Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What would you do, go all in with huge differences?

114 replies

Smetasmerwig · 12/03/2024 05:06

Looking for opinions on a rather complex situation between two work colleagues

Male - 27, ambitious, caring, rents a room, start of career.

Female - 38, winding down in career, owns £2m house in London, pregnant .

First pregnancy for both, they are keen to make a go of things. Have been friends/colleagues for over 5 years. Pregnancy was unplanned and unexpected (heat of the moment sex).

Male wants to get married/buy a home and build a family. Female is concerned she may end up losing her home if the relationship fails.

YANBU - If you were the woman, would you avoid marrying this man?

OP posts:
moonfacer · 12/03/2024 11:57

Did I envisage being a father in my 20s? No, but life happens and I'm trying to do what I think is responsible and also I want stability for my future child.

Why does stability for your future child mean you being entitled to half her house?

moonfacer · 12/03/2024 11:47

Smetasmerwig · 12/03/2024 11:06

I deliberately didn't specify who I was in the party as I wanted an impartial view, as friends and family are not giving that to me right now. Some are saying she is a predator, some are saying I'm a predator. It's exhausting. People have unplanned pregnancies all the time for no reason, just because of the age and finances people seem to think there is an agenda.

But general consensus seems to be that she shouldn't marry me because I'm likely to run off eventually with her riches.

We met at work. I never knew she was so much older than me whilst we formed the friendship over the first few years. She is young, vibrant and in my view looks great (she complains she is not fit anymore and her chron's has altered her body somewhat). We both look the same age, people are shocked when they find she is 10years older.

I helped her out in a tight situation a few years back and the friendship blossomed from there. I've always been attracted to her and I think the same for her too. She is smart and has her life together. She makes me a better person and I believe I do the same for her too.

Did I envisage being a father in my 20s? No, but life happens and I'm trying to do what I think is responsible and also I want stability for my future child.

Do you acknowledge that she’s right to be worried that you will want a share of her house, OP?

Zoreos · 12/03/2024 11:34

I think the biggest thing that you need to come to terms with is that marriage is no certainty of a strong family unit. In many cases, co-parenting is much healthier for the child than pushing a broken relationship for the sake of being a family unit. You are more than capable of achieving this without being married and putting her finances at risk if you were to divorce later down the line. You can be an extremely successful team for the child through a strong co-parenting relationship which would always need to be the priority over a romantic relationship. Everything by the sounds of it is very unexpected, new territory. Focus on processing and enjoying the idea of parenthood before trying to rush into anything other huge commitments and certainly (not saying you are) don’t try and push any decisions on her that she isn’t 100% enthralled about. Being a more mature mother is extremely hard going physically and mentally without her pre-existing health conditions. Please, use your time, energy and motivations wisely to support her the best that you can.

KimberleyClark · 12/03/2024 11:31

Would you be so keen to marry her if she didn’t have a £2m London home?

pikkumyy77 · 12/03/2024 11:31

I’ve just read that this is a reverse. Hm.

I still think this is a complex situation in which financial caution (or modesty) is needed. If she has Crohn’s disease it is going to monkey with her health and energy and looks (probably) eventually.

If I were you (the msn) I would suggest not marrying. I would offer to move in snd live like a committed family, pay your share of baby/family life but retain rent money in savings to buy your own property/build your own equity.

If your career is ramping up you may need to travel or otherwise be unavailable. Be prepared to help oay for childcare or additional health care stuff for your partner.

If she is likely to predecease you ask her to make a will leaving the house in trust for the baby with a life interest for you.

pikkumyy77 · 12/03/2024 11:22

Smetasmerwig · 12/03/2024 08:12

His dad left his mum early in life and he is determined to not have a child with an absent father. He is keen on what he calls building a strong family unit

The creepiest people talk the biggest.

Revelatio · 12/03/2024 11:19

Don’t press for marriage. You need to begin a relationship properly first. Will you be supporting her on maternity leave?

You can be fully committed and provide a stable life without marriage. It’s usually recommend for women as they are more likely to have to give up work and lose out on earnings and income and it gives them security. This doesn’t look the case for you as your partner will be taking a step back and you will be hopefully forging a successful career.

If you do break up, not being married won’t affect your rights as a father.

OneTC · 12/03/2024 11:10

You've already rushed the kid bit, rushing a wedding into it isn't the best idea.

If you're committed to making it work then take a bit of time over it

Smetasmerwig · 12/03/2024 11:06

I deliberately didn't specify who I was in the party as I wanted an impartial view, as friends and family are not giving that to me right now. Some are saying she is a predator, some are saying I'm a predator. It's exhausting. People have unplanned pregnancies all the time for no reason, just because of the age and finances people seem to think there is an agenda.

But general consensus seems to be that she shouldn't marry me because I'm likely to run off eventually with her riches.

We met at work. I never knew she was so much older than me whilst we formed the friendship over the first few years. She is young, vibrant and in my view looks great (she complains she is not fit anymore and her chron's has altered her body somewhat). We both look the same age, people are shocked when they find she is 10years older.

I helped her out in a tight situation a few years back and the friendship blossomed from there. I've always been attracted to her and I think the same for her too. She is smart and has her life together. She makes me a better person and I believe I do the same for her too.

Did I envisage being a father in my 20s? No, but life happens and I'm trying to do what I think is responsible and also I want stability for my future child.

OP posts:
tryingtohelp82 · 12/03/2024 10:38

I hope the last post is sarcasm. Far past prime?? Many of us only get our confidence as women from that age onwards

I don't like age gaps in general but the people going on about it with this, would they say the same with older man with money and younger woman? Would it be a problem that she's attractive?
The hypocrisy is shit

SnapdragonToadflax · 12/03/2024 10:36

It seems highly unlikely they were 'great friends' when he was 22 and she was 33. That's a weird age gap - he's only just left uni, she's established in her career. I wouldn't have had any interest in 22 year olds at that age.

Is it a reverse? 38 year old man getting a 27 year old woman pregnant seems significantly more likely, and perhaps OP is trying to make a point about women marrying for money while forgetting the physical, emotional and mental labour of motherhood.

Anyway. In the unlikely even that this is real, no of course she shouldn't marry him.

AnonymousUser6 · 12/03/2024 10:32

TempleOfBloom · 12/03/2024 10:12

I would say the woman should take what she can get at her age

What?

ThT’s insulting to both of them, and ridiculous.

Well everyone knows 38 is far beyond the prime age for a woman! I would also be questioning the pregnancy being an accident as a previous poster suggested. She’s obviously a smart 38 year old woman not a teenager. She has chosen to prioritise her career which is fine but she shouldn’t have her cake and eat it, now trapping a 27 year old into having a child with her but not sharing any financial benefit. Imagine if she was a wealthy man refusing to marry a younger woman he had got pregnant and refusing to marry her to guard his wealth - mumsnet would be in uproar.

TempleOfBloom · 12/03/2024 10:12

I would say the woman should take what she can get at her age

What?

ThT’s insulting to both of them, and ridiculous.

crumpet · 12/03/2024 10:11

Too soon for marriage. Allow time for the relationship to become established. - they have gone very fast from colleagues to friends to parents. The relationship “as a couple” has not had time to develop.

OneTC · 12/03/2024 10:08

I'm not the marrying type so I wouldn't really ever be all like "yeah marriage go for it" but this situation would make me even less keen than normal.

Live together, see how things go, get married later if you want.

AnonymousUser6 · 12/03/2024 10:00

I would say the woman should take what she can get at her age and own up to her responsibilities and settle down with the poor younger guy. Predatory to sleep with a man so much younger than you and then discard him. If I were his mother I would hate you for ruining his life.

Wishimaywishimight · 12/03/2024 09:18

I raise my eyebrows a little at "heat of the moment sex" leading to an "unplanned" pregnancy in a 38 year old woman tbh. Yep, of course it is equally the mans responsibility however he is not the one left holding the baby.

Did you/she perhaps see this as a last chance to have a baby? If so, she should proceed with the pregnancy but definitely not marry just yet, see how things go when the baby arrives.

OneMoreTime23 · 12/03/2024 08:59

how much of the house does she actually own? (My sister “owns” a £1.5m house in London, but she’s actually only paid for about £600k of it.)

she’s also a single parent having got unexpectedly pregnant at 39. She has underlying health conditions. I’m not sure she would recommend it. (4 years on she’s moved home and rented the London house out. Dad has completely disappeared. She can’t work due to the child having significant SN.)

TempleOfBloom · 12/03/2024 08:53

I would be surprised if my 22 year old Ds had a ‘great friend’ who was a 33 yo woman, tbh.

Why is marriage necessary? Why does a house need to be bought?

MeganOIiver · 12/03/2024 08:47

The query and challenge is the age gap, financials and working relationship.

I dont think any of the above is the issue. The issue is why the hell go from friendship to marriage with no in between? And absolutely a decent pre-nup if getting married which would remove any questions marks about motive.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 12/03/2024 08:36

A strong family unit doesn't mean parents who shouldn't be together, gritt8ng their teeth and staying together because they have kids. Saying that, I know people who have made it work when they have had kids without knowing each other and these two have more chance than most of making it work since they are good friends.

I'd strongly advise if they stay together it's for each other not the child. That will actually translate into what's best for the child as well. So they do things at a normal relationship pace. Date throughout the pregnancy and see if a relationship is still what they want. If it is, he moves into hers and pays a bit of rent and bills. Eventually they can buy together or he buys somewhere else as an investment but she legally protects her current assets in case of a split. It doesn't need to be 'all in' or 'all out' at this early stage.

LadyNijo · 12/03/2024 08:29

This all sounds quite odd to me. They were colleagues and friends, despite being at different life stages, but weren’t in a relationship because of work, suddenly had one-off sex and she conceived despite her significant health problems? And he’s desperate to move in to her £2 million house and out of his house share? And you know all about this, including the value of her house?

BabyYodasGotMyTeacher · 12/03/2024 08:21

Why can't they just move in together and build a strong family unit anyway? Marriage is not a precursor....

DP didn't see the point in marriage as his parents divorced when he was a young child. We are a traditional family unit, 2 DC (10&12) just without a piece of paper. Just make sure any house purchases are covered by declaration of trust (I think that's what it was called) and that wills are in place.

Smetasmerwig · 12/03/2024 08:12

lemonmeringueno3 · 12/03/2024 06:07

I think there's a middle ground between 'no relationship' and 'marriage'. Why can't they do that while they co-parent and decide what they both want?

In her shoes, I definitely wouldn't ever marry someone with fewer assets. It never benefits the partner who is financially stronger. But I don't see why they can't live together while they figure it all out, especially if they were considering it anyway. The age gap isn't an issue to me as it isn't that big. If their differences in terms of career eventually see them drifting apart, well at least they gave it a go.

His dad left his mum early in life and he is determined to not have a child with an absent father. He is keen on what he calls building a strong family unit

OP posts:
NotDonna · 12/03/2024 08:11

Middle ground? Live together? Suck it and see? Plus a decent pre-nup!!