Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For not wanting to pay my therapist when I was sick!!

309 replies

Anonymous2566 · 12/03/2024 23:21

So, I’ve been seeing my therapist for about a year and things are going well. I’ve been very dedicated and always attend my sessions and pay upfront. My issue is, the cancellation policy. The agreement stipulates that I must give 72 hours notice for cancellation, otherwise the full payment is due. I was sick a few weeks back and let my therapist know on the day, she wished me better, advised me to relax and then put something about the cancellation policy, but that she didn’t wish to charge me on this occasion. Again, I have been sick and had to cancel my session on the day. She sent a similar message, wishing me better etc, but this time included something like “I’m afraid this is very short notice to cancel
without charge” and then offered a reschedule, which was online and didn’t suit as I was still feeling poorly.

AIBU to not want to pay this? How could I possibly give 72 hours notice when I woke up sick?!! It’s seem a little inflexible.

OP posts:
Otherstories2002 · 13/03/2024 18:38

Anonymous2566 · 12/03/2024 23:53

No, she isn’t, she’s a private therapist. I get that she has bills to pay and if I was doing it from the start and for no good reason, I can understand the need to charge. It was just unfortunate I had two bouts of illness quite close together. For holidays etc, I’ve always given plenty of notice. I’ve also been very understanding when she has been sick and emailed in the morning.

Do you still pay her when she cancels?

No of course not.

You cannot expect her to lose out because you’re ill. Honestly the entitlement.

BobbyBiscuits · 13/03/2024 18:09

She cannot fill the session at such short notice so she loses an hours wages. I can't see how else it could work. Everyone bailing at the last moment would mean she has no income. She waived it once and you agreed to it when signing up presumably.
Just know that if you're too sick suddenly then you'll have to pay the fine. Most people would either accept the cost or force themselves to do the session. I doubt you'd find another one who wouldn't have this type of stipulation, unless it's NHS.

CowCuddler · 13/03/2024 18:04

I find your comment about you 'agreeing to the terms in the contract that say you would pay if you give less than 72 hour notice, but that you didn't think this applied to illness', quite interesting.

Perhaps you should do some work on boundaries with your therapist. She made her boundaries quite clear from the start. You seem to think they don't apply all the time or when they don't suit you.

99% of people think you're being unreasonable. Perhaps just accept that you are?

beanii · 13/03/2024 17:40

Imagine if all of her appointments that day were cancelled last minute - who pays her?

She was very kind the first time - be grateful.

Mh67 · 13/03/2024 17:37

Your very lucky she didn't charge you first time.
The lady has bills to pay hence the cancellation charge

ComSci · 13/03/2024 17:37

Woodenwonder · 13/03/2024 12:30

Well quite. She's got this fictitious mortgage that we've invented to pay. She might be minted for all we know and have no mortgage at all but that's irrelevant.

All I'll say is what I said - Therapy is a lifestyle business and people being ill or pretending to be so and not wanting to pay the cancellation fee is no doubt one of the pitfalls of being one. I think if you have no wiggle room as a therapist for empathy because of money then maybe taking mental load off people isn't the calling, money is. Not for profit or volunteer therapists are awesome though.

I am a totally shit business woman though and work with homeless people for a living and in my spare time so I'll accept my perspective is screwed.

Are you serious? Why do people have this idea that therapists are just nice people who should do the work for free? Volunteer therapists are awesome and the rest are what? Capitalist bastards making a profit out of other people's miserty? It's a hard job that requires initial training and continuing CPD, therapists are professionals that should be paid for the years they have trained, the experience they have, the room hire, insurance, CPD, membership fees etc that are ongoing business expenses. And the idea that somehow only rich people who don't ahve to charge should be therapists is incredibly priviledged and means that the profession is seriously lacking in diversity as it is.

And what, exactly, is a "lifestle business"?

Bakewellpuddingandcustard · 13/03/2024 17:27

GoosieLucie · 13/03/2024 14:19

YAB totally Unreasonable to expect not to have to pay for a session that you've cancelled at short notice!

The 72 hours notice period is for planned absences. If you're taken ill suddenly it will mean having to cancel on the day and thus not giving at least 72 hours notice. That means, of course, that you will still need to pay for the session that you can't attend.

I don't understand why you are so up in arms about this. It's pretty obvious to me (and almost everyone else) and seems to me to be a fair and reasonable policy.

Suppose, for example, that you make cakes for a living. Somebody orders a birthday cake, to be collected on Saturday. You buy the ingredients and make the cake on the Thursday and decorate it on the Friday. On Saturday morning your customer phones to cancel the order because the child is ill. So, do they still have to pay for the cake? Of course they do!

This with bells on!

Craftycorvid · 13/03/2024 17:21

Another therapist here - my overheads are mahoosive, as are those of all therapists. As pp have said, a raft of added expenses including membership of professional bodies, insurance, room hire, supervision and our own personal therapy. We don’t trouser the whole fee, maybe only half of it on a good day. I appreciate that someone might consider the hourly rate and think it extortionate unless they realise where it all goes. In terms of short-notice cancellations: I’d always use common sense and discretion. Sudden bereavements and things like that, I’d waive the fee to avoid adding to distress. I have also contracted that short notice cancellations aren’t charged where the reason is serious long-term illness or care for someone who has serious long-term illness.

ilovesooty · 13/03/2024 17:19

TorroFerney · 13/03/2024 15:08

I think it’s unreasonable of me not to have understood your post properly before commenting!

No worries. I might not have explained it very well initially and the thread was moving pretty quickly.

HighonCatnip · 13/03/2024 16:26

In therapy, therapists are often taught that what happens in the room happens outside it. A client that just cannot stop talking for the therapist to get a word in edgeways is likely to do the same to their friends and family in their day to day life. Someone who is really closed off and finds it hard to share their emotions in therapy, likely to be the same with their family. So this would be really useful and valid to bring up in the session OP. A client who feels aggrieved at paying a fee that was explicitly laid out in the T&Cs they agreed to when starting therapy may well display or at least feel that sense of entitlement and being hard-done-by in the rest of their life when situations crop up that are very fair and predictable but unpalatable. Definitely bring it up to discuss.

TorroFerney · 13/03/2024 15:08

ilovesooty · 13/03/2024 13:41

You think it's reasonable for me to keep the money for a session the client hasn't been able to attend due to my illness? I have explained above that the payment rolls over and I'm not offering a free session on top.

I think it’s unreasonable of me not to have understood your post properly before commenting!

WinterDeWinter · 13/03/2024 14:57

Just to add - as well as the need for the therapist to model good boundaries so that the patient can learn them at a behavioural level, there is also the possibility that the foundation of this critical relationship will be undermined by a failure to hold them. They might experience it as care and feel gratitude - or they might, consciously or unconsciously, wonder why they have been given special treatment, and what might be asked of them in return. Do they 'owe' the therapist now? Or they might experience it as the therapist infantilising them, like a parent previously did, or as an indication that they are so damaged that they must be treated with kid gloves. Or that they are the centre of the universe around which everything else must be arranged - which can be quite a terrifying message. The therapist may sometimes make an exception, but there will be real thought behind their decision to do so that will be specific to that patient.

Sometimes they might let the patient know that they will be giving attention to them anyway, even if the patient isn't in the room, during that time. This can sometimes be a very powerful experience for the patient.

So there's a lot going on behind this idea - one reason that it's called a depth psychotherapy.

Rainydayweather · 13/03/2024 14:47

As a therapy client, I like having these boundaries in place. I don't expect favours from my therapist, and he doesn't offer them to me. It's a relationship built on mutual respect within a clear framework which was set out when we started working together

I agree with this.

Rainydayweather · 13/03/2024 14:42

So, you should not have to lose £75 but she should. Is that your argument?

Does that sound fair to you?

If you bought tickets to the theatre, or cinema or anything else, you would pay whether or not you used them. This is the same.

JungsWordTest · 13/03/2024 14:35

Anonymous2566 · 13/03/2024 10:05

I get the posts about it impacting income and yes I did ‘agree’ to those t&cs but I seemed to think that 72hrs was for things like planned holiday etc which is easy to give plenty of notice for. I am surprised it’s for illness and as others have pointed out, 72 hours is U.

I agree with a post upthread that therapy is different to other industries and that has made my reaction to this complicated. Btw, I never said “I’m not paying her”, I said I don’t want to - which many have expressed they wouldn’t want to either, even if they eventually do.

And to a previous poster, no I’m not going to use this as evidence against my therapist. I just wanted to know if this was common practice and what others experiences are with their therapist and cancellation.

Edited

I'd take this to your therapist. There is nothing that happens with a therapy session that lies outside the parameters of 'therapy', and this is no exception. All grist for the mill, as we were told many times in therapy training.

GoosieLucie · 13/03/2024 14:19

YAB totally Unreasonable to expect not to have to pay for a session that you've cancelled at short notice!

The 72 hours notice period is for planned absences. If you're taken ill suddenly it will mean having to cancel on the day and thus not giving at least 72 hours notice. That means, of course, that you will still need to pay for the session that you can't attend.

I don't understand why you are so up in arms about this. It's pretty obvious to me (and almost everyone else) and seems to me to be a fair and reasonable policy.

Suppose, for example, that you make cakes for a living. Somebody orders a birthday cake, to be collected on Saturday. You buy the ingredients and make the cake on the Thursday and decorate it on the Friday. On Saturday morning your customer phones to cancel the order because the child is ill. So, do they still have to pay for the cake? Of course they do!

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/03/2024 14:11

I am a therapist and I have a 48 hours cancellation policy. Mainly because I have to pay room hire if I cancel that in less than 24 hours, so would be out of pocket as well as losing the fee earned from the session.

There are also fees for insurance, supervision, ongoing training that form part of our registration requirements (and registration itself) that all need to be covered before you make any income. I have a small client list and limited sessions available, it starts to cost me more money than I make if people cancel without payment, which means from a very pragmatic point of view I would need to stop working.

Its good to take you’re reaction back into therapy though, money in the relationship does have meaning beyond mere payment for time so it’s good food for the therapeutic relationship.

SpringboksSocks · 13/03/2024 14:01

I’m a therapist and I have a mortgage to pay. We still have to pay for room hire etc if a client doesn’t come so we end up out of pocket if clients cancel, as it’s usually not possible to fill the slot with less than 72 hrs notice. Like your therapist, I try not to charge the first time as a goodwill gesture, but it’s not financially viable to do this ongoing. If your therapist has a few cancellations in a month and doesn’t charge then she may well not be able to pay her bills.

AuldWeegie · 13/03/2024 14:01

Nrtft, but She offered to reschedule an online session, which you turned down. Unless you had violent d&v, you should have taken it.

wutheringkites · 13/03/2024 13:57

As a therapy client, I like having these boundaries in place. I don't expect favours from my therapist, and he doesn't offer them to me.

It's a relationship built on mutual respect within a clear framework which was set out when we started working together.

If I got to the point where I was bitching about him on mumsnet for not letting me off paying for a week, my real concern would be that we no longer had the relationship needed to work together.

ilovesooty · 13/03/2024 13:41

TorroFerney · 13/03/2024 13:29

I think it's a really poor example of boundaries/being assertive/knowing your worth to be honest - all skills I want my therapist to model.

You think it's reasonable for me to keep the money for a session the client hasn't been able to attend due to my illness? I have explained above that the payment rolls over and I'm not offering a free session on top.

WinterDeWinter · 13/03/2024 13:40

timeafterrhyme · 13/03/2024 13:29

@WinterDeWinter no psychodynamic therapist who works to an ethical framework is going to insist on a client who is too sick for therapy attending.

You are plainly wrong.

Unless you're talking about therapists who aren't registered with a membership body, in which case people should steer clear.

I don't think I said they would insist on the patient attending, did I? I said they would expect the patient to pay for their weekly session, even though they were sick, though they would probably offer an alternative time if they had one available.

Lowin2024 · 13/03/2024 13:35

enchantedsquirrelwood · 13/03/2024 09:53

I actually think, and I've posted on here before, that I don't think these cancellation policies are reasonable. And it's not about whether it is in the terms and conditions - they have to be reasonable. We can argue whether they are reasonable, but it's not the case in consumer law that you are bound by something because you agreed to it.

If I cancel an appointment, they want to charge me. But if they cancel, they don't pay me the cost of the appointment. I might have made a loss if I eg needed to pay for childcare or had already bought a train ticket or whatever.

If you don't cancel at all and simply don't turn up, it's fine to charge. If you cancel at short notice, well I think they need to consider if they want you to turn up ill. If you cancel the day before they've time to fill the appointment slot. 72 hours is ludicrous.

Edited

It really isn’t true that if someone cancels the day before you have time to fill the slot. I am a children’s therapist - I have children waiting to be seen but I can’t just randomly slot a child into an empty slot - to take on a new client I need to do a full assessment, which requires a longer slot and then the capacity to offer them regular input. A single one off cancellation slot is very difficult to fill for certain industries.

TorroFerney · 13/03/2024 13:29

Anonymous2566 · 13/03/2024 00:28

If I am ill on the day (it's only ever happened once) the client's next session is free. My supervisor models the same policy.

This I think is a really good policy.

I think it's a really poor example of boundaries/being assertive/knowing your worth to be honest - all skills I want my therapist to model.

timeafterrhyme · 13/03/2024 13:29

@WinterDeWinter no psychodynamic therapist who works to an ethical framework is going to insist on a client who is too sick for therapy attending.

You are plainly wrong.

Unless you're talking about therapists who aren't registered with a membership body, in which case people should steer clear.

Swipe left for the next trending thread