Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is there any hope for my son?

64 replies

onlyoneoutcome · 11/03/2024 18:00

Such a long story but my son is 13 and has been anxious all of his life. He is profoundly attached to me to
The point that I am
Absolutely smothered. He will go to school but will do anything to avoid going, get out of classes, generally anything so he can be with me. Dad left a few years ago.
I've other children with special needs and as I was taken with working
Full time and parenting, sex took a nose dive and he found it elsewhere. He was an absent father and husband well before these issues though. I think it simply gave him an excuse to leave.
So kids have nothing to do with dad and vice Versa.
Son is so attached. He is much loved but sadly he engulfs all family
Time to detriment of others time and my
Mental health. He is controlling and manipulative but not deliberately. He will do
Anything to keep me near. Endless texts and calls
And declarations of gratitude and live but can be angry, aggressive and rude to me too. Like two different boys at times .
I cannot read a book . I cannot watch anything of my
Choosing on tv. I cannot sleep on my own. My life is utterly depressing.
I have got him
Assessed and he does not have ASD. He does have anxiety forever and is grieving apparently. I'm waiting for yet another intervention... this time art psychotherapy and CBT. He is also in wait list for CAMHS. Nine months at present.
I've been sent all different directions with him. Nothing has ever worked. It is
Almost like he does not want to get independent or unattached.
He believes that everyone is out to get him and imagines scenarios where he is hates by everyone. He also hides when we are out in case anyone sees him and tries not to leave the house at weekends.
I am at a huge loss and utterly depressed myself because of this so cannot be the mother I want to be.to him
Or the others . I am getting counselling and find it hard not to be angry with my lot.
Is there any hope for him?
Will it always be like this for him and for us ?
Please share your thoughts or experiences. I'm really at the end of my nerves.
Thanks.
Thankfully I work full time so I have that break.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Morwenscapacioussleeves · 13/03/2024 19:25

Bloody hell, OP is looking for support make your own thread to bicker about mumsnet diagnosis!!

onlyone I don't have any solutions for you but there is always hope. Please take some time to get your own oxygen mask on/find a way to allow you to recharge (I know it sounds impossible but it's not just for you it's for your kids). A very close friend deals with similar sounding anxiety in her child (& it is actually a manifestation of OCD in her case) so I understand just how utterly exhausted you must be 💐💐💐

Mumkins42 · 13/03/2024 18:58

circlesnsquares · 12/03/2024 14:32

I have looked up PDA and the advice to parents is very similar to parenting advice which is based on developmental research - eg such as that in ahaparenting. com (the advice is from a clinspscych and based on peer reviewed research about child development and parenting) - which would also be the same as the parenting advice for children with high levels of anxiety.

Interventions for schools for PDA might be different, as distinct from advice to parents, I am not sure. But the OP wanted advice about the home situation, I thought.

Can you explain a bit further what differences there are in your experience, PDA vs anxiety, though?

I'd love to see a school that even knows what PDA is. I'm not sure about the guidance on anxiety but everything I read regarding PDA, and I've read loads for personal reasons, is that autonomy, control and a relationship with a parent that's more equitable as opposed to parent directing child is essential. It has made a huge difference in my personal relationship with my child who does have some minor PDA traits . It's a huge culture shift for any parent and a school when we're so used to directing everything without much explanation rather than collaborating as equals.

Bit of a tangent...😁

Careforcarers · 13/03/2024 09:31

💐

I feel for you.

Yourowncase · 12/03/2024 20:35

Peelingpotatoes · 12/03/2024 20:17

No one is providing suggestions of how to manage this though. Everyone is just piling on various diagnoses.
This happens a lot on mumsnet.com but it's very presumptuous to assume you know better than the professionals and also the op who has only mentioned autism to say it was explored and refuted as part of a professional assessment.
She must know the signs quite well as she has at least one other child who is autistic.

She has not asked for help in diagnosing her child from this forum. She wants suggestions to manage her situation. If people want to give suggestions for that based on a pda profile or whatever else they personally think is going on then they should. That's not what I'm seeing though. I'm just seeing people excited to be 'right' about her child's diagnosis and urging her to explore avenues for diagnosis which does not actually help her in the current moment at all.

I’m not trying to diagnose her child with anything- I don’t know the kid!

I’ve said that some of the behaviour is pda ish (it being a condition characterised by certain behaviours that some ND experts think might exist independently of autism or also be linked to other ND)…so maybe some of the things that help pda kids/families might help the op and her son.

If she doesn’t think so she doesn’t need to try!

She literally said “please post your thoughts and experiences”- my thought is “that sounds like my pda kid” and my experience is “the things that help pda are different from mainstream MH intervention” so I mentioned it.

Peelingpotatoes · 12/03/2024 20:17

Yourowncase · 12/03/2024 19:55

🤦‍♀️ if he is exhibiting signs of PDA influenced behaviour then she could try coping with the behaviour using methods that can work well for pda.

We don’t know which professional is correct, we don’t know them.

It doesn’t do any harm to try different approaches to helping the child- if the op was wedded to continuing to do everything the way she is now she wouldn’t have posted.

Edited

No one is providing suggestions of how to manage this though. Everyone is just piling on various diagnoses.
This happens a lot on mumsnet.com but it's very presumptuous to assume you know better than the professionals and also the op who has only mentioned autism to say it was explored and refuted as part of a professional assessment.
She must know the signs quite well as she has at least one other child who is autistic.

She has not asked for help in diagnosing her child from this forum. She wants suggestions to manage her situation. If people want to give suggestions for that based on a pda profile or whatever else they personally think is going on then they should. That's not what I'm seeing though. I'm just seeing people excited to be 'right' about her child's diagnosis and urging her to explore avenues for diagnosis which does not actually help her in the current moment at all.

Yourowncase · 12/03/2024 19:55

Peelingpotatoes · 12/03/2024 19:21

Yes and according to op the professionals who are qualified to diagnose autism held an mta and concluded not. The only other mention is a camh psych who believed it was autism but said to refer back if it wasn't which suggests it was by no means a sure thing.

Also the point I was making is that throwing out diagnoses is hardly helpful to the op anyway! She's looking for how to cope with the symptoms - not for a name for the condition. That would be a professional's remit rather than mumsnet and she seems to already be well versed in exploring those avenues herself.

🤦‍♀️ if he is exhibiting signs of PDA influenced behaviour then she could try coping with the behaviour using methods that can work well for pda.

We don’t know which professional is correct, we don’t know them.

It doesn’t do any harm to try different approaches to helping the child- if the op was wedded to continuing to do everything the way she is now she wouldn’t have posted.

Peelingpotatoes · 12/03/2024 19:21

Yourowncase · 12/03/2024 17:16

Have you read the op’s posts? There is disagreement between professionals about whether he has asd.

How do you know which professional is correct?

I don’t know which one is, but I do know that this behaviour is very reminiscent of PDA autism.

Yes and according to op the professionals who are qualified to diagnose autism held an mta and concluded not. The only other mention is a camh psych who believed it was autism but said to refer back if it wasn't which suggests it was by no means a sure thing.

Also the point I was making is that throwing out diagnoses is hardly helpful to the op anyway! She's looking for how to cope with the symptoms - not for a name for the condition. That would be a professional's remit rather than mumsnet and she seems to already be well versed in exploring those avenues herself.

GarlicAndTangerines · 12/03/2024 18:01

He sounds exactly like an autistic boy I once knew...

Mumkins42 · 12/03/2024 17:22

Yourowncase · 12/03/2024 14:08

@circlesnsquares

Whether or not he has high level autism or PDA or anxiety, the therapeutic things that work are the same

This is not true about PDA- very few if the usual interventions that are used for asd or mental health problems are effective with PDA unless they are heavily adapted by someone who knows PDA.

This is why PDA children still struggle in special schools.

I believe understanding this and having a diagnosis is absolutely essential. It changes everything. Agree entirely ref approach to PDA. Def not one size fits all.

Yourowncase · 12/03/2024 17:16

Peelingpotatoes · 12/03/2024 17:05

Why do people on the Internet think they know better than actual medical professionals based on a few paragraphs? Op's son has been tested for autism and it was determined he doesn't have it. No clue why you all think you know better having never met the child. So many diagnoses being thrown out here none of which are actually helpful.

Op I'm also no expert and you'll know your son best but is it possible that telling him exactly where you're going and for how long etc could feed the beast. If you've another adult there to keep tabs could you leave your phone at home and go out for a while telling him you're uncontactable for the duration? If nothing else it would be good for your own mental health to get that uninterrupted break.

Have you read the op’s posts? There is disagreement between professionals about whether he has asd.

How do you know which professional is correct?

I don’t know which one is, but I do know that this behaviour is very reminiscent of PDA autism.

Peelingpotatoes · 12/03/2024 17:05

Why do people on the Internet think they know better than actual medical professionals based on a few paragraphs? Op's son has been tested for autism and it was determined he doesn't have it. No clue why you all think you know better having never met the child. So many diagnoses being thrown out here none of which are actually helpful.

Op I'm also no expert and you'll know your son best but is it possible that telling him exactly where you're going and for how long etc could feed the beast. If you've another adult there to keep tabs could you leave your phone at home and go out for a while telling him you're uncontactable for the duration? If nothing else it would be good for your own mental health to get that uninterrupted break.

badwolf82 · 12/03/2024 16:46

This sounds like severe separation anxiety. I have dealt with a milder case as an adult. What really worked for me was metacognitive therapy. Its similar to CBT but has some additional components.

FlowerBarrow · 12/03/2024 16:41

Before you posted that his sibling has ocd I wondering OP if he was having intrusive thoughts about you/losing you making him behave this way that he hadn’t been able to express?

Daisybuttercup12345 · 12/03/2024 16:37

My neighbour had a child like this. They sent him to boarding school as a weekly border. 2 years later he is a different child. Very supportive school though.

TadpolesInPool · 12/03/2024 15:46

I have 2 DC with ADHD and anxiety. I too feel suffocated sometimes OP so you're not alone.

Pps have posted good advice. Only one I wouldn't follow is getting a cat. Dcs persuaded us to get a cat because they thought stroking it would calm them.
It's true it absolutely does. And they both totally adore DCat. So when he started going out they both panicked. Then it was just a panic if we called DCat and he didn't appear immediately (you know, as he was being a cat and off exploring). Now, 2 years in its getting better but they still get stressed every bloody evening about whether we can get the cat in for the night (its dangerous where we live at night for cats). Sigh.

We've started therapy for our 9 year old due to his school refusal last year and nightly nightmares. I've also put in a request for my 12 year old to start therapy cos he's struggling a lot right now and I'm noticing some tics. He emails me most days from school panicking about something and we need help.

Yourowncase · 12/03/2024 15:31

circlesnsquares · 12/03/2024 15:04

@Yourowncase it was quite a wide variety of sites, from professional advice to blogs. I didn't make a note of any website names, I am sorry, and I don't have time to look back now! NB the US doesn't recognise PDA at the moment and ahaparenting is US - but the body of child development/parenting research they refer to is used both in UK and US, if that makes sense. Autism and trauma can present in very similar ways, as you probably know. Similarly, behaviour can be interpreted in more than one way - ahaparenting I think would see behaviour as communication, and talks about how to respond. I apologise I am rushing at the moment, and so this may sound disjointed or not clear, if so apologies.

https://www.pdasociety.org.uk/what-is-pda-menu/about-autism-and-pda/

https://www.pdasociety.org.uk/life-with-pda-menu/family-life-intro/helpful-approaches-children/

https://childmind.org/article/pathological-demand-avoidance-in-kids/

These all have sections on how best to work with pda children, and why usual parenting and education methods don’t tend to work well.

For example PDA children need very low demand care-

many asd interventions are very routine based- designed to reduce anxiety due to uncertainty, and to habituate certain activities to make transition points easier for children-

this is likely to be very stressful for pda children because the expectation to follow a routine is a demand in itself, and involves doing x then y then z each time and each of them is a demand as well.

Unlike many children with more classic presentations of asd, pda children can actually be relieved by changing routine and having spontaneity in their day- this is very difficult in schools where they have timetables.

Habituation also doesn’t tend to reduce anxiety because the activity remains a demand, then the repetition to make it habitual is also a demand.

That’s only one example, and obviously varies from person to person.

About autism & PDA

About autism & PDA PDA (Pathological Demand Avoidance) is widely understood to be a profile on the autism spectrum, though we are still at an early stage in our understanding and PDA research is in its infancy. Whilst autism is a widely recognised ter...

https://www.pdasociety.org.uk/what-is-pda-menu/about-autism-and-pda/

circlesnsquares · 12/03/2024 15:04

@Yourowncase it was quite a wide variety of sites, from professional advice to blogs. I didn't make a note of any website names, I am sorry, and I don't have time to look back now! NB the US doesn't recognise PDA at the moment and ahaparenting is US - but the body of child development/parenting research they refer to is used both in UK and US, if that makes sense. Autism and trauma can present in very similar ways, as you probably know. Similarly, behaviour can be interpreted in more than one way - ahaparenting I think would see behaviour as communication, and talks about how to respond. I apologise I am rushing at the moment, and so this may sound disjointed or not clear, if so apologies.

Yourowncase · 12/03/2024 14:46

circlesnsquares · 12/03/2024 14:32

I have looked up PDA and the advice to parents is very similar to parenting advice which is based on developmental research - eg such as that in ahaparenting. com (the advice is from a clinspscych and based on peer reviewed research about child development and parenting) - which would also be the same as the parenting advice for children with high levels of anxiety.

Interventions for schools for PDA might be different, as distinct from advice to parents, I am not sure. But the OP wanted advice about the home situation, I thought.

Can you explain a bit further what differences there are in your experience, PDA vs anxiety, though?

Where did you look up pda?

Sidebeforeself · 12/03/2024 14:41

Apologies if this is the bleeding oblivious OP but have you tried just focussing on tacking one thing? For example, the co-sleeping ..talking to him about why you want it too change, how it makes you feel, how it’s impacting on both your lives. Then slowly introducing steps to change it e.g he goes to bed first, you’ll join him later or whatever and gradually building up to one night,then two etc? Im just thinking if you can crack one thing then it gives you lots of opportunity for praise, talking it through etc so it can be applied to other behaviours?

4321PasstheParcel · 12/03/2024 14:38

Does he like animals ?

Can you get a dog or a cat that can become his best friend, instead of you ?

The dog would also get him out of the house for exercise

Jumpinginwithbothfeet · 12/03/2024 14:34

This sounds very much like my 13 year old son. He has had anxiety for years and barely leaves the house now not even for school. We have finally had assessment from CAMHS and they have prescribed sertraline. I am so so hopeful this will help after years and years of trying everything else we possibly could.

circlesnsquares · 12/03/2024 14:32

Yourowncase · 12/03/2024 14:08

@circlesnsquares

Whether or not he has high level autism or PDA or anxiety, the therapeutic things that work are the same

This is not true about PDA- very few if the usual interventions that are used for asd or mental health problems are effective with PDA unless they are heavily adapted by someone who knows PDA.

This is why PDA children still struggle in special schools.

I have looked up PDA and the advice to parents is very similar to parenting advice which is based on developmental research - eg such as that in ahaparenting. com (the advice is from a clinspscych and based on peer reviewed research about child development and parenting) - which would also be the same as the parenting advice for children with high levels of anxiety.

Interventions for schools for PDA might be different, as distinct from advice to parents, I am not sure. But the OP wanted advice about the home situation, I thought.

Can you explain a bit further what differences there are in your experience, PDA vs anxiety, though?

Yourowncase · 12/03/2024 14:08

@circlesnsquares

Whether or not he has high level autism or PDA or anxiety, the therapeutic things that work are the same

This is not true about PDA- very few if the usual interventions that are used for asd or mental health problems are effective with PDA unless they are heavily adapted by someone who knows PDA.

This is why PDA children still struggle in special schools.

circlesnsquares · 12/03/2024 13:52

I am not sure diagnoses labels are much help from a practical point of view. Whether or not he has high level autism or PDA or anxiety, the therapeutic things that work are the same. If autism were seriously affecting other areas of his life such as school work that would be a different matter and presumably the school would want intervention. It doesn't sound as though that is the case.

OP is clearly very loving, this is evident from how her son needs her and relies on her, but I think the posters who are saying there has not been parenting problems or trauma underestimate the effect of an absent parent on a child. Here the father was not engaged even while at home, and he has since buggered off with someone else and from the sound of it makes zero effort still. This IS a parenting problem and it IS traumatic, however wonderful the remaining parent is. I don't know whether OP talks about this terrible loss with her son, if not that is definitely worthwhile too. There might also have been other things which have happened which he has found it hard to express. Or he may just need extra help while he comes to terms with it. At thirteen it is likely to be hitting hard.

Hats off to all the single parents or acting single parents who are trying to make up for the absence of the other!

KindlyPsych · 12/03/2024 03:05

Your son is not a customer for reducing his anxiety. You need SPACE Treatment (Supportive Parenting for Anxious Childhood Behaviours), which is a parent intervention for anxious children and adolescents. Www.spacetreatment.net. Look under SPACE Providers and filter by country to find UK providers.

SPACE | SPACE Treatment

http://www.spacetreatment.net

Swipe left for the next trending thread