Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What would you do, go all in with huge differences?

114 replies

Smetasmerwig · 12/03/2024 05:06

Looking for opinions on a rather complex situation between two work colleagues

Male - 27, ambitious, caring, rents a room, start of career.

Female - 38, winding down in career, owns £2m house in London, pregnant .

First pregnancy for both, they are keen to make a go of things. Have been friends/colleagues for over 5 years. Pregnancy was unplanned and unexpected (heat of the moment sex).

Male wants to get married/buy a home and build a family. Female is concerned she may end up losing her home if the relationship fails.

YANBU - If you were the woman, would you avoid marrying this man?

OP posts:
PocketSand · 12/03/2024 15:28

You won't be sacrificing a lot - you won't be pregnant or breastfeeding or working part time etc until your child starts school etc. ie you won't be taking a career break for childcare.

If your work colleague/friend were not pregnant with your child you would not even be thinking about moving in with her because you enrich each other's lives, enjoy spending time together. You are not a benefit and I don't just mean financially.

Given your limited history with the mother you take things slowly - you keep what you already have (ie stay in your house share) and contribute legal minimum of child support. There is no starting from scratch if things don't work out.

You are not bringing much to the table. I think you know this. Would you be so keen to move in with a ONS older pregnant woman with health issues in social housing? Same security of tenure.

And where is the feeling? Just security, rights, duties etc like a legal contract.

Sperm donor would have been cheaper but maybe she'll lock you into a water tight contract/prenup and you won't be able to profit from your marriage/parenthood?

Zoreos · 12/03/2024 15:25

pinkyredrose · 12/03/2024 15:10

At her age?

Sorry, 38 and 28 isn’t predatory by any means. OP said there is a ten year age difference. He’s two years younger than myself that’s not a very young man. Nor is she an old woman. He is nearly in his thirties and many younger men have children and make an excellent job of it without trying to rip off a millionaire. There are no prizes for being a good father when you have unprotected sex. If you’re not clever enough at this age to realise having unprotected sex doesn’t carry a high chance of conception then I really cannot recommend anything other than re-education and abstinence. He’s not a knight in shining armour as much as he clearly loves to think he is. If I were dating your son I’d suggest to you that you had a serious lack of unhealthy boundaries pertaining to your son’s sex life. Gross and weird on your part.

pinkyredrose · 12/03/2024 15:16

Smetasmerwig · 12/03/2024 13:35

And finances are important. I don't want to be in a situation where she decides to walk, and I'm having to build a life from scratch whilst staying close to my child. Marriage provides a degree of security which I need.

You've got £ signs in your eyes. How do you know so much about her bills and house value? Would you still want to marry her if she rented a bedsit?

Zoreos · 12/03/2024 15:11

makeanddo · 12/03/2024 15:06

OP you say you will be giving up a lot . What do you mean by that exactly?

You also comment about her walking away and you having to start from scratch - do you mean home wise? Because it doesn't sound as if you have much financial security except your job, you're not giving anything up are you? It sounds as though you want the security she is giving you, again something you want to fulfill your dream of having a family.

Sorry but this 100%. You rent a room, if you marry and divorce she loses a mil. It’s really night and day difference. Multiple people have told you that marriage won’t create a happy family unit, you’re not entitled to a million pounds in security just because you give up a room you’re renting and you got her pregnant. You can find other rooms to rent easily, where will she easily find a million pounds? You’re not covering yourself in any glory here pal, you’re not putting her first by trying to dig your heels into an easy half of a house that you’ve done nothing for. There is no honour in taking advantage of a pregnant, vulnerable woman with health difficulties.

pinkyredrose · 12/03/2024 15:10

AnonymousUser6 · 12/03/2024 10:00

I would say the woman should take what she can get at her age and own up to her responsibilities and settle down with the poor younger guy. Predatory to sleep with a man so much younger than you and then discard him. If I were his mother I would hate you for ruining his life.

At her age?

makeanddo · 12/03/2024 15:06

OP you say you will be giving up a lot . What do you mean by that exactly?

You also comment about her walking away and you having to start from scratch - do you mean home wise? Because it doesn't sound as if you have much financial security except your job, you're not giving anything up are you? It sounds as though you want the security she is giving you, again something you want to fulfill your dream of having a family.

Ponderingwindow · 12/03/2024 14:41

If it were the 20something just starting out who was pregnant, I would advise her to strongly reconsider having the baby. If she decided to continue, then she should do everything possible to protect herself financially.

it doesn’t matter who has more money, the vulnerable person is the one who is pregnant. We could be talking about two woman who conceived using donor sperm. The one carrying the baby is the one taking the huge risk. pregnancy is dangerous. Even a relatively normal pregnancy can still end up interfering with a woman’s ability to earn.

op is a young male who can keep working without interruption. If he is a responsible father he will do his half of the child care and that will impact his earning power. However, we all know that most men in these situations don’t actually do their duties as father’s and don’t think they should have to worry about things like leaving work before the nursery closes or taking a day off because a child is sick.

Perhaps op is one of the good ones and will actually step up and take on half the responsibilities. He should do that regardless of any commitment from the mother of his child. his commitment is not to the mother, it is to the child.

Obeast · 12/03/2024 14:37

'Like most, I just didn't think it would happen'

Dude. Incorrect. Most people would know pregnancy is a risk when choosing to ejaculate on to a vagina. Not even a 'risk' but an entirely predictable outcome.

Can you tell us why you'd expect your colleague to marry and house you and give you half her £2million property if and when you break up. From the relationship you are not in. ?

@Lookatmeivechangedmyname OPs colleague is not his family though. Of course she should safeguard her wealth.

Revelatio · 12/03/2024 14:21

Of course the sex makes a difference. If he was having the baby, giving up a few years of his career, then doing less at work and being home more with the child then the overwhelming response would be he should get married. This is not the case here. The woman is giving up her career, he’s young enough to make more money in the future, and will be full time at work.

Sex completely matters in this instance.

mitogoshi · 12/03/2024 14:13

He can move in, but not marry at this point, reconsider down the road

Ponoka7 · 12/03/2024 14:08

Britpop123 · 12/03/2024 13:56

This is where the sexes of the people involved mean you’d get different answers the other way round

in your case no, the woman with assets should not risk them and if the man insists on it he’s a freeloading bastard

if it was the other way round then the woman should insist he share, refuse to move in without being on the deeds, and if he refuses he’s a selfish controlling bastard

When that advice is given it's because the man wants her to be a SAHM or go part time so he isn't inconvenienced by having a child or housework. The OP is still going to pursue his career.

paintingvenice · 12/03/2024 14:01

Britpop123 · 12/03/2024 13:56

This is where the sexes of the people involved mean you’d get different answers the other way round

in your case no, the woman with assets should not risk them and if the man insists on it he’s a freeloading bastard

if it was the other way round then the woman should insist he share, refuse to move in without being on the deeds, and if he refuses he’s a selfish controlling bastard

No one would ever suggest you insist on marriage to someone you aren’t even in a relationship with regardless of gender!!!

If the roles were reversed here people would say to the higher earner, be the most supportive partner that you can, get to know each other and build a relationship. They still wouldn’t be suggesting moving in together or giving up independent homes at this stage.

crumpet · 12/03/2024 13:57

The money is a bit of a red herring here. They have not had a chance to establish a relationship as a couple to see if it has a future.

Britpop123 · 12/03/2024 13:56

This is where the sexes of the people involved mean you’d get different answers the other way round

in your case no, the woman with assets should not risk them and if the man insists on it he’s a freeloading bastard

if it was the other way round then the woman should insist he share, refuse to move in without being on the deeds, and if he refuses he’s a selfish controlling bastard

ConflictedCheetah · 12/03/2024 13:53

EmilyTjP · 12/03/2024 13:36

Wow imagine the responses if this was the other way round.

38 year old Man, £2 million house and winding down career, gets 27 year old woman pregnant . You’d all be telling her to marry him for security!

If the roles were reversed the difference is that the woman, and lower earner, would likely be left supporting the baby while the man can continue to progress and earn.

SleepingStandingUp · 12/03/2024 13:50

Smetasmerwig · 12/03/2024 13:33

Marriage for me is important and I believe demonstrates intent that we are committed to working to making if work.

I will be sacrificing a lot to ensure I can be the best parent I can be and I need to feel comfortable that we are both all in.

But you're proposing marriage before you even love each other romantically because you want financial responsibility. Otherwise what? You're out? You'll have ot EOW once they're five?

Haydenn · 12/03/2024 13:50

Smetasmerwig · 12/03/2024 13:35

And finances are important. I don't want to be in a situation where she decides to walk, and I'm having to build a life from scratch whilst staying close to my child. Marriage provides a degree of security which I need.

So even you admit its about shoring up your financial future! You don’t use your baby to trap a woman into providing you with security.

SleepingStandingUp · 12/03/2024 13:48

Smetasmerwig · 12/03/2024 13:23

Why did you get married?

I think my situation is quite different as we have been friends for 5 years and very close. I'd also add that the main reason for financial disparity is age. I will catch up, so hopefully this will help.

Because we'd had a romantic relationship and were in love. Not because I was pregnant or he owned an expensive house.

SoEmbarrassed2024 · 12/03/2024 13:46

His dad left his mum early in life and he is determined to not have a child with an absent father. He is keen on what he calls building a strong family unit

Don't be an absent father then. You can do that without marriage!

You talk as if being friends and colleagues is the equivalent of being in a relationship, it isn't. You don't know each other in the way you would have if you'd been in a relationship and you need to do that bit before you even consider marrying each other

If you keep pushing it as marriage or nothing you may find she decides that co-parent is all you are ever going to be....

SleepingStandingUp · 12/03/2024 13:46

They've not been in a relationship long enough to contemplate marriage

So whilst she's pregnant, assuming she wants the baby, they date and decide of there's enough there for a romantic relationship.

If she will need extra help with medical and pregnancy then he can RENT a room as per previous plan. Less than market rent and half of bills

If a relationship works, they can progress to one room, ideally when baby comes so he pulls his weight.

And they take it from there.

If they get to a point where they both want marriage because of how they feel about each other, she can look into that.

If a relationship doesn't work, he could keep renting a room there for now whilst baby is too young to move between homes

Ponderingwindow · 12/03/2024 13:41

Marriage isn’t really a fairytale. It’s about finding the person who shares your values and has a shared economic and life plan and wants to work it with you. That is why part of why marriage mitigates risk for women. It is two people working towards a secure financial future instead of just one. Pregnancy is inherently risky and puts a woman at risk financially. That is why the mitigation of having a solid partner is important.

however a bad marriage expensive. It needs to well chosen. Even a cohabitation can go wrong and end up very costly.

yes, its much better to be married before having a baby. But that doesn’t mean rush off and marry whatever random man happens to be the father of your child. It means carefully choosing a partner and carefully planning a pregnancy.

upon finding herself unexpectedly pregnant with a recent partner, if she decides to proceed with the pregnancy, often the best choice a woman can make is to stay as independent as possible.

Herdinggoats · 12/03/2024 13:41

Of course he wants to get married and buy a home 🤣🤣🤣🤣 who the fuck will be paying for that.

moonfacer · 12/03/2024 13:40

Lookatmeivechangedmyname · 12/03/2024 13:39

Is he? Reverse the situation. A woman gives up her home to raise a child with a wealthy man in his home. They split.

He doesn’t need to give up his home. He can save up for and buy his own home, just like everybody else.

Lookatmeivechangedmyname · 12/03/2024 13:39

moonfacer · 12/03/2024 13:37

Mate, you’re a gold digger. I hope she sees through you.

Is he? Reverse the situation. A woman gives up her home to raise a child with a wealthy man in his home. They split.

moonfacer · 12/03/2024 13:38

Obeast · 12/03/2024 13:25

So?
No response to the questions I (and others) asked?

I’m guessing he wanted a thread full of people saying she should marry him so that he could show it to her 🙄

Swipe left for the next trending thread