Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandparents going over our head to fund gap year

383 replies

Pinkyoo · 12/03/2024 17:17

DD is doing her A-Levels and has decided to take a gap year. We told her she will need to fund this herself.
She's been in touch with an internship group where she can do a 16 week internship in Colombia. She's desperate to do it. It is £5500 for the fees alone (including accommodation), then flights and living costs.
DD has been working part time since the day after her 16th birthday and saves most of what she earns. We've already helped contribute to the cost of her inter-railing in Europe over summer with her friends.

Today my mum told me that she and my dad have decided they will entirely fund the internship, including flights. But need DD to use her savings to cover the living costs (recommended $100-200 per week).

They've said they will also help her with travelling for some of her gap year.

We are in a position where when DD goes to uni, we can cover her living costs and give her money for food. But she will need to work to travel etc.

I hate that my parents have gone over our head to fund this. I'd hoped DD would find full time work in her gap year. Now it's looking more like travel in the summer, travel in autumn, internship January, then maybe more travelling.

AIBU to think this is ridiculous and they are spoiling her?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
mjf981 · 12/03/2024 22:19

Shes 18 OP. An adult. She can do what she wants.
You can offer pad ice but ultimately it’s up to her. Try not to push her away by ‘telling’ her.

SleepingStandingUp · 12/03/2024 22:17

Pinkyoo · 12/03/2024 17:22

Apparently it's in Marketing & PR.
Haven't looked into it as I didn't support the idea.

She's not a baby op. She's an adult. Refusing to let other people support her because you think it's not something you'd choose is unfair

Pinkyoo · 12/03/2024 22:16

@PollyPut It's not even the distance that bothers me, she can be as many hundreds of miles away she likes as long as it's somewhere safe!
She seems the be on a "if I never take risk life will be boring" tangent whenever we talk.

I categorically would prefer at 18 she avoided South America and South East Asia entirely.

OP posts:
DirectionToPerfection · 12/03/2024 22:14

PollyPut · 12/03/2024 22:06

Really? You think it's a good idea for an 18 year old to go to Columbia? You'd be happy for your own daughter to do it, would you?

Going by OPs initial post she doesn't have any safety concerns at all, she's just pissed off that her parents are doing this for her daughter. That's obviously driven by some kind of resentment or jealousy.

I would certainly advise any young woman to do their research and go with a reputable company. I wouldn't snipe about their plans and pressure them to get a job instead.

As a PP said, OP's daughter isn't going to listen to her now after her negativity.

PollyPut · 12/03/2024 22:13

rainbegone · 12/03/2024 22:11

YABU. I had a similar dilemma when my sister wanted to give DD a monthly allowance when she went off to Uni. I felt that DD should work to pay her way, but soon realised that if my sister wanted to do that and it made her happy then I wouldn't object. It has meant that DD can concentrate fully on her studies and not worry financially, she has worked hard and had great results in her 2 years at uni. DD is so grateful to my sister. They keep in touch regularly and have developed such a lovely bond.

Your daughter sounds hardworking and far from spoilt. Your parents should have asked you first, but maybe knew that you'd say no, so when straight to your daughter. I'd let them help your daughter.

You sound mean

Paying to go and work in Columbia, thousands of miles away from home, is not the same as paying to go to learn at uni though!

Pinkyoo · 12/03/2024 22:12

Does anywhere here actually think letting an 18 year old go to Colombia is a good idea?
Regardless of the actual value of what she wants to do. Can anyone say they would let their 18 year old go to Colombia for 4 months?

OP posts:
rainbegone · 12/03/2024 22:11

YABU. I had a similar dilemma when my sister wanted to give DD a monthly allowance when she went off to Uni. I felt that DD should work to pay her way, but soon realised that if my sister wanted to do that and it made her happy then I wouldn't object. It has meant that DD can concentrate fully on her studies and not worry financially, she has worked hard and had great results in her 2 years at uni. DD is so grateful to my sister. They keep in touch regularly and have developed such a lovely bond.

Your daughter sounds hardworking and far from spoilt. Your parents should have asked you first, but maybe knew that you'd say no, so when straight to your daughter. I'd let them help your daughter.

You sound mean

PollyPut · 12/03/2024 22:11

@Pinkyoo I would help her research other options. Agree with PPs about the value of this particular position and her personal safety. I think you need to speak to the GPs to to explain your concerns. Try to look at alternative options. Do the unis she's applying to have any programs or connections?

MolkosTeenageAngst · 12/03/2024 22:08

Life in your late teens and early twenties is for living, she has her whole adulthood to work a full time job. I spent my gap year travelling and another 2 years straight after graduating from uni volunteering abroad and they were sone of the best days of my lives. I’ll never get those experiences again now I have adult roles and responsibilities I can’t really just abandon for a year. I’d be pleased on her behalf she has grandparents who can fund an adventure like this for her and that she’ll get to live a bit before having to knuckle down at uni and enter the daily grind of adult life.

PollyPut · 12/03/2024 22:06

DirectionToPerfection · 12/03/2024 21:40

You are being ridiculous!

I bet she can't wait to get away from your negativity.

Really? You think it's a good idea for an 18 year old to go to Columbia? You'd be happy for your own daughter to do it, would you?

baileybrosbuildingandloan · 12/03/2024 22:00

I'd do it for my grandkids if I could.

Let your DD have some fun. She sounds pretty clued up. It'll be fabulous for her.

Shetlands · 12/03/2024 21:59

It sounds like she's going to argue about every concern you have so could you have a conversation with the grandparents about ensuring she's in a safe environment and working for a reputable company? She's more likely to listen to them at the moment and they will surely want her to have the safest experience.

Nextdoor55 · 12/03/2024 21:53

No I would appreciate it, they're doing a nice thing for their grandchild, I'd let them

Sakura7 · 12/03/2024 21:53

SuperstarDeejay · 12/03/2024 21:44

I'd be really worried about a lone young woman in Colombia.

Unfortunately, you've been so relentlessly negative about this trip that she's not going to listen to you about any of it now. She's not stubborn, she's just tuned you out because you were being so unreasonable.

Exactly this.

Bellsbeachwaves · 12/03/2024 21:46

I went to South America when I was about 20 ish. Unbelievably awesome experience and I am so so glad I did it. Plus she can speak some Spanish! Yes it must be terrifying for you... But you might have to let her go. Buy her a lonely planet columbia and tell her how she might be able to protect herself... Although she might not listen to you ;) can you hook her up with anyone who has been before if she hasn't already?

Sixpence39 · 12/03/2024 21:45

She has the next 50 years to work full time. Let her explore the world while she can!

SuperstarDeejay · 12/03/2024 21:44

I'd be really worried about a lone young woman in Colombia.

Unfortunately, you've been so relentlessly negative about this trip that she's not going to listen to you about any of it now. She's not stubborn, she's just tuned you out because you were being so unreasonable.

curlymacv · 12/03/2024 21:42

I moved to South America for a year when I was 17. First solo travel experience in a similar sort of programme. It was absolutely incredible. Bit weird you don't want your daughter to take such an amazing opportunity.

If you don't like the company, just find another? There's lots. Or even do something else like a language course. Plenty of options.

lemonmeringueno3 · 12/03/2024 21:42

Once she leaves university she's staring down the barrel of about 50 years of working. Why not let her enjoy these years now, if she wants to do it, and it's covered financially? I'd get on board and help her plan. She'll always remember how you respond to this - with shared excitement or with unfathomable resentment.

Momstermunch · 12/03/2024 21:42

Are you the same poster who posted about her daughter being 'lost' or words to that effect because you and her school wanted her to do finance/law/medicine and she wants to do marketing/languages.

If so, I'm kind of glad she has someone in her corner.

Nazzywish · 12/03/2024 21:40

Why don't you research few reputable options for her OP. A pain I know but bests her thinking your just trying to block everything. She ll likely be abit more amenable to discussing other routes then.

Namechanger789 · 12/03/2024 21:40

Colombia is quite dangerous 😬
I worked in Brazil teaching English in my 20s and had fun overall but some pretty scary experiences too. I think i was quite naive to the poverty and the risks of living and working there. She needs to go with a reputable organisation. How about Costa Rica or somewhere generally a bit safer?

Pinkyoo · 12/03/2024 21:40

Naptimeagain · 12/03/2024 21:38

I agree with pps that the role she's looking into isn't an internship, it's paying - a lot - to fill a space on a CV, and unlikely to convince future employers, and there's a risk that she'll be hanging out with other English speaking 'interns' and won't improve her language skills.

If her grandparents are happy to fund a gap year, a residential Spanish course in Spain would be great, and some travelling after that. There is lots of availability, and as a pp suggested, she could do some TEFL too.

Columbia sounds a bit risky for a first independent travel experience, there's a high risk of crime, and 18 year olds don't always have street smarts to be safe in a very different culture, never mind the sometimes predatory 20something year old backpackers in hostels.

She's being a bit difficult about it.

She wants to south east Asia alone August-December which terrifies me as well.

Insists she doesn't want to teach English, wants to go to South America etc.
She's being stubborn and won't take on any advice!

OP posts:
DirectionToPerfection · 12/03/2024 21:40

Pinkyoo · 12/03/2024 21:35

Just had a bit of a tiff with DD.

She says she has done her research and while she agrees Colombia isn't the safest, she is prepared to take the necessary caution to make it work and "doesn't want to always do the safe thing if it limits her".
She also says she will do the necessary research on the company and if she is happy with it and her grandparents are happy to pay I should "let her get on with it".

Her attitude is bothering me now.

You are being ridiculous!

I bet she can't wait to get away from your negativity.

Naptimeagain · 12/03/2024 21:38

I agree with pps that the role she's looking into isn't an internship, it's paying - a lot - to fill a space on a CV, and unlikely to convince future employers, and there's a risk that she'll be hanging out with other English speaking 'interns' and won't improve her language skills.

If her grandparents are happy to fund a gap year, a residential Spanish course in Spain would be great, and some travelling after that. There is lots of availability, and as a pp suggested, she could do some TEFL too.

Columbia sounds a bit risky for a first independent travel experience, there's a high risk of crime, and 18 year olds don't always have street smarts to be safe in a very different culture, never mind the sometimes predatory 20something year old backpackers in hostels.