Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

These aren’t little secrets that I’ve discovered DH is keeping.

379 replies

Yahyahyahyoyo · 12/03/2024 21:00

I snooped on DHs phone. In my defence, I looked through it to check if he had asked DSs cub leader to add me to the parent WhatsApp group. I’ve been asking for weeks, and no… he hadn’t, despite telling me he had.

Anyway, a message from a mutual friend popped up asking if he’d ‘set the business up yet’. DH is employed F/T already. He is the breadwinner and earns fairly well. I work P/t but on a very low wage as I took a while out to bring up the kids and had to restart my career from the bottom (my sector had moved on so much). He has mentioned absolutely nothing about leaving his job, setting up a business and going self employed. Yet, he has set up business pages on social media, got a logo designed, and researched the cost of local storage. It would involve spending 2-3 grand buying what is required for this business, plus the storage fees. We do not have any spare money. This business would also mean working anytime, night or day and travelling all other the country, which worries me as we have two young children, one with autism.

The second thing I’ve found is that he’s planning on buying an expensive e-bike- the cheapest he’s talking about on his bike group chat us £2500, but there’s also some more expensive ones he’s looking in to. Again, we don’t have this money. He’s put his existing bike up for sale for £1200, but I’ve discovered in the listing (I had to snoop all over marketplace to find it) that he bought his original bike brand new for £2400, despite telling me it was second hand. This is not the first time he’s lied about bike stuff. He’s bought so many accessories, helmets, shoes, clothing for bikes and told me he’s had them for years when I’ve questioned it. Last year he bought something and said it cost £60, then one of his friends slipped up and said they actually cost £300.

he’s not mentioned any of this to me. I’ve discovered it all from social media and his search history. Aren’t these things a spouse should discuss first? I will confront him, but need to think about what I’m going to say. I’m autistic, so I’m cautious about whether I’m over-reacting.

YANBU- These secrets are a big deal
YABU- it’s not that big of a deal

OP posts:
mandlerparr · 14/03/2024 18:37

He is in more debt than you know or realize right now. I can almost guarantee it. Why or how, that I do not know. Only you both can figure that out. Some people spend money like water. And pretend like they don't. And will deny up and down that they are the ones doing it, even when you show them the bank statements and credit card statements and atm withdrawals that both of you had made. They will still swear up and down that they didn't. Or they will bring out the old favorite "I made the money; I should get to spend it!" Yeah, no. Not if you have to put groceries on a credit card to spend that money. not if you can't change the oil on your car or pay your house taxes because you are spending like crazy.
so, whoever that is the in relationship probably has a bunch of hidden debt or are forcing the household into debt.

ChickenT2b · 14/03/2024 18:32

If you don’t have spare money and have joint finances. Why haven’t you seen this spending? Sounds like he’s hiding money or income to me.

Middleagedspreadisreal · 14/03/2024 18:15

Leave him. He is not your 'partner'. It will only get worse.

tattygrl · 14/03/2024 13:47

I think the people questioning why OP's husband feels he has to lie to her and suggesting perhaps the problem is that OP is over-zealous about monitoring spending etc. are a bit out of line in this instance. I totally get that viewpoint, and in other circumstances it could be worth looking at it like that, but OP's husband has started a business completely in secret! Not only does that involve the huge financial investment and risk, but from what OP's said, involves travelling and being available to work at all hours. This is a huge lifestyle change.

OP, I hope the big talk goes well. You're completely within reason to be shocked, worried and concerned. If it was just the spending on expensive hobby items, that would be one thing. But what he's done with the business will change both of your lives hugely.

Sahj123 · 14/03/2024 13:25

Wow. You’ve done nothing wrong searching his phone, my husband and I use each others all the time lol it’s whatever works for you guys so ignore comments that say otherwise.

I will say however, this marriage will not work in my opinion based on what I’ve read. He CONTINUALLY lies to your face! Again and again and AGAIN!!! How can you live like that!? He has NO respect for you, NO respect for your family, NO respect for your marriage. It’s all a lie!

Next Steps:
Speak to a solicitor ASAP, get all the info you need to answer your questions and take all the evidence you need (mortgage, bank statements, credit card debt, assets, ALL OF IT)
Do your courses, do a benefits calculator, speak to citizens advice
Initiate divorce proceedings but don’t serve
Pack his bags for him, have all your evidence of deceit and lies printed. Sit him at the table, present it all, secret meetings, business start up, bike being new, EVERYTHING.
Watch him lie and lie again, then present the divorce papers and ask him to leave, his stuffs already packed in his car etc.
Set up a few appointments with a life coach and or therapist to support you through this divorce
Try and build a network of support around you with family, friends, school mums etc

GO AND LIVE YOUR BEST LIFE WITH YOUR BABIES xx

WinterWonder · 14/03/2024 11:48

So, it sounds like he has spare money. Is he being honest with you and sharing his actual earnings? I know lots of couples seem to find this hard, but if you were childcare for years you need to have the full benefit of his wages

Paddingtonthebear · 14/03/2024 11:27

I say this as a friend found out her husband of 25 years had secretly invested joint money in to a failed business without her knowledge, racked up joint credit card debt whilst hiding the evidence and then finally left her for someone else after it was all revealed. He then swiftly declared himself bankrupt and she was left responsible for all their joint debt and a house in negative equity.

Paddingtonthebear · 14/03/2024 11:22

Snooping is not ideal but neither is deception. And he is deceiving you if he is hiding financial information, hiding purchases and spending your joint family income on secret items whilst you live as though family finances are tight. None of this adds up OP and it seems he is having a lovely time deceiving you. At least now you know, he could be putting you and your kids in a very precarious financial situation and you need to start protecting yourself quick smart. I’d be checking the mortgage, bank statements, credit checks, anything that you are both tied to.

Winter2020 · 14/03/2024 11:21

Hi OP,
My question might have got lost in a busy thread but does your child with Autism get DLA?

If so that money is to help your child and your family with extra costs/activities/care/therapy etc arising from their needs - not for your husband to buy bikes with. When you discuss finances with him make sure that money is ringfenced for your child/family activities and isn't the extra that is allowing him to spend on his hobbies.

Sundownmemories · 14/03/2024 11:02

Yahyahyahyoyo · 12/03/2024 21:00

I snooped on DHs phone. In my defence, I looked through it to check if he had asked DSs cub leader to add me to the parent WhatsApp group. I’ve been asking for weeks, and no… he hadn’t, despite telling me he had.

Anyway, a message from a mutual friend popped up asking if he’d ‘set the business up yet’. DH is employed F/T already. He is the breadwinner and earns fairly well. I work P/t but on a very low wage as I took a while out to bring up the kids and had to restart my career from the bottom (my sector had moved on so much). He has mentioned absolutely nothing about leaving his job, setting up a business and going self employed. Yet, he has set up business pages on social media, got a logo designed, and researched the cost of local storage. It would involve spending 2-3 grand buying what is required for this business, plus the storage fees. We do not have any spare money. This business would also mean working anytime, night or day and travelling all other the country, which worries me as we have two young children, one with autism.

The second thing I’ve found is that he’s planning on buying an expensive e-bike- the cheapest he’s talking about on his bike group chat us £2500, but there’s also some more expensive ones he’s looking in to. Again, we don’t have this money. He’s put his existing bike up for sale for £1200, but I’ve discovered in the listing (I had to snoop all over marketplace to find it) that he bought his original bike brand new for £2400, despite telling me it was second hand. This is not the first time he’s lied about bike stuff. He’s bought so many accessories, helmets, shoes, clothing for bikes and told me he’s had them for years when I’ve questioned it. Last year he bought something and said it cost £60, then one of his friends slipped up and said they actually cost £300.

he’s not mentioned any of this to me. I’ve discovered it all from social media and his search history. Aren’t these things a spouse should discuss first? I will confront him, but need to think about what I’m going to say. I’m autistic, so I’m cautious about whether I’m over-reacting.

YANBU- These secrets are a big deal
YABU- it’s not that big of a deal

Do you have access to your online banking so you can see what’s going in and out? If my husband spent £300 on an item I would notice almost immediately and it would make a huge difference to everything else we needed to buy that month. If you didn’t notice £300 leaving your account maybe you are better off than he tells you?
he sounds like he wants to keep up with the joneses, if he’s chatting to people with more money than you who have better bikes than him that’ll be why he’s decided he needs a new bike! Sounds like he needs to grow up a bit and realise that not everyone has the same circumstances in life.
my husband is as tight as they come and hates spending, I am the spender in our marriage but he doesn’t keep tabs on my spending. If either of us were to buy anything over £100 it would be a discussion.
i think you need to have a conversation, check your banking daily and ask him what he’s planning to give up in order to afford all these extra non necessity luxuries.

Midwinter91 · 14/03/2024 10:44

I think it’s really selfish and mean. Are you spending thousands of the family money on a hobby? Probably not. Do you have free time to be designing logos and researching set up for a business? Probably not.

Bootsforboots · 14/03/2024 10:05

potaytopotahto33 · 12/03/2024 21:46

FWIW I don't think people need to be completely transparent. They just need to be fair to each other and meet their financial obligations. You have nothing to feel guilty about especially with your ex's controlling questions.

MN is obsessed with the 'one pot' method. Even here, the OP has a joint account and seems to think it's the only one, although it's debatable whether he really pays his entire salary into it.

DH and I know each other's salaries. We put an agreed proportion into the joint that covers joint spending + savings. The rest, in our personal accounts.
Now whether I buy Gucci or he buys a motorbike with the rest, neither of us really cares. When we have kids and one of us goes PT the higher earner will put more in the joint, from which the PT parent will take their agreed 'personal spend' amount. Both completely theirs to do with as they wish. Of course if money is really tight THEN everything has to go into the joint.

Edited

@potaytopotahto33 this!

Anniegetyourgun · 14/03/2024 08:37

They not only have children, they have one child with particular needs that makes working full time pretty much impossible for one parent, plus one pre-schooler. The pre-schooler may be able to go to nursery but it sounds like the elder child would be difficult to place. So how does OP juggle these elements to increase her income? She says she's working on it (taking a course). That's to be applauded, but will take a while to bear fruit. Meanwhile, the spouse she trusted to look after them has apparently been happily spending like there's no tomorrow - or possibly not. This is where we came in.

Rosscameasdoody · 14/03/2024 08:01

Eastie77Returns · 14/03/2024 06:57

Well now, it’s not all I can contribute but I was trying to keep the comment succinct.

It seems OP doesn’t earn much. Her DH has a much higher income and is spending a lot of it on expensive hobbies and now setting up a business.

OP can sit around wailing about it, keep checking his phone to find out what he is up to next and leave herself financially vulnerable in later life (poor pension etc) by consigning herself to a low income.

Or she could get a better paid job and become a bit more independent.

But, as has already been pointed out, OP getting a better paid job doesn’t solve the problem of his secretive behaviour regarding setting up a business. . They are financially linked and if it fails, OP will likely share in the consequences of that - insolvency, bankruptcy, homelessness, to name but a few. And they have children. If he’s so secretive about it all, she has no idea what he’s doing. She could be named as a co-owner or director without her knowledge and she will be liable if he commits any financial misconduct or even criminality. Unless she knows what’s going on, this is where she’s most vulnerable and she can’t solve that with a better job.

Rosscameasdoody · 14/03/2024 07:50

FasterthanaButteredOtter · 13/03/2024 23:43

This was my thought. Could he have been squirreling some away into a different account for things like business/bikes?

OP says he has two credit cards. If she doesn’t have access to those, l’d hazard a guess that that’s likely where the spending is.

Eastie77Returns · 14/03/2024 06:57

PaminaMozart · 14/03/2024 01:16

11 pages and this is all you can contribute?

FFS

Well now, it’s not all I can contribute but I was trying to keep the comment succinct.

It seems OP doesn’t earn much. Her DH has a much higher income and is spending a lot of it on expensive hobbies and now setting up a business.

OP can sit around wailing about it, keep checking his phone to find out what he is up to next and leave herself financially vulnerable in later life (poor pension etc) by consigning herself to a low income.

Or she could get a better paid job and become a bit more independent.

Italianita · 14/03/2024 01:18

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

PaminaMozart · 14/03/2024 01:16

Eastie77Returns · 14/03/2024 00:03

Get a better paid job.

11 pages and this is all you can contribute?

FFS

Eastie77Returns · 14/03/2024 00:03

Get a better paid job.

startingarumor · 14/03/2024 00:01

@iamnotgroot0 My phone isn't locked and my husband is free to look at it without me caring. Everyone has different boundaries

tachetastic · 13/03/2024 23:53

Cloverforever · 13/03/2024 22:35

You ask that in such a confrontational/accusatory way. Why?

I disagree. I don't think a conversation between any couple needs to be confrontational or accusatory. My entire point was to encourage conversation rather than reliance on rumour and conjecture.

Does that make sense, @Cloverforever .

FasterthanaButteredOtter · 13/03/2024 23:43

Lammveg · 12/03/2024 21:20

Are you sure you know how much money he has? Does he have a secret account or something?

This was my thought. Could he have been squirreling some away into a different account for things like business/bikes?

BritneyBookClubPresident · 13/03/2024 23:39

LuluBlakey1 · 12/03/2024 23:20

Bottom line is he lies to you regularly over important things. That would be it for me- I would never trust him.

This

Mothership4two · 13/03/2024 23:39

OH and I look at each others phones and emails. There's nothing very damning on there and I couldn't care less if he "snoops". I doubt he would because he knows there's nothing there that he doesn't know already and vice versa. I would find it worrying if he became secretive, changed passwords and was protecting info on his devices. Although not as worrying as him planning to leave his job and set up a business without menitioning it to me (or being able to give my input)!

PoochiesPinkEars · 13/03/2024 23:27

Good luck op.
I know you started this thread to sense check if your concern was fair, but personally I think you have your head screwed on so I would trust your judgement and instincts.
I hope you have some good rl support and the damage isn't worse than you know.

Swipe left for the next trending thread