Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Center Parcs should be ashamed of this

364 replies

ReallyCenterParcs · 12/03/2024 16:24

I think it may have been deleted now, but not before Center Parcs hid or deleted comments pointing out the stereotyping and misogyny of this Facebook post...
One comment I saw said mum's not keeping up because of all the shopping, cooking, washing and organising she had to before the family got to sodding Center Parcs in the first place. And she's riding a shite bike they've given her

To think Center Parcs should be ashamed of this
OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
GreenAppleCrumble · 13/03/2024 11:23

Well, of course she’s fictional, the whole situation is fictional, yet people will interpret it (and see it as sexist or not) based on their own experiences.

The interpretation isn’t intended to take place in the context of each person’s own experiences as such, though; it’s the popular interpretation that counts in advertising. Even those posters who are earnestly pointing out that they are better cyclists than their husbands must be aware that the popular perception is that men are going to get stuck into these fun, active pursuits more readily whilst boring old mum trails behind.

It’s just tedious when advertising perpetuates this. That’s all.

Caerulea · 13/03/2024 11:20

Things the daughter could have been saying -

'can we get ice-cream after?'
'can we go to the pool after this?'
'best holiday EVER'
'I wish we didn't have to go home'
'could we do (insert things CP offer, I've no idea I'm too poor) tomorrow?'

There's a bunch of stuff she could have been saying that didn't involve rolling her eyes at mum.

Now, if it were my kids I wouldn't even be in tbf picture, I'd be upside down in a bush just out of shot cos I hate cycling. They'd be saying' fgs, dad, mum is in the bushes again!' But it's not about me personally, it's about all of us as mums & middle-aged women being slow & boring & not joining in & not being fun & & & ad infinitum.

It's not about the dad, it's not about the daughters, it's not about any one person's experience it's the sweeping statement of 'That' moment. So well recognised, so 'mum is useless at doing anything fun' & it can fuck right off with it.

(fwiw, not offended, just bored of it all)

Bloom15 · 13/03/2024 11:19

I couldn't care less about this. I can't be offended by this.

If I was in that holiday I wouldn't be in the bike - I'd be the in the cabin having a glass of wine

inamarina · 13/03/2024 10:45

GreenAppleCrumble · 13/03/2024 10:05

But how do you know the woman in the picture is the type who constantly does everything for everyone rather than someone who’s in a similar situation like PP?

The woman in the photo is fictional?! She doesn’t have a backstory beyond what’s there in the image.

What’s important is that she is being called the slow one. That’s all we know. That’s the one thing CP have given us here. Mum is slow.

So, given what we know (despite many pp pretending not to) about the colossal weight of sexism against women over the centuries, and how part of this rests particularly on middle-aged mums being dull, less fun than young-at-heart dad, do you think this was the most intelligent marketing decision?

It’s not “offensive” as such. It’s just a reminder of where mum sits in the pecking order in the wider consciousness.

Well, of course she’s fictional, the whole situation is fictional, yet people will interpret it (and see it as sexist or not) based on their own experiences.
Some posters assume mum is tired after packing, organising, cooking, cleaning and so on, while others think she’s just taking it easy and the child shouting “Keep up, mum!” is excited and not implying mum is always slow.

IntermittentFarting · 13/03/2024 10:43

But mum isn't slow @GreenAppleCrumble

They're all together in a group and she's a couple of inches away from being level with dad. She could easily overtake one of her small daughters if she wanted to.
She's being told to keep up by a small child who thinks she's the fastest and doesn't realise that parents deliberately stay behind. Mum is being addressed because she'd the one the child can see.

As I said before, it looks as if the tagline was made to fit an image, rather than the other way around.

I agree with you about millennia of sexism and inequality, though!

GreenAppleCrumble · 13/03/2024 10:36

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 13/03/2024 10:23

It's not a joke about mum, though. It's not a joke at all.

And this is the crux of the matter

People are taking it as some sort of "joke".

It's not.

It's a strapline. A tagline. An attempt to tug at nostalgia.

Not. A. Joke.

It’s a light-hearted comment. It’s not ‘a joke’ with a punchline or a pun - I think everyone knows that.

It’s jokey in tone.

The problem is that the single characteristic they’ve chosen to highlight is mum is slow

And because this is advertising, we can assume that mum being slow is the thing mums are supposed to identify with here. That’s basically how advertising works. That’s even without the ‘that moment’ element that directly invites everyone to identify with this experience of mum being slow

People are acting all confused about accusations of sexism, as if they haven’t grown up in a world in which middle-aged women are at the bottom of the pecking order. No, it’s not blatant sexism. It may not even be deliberate - it’s just a bunch of men in marketing dumping their ingrained prejudices onto an ad campaign. It’s not malicious. It’s ingrained.

But it is there.

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 13/03/2024 10:23

It's not a joke about mum, though. It's not a joke at all.

And this is the crux of the matter

People are taking it as some sort of "joke".

It's not.

It's a strapline. A tagline. An attempt to tug at nostalgia.

Not. A. Joke.

Marchitectmummy · 13/03/2024 10:16

EnjoyTheFlowers · 13/03/2024 05:01

Agree. Not the worst example but it’s sexist nonetheless. But MN is full of women doormats who simply do not understand or see sexism. I don’t know what it is…brainwashing by the patriarchy? lack of intelligence? trying to look ‘cool’? I honestly don’t know.

The forum is populated by so many women who don’t seem keen to stamp out everyday sexism and it’s depressing. I have one of the few equal relationships I know, and I cannot believe what some women are happy to tolerate and condone from their male partners.

This is a relatively ‘minor’ example but we should have zero tolerance. I don’t go round ‘looking for offence’, which is the new thick term for ‘PC gawn maaad’. I would be delighted not to see it!

So your response to apparant sexism is to attack the intellect of women on mumsnet?

Hhhhhm.

GreenAppleCrumble · 13/03/2024 10:05

But how do you know the woman in the picture is the type who constantly does everything for everyone rather than someone who’s in a similar situation like PP?

The woman in the photo is fictional?! She doesn’t have a backstory beyond what’s there in the image.

What’s important is that she is being called the slow one. That’s all we know. That’s the one thing CP have given us here. Mum is slow.

So, given what we know (despite many pp pretending not to) about the colossal weight of sexism against women over the centuries, and how part of this rests particularly on middle-aged mums being dull, less fun than young-at-heart dad, do you think this was the most intelligent marketing decision?

It’s not “offensive” as such. It’s just a reminder of where mum sits in the pecking order in the wider consciousness.

Tahinii · 13/03/2024 09:59

IntermittentFarting · 13/03/2024 07:52

But MN is full of women doormats who simply do not understand or see sexism. I don’t know what it is…brainwashing by the patriarchy? lack of intelligence? trying to look ‘cool’? I honestly don’t know.

Oh the irony.
"Women doormats... do not understand... lack of intelligence..."
You're 100 times more sexist than Centre Parcs @EnjoyTheFlowers . And you wonder why more women aren't feminist? Perhaps look at how some feminists treat other women if they don't tow the line or do or say exactly what they'd like them to.

Some people disagree with you about what the ad means and/or is portraying. Because women have lots of different opinions. But you're intelligent enough to know and understand that, I think.

Well, quite!

I don’t like the CP ad but this post is incredibly offensive and patronising. Honestly what goes through their heads before they click ‘post’?

GreenAppleCrumble · 13/03/2024 09:42

MustBeNapTime · 13/03/2024 08:10

No, it wouldn’t be the same if it were the dad; that’s not how sexism works.

Please could you explain how sexism works.

I think the post directly below yours does it to some extent. It’s to do with millennia of imbalance between the sexes. I think you know this 🤷‍♀️

IntermittentFarting · 13/03/2024 09:30

WillVioletsDad · 13/03/2024 09:00

As a bloke (and dad) I feel that this advert is actually a bit misogynistic, but would be fine if it was the dad being told to keep up. It's the difference between punching up and punching down.

As the risk of mansplaining, my take is that we live in a society where women are still too often regarded as lesser and weaker (despite doing most of the work). So making the joke about the mum is reinforcing negative stereotypes. Whereas if the joke had been about dad, it would have been refreshingly rejecting / inverting that negative stereotype.

It's not a joke about mum, though. It's not a joke at all. It's just about the enthusiastic ebullience of children thinking they're the fastest and showing off.

The child turning round can only see mum because of their positioning, so that's why she's addressing her. Mum isn't lagging behind; she's pretty much on a par with dad. If she was further forward she'd be in danger of bumping the child ahead. This young woman could very easily keep up with her young daughters.

It looks very much to me like its a caption used to fit an image they'd already decided to use.

Seymour5 · 13/03/2024 09:23

Jovacknockowitch · 13/03/2024 09:04

Centerparcs should be ashamed of almost everything.

Really? We like it. We first went over thirty years ago. Visits have not been regular, but for a multigenerational family group, it’s suited us. We’re going again later this year.

HeeyMacarena · 13/03/2024 09:22

I love it and it makes me proud when my children are enjoying cycling so mucho or so eager to get somewhere that I can barely keep up with them - something much more common now the youngest is 8!
I think I probably had several keep-up-mum moments in center parcs and they are sweet memories.
There weren´t any keep-up-dad moments because a) he didn´t come and b) he is a competitive cyclist (as in takes part in races, not competing against his family) so very few people can leave him behind on a bike, even an over-excited 8 year old on her first trip to the C-P pool.

Seymour5 · 13/03/2024 09:17

JL690 · 13/03/2024 07:44

OK, let's take the sexism out of it and change the words to That "KEEP UP OLDIES" moment.

I’m a proper oldy as is DH! If the DGC shout ‘come on Gran/Gramps’ we’ll take it as encouragement. 😉

Sharptonguedwoman · 13/03/2024 09:15

EarlofShrewsbury · 12/03/2024 16:29

I fail to see what's wrong with it.

At first glance, nothing. As an older women I am now utterly fed up with the casual sexism and misogyny inherent in our society. It just goes on and on. if the slogan was 'Keep up, Dad'. No problem at all. Always mothers, failing somehow.

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 13/03/2024 09:11

And the poster claiming not seeing this as sexist makes you "a doormat" needs to re evaluate their own language

Talking down at women like this is disgusting

Claiming they aren't "part of the sisterhood" because they don't see sexism the same as you is ridiculous

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 13/03/2024 09:08

Again..
Its a WHOLE advert

You take the WHOLE picture into account.

It's not making fun of the woman. She is a young woman with a young family. She isn't lagging miles behind. She isn't fat. She isn't struggling along with a picnic basket and bags whilst her family leave her to it. She is wearing appropriate clothing the same as the others. The children are having a fun time, one is calling back Mum because that is what kids do. She is smiling as she watches them.

Some of you can act like it's not an experience you are familiar with but there are people out there who do recognise this scenario. Who have smiled and watched their kids zoom ahead and listened to them call back.

Jovacknockowitch · 13/03/2024 09:04

Centerparcs should be ashamed of almost everything.

WillVioletsDad · 13/03/2024 09:00

Okthen100 · 12/03/2024 16:53

How would you have felt if the person at the back was a Dad? Would that be OK?

As a bloke (and dad) I feel that this advert is actually a bit misogynistic, but would be fine if it was the dad being told to keep up. It's the difference between punching up and punching down.

As the risk of mansplaining, my take is that we live in a society where women are still too often regarded as lesser and weaker (despite doing most of the work). So making the joke about the mum is reinforcing negative stereotypes. Whereas if the joke had been about dad, it would have been refreshingly rejecting / inverting that negative stereotype.

inamarina · 13/03/2024 08:52

Okthen100 · 13/03/2024 08:25

The woman in the photo is an actress.

So why assume that she “is fed up she's already done everything and packed bags and cooked and cleaned”?
People are projecting their own experiences onto the ad and based on that some find it sexist while others don’t.

Poetnojo · 13/03/2024 08:48

EnjoyTheFlowers · 13/03/2024 05:01

Agree. Not the worst example but it’s sexist nonetheless. But MN is full of women doormats who simply do not understand or see sexism. I don’t know what it is…brainwashing by the patriarchy? lack of intelligence? trying to look ‘cool’? I honestly don’t know.

The forum is populated by so many women who don’t seem keen to stamp out everyday sexism and it’s depressing. I have one of the few equal relationships I know, and I cannot believe what some women are happy to tolerate and condone from their male partners.

This is a relatively ‘minor’ example but we should have zero tolerance. I don’t go round ‘looking for offence’, which is the new thick term for ‘PC gawn maaad’. I would be delighted not to see it!

This is the most misogynistic part of the whole thread, ad included. Well done enjoytheflowers, zero tolerance my arse!
Maybe take a look in the mirror and reflect on how you speak about women online before you start saying you are trying to stamp out everyday sexism, seems to me like your just stamping on women who don't 100% agree with you. Sounds a lot like some shitty men I've seen 🤔

Ramalangadingdong · 13/03/2024 08:41

Bbq1 · 12/03/2024 23:09

Those worried about "building up tge confidence of girls", I think it's safe to say the kid leading the family is in fact a girl.

But she won’t be leading if she marries and has kids. Her brilliance will be sidelined and she will become just mum who can’t even ride a bike anymore - according to Centerparcs.

Op didn’t say she was “offended” a pp used the term because it is a dog whistle and it worked.

I am not “offended” by the poster but it is the 21st century and whoever came up with that campaign needs to keep up.

Okthen100 · 13/03/2024 08:25

inamarina · 13/03/2024 08:10

But how do you know the woman in the picture is the type who constantly does everything for everyone rather than someone who’s in a similar situation like PP?
Fwiw, I know several couples/ families where the man is the main breadwinner and carries a huge chunk of (or the entire) financial responsibility while the woman works part time/ doesn’t work/ is free to leave a job she doesn’t like without having another one lined up.
Most of them don’t have young children, some don’t have any children at all.
Of course that’s just anecdotal, but that’s what I see around me.
In the same way as others might see couples where both work full time and the woman still does most of the housework/ childcare.

The woman in the photo is an actress.

crumblingschools · 13/03/2024 08:22

Surely this appears to be sexist as it has been the norm to show women as the weaker sex, so it would be unusual to see a photo like that with a caption saying ‘keep up dad’ unless dad is portrayed as a fat joke like figure.