Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandparents going over our head to fund gap year

383 replies

Pinkyoo · 12/03/2024 17:17

DD is doing her A-Levels and has decided to take a gap year. We told her she will need to fund this herself.
She's been in touch with an internship group where she can do a 16 week internship in Colombia. She's desperate to do it. It is £5500 for the fees alone (including accommodation), then flights and living costs.
DD has been working part time since the day after her 16th birthday and saves most of what she earns. We've already helped contribute to the cost of her inter-railing in Europe over summer with her friends.

Today my mum told me that she and my dad have decided they will entirely fund the internship, including flights. But need DD to use her savings to cover the living costs (recommended $100-200 per week).

They've said they will also help her with travelling for some of her gap year.

We are in a position where when DD goes to uni, we can cover her living costs and give her money for food. But she will need to work to travel etc.

I hate that my parents have gone over our head to fund this. I'd hoped DD would find full time work in her gap year. Now it's looking more like travel in the summer, travel in autumn, internship January, then maybe more travelling.

AIBU to think this is ridiculous and they are spoiling her?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
SabrinaThwaite · 12/03/2024 23:37

Pinkyoo · 12/03/2024 21:35

Just had a bit of a tiff with DD.

She says she has done her research and while she agrees Colombia isn't the safest, she is prepared to take the necessary caution to make it work and "doesn't want to always do the safe thing if it limits her".
She also says she will do the necessary research on the company and if she is happy with it and her grandparents are happy to pay I should "let her get on with it".

Her attitude is bothering me now.

My twenty something DS and a couple of friends went to Colombia for a backpacking trip. They are all sensible adults. They had an amazing time, but I’m not convinced it’s safe. I was glad he got back only missing a debit card and phone.

Whereareallthemillionaires · 12/03/2024 23:37

I spent a year, on my own, travelling and working in Macau, Hong Kong and China after my degree. Macau is just one huge drug barons den, or was in the 80s when I was there.

Then after my postgrad I studied at Oklahoma Uni and travelled down to Mexico through to Columbia and down to Peru. On my own and mainly by bus.

I was 24/25.

Maybe as I’d already travelled and lived abroad I was very aware of safety issues. But if you have the bug to travel, and I still do then it’s an itch that just has to be scratched.

If your dd has an arranged internship in Columbia and it’s legit I don’t see an issue.

It’s far safer now than it used to be.

Ps. All three of mine travelled before they started Uni including to some very wild places.

Vitriolinsanity · 12/03/2024 23:30

Have they told her (not read that, but happy to stand corrected).

Otherwise, though what an amazing thing for them to do. Frankly, id swallow any ire and take it for the amazing opportunity.

SabrinaThwaite · 12/03/2024 23:29

Pinkyoo · 12/03/2024 21:12

Thanks, clearly I should but out on the money front.

DD really want the opportunity to actually live somewhere else for part of her gap year and travel for the rest. She also wants something that can go on her CV even if it is a lot of shadowing etc.
She's really attracted to South America.

Does anyone have any ideas of what she could do instead as people don't seem to support to the paying for work experience.

Does anyone think paying for work experience is ok?

A bit late to this but …

I wouldn’t be paying (an exorbitant amount) to do an unpaid internship in Colombia.

If your DD is keen to go to South America to improve her language skills and travel then I’d be looking at the companies that place you in local language schools for a few weeks and incorporate travel and volunteering opportunities as well.

I’d certainly be wary of an 18 yo going to Colombia unless you were very, very confident of the company organising it.

MumblesParty · 12/03/2024 23:12

Pinkyoo · 12/03/2024 22:12

Does anywhere here actually think letting an 18 year old go to Colombia is a good idea?
Regardless of the actual value of what she wants to do. Can anyone say they would let their 18 year old go to Colombia for 4 months?

@Pinkyoo no, I think it sounds dangerous and completely insane. There are plenty of safer countries where she can speak Spanish, if that’s what she wants.

SneakySnakeEx · 12/03/2024 23:07

I'd be thrilled if i haf parents who'd do this for my dc. What a great opportunity. They can spend their money as they wish. Can't take it with them!

Oblahdeeoblahdoe · 12/03/2024 23:03

Pinkyoo · 12/03/2024 22:12

Does anywhere here actually think letting an 18 year old go to Colombia is a good idea?
Regardless of the actual value of what she wants to do. Can anyone say they would let their 18 year old go to Colombia for 4 months?

I've been to Bogotá a couple of times and it's no more dangerous than most cities in the world. I met women who were travelling all around Colombia by themselves and said they felt perfectly safe. Obviously one should take the same precautions as you would anywhere. I'm sorry I have no idea how internships would work there though.

Garlicking · 12/03/2024 22:58

YANBU with your reservations ... but ... One of the (many, possibly never-ending) roles of a parent is to let the fledglings zoom off out of the nest, being ready to catch them if they fall.

DD's proposed year out sounds wonderful! It's quite heartening that she's not going to annoy some bush tribe somewhere with half-hearted attempts at hut building. There's a small possibility that she'll learn something useful about office work, being in a team and customer relations. Her Spanish will improve beyond measure. Colombia's an incredibly beautiful country.

Travel always smooths down a few rough edges, broadens horizons and brings unexpected adventures. If any of those adventures go badly wrong, as they can anywhere, please let her know you will take care of her - and also that running out of drinks money/shampoo/etc is not a parental rescue situation 😉

I can see why you're annoyed with your parents, but this is probably not the time to get in a tug-o'-war with them over parental authority.

Thethuthinang · 12/03/2024 22:54

When my son took a gap year and then applied to various US unis, he was told they did not want students to be working jobs during their gap year. It was supposed to be volunteer work, though it could be funded by scholarship or stipend. Perhaps UK unis are different. But I do highly recommend a gap year. DS returned with renewed energy and focus, and had matured. He also had dengue fever, which I do not recommend.

Ger1atricMillennial · 12/03/2024 22:53

I feel your dilemma OP. There is definitely a compromise to be made somewhere. She wants to do Spanish... maybe the compromise that she goes and works in Spain for 180 days. Its closer if something goes wrong, and she can learn all the really tough stuff about moving countries first i.e. bureaucracy/culture differences, being part of the traveler culture.

Then she will have a bit of better understanding of what it takes to move countries and she can fund herself to go to S.America sounds like a great idea, especially if she wants to do languages.

TravellinT · 12/03/2024 22:49

Hi OP,
My friend sent me this, I think she mentioned above that I did something similar a few years ago now.
The company I arranged my intern abroad through doesn't exist anymore, however if you PM me I'll send some others that I know are reputable.

I did my internship in Cartagena, Colombia. My role was Events and Marketing. I worked with an NGO who focused on encouraging children and young adults to adopt healthy habits including affordable cooking and sports. A lot of it was "watching" what the others were doing. Occasionally getting given the odd job. We hosted events at a tennis court frequently and I loved that as it was a real opportunity to meet locals. That was only 3 days a week and I viewed it as though that was voluntary and I wasn't paying for it.

What I felt I was paying for were

  • Accomodation
  • In country guide who helped with transport and healthcare etc.
  • Spanish classes for 6-8 hours a week
  • Organised Excursions 2 times a week
  • Colombian Cooking classes once a week
  • Salsa lessons followed by a in accommodation party once a week
  • Breakfast

In the end this all seemed worth the cost.

As for Cartagena itself. I just was extra vigilant, we never really went out alone, definitely not drinking alone or without a big group. Didn't carry anything expensive, I took a cheap flip phone, and a cheap smart phone. I left the iPhone at home as it wasn't worth the risk. Never carried a lot of cash (never more than I could afford to lose). We had one dodgy encounter where a guy mugged some of us, but it was as simple as not fighting and giving what we had. All I had was the flip phone and money, he left the phone on the pavement as clearly he didn't see it worth his time, took the money. It wasn't a lot of money and while I was shaken up, we were ok.
I've had my phone stolen out of my hand in a not horrendously awful part of SE London though so I don't think that was special to Colombia.
If you have any questions DM me but I wouldn't say no if I were you, it was one of the best experiences of my life. I have friends all over the world now who I get to go visit and I'm so glad I got the opportunity.

BabaBarrio · 12/03/2024 22:47

I think bankrolling a grand European inter-rail months long vacation is more frivolous and likely to “spoil” a teenager than is funding a 16 week professional internship during a gap year. You can’t put backpacking across Europe, drinking, partying, and being a tourist on a resume for a career building job like you can with an internship.

Band3benefits · 12/03/2024 22:46

This sounds like a scam tbh

DirectionToPerfection · 12/03/2024 22:41

scoobysnaxx · 12/03/2024 22:37

I think the problem is that they went over your head.
I think it would've been appropriate to discuss this with your first, before their grandchild.

However, I do think it's nice of them to offer this.

Carving a life out for yourself is so hard. And the demands and responsibilities only increase in life.

She's young and obviously a hard worker and responsible saving etc.

I'd want to support her to travel etc while she's young if I could afford it.

In my 20s I lived between my parents and my boyfriends for years. They only asked for a token amount out of principle (a pittance). They knew I was working hard, working full time, saving, completed my degree and 2 post grad courses. Other peoples parents were charging them rent and bills from 18.

House prices are insane and so is the cost of living. I am so so thankful to my parents that they relieved me of the pressure of paying them rent and bills during this time. They knew that saving my own money was too necessary.

I think overall it's marvellous your parents want to fund her gap year so she can travel etc. they just should've discussed it with you first.

I would guess they've gone over OP's head because they know what she's like and how she'll react.

Again, her DD is an adult, so her grandparents don't need permission to make this offer to her.

scoobysnaxx · 12/03/2024 22:37

I think the problem is that they went over your head.
I think it would've been appropriate to discuss this with your first, before their grandchild.

However, I do think it's nice of them to offer this.

Carving a life out for yourself is so hard. And the demands and responsibilities only increase in life.

She's young and obviously a hard worker and responsible saving etc.

I'd want to support her to travel etc while she's young if I could afford it.

In my 20s I lived between my parents and my boyfriends for years. They only asked for a token amount out of principle (a pittance). They knew I was working hard, working full time, saving, completed my degree and 2 post grad courses. Other peoples parents were charging them rent and bills from 18.

House prices are insane and so is the cost of living. I am so so thankful to my parents that they relieved me of the pressure of paying them rent and bills during this time. They knew that saving my own money was too necessary.

I think overall it's marvellous your parents want to fund her gap year so she can travel etc. they just should've discussed it with you first.

Teajenny7 · 12/03/2024 22:36

Pinkyoo · 12/03/2024 17:22

Apparently it's in Marketing & PR.
Haven't looked into it as I didn't support the idea.

Really? You haven't looked into an internship in Columbia? Do you know much about Colombia?

I think travel and an internship is a great idea and would loved to have had financial help to do it.

BabaBarrio · 12/03/2024 22:36

Pinkyoo · 12/03/2024 17:17

DD is doing her A-Levels and has decided to take a gap year. We told her she will need to fund this herself.
She's been in touch with an internship group where she can do a 16 week internship in Colombia. She's desperate to do it. It is £5500 for the fees alone (including accommodation), then flights and living costs.
DD has been working part time since the day after her 16th birthday and saves most of what she earns. We've already helped contribute to the cost of her inter-railing in Europe over summer with her friends.

Today my mum told me that she and my dad have decided they will entirely fund the internship, including flights. But need DD to use her savings to cover the living costs (recommended $100-200 per week).

They've said they will also help her with travelling for some of her gap year.

We are in a position where when DD goes to uni, we can cover her living costs and give her money for food. But she will need to work to travel etc.

I hate that my parents have gone over our head to fund this. I'd hoped DD would find full time work in her gap year. Now it's looking more like travel in the summer, travel in autumn, internship January, then maybe more travelling.

AIBU to think this is ridiculous and they are spoiling her?

Internships are full time work, but often either unpaid or you pay tuition fees for the privilege of a leg up on other, less privileged, aspiring students towards your career of choice. The grandparents are contributing in a way that will help her get a good start on her career as much as her degree will. 16 weeks is more than January? January to April?

SuperstarDeejay · 12/03/2024 22:35

South East Asia is generally fine for young travellers and is teeming with them, I'm not sure what your concerns are there.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 12/03/2024 22:34

Pinkyoo · 12/03/2024 22:16

@PollyPut It's not even the distance that bothers me, she can be as many hundreds of miles away she likes as long as it's somewhere safe!
She seems the be on a "if I never take risk life will be boring" tangent whenever we talk.

I categorically would prefer at 18 she avoided South America and South East Asia entirely.

I spent a year in South East Asia as an 18yo. It was one of the best things I've ever done, and I am immensely grateful to my parents for supporting my plans and not trying to limit me. It's only with hindsight that I've truly understood how incredibly hard this must have been for my ultra anxious mum. This makes me appreciate them all the more.

I think it's fair enough to have concerns about Colombia, but ridiculous to write off huge regions like the whole of South America and South East Asia.

fredandme · 12/03/2024 22:30

I travelled round Colombia independently not long ago and loved it. The people were great, amazing scenery, history and culture. Never an issue with safety. Sure, you must be aware of risks like many places and there are areas off limits but some people have an outdated fearful idea about Colombia due to its history. No, I wouldn't hang around certain parts of Bogota or Medellin at night but other towns were fine. I'd be more concerned about a country like Mexico currently.
In any case, if she has decent Spanish (which will improve considerably whilst living there) and has help with accommodation and work then she will soon find her feet. Is she generally sensible, smart, adaptable, has common sense?
The main thing that strikes me is the cost and it sounds like a rip off for an internship.

PollyPut · 12/03/2024 22:28

Pinkyoo · 12/03/2024 22:16

@PollyPut It's not even the distance that bothers me, she can be as many hundreds of miles away she likes as long as it's somewhere safe!
She seems the be on a "if I never take risk life will be boring" tangent whenever we talk.

I categorically would prefer at 18 she avoided South America and South East Asia entirely.

Much of South America would be much safer. If she's insisting then she should be doing some research to work out which areas are safer before planning a trip. That's what adults do.

Has she, and your parents, read the relevant FCO page?
https://www.gov.uk/foreign-travel-advice/colombia

Colombia travel advice

FCDO travel advice for Colombia. Includes safety and security, insurance, entry requirements and legal differences.

https://www.gov.uk/foreign-travel-advice/colombia

Dearover · 12/03/2024 22:28

Presumably she won't be quite as independent in 18 months time when she needs you to fund her through university when she's only entitled to receive the minimum maintenance loan.

Even if she is inexperienced (as most 18 year olds are) she does not need to pay £5k for an "internship". She's chucking that money away.

Containerhome · 12/03/2024 22:24

She's being stubborn because you keep dismissing everything without finding anything out about it.

TDIAP · 12/03/2024 22:23

Pinkyoo · 12/03/2024 22:12

Does anywhere here actually think letting an 18 year old go to Colombia is a good idea?
Regardless of the actual value of what she wants to do. Can anyone say they would let their 18 year old go to Colombia for 4 months?

I have to admit despite the fact I think you are unreasonable to want to block her going, I wouldn’t want an 18 year old to go there alone. Are there other countries she would be interested in?

Sakura7 · 12/03/2024 22:23

Pinkyoo · 12/03/2024 22:12

Does anywhere here actually think letting an 18 year old go to Colombia is a good idea?
Regardless of the actual value of what she wants to do. Can anyone say they would let their 18 year old go to Colombia for 4 months?

What do you mean 'let' her?

She's an adult and you're not funding this.