Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandparents going over our head to fund gap year

383 replies

Pinkyoo · 12/03/2024 17:17

DD is doing her A-Levels and has decided to take a gap year. We told her she will need to fund this herself.
She's been in touch with an internship group where she can do a 16 week internship in Colombia. She's desperate to do it. It is £5500 for the fees alone (including accommodation), then flights and living costs.
DD has been working part time since the day after her 16th birthday and saves most of what she earns. We've already helped contribute to the cost of her inter-railing in Europe over summer with her friends.

Today my mum told me that she and my dad have decided they will entirely fund the internship, including flights. But need DD to use her savings to cover the living costs (recommended $100-200 per week).

They've said they will also help her with travelling for some of her gap year.

We are in a position where when DD goes to uni, we can cover her living costs and give her money for food. But she will need to work to travel etc.

I hate that my parents have gone over our head to fund this. I'd hoped DD would find full time work in her gap year. Now it's looking more like travel in the summer, travel in autumn, internship January, then maybe more travelling.

AIBU to think this is ridiculous and they are spoiling her?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
BIossomtoes · 13/03/2024 08:23

Team grandparents. She sounds like a young woman with her head screwed on and her grandparents are encouraging her spirit of adventure and wish to be independent.

DigitalDust · 13/03/2024 08:16

Rollinroller · 13/03/2024 08:04

It’s not clear what that lesson is.

Agree, and also “parenting choices being overruled” isn’t really a thing once they’re an adult!

Rollinroller · 13/03/2024 08:04

Mummame222 · 12/03/2024 17:37

OP is clearly trying to instil some fundamental life lessons into her DD. This is a parenting choice she’s made that’s been totally overuled by grandparents. That’s not ok.

It’s not clear what that lesson is.

CommentNow · 13/03/2024 08:01

Shes 18. You dont get a say.

She is self motivated and already works and saves hard.

She has her whole life to be tied down to a relationship and a job. This is her only truly free time.

Are you jealous? Cross that she is deferring uni when you've been saving for it? Why are you happy to fund the experience you want her to have but not just pleased for her being rewarded by other people that love her for her hard work? This is a you problem.

I would be more worried about her being away from me so I think you're off base to have a problem just because someone else is paying.

FeistyFrankie · 13/03/2024 07:53

I was your daughter. Desperate to travel and do some volunteering in a gap year. I’d been working and studying really hard and I knew I needed a break before going to uni. My parents completely refused to support me and essentially bullied me into going straight to uni. I dropped out after six months.

let your daughter pursue what she wants. She’s an adult and you will only damage your relationship with her if you try to stop her.

I did go back to uni and get my degree btw. But I really wish my parents had supported me. They didn’t listen and it sounds like you’re not listening either.

rainbegone · 13/03/2024 07:48

Ihearditfrommyradio · 13/03/2024 06:42

Working whilst at Uni isn't just about earning money.

Employers look very favourably on graduates who have shown the initiative to get real work experience whilst at Uni, basically they will always go with a graduate who has worked rather than one that hasn't, even if the degree isn't as good.

It's brilliant what your sister is doing buy it could also backfire.

Your daughter should volunteer somewhere at the very least.

Thanks for the advice. I should also mention that DD is doing a sandwich course and is going to start her placement in June, so that should stand her in good stead. She also works in the summer holidays.

AlwaysFreezing · 13/03/2024 07:32

I don't think it's a case of let her. She's an adult and can choose what she does, whether you approve of it or not. In an ideal world, you'd be able to dicuss it together and she'd listen to your advice, sure.

But she has listened, she disagrees and she has made a decision.

In a way, this is great training for the other adult decisions she might make that you don't approve of. If you keep disapproving, she's going to stop telling you stuff and you'll have even less input.

With kindness, this is the next step in her life and how you respond will determine the sort of adult to adult relationship you have with her. Think carefully about how you see that, and try and act in a way that won't damage it.

I know this isn't what you want to hear, but I think it's great that people are giving you all sides of this and giving you the opportunity to really manage this.

CurlewKate · 13/03/2024 07:28

@Ihearditfrommyradio "Employers look very favourably on graduates who have shown the initiative to get real work experience whilst at Uni, basically they will always go with a graduate who has worked rather than one that hasn't, even if the degree isn't as good."

Could you give some evidence for this, please?

EmmynAnny · 13/03/2024 07:06

Just to offer a different perspective.

My niece is 19, in her first year of uni. Her mum (my sister) passed away the summer before she went into year 7. Both she and her husband were doctors. A year before she passed when she was diagnosed with a terminal illness they packed up and moved to a small town in the north. Clearing their mortgage.
This meant all her life insurance was left for "fun".
She made direct notes about what it should be spent on. Part of that was a gap year or a fun year for her only DD. She had gone straight to med school and said her biggest regret wasn't seeing the world. She wrote in a letter that no one will ever live a perfect life and manufacturing hardship is an odd form of cruelty.

My niece did 4 months in South East Asia and Australia, 4 months teaching English in Central America, 2 months travelling South America and 1 month travelling Central America. She did all her travelling on tours (was originally just going to be the SE Asia part as a tour but she loved it so much she did them all as tours). It was expensive but my niece flourished. She is one of the most interesting, worldly and mature people I know. She's fascinating to talk to.
This was all funded every penny. Must have been 20k if not more in the end.

She worked 16-18 off her own back and lots of the savings she made still exists, she says she is saving for travelling in the summer and for her year abroad at uni. She is working at uni too despite not needing too as her the inheritance covers fees, accommodation and living expenses.

My brother in law was warned over and over that he shouldn't allow all this as she'd be spoilt and isolated from her peers. The opposite is true, she has a lovely core friendship group and is so friendly that she is well loved by even those who aren't her friends. No one cares that she went travelling for free or that she works for fun as she isn't arrogant or snobby about it. She gives herself a budget to stick to anyway.

DH and I have smaller children but we are now making it a priority to save for them to have the same wonderful experiences.

Please let her do this, if she has been raised well which it sounds she has been it will be one of the most enriching experiences of her life. Your child will face struggles as life goes on. We don't need to make our kids struggle as parents. It's a weird Mumsnet mindset that supporting and providing for your children will ruin them. I'm not sure where it comes from but it's not the case!

AnnaKing81 · 13/03/2024 06:47

This is an amazing opportunity!
Please allow her to grasp it with both hands, without being made to feel guilty.

My DD is the same age and her gap year soon will be funded by the money my Dad who has a lot more money than I, will give her.

I'm just honestly grateful to have that back up.

Your parents will be thrilled to giver this opportunity. They wont be around forever, allow them to do this. I imagine they will be really happy if she is...

Ihearditfrommyradio · 13/03/2024 06:42

rainbegone · 12/03/2024 22:11

YABU. I had a similar dilemma when my sister wanted to give DD a monthly allowance when she went off to Uni. I felt that DD should work to pay her way, but soon realised that if my sister wanted to do that and it made her happy then I wouldn't object. It has meant that DD can concentrate fully on her studies and not worry financially, she has worked hard and had great results in her 2 years at uni. DD is so grateful to my sister. They keep in touch regularly and have developed such a lovely bond.

Your daughter sounds hardworking and far from spoilt. Your parents should have asked you first, but maybe knew that you'd say no, so when straight to your daughter. I'd let them help your daughter.

You sound mean

Working whilst at Uni isn't just about earning money.

Employers look very favourably on graduates who have shown the initiative to get real work experience whilst at Uni, basically they will always go with a graduate who has worked rather than one that hasn't, even if the degree isn't as good.

It's brilliant what your sister is doing buy it could also backfire.

Your daughter should volunteer somewhere at the very least.

cafesandbookshops · 13/03/2024 06:31

OP, I lived in Colombia for two and a half years so I can give you advice on areas particularly on the northern coast. Colombia has made progress in development and safety in the last few years. I’m not saying it’s completely safe but the only issues you are likely to encounter there are pick pocketing and being overcharged.

When I needed help with a passport issue, the British embassy there were amazing and I also needed emergency dental treatment, I was well looked after. There are many amazing experiences to be had in Colombia if you are careful and do your research. Many people on this thread are making generalisations and can’t even spell the country correctly. It’s Colombia, not Columbia.

I can’t really advise about the internship unfortunately as I’m a teacher however if your daughter has the travel bug and is prepared to do the research and work involved, I would get involved and make it as safe as possible. Trying to stop her will just cause resentment.

nehagupta5 · 13/03/2024 06:11

Hi there. My son is also finishing A levels this year and I understand your desire for your daughter to be responsible, but she seems pretty responsible already so you have already accomplished that! Having this abundance come to her with a lot of love is wonderful will help her to be a more well rounded human who can work hard and also relax and enjoy the gifts of the Universe! Let her embrace her good fortune and you too can be grateful for such loving parents! Not everyone gets this 💖

SquishyGloopyBum · 13/03/2024 05:58

It sounds like you just don't want her to go. You thought everyone on here would agree with your op and now they haven't, you have latched on to the safety aspect to justify your concern.

You say south east Asia terrifies you too, why?

You seem to just want to hold your daughter back and clip her wings. Thank goodness for the grandparents to be honest.

Loulou599 · 13/03/2024 01:29

It sounds like a cliché. A year in South America where you actually have to pay 4 figures to be an intern?
Come on...

Flossflower · 13/03/2024 00:10

I think that there are 2 issues here. Firstly, your parents going above your head and secondly, you think your daughter ought to be more responsible for her finances and get a job to start saving.
I don’t hold with the MN idea that children need to help pay their way through university to teach them financial competence. Most children will learn this before they are 18. We were lucky enough to be able to completely finance our children through uni and they can clearly manage their finances now. Both my children have saved up and gone travelling through Africa, South America and Asia. Yes we were very worried at the time. However, they probably won’t get another chance to do,this.
I think if I was helping grandchildren, I would run it past their parents first.

TravellinT · 13/03/2024 00:02

I think people here are being a bit over the top about Colombia and its safety.
I've lived all over the world (including Colombia at 18) and the least safe places have never been those that the statistics would tell you they are.
Obviously it's about being smart, vigilant and cautious. No expensive phones or lots of cash, staying in groups, avoiding being out at night etc.
The most terrifying experience I've ever had was in the states. I felt threatened and intimidated by a police officer and it's the only time while travelling I've felt scared.
I've lived in Cartagena and Montevideo in South America and had positive experiences.
No where is truly safe and I think in "dangerous" places you naturally have exercise more caution, inadvertently making it safer.
If it's with an established provider they will give lots of tips and you should be with other people most of the time, so some safety in numbers.

CBAMumma · 12/03/2024 23:52

I think she's being incredibly naiive about Colombia. Could you encourage her to go somewhere less ambitious for now, and say you'll suport her decision if she wants to do the Colombia trip after uni? She'll at least be a bit wiser by then, and also quite likely to have gone off the idea.

There was a post on here last week from a mother whose daughter was set up by the police in a South American country and she was an experienced traveller. It's all very well being fearless and pushing your boundaries, but build up some street-smarts first!

Josette77 · 12/03/2024 23:51

You're not the OP who posted about her DD wanting to take a gap year and study languages at uni, and being upset because she doesn't know what she wants to do with her life?

Either way you need to back off.
You are being far more stubborn than your DD right now.

User373433 · 12/03/2024 23:50

I personally think funding living costs and all food through uni is more 'spoiling' than what the grandparents are doing tbh. I don't think I'd worry about her being spoiled though, she sounds like she has an adventurous spirit that will require dedication to her studies/job promotions to keep funding so I don't think it will make her work shy or whatever your concerns are. I wish my teenager had even a modicum of interest in similar.

Crazycatlady79 · 12/03/2024 23:46

I think your daughter sounds brilliant and it's lovely that her grandparents have offered to financially contribute to her travels.

Whereareallthemillionaires · 12/03/2024 23:43

Elephantsareace · 12/03/2024 23:40

I started full time work at 16 and will have to work until 67 at the earliest. 51 fucking years solid. One of the few regrets I have is not doing some travelling when I was younger. If you can't do it at 18, when can you? Support her with this, she has a long working life ahead of her and at 18 you can't stop her anyway.

You can still do it now.
My dh and I are in our late 50s and we still explore.

Staying in packpackers hostels is not just for the young.

tenpoundpombear · 12/03/2024 23:40

Pinkyoo · 12/03/2024 22:12

Does anywhere here actually think letting an 18 year old go to Colombia is a good idea?
Regardless of the actual value of what she wants to do. Can anyone say they would let their 18 year old go to Colombia for 4 months?

That's not what the OP was about, though. She's an adult, as are her GPs and what they decide is between them.

Replying to this post on its own no, I'm not sure I'd want my daughter working in Columbia so I'd be researching the safety with her, and discussing it together. And if she decided she wanted to go then I'd support her because she's old enough to make her own informed choices.

Elephantsareace · 12/03/2024 23:40

I started full time work at 16 and will have to work until 67 at the earliest. 51 fucking years solid. One of the few regrets I have is not doing some travelling when I was younger. If you can't do it at 18, when can you? Support her with this, she has a long working life ahead of her and at 18 you can't stop her anyway.

Blueink · 12/03/2024 23:39

Yes YABU it’s great her DGP are supporting her