issues remain unexplored.

Edited

Interesting. Not sure what difference does it make if you meet your therapist on a Monday afternoon every week to if you meet them Monday afternoon one week and on a Wednesday morning another week.

Reading more post in this thread I think it may be a different approach to things in different places, I am not in the UK.

narkyspirit · 13/03/2024 11:13

You need to pay the therapist, I get this frequently with work, its normally on a day rate so its hundreds of pounds and sometimes multiple days get cancelled in a week.

Pay up or find another therapist! I block customers now if they cancel more than twice at short notice..

NotQuiteNorma · 13/03/2024 11:13

You ignored the 72hr clause twice even though you knew it was there. If you think it's an unreasonable clause for Illness then you don't agree to the contract at the start and look for another therapist. It's not difficult. People can't go around agreeing to contracts then expect special treatment when they don't want to be bound by the terms. You had a chance not to agree when you were given the contract. Tne lesson here is read what you are signing, if you did read it and still carried on then you've got even less cause to complain.

SherrieElmer · 13/03/2024 11:10

Bit of a cheeky fucker, aren't we ?

katepilar · 13/03/2024 11:07

SoupDragon · 13/03/2024 09:53

The OP cancelled on the day both times

Yes, I have read that. Not sure why you think I havent.

Mountainpika · 13/03/2024 11:04

Seems reasaonable to me. My therapist hires a room in a centre - they can't fill that at very short notice. He still has to pay, I expect. Plus he loses payment for his time unless he can fill it at short notice.
Having said that, I needed an appointment recently (I have therapy as and when I need it) and was waiting to hear back. First thing in the morning I had an email to say he'd had a cancellation that morning if I could make it. I could. So he didn't actually lose any business, just with a different client.

SylvanianAddict · 13/03/2024 10:59

YABU- very very U- not only can she not fill that time at less than 72h notice but she also rents the room for an hour too so she’s losing her own money for something that is not her fault.

WinterDeWinter · 13/03/2024 10:56

katepilar · 13/03/2024 10:52

In my experience and in experience of anyone I know we dont have a weekly slot, we just book sessions that are available at the time of the booking.

In my experience this is a sign that the type of therapy offered is not a 'depth' one, so less able to offer lasting change at a systemic level. It will address the symptoms but not the cause, and is best thought of as emotional coaching or mentoring. It can be helpful, but the fundamental issues remain unexplored.

Causewerethespecialtwo · 13/03/2024 10:56

Anonymous2566 · 13/03/2024 10:05

I get the posts about it impacting income and yes I did ‘agree’ to those t&cs but I seemed to think that 72hrs was for things like planned holiday etc which is easy to give plenty of notice for. I am surprised it’s for illness and as others have pointed out, 72 hours is U.

I agree with a post upthread that therapy is different to other industries and that has made my reaction to this complicated. Btw, I never said “I’m not paying her”, I said I don’t want to - which many have expressed they wouldn’t want to either, even if they eventually do.

And to a previous poster, no I’m not going to use this as evidence against my therapist. I just wanted to know if this was common practice and what others experiences are with their therapist and cancellation.

Edited

“Btw, I never said “I’m not paying her”, I said I don’t want to - which many have expressed they wouldn’t want to either, even if they eventually do”

No-one wants to pay for a service that they are unable to use due to illness. You are no different to anyone else on that, it’s not unreasonable to feel a bit annoyed about that. But you should be annoyed that you got ill, not at the person providing the service you were unable to use.

Its happened to me loads of times - my kids couldn’t go to nursery because they were ill, I had to cancel my PT or beauty appointments because my kids or I were ill, we couldn’t go on a weekend away because one of the kids had chickenpox, I couldn’t go to work because my child was ill (and I don’t get paid as a consequence). Yes it sucks and I was disappointed, but I understood they were all to be paid. It’s my misfortune that my kids or I are sick and so the consequence is mine, not someone else’s.

MrsKeats · 13/03/2024 10:55

Duh · 13/03/2024 09:10

Are you planning to work through your issue of self entitlement with this therapist?

Quite.

ouch321 · 13/03/2024 10:53

Why are you putting 'agree' in quote marks? You did agree to the TsCs.

And gathering 'evidence' against her?

I'd put money on you not paying her despite you saying you will.

katepilar · 13/03/2024 10:52

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 12/03/2024 23:28

Generally therapy takes place at a specific time each week with that therapist and she will hold that slot for the client as long as they're working together. Her policy is pretty standard, I think. I agree that it's tough when you're ill and I have been on the receiving end of that, but think of it as holding your slot.

Edited

In my experience and in experience of anyone I know we dont have a weekly slot, we just book sessions that are available at the time of the booking.

Lambzig · 13/03/2024 10:50

I am a therapist and I have a 48 hours cancellation policy. Mainly because I have to pay room hire if I cancel that in less than 24 hours, so would be out of pocket as well as losing the fee earned from the session.

It was good to see that a lot of people on here think it is reasonable. Its my main income, I can rarely fill that time with another client and I do waive the fee for the first time too.

I think sometimes people forget its a job (the whole profession is set up a bit like that with an emphasis on volunteering etc in a way that doctors or nurses would not be expected to, but I will get off my soap box about that).

ButterflyTable · 13/03/2024 10:48

@WinterDeWinter absolutely agree. The relationship is valuable and OP if you don’t have that relationship then deffo talk to your therapist, I would not even consider not paying my therapist if I couldn’t make it, I actually re-call making the payment then emailing her to tell her I couldn’t make it as I didn’t want her to think she would have to chase me for payment.

NaomhPadraigin · 13/03/2024 10:45

It's not like she's a hairdresser who could cover the gap with a wait list or a walk in.

WinterDeWinter · 13/03/2024 10:45

Most depth (ie psychodynamic) therapists don't allow any cancellation for any reason. The weekly slot is allotted to you, and that security is critically important to the process.

She can't take it away from you, and you commit to paying to keep it accessible to you on an ongoing basis.

Is her time valuable to you? That's an important question in your relationship. Since that relationship is at the heart of the process of therapy, this is something you should definitely discuss in your next session.

Ellie1015 · 13/03/2024 10:43

Some people lie about being ill when too tired or other plans come up. Charging is to deter that and because she is unlikely to fill the space at short notice.

She was kind enough not to charge the first time, yes it is unlucky to be ill again but not likely to happen again for a while just one of those things.

ButterflyTable · 13/03/2024 10:38

I had a gesture of goodwill on my first session but I’ve missed another since then due to illness and paid.

Itloggedmeoutagain · 13/03/2024 10:36

Anonymous2566 · 13/03/2024 10:05

I get the posts about it impacting income and yes I did ‘agree’ to those t&cs but I seemed to think that 72hrs was for things like planned holiday etc which is easy to give plenty of notice for. I am surprised it’s for illness and as others have pointed out, 72 hours is U.

I agree with a post upthread that therapy is different to other industries and that has made my reaction to this complicated. Btw, I never said “I’m not paying her”, I said I don’t want to - which many have expressed they wouldn’t want to either, even if they eventually do.

And to a previous poster, no I’m not going to use this as evidence against my therapist. I just wanted to know if this was common practice and what others experiences are with their therapist and cancellation.

Edited

Cancellation is cancellation. It doesn't matter the reason. Can she say to the bank that she can't pay the mortgage because she had team clients cancel but they were sick so that's OK? You say you get it but you clearly don't get it at all.

Scirocco · 13/03/2024 10:34

Of course you have to pay. It's a scheduled private appointment. You not turning up (for whatever reason) doesn't negate the overheads or the fact that she can't just slot someone else or some other work into that appointment slot at such short notice. If she didn't charge, she'd be out of pocket herself.

Rosesanddaisies1 · 13/03/2024 10:32

YABU, and she's been generous this first time. What if every client did this?