Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset at being called milk machine

83 replies

PeachShark · 12/03/2024 10:21

MIL has referred to me as milk machine twice.
On one hand she generally has no filter and this could be just seen as her odd sense of humour.
On the other hand she doesn’t like me taking DS when he is due a feed and will try to comfort him herself - ignore me when I say he’s due a feed or tell me to give him a minute - then when I come to take him says “where’s the milk machine, milk machine he wants milk” feels to me as if she doesn’t want to acknowledge that maybe DS wants his mummy and I am more than just a bloody milk bottle to my child?

Do you reckon it’s loaded? Or am I reading too much into an innocent but not so nice joke…

OP posts:
Babaquestions · 12/03/2024 21:55

UpsideLeft · 12/03/2024 10:26

Older generations say some weird shit

And they it's fine when it's absolutely not to every other generation

My baby dd's grandparents (maternal and paternal) are all in their late 40s and early 50s. Maybe that's the same for OP? Yes they're an older generation than mine, but they don't think breast feeding is weird. Age isn't an excuse to say hurtful things.

StopStartStop · 12/03/2024 21:54

She's extremely rude.

fiftysevenorangepumpkins · 12/03/2024 21:50

PeachShark · 12/03/2024 21:43

Thanks for the responses, interesting to hear different perspectives. Obviously from her point of view she would say it was absolutely meant as a joke but there has been a lot of things said and done that makes me feel like it’s not that innocent. But it’s not unlike her to say outrageous things in general! (Eg, yesterday kept saying to DH “I have no idea how you both made such a beautiful baby” he said it was like she was basically calling us ugly the way she kept saying it!

Just for some context as to why I feel defensive towards her, just a couple of examples of things she’s said (and this is only to do with breastfeeding - there’s been much more but we’d be here all day)
She has said the quality of my breast milk might not be good enough (DS always had steady weight gain so was no reason to be questioning this in the first place)
Also said that I should pump and give DH bottles because what would we do if something happened to me or I ended up in hospital… she never pumped and her DC never used bottles 🤷‍♀️ I think the reason she wants me to pump is just so she can give him a bottle and it takes me out of the equation when we’re over.

@preggo39 she breastfed her DC for 2 years! It’s clear that she hates when I have to take him for feeds. She used to being in control of everything and it’s something she cannot control/ take over.

@moonfacer we see them once a week, sometimes more. We live pretty close so a weekly visit is expected - and I know they’re hoping for more when I return to work.

Edited

Sounds like she doesn't want to lose control to the next generation.

Try to ignore her and do your own thing, BF if you want/don't want, your milk will be absolutely fine, assuming you are yourself healthy and not suffering from malnutrition, which I am sure you are not, and even then, the milk takes the best / most appropriate for the baby as your body did when you were pregnant

fiftysevenorangepumpkins · 12/03/2024 21:47

PeachShark · 12/03/2024 10:21

MIL has referred to me as milk machine twice.
On one hand she generally has no filter and this could be just seen as her odd sense of humour.
On the other hand she doesn’t like me taking DS when he is due a feed and will try to comfort him herself - ignore me when I say he’s due a feed or tell me to give him a minute - then when I come to take him says “where’s the milk machine, milk machine he wants milk” feels to me as if she doesn’t want to acknowledge that maybe DS wants his mummy and I am more than just a bloody milk bottle to my child?

Do you reckon it’s loaded? Or am I reading too much into an innocent but not so nice joke…

It might be an older person's view that they think it's weird you're not bottle feeding. Of the older generations in both mine and DH family, I got the impression that breastfeeding was for "poorer" people (their opinion) and we surely had enough money for formula. I also had the same when I used a sling, as if "people will think you can't afford a pram" even though we had a pram!!

PeachShark · 12/03/2024 21:43

Thanks for the responses, interesting to hear different perspectives. Obviously from her point of view she would say it was absolutely meant as a joke but there has been a lot of things said and done that makes me feel like it’s not that innocent. But it’s not unlike her to say outrageous things in general! (Eg, yesterday kept saying to DH “I have no idea how you both made such a beautiful baby” he said it was like she was basically calling us ugly the way she kept saying it!

Just for some context as to why I feel defensive towards her, just a couple of examples of things she’s said (and this is only to do with breastfeeding - there’s been much more but we’d be here all day)
She has said the quality of my breast milk might not be good enough (DS always had steady weight gain so was no reason to be questioning this in the first place)
Also said that I should pump and give DH bottles because what would we do if something happened to me or I ended up in hospital… she never pumped and her DC never used bottles 🤷‍♀️ I think the reason she wants me to pump is just so she can give him a bottle and it takes me out of the equation when we’re over.

@preggo39 she breastfed her DC for 2 years! It’s clear that she hates when I have to take him for feeds. She used to being in control of everything and it’s something she cannot control/ take over.

@moonfacer we see them once a week, sometimes more. We live pretty close so a weekly visit is expected - and I know they’re hoping for more when I return to work.

OP posts:
Moonshine5 · 12/03/2024 19:56

It is rude but I'm inclined to think she thinks she's being funny, I don't see this as malice personally.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 12/03/2024 18:26

NoCloudsAllowed · 12/03/2024 10:30

Let me guess, she formula fed or used formula after a few weeks?

I'd ham it up and do a dalek impression, saying 'MILK MACHINE MUST FEED HUMAN INFANT' every time she does it, waving little dalek arms for the baby, be so annoying and over the top that she stops :)

😂😂
Please do it, OP!

Xenoi24 · 12/03/2024 18:00

That's really very unpleasant and offensive.

Her behaviour around giving you back your baby/letting you feed and comfort your baby is fucked up too.

Honestly, why are so many mils mental like this. They are an embarrassment to woman kind.

I think I would go for "don't ever call me that again", with a protracted hard look.

If she protests, just keep repeating it.

If she calls you it again, leave immediately.

Some c*nts need trained. Since they cannot act like decent human beings themselves.

TimetoPour · 12/03/2024 17:51

Urgh. The sad woman is unhappy you are doing something she can’t. You are feeding the baby and you are comforting the baby in a way she can’t and she doesn’t like it.

Next time say to her, “why do you keep saying that?”. I guarantee she will give a faux “I don’t know what you are talking about”. Then say you don’t like it when she calls you names. She will be uppity that she has been called out but you will have done it in a way that only she looks bad.

Shoxfordian · 12/03/2024 17:47

Call her on it every time. Where's your husband when she's saying this? Why isn't he standing up for you?

IntermittentFarting · 12/03/2024 17:44

DetOliviaBenson · 12/03/2024 16:59

How old is this older generation though? In her eighties or older? Fair enough. Younger, then no. I'm a grandmother and I'm 45. I don't consider myself an "older generation" yet.

No it's not bloody well fair enough. There's not a point at which ageism is fair enough.
My mum is just about to turn 80 and she doesn't say 'weird shit'.

W0tnow · 12/03/2024 17:15

She breastfed her for 2 years, she's fine with breastfeeding - a good trait in a MIL.

She is also a grandmother. Most of them are absolutely batshit over their grandchildren. Totally batshit. Devoid of all reason and crazy in love.

My own mum never allowed us to sleep in the bed with her. Ever. Then I had children and she trained them at a young age (whenever they were staying at her place) that whenever they woke in the night, not to bother mummy. "Just hop into bed with nana." I vote not to rock the boat.

Allshallbewell2021 · 12/03/2024 17:09

That's a horrible expression, very derogatory; I would try to be very clear that you don't want to be called that.

fleurneige · 12/03/2024 17:01

Milk machine is so so much better than 'bile machine'

DetOliviaBenson · 12/03/2024 16:59

UpsideLeft · 12/03/2024 10:26

Older generations say some weird shit

And they it's fine when it's absolutely not to every other generation

How old is this older generation though? In her eighties or older? Fair enough. Younger, then no. I'm a grandmother and I'm 45. I don't consider myself an "older generation" yet.

Topseyt123 · 12/03/2024 16:46

Just tell her bluntly that you dislike it, it isn't funny and to pack it in pronto as it is disrespectful.

I didn't breastfeed, but would never have referred to friends who did in any such way.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 12/03/2024 16:44

Thedogscollar · 12/03/2024 16:42

Speaking as a midwife that is shocking and I hope you reported it.
@PeachShark Tell your mother in law that you do not want to referred to like this and to please stop.
I will never understand the bizarre attitudes towards breastfeeding in the UK.

Tbh that was the least of my issues with the treatment I experienced by midwives. It was 23 years ago, I hope things have changed.

Thedogscollar · 12/03/2024 16:42

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 12/03/2024 16:32

A midwife referred to me as a cow,I think I prefer milk machine tbh.

Speaking as a midwife that is shocking and I hope you reported it.
@PeachShark Tell your mother in law that you do not want to referred to like this and to please stop.
I will never understand the bizarre attitudes towards breastfeeding in the UK.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 12/03/2024 16:32

A midwife referred to me as a cow,I think I prefer milk machine tbh.

RawBloomers · 12/03/2024 16:29

This could be loaded but to me it sounds more like a way of using humour to acknowledge the relentlessness of breast feeding especially in the early weeks - something it sounds like she should be well aware of.

Humour as a way of coping with the hard bits of life seems to have taken a battering in recent years as so many people focuses on the literal rather than wryness or the deprecation, etc. But I suspect thats what you’re missing when you think she’s being insulting. That was the way my parents were to a great extent and, especially, their parents. They had a lot of dark spots to cope with and that was one of the ways they got through it. It’s supposed to take the edge off, a joint acknowledgement that things could be better but you’ll get through it anyway.

That’s just going off your post and not knowing her for years as you obviously have. Is she actually really judgy, or does she make comments you find shocking but carry on helping/being friends with/etc. whoever you thought she was being mean to? Does she say stuff about herself as well as others? Does she argue with people disagreeing with her or does it not really matter to her because it was never meant to be taken literally?

Even if you decide it isn’t loaded, it’s still a good idea to say something to her - if only along the lines of “I really don’t like that MiL, could you stop, please.” - rather than let resentment and dislike build up.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 12/03/2024 16:21

@PeachShark - how well does she take it when the ‘jokey’ comments are directed at her? My suspicion is that she would take it very badly - so it’s fine for her to make jokes at other people’s expense but she is too sensitive for the tables to be turned on her.

I think I’d be blunt - “MIL - I’ve told you I hate being called the milk machine - it is not a joke, it is hurtful and dehumanising. I assume you want to have a decent relationship with the mother of your grandchild, so I suggest you knock it off pronto. If you can’t treat me with respect and decency, you’ll be seeing a lot less of me and of your grandchild.”

mathanxiety · 12/03/2024 16:13

Yes, it's loaded. She clearly has silly issues around breastfeeding.

I'd tell her I'd prefer to be a milk machine than someone full of vinegar and spite.

Trinity65 · 12/03/2024 14:26

UpsideLeft · 12/03/2024 10:26

Older generations say some weird shit

And they it's fine when it's absolutely not to every other generation

ALL of us ??!

YANBU Op (from an older generation!)

KarmaCaramello · 12/03/2024 14:03

WhamBamThankU · 12/03/2024 13:07

When she comes to take baby from you keep saying "Yoda's here for you 😊 old yoda wants a cuddle" etc. wrinkly old ballsack also works

😂😂😂

preggo39 · 12/03/2024 13:21

And @CleftChin suggestion is good - completely ignore her every single time. That'll annoy the shit out of her!