Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandparents going over our head to fund gap year

383 replies

Pinkyoo · 12/03/2024 17:17

DD is doing her A-Levels and has decided to take a gap year. We told her she will need to fund this herself.
She's been in touch with an internship group where she can do a 16 week internship in Colombia. She's desperate to do it. It is £5500 for the fees alone (including accommodation), then flights and living costs.
DD has been working part time since the day after her 16th birthday and saves most of what she earns. We've already helped contribute to the cost of her inter-railing in Europe over summer with her friends.

Today my mum told me that she and my dad have decided they will entirely fund the internship, including flights. But need DD to use her savings to cover the living costs (recommended $100-200 per week).

They've said they will also help her with travelling for some of her gap year.

We are in a position where when DD goes to uni, we can cover her living costs and give her money for food. But she will need to work to travel etc.

I hate that my parents have gone over our head to fund this. I'd hoped DD would find full time work in her gap year. Now it's looking more like travel in the summer, travel in autumn, internship January, then maybe more travelling.

AIBU to think this is ridiculous and they are spoiling her?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Mamabear487 · 13/03/2024 16:43

You sound like your stopping her from living her life. Let her go travelling and have a gap year don’t dictate what she does she’ll resent you. Also you sound like you need a bloody holiday

TheBerry · 13/03/2024 16:27

What kind of weird, puritanical outlook do you have to insist that she pays for it herself when her grandparents are happy to help?

She’s not spoiled. She’s not getting a pony. She’s embarking on a great life experience, working hard, expanding her horizons, and starting university soon.

No1toldmeaboutit · 13/03/2024 16:25

Wow. An amazing opportunity for your DD and you aren’t happy about it? Let her get all the life experience she can while she is young, she has the rest of her life to work

mrsbitaly · 13/03/2024 16:10

CurlyhairedAssassin · 12/03/2024 17:27

God, these poor youngsters have got a lifetime ahead of them of slogging away for the most basic of lifestyles till they're 70, probably, for a measly pension and god knows what rubbishy housing. What's wrong with having a year of doing something different before knuckling down for the rest of their life?

This is a perfect response. I never had this opportunity it's too late for me now. I want my children to enjoy life whilst they are young but get a good education and then a job

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 13/03/2024 16:02

If she were an ungrateful child who couldn't be arsed to earn any money to help fund this opportunity, you would have a point. But she's been working and saving money since she was 16, has looked into this internship herself, plus it will be relevant to her university studies. I'm absolutely baffled that you could be anything other than delighted at your parents funding it Confused. I honestly don't remotely understand why it would be anything but a brilliant thing to fund (unless it's not a legit organisation).

MrsPCR · 13/03/2024 15:57

YABU and perhaps a little jealous.

You said yourself, she's worked hard to save since her birthday, so she's demonstrated her commitment and desire to do this. Grandparents have just been amazingly kind and general to help facilitate this more easily for her, as they can clearly see the value too.

This is an absolutely amazing opportunity! Thank the grandparents, say they really shouldn't have and let your daughter have an amazing year and truly benefit from the experience, rather than worrying about money or working and missing out on other opportunities.

KreedKafer · 13/03/2024 15:56

Pinkyoo · 12/03/2024 22:16

@PollyPut It's not even the distance that bothers me, she can be as many hundreds of miles away she likes as long as it's somewhere safe!
She seems the be on a "if I never take risk life will be boring" tangent whenever we talk.

I categorically would prefer at 18 she avoided South America and South East Asia entirely.

Stop treating your adult daughter like a child. She can go wherever she likes.

Also, you're being ridiculous if you think the entire continent of South America and the whole of SE Asia is 'unsafe'. For a start, they are absolutely full of 18-year-olds travelling and secondly, they're not homogenous. Saying that South America is unsafe on the basis of what you've heard about Colombia is a bit like saying Europe is unsafe because you've heard bad things about Belarus or Kosovo.

You sound like a really controlling, patronising parent and if I were your daughter I'd be doing literally everything possible to break away and do my own thing. You're really infantilising her and projecting your own anxieties and hangups on to her.

Victoriancat · 13/03/2024 15:54

Annoyed, or jealous? Stop being a misery.

waterrat · 13/03/2024 15:54

Hi Op - I have worked in this field and really it won't be considered impressive that she pays to go and do a fake internship anywhere. the whole 'painting the walls of schools ' thing is totally discredited. You can google and read about how fake it all is.

Why would any business or charity in S America or asia need a totally skillless UK student to do work or volunteering for them? their countries are full of local people who could do it. It's just a money making rip off.

KreedKafer · 13/03/2024 15:50

I'd hoped DD would find full time work in her gap year

You can hope all you want, but your daughter is an adult and what she chooses to do in her gap year is none of her business. Why shouldn't she travel, if her grandparents are happy to help out?

The internship in Colombia sounds like a brilliant opportunity and quite frankly you should be bloody delighted that your daughter is going to be able to broaden her horizons and see the world rather than spending a year in a job that, given that it's only a gap year, will very likely be low-paid and dull. She's already been working part-time since she was 16 so, if other options and funds are available to her, why on earth should she spend her gap year doing more of the same?

Johnnybegood2 · 13/03/2024 15:42

She's young and may only have this opportunity once. Why not allow her to relax and enjoy herself before the realities of life hit her! She's got 40 years of working to come.

HollaHolla · 13/03/2024 13:24

As others have said, it’s nothing to do with you ‘letting’ an 18 year old do anything. If you listened, and really discussed both points of view, you might end up with a more respectful relationship.

From my experience, I went to Uni young (just turned 17, in Scotland), and so didn’t do a gap year. I did, however, travel/live overseas for 4 years post-Uni. If my folks had said I couldn’t go, you know what? I’d have gone anyway, and would have destroyed our relationship.
wish I had grandparents who would be supportive financially (I had no living grandparents by then), and your daughter is incredibly fortunate that her grandparents are supportive - emotionally, and financially.

I always remember what my mum said to me as I left alone for SE Asia (first stop!), aged 21. If anything happens, and you want to get on a flight home, call us, and we will find the money. Also, if anything happened, and you need us, you’re never more than a day away from us. My parents weren’t /aren’t wealthy, but I knew I had their support - even if I know they worried sick about me!

DirectionToPerfection · 13/03/2024 12:31

tittybumbum · 13/03/2024 11:44

Of course they do but there is also a lot to be gained by teaching young people that they have to work and sacrifice to get the opportunities

A contribution would have been great but paying for the entire gap year is infantilising and not teaching anything.

Gap years are amazing opportunities to grow and learn and mature. Develop hard work and dedication and self motivation and then the subsequent reward. Or they can be a massive jolly when paid for by someone else. Wasted opportunity

She has been working since her 16th birthday and saving her money.

She sounds like she has her head screwed on to me, so your post seems very unfair.

BreakingAndBroke · 13/03/2024 11:57

She has 50 years to get bogged down in work - let her travel while she is young enough to enjoy it!

Meow8989 · 13/03/2024 11:57

I did one when I was 23 - I lived and worked in New York in financial services- I had graduated into the crisis and so grad jobs or internships were scarce

I paid £6k and paid for flights - charity sourced our internships which we interviewed for and we got free accommodation and a monthly stipend of $1k + travel card. (Count up the above and tell me one year to live in nyc and $1k pure disposable income isn’t amazing - this was 2013/14).

i did it for one year a returned to the UK - interviewed and started a job paying £40k within 2 months.

invaluable experience but yes do your research.

BIossomtoes · 13/03/2024 11:56

MrsSkylerWhite · 13/03/2024 11:52

Am I the only person who would have a problem with a young woman travelling to Colombia?

Not in these circumstances. It’s a pretty middle class, Radio 4 kind of way to do it.

fredandme · 13/03/2024 11:54

Many people on this thread are making generalisations and can’t even spell the country correctly. It’s Colombia, not Columbia.

Yes!

MrsSkylerWhite · 13/03/2024 11:52

Am I the only person who would have a problem with a young woman travelling to Colombia?

tittybumbum · 13/03/2024 11:46

mitogoshi · 12/03/2024 17:26

Internships are meant to pay them not cost money. At the worst it's unpaid so she's going to need money for living costs and flights but I've never heard of paying for an internship, sounds like a scam

They aren't scams. They are a well trodden path. Businesses that are set up to connect volunteers with charities. The money goes to the business and the charity gets the labour.
Sure it's a middle class thing but they can be really great and good businesses only use credible charities where the volunteer gets proper valuable experience in an organised and safe way.

tittybumbum · 13/03/2024 11:44

Amba1998 · 12/03/2024 17:22

Are you joking? What a fantastic opportunity for her. It’s not that they’re funding her to sit at home and play on her phone for a year. It will be a wonderful enriching experience and then she has to come home go to uni and get on with real life in which case she will then have to learn how to adult and budget and work for the rest of her life

I’d be excited for her.

don’t you want her to have amazing experiences?

Of course they do but there is also a lot to be gained by teaching young people that they have to work and sacrifice to get the opportunities

A contribution would have been great but paying for the entire gap year is infantilising and not teaching anything.

Gap years are amazing opportunities to grow and learn and mature. Develop hard work and dedication and self motivation and then the subsequent reward. Or they can be a massive jolly when paid for by someone else. Wasted opportunity

Growlybear83 · 13/03/2024 10:24

I've read your more recent posts, OP, and while my daughter didn't go to South America, she did travel round India and south east Asia on her own for six months and then ended up in Cairo, where she enrolled on an Arabic course and found herself a flat, again helped by the money my
Mum had given her. I was a bit apprehensive when we waved her off at Heathrow, but she had planned her first couple of months meticulously and had researched everywhere she went very carefully. She has always said thst she never felt in any danger and she had no serious incidents - i think the worst thing that happened was getting her solar powered phone charger snd my sandals stolen. The year she was away completely changed her life, very much for the better, and she came home a much more mature, caring, and thoughtful person. She stopped drinking, taking dodgy substances, and became healthy.

Growlybear83 · 13/03/2024 10:13

I'm a bit shocked by your attitude to be honest, OP. I can still remember my daughter's face when my daughter had finished her first degree and my Mum told her that she had saved several thousand pounds in a savings account for her over the years and she wanted her to use it to enjoy herself. Her initial reaction was shock and then she told my mum that the money would enable her to follow her dreams in terms of her trip. My mum never forgot what a life changing difference she had made to my daughter and we were so happy that my Mum was able to do this for her. We had helped out as much as we could with university costs and would have really struggled to contribute much to my daughter's trip overseas, so I can't imagine not being over the moon thst my Mum had stepped in to help her. My mother in law had also saved some money for her, albeit a much smaller amount, and gave my daughter access to the account at around the same time. Both mothers had asked me over the years how I wanted the money to be used but I always made it clear that it was not my place to decide.

LogicVoid · 13/03/2024 10:10

You are heading for a major estrangement, where you will have no influence or guidance to offer (demand).

Drop the rope. You are feeding the conflict. Back off. Apologise and tell her you will trust her to do her research thoroughly and make good choices for herself.

Mummame222 · 13/03/2024 10:02

DigitalDust · 13/03/2024 08:16

Agree, and also “parenting choices being overruled” isn’t really a thing once they’re an adult!

Oh sorry, maybe I misread. I thought DD was 16.

Herdinggoats · 13/03/2024 08:53

I don’t understand why you said she could do it if she funded it herself if you didn’t want her doing it full stop. You say that you don’t agree with the internship but you didn’t actually tell her this at the time. You’ve moved the goalposts on her. Not fair.