Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the response to Kate’s illness and photo is insane?

138 replies

Grosshesselohe · 11/03/2024 15:58

And that the public are approaching levels of hysteria not seen since Diana’s funeral?

I’ve put this in AIBU not Royal because it’s the only way to get a vote - and hopefully restore faith in our collective common sense.

YABU - the dramatic response is completely justified

YANBU - people are acting like loons & should leave Kate alone

OP posts:
Ironfloor269 · 13/03/2024 08:44

Hopefully now William and Kate will empathise with the horrendous media circus Meghan had to suffer.

DryIce · 13/03/2024 08:41

SmashedPrawnsInAMilkyBasket · 12/03/2024 14:42

I had major abdominal surgery and was signed off for three months, several years ago. In that time, none of my colleagues heard from me, but not one of them thought I must be dead, or in a coma, or abducted by aliens, or replaced by a robot me, or horribly disfigured from an accident on the operating theatre, or run away to start a new life in Alaska. They knew I wasn’t expected back for three months, so when I started back they said hello and asked me how I was. Why isn’t it the same for her?

People in this country have gone nuts in the past ten years or so. So willing to be manipulated by politicians and conspiracy theorists, lives playing out like episodes of Jeremy Kyle. It’s like real life and the internet can’t be separated in their minds.

The mistake that Kensington Palace has made is allowing the collective madness to cause them to stop holding the line.

Your last paragraph, I absolutely agree. They should have just left it. The difference is - they didn't!

In your example, your colleagues may have been plodding along hoping you were doing fine. But if your husband sent them a demonstrably false picture of you captioned SmashedPrawns is absolutely fine - it may have raised some eyebrows.

Again, I am not into the speculation - I don't have any information to be able to determine why, so it seems a pointless exercise. Presumably it could be as simple as she doesn't want to be seen not looking her best, and fair enough.

But the future king essentially lying to us, and trying to use reputable (not tabloid!) media to do it is a big deal. And if you do submit false information and are found out, the obvious question is why would you do that?!

sweepleall · 12/03/2024 20:54

Sunflowerfieldsinsummer · 12/03/2024 20:48

Motivation for what? Sharing the Telegraph article?

For bringing in Meghan - are you a William and Kate fan? A royalist?

genuinely interested

Sunflowerfieldsinsummer · 12/03/2024 20:48

sweepleall · 12/03/2024 20:34

What’s your motivation here? Genuinely interested

Motivation for what? Sharing the Telegraph article?

sweepleall · 12/03/2024 20:34

Sunflowerfieldsinsummer · 12/03/2024 19:57

I’m pretty sure she’d be issuing a rebuttal via Scobie if the sources weren’t instructed by her. Unfortunately Meghan has form for this. She has been smearing and leaking and insinuating for years.

What’s your motivation here? Genuinely interested

Sunflowerfieldsinsummer · 12/03/2024 19:57

I’m pretty sure she’d be issuing a rebuttal via Scobie if the sources weren’t instructed by her. Unfortunately Meghan has form for this. She has been smearing and leaking and insinuating for years.

Spectre8 · 12/03/2024 19:51

Sunflowerfieldsinsummer · 12/03/2024 16:31

Edited

Sources close to...seriously thus shit is whatvpeople seem to take as fact even if the person themselves hasn't said it.

It goes for whether it's sources close to meghan or I read today sources close to the RF say Catherine is beside herself worried

It's speculative bs!

ColleenDonaghy · 12/03/2024 16:53

sweepleall · 12/03/2024 16:29

The reaction to the illness has been insane, I agree.

The reaction to our future head of state faking (not touching up ) a photo released to the world media has actually been quite tame.

I know the royalists want to make this about Harry and Meghan or cheese or whatever but it's actually quite possible not to be Sussex squad or whatever and critical of William and Kate here

Completely agree with this.

sweepleall · 12/03/2024 16:35

DryIce · 12/03/2024 14:13

I am not a royalist, or conspiracy theorist, and didn't really give a shit about any of this hoopla.

Until the news about that photo - a future head of state issuing information that is so edited reputable news companies refuse to use it, the media publicly calling the royal family's approved information unreliable. well that does seem like news actually.

The whole royal family is basically a PR business, it seems such a nonsensical cock up. They didn't need to issue anything, they'd already said she was off ill/recuperating. One of the most PR focused businesses in the world making such a series of ham fisted decisions does make you wonder why - what could be worse than how they're making themselves appear now!

Totally agree.

Either they have the worst PR advisors money can buy or William and Kate are personally making these very poor decisions

Sunflowerfieldsinsummer · 12/03/2024 16:31

Tell that to Meghan..Meghan would never make a mistake… according to Meghan

sweepleall · 12/03/2024 16:29

The reaction to the illness has been insane, I agree.

The reaction to our future head of state faking (not touching up ) a photo released to the world media has actually been quite tame.

I know the royalists want to make this about Harry and Meghan or cheese or whatever but it's actually quite possible not to be Sussex squad or whatever and critical of William and Kate here

LivelyBlake · 12/03/2024 16:20

Sunflowerfieldsinsummer · 12/03/2024 15:21

KP haven’t made a “huge mistake”. Just because the media and a few fanatics keep saying it, doesn’t make it true.

It reminds me of this stanza from Kipling’s poem:

If you can keep your head when all about you
Are losing theirs and blaming it on you,
If you can trust yourself when all men doubt you,
But make allowance for their doubting too;
If you can wait and not be tired by waiting,
Or being lied about, don’t deal in lies,
Or being hated, don’t give way to hating,
And yet don’t look too good, nor talk too wise

Edited

IMO they have, because their comms team should have realised the relevance of the photo and made sure it was 100% non controversial.

Personally I’m happy with photo editing, I know it’s widespread, but why give ammunition to the loonies out there?

Sunflowerfieldsinsummer · 12/03/2024 15:21

KP haven’t made a “huge mistake”. Just because the media and a few fanatics keep saying it, doesn’t make it true.

It reminds me of this stanza from Kipling’s poem:

If you can keep your head when all about you
Are losing theirs and blaming it on you,
If you can trust yourself when all men doubt you,
But make allowance for their doubting too;
If you can wait and not be tired by waiting,
Or being lied about, don’t deal in lies,
Or being hated, don’t give way to hating,
And yet don’t look too good, nor talk too wise

LivelyBlake · 12/03/2024 14:56

You can believe both that KP has made a huge mistake with the handling of this photo and that conspiracy theorists are loonies and the media should not feed them.

SoupDragon · 12/03/2024 14:46

Lampslights · 12/03/2024 13:39

Tell us youve not understood the issue without telling us you’ve not understood the issue,

Tell us you're a conspiracy theorist without telling us you're a conspiracy theorist.

I've understood the issue completely.

SmashedPrawnsInAMilkyBasket · 12/03/2024 14:42

I had major abdominal surgery and was signed off for three months, several years ago. In that time, none of my colleagues heard from me, but not one of them thought I must be dead, or in a coma, or abducted by aliens, or replaced by a robot me, or horribly disfigured from an accident on the operating theatre, or run away to start a new life in Alaska. They knew I wasn’t expected back for three months, so when I started back they said hello and asked me how I was. Why isn’t it the same for her?

People in this country have gone nuts in the past ten years or so. So willing to be manipulated by politicians and conspiracy theorists, lives playing out like episodes of Jeremy Kyle. It’s like real life and the internet can’t be separated in their minds.

The mistake that Kensington Palace has made is allowing the collective madness to cause them to stop holding the line.

brunettemic · 12/03/2024 14:27

By response do you mean people constantly starting threads about it…like this one?

Echobelly · 12/03/2024 14:19

Yup, how has it gone to a second day? 🙄And we'll probably get a third and a fourth... I think more important things are going on.

peppermintcrisp · 12/03/2024 14:18

What is the government trying to hide? What have they instructed spin doctors to distract us from?

An attack on Russia with the US?

MaryGreenhill · 12/03/2024 14:18

Absolutely !

FerryBerryHerry · 12/03/2024 14:17

Yes it’s bizarre. She’s recovering from surgery, she’s said she won’t be about now till the end of March, leave her be.

Definitely driven by the media to a large extent as it’s obviously in their interest to generate a load of intrigue around a non-story as it creates engagement, which equals revenue

DryIce · 12/03/2024 14:13

I am not a royalist, or conspiracy theorist, and didn't really give a shit about any of this hoopla.

Until the news about that photo - a future head of state issuing information that is so edited reputable news companies refuse to use it, the media publicly calling the royal family's approved information unreliable. well that does seem like news actually.

The whole royal family is basically a PR business, it seems such a nonsensical cock up. They didn't need to issue anything, they'd already said she was off ill/recuperating. One of the most PR focused businesses in the world making such a series of ham fisted decisions does make you wonder why - what could be worse than how they're making themselves appear now!

Prawncow · 12/03/2024 14:05

As someone posted on another thread, what’s really shocking about this whole thing is how many seemingly normal people are utterly batshit when you scratch the surface. What started out as nosiness and a sense of entitlement - why won’t they tell us her private medical information- turns into rumours and wild theories.

Lampslights · 12/03/2024 13:56

Bridgetta · 12/03/2024 13:51

I don’t. Nobody has forced her to play this silly game. If anything she’s setting a bad example for Charlotte. We all get sick, we all will get old. These are not unacceptable things.

I dunno. I think genuinely something is very wrong. Kate does not wish her face to be seen. Like she really really doesn’t wish her face to be seen. And that’s kinda weird, it’s at least a couple of months post surgery. Why all the cloak and dagger stuff.

Thsts the issue, why all the cloak and dagger stuff. Is something up with her face?

Bridgetta · 12/03/2024 13:51

DisappearingGirl · 12/03/2024 12:10

Well if she did replace her whole face on the image (not saying she did) then I agree that's not a wise move.

But if she did do that, just imagine what that tells us about the psychological pressure she must be feeling to look perfect even after her op.

I feel really sorry for her!

I don’t. Nobody has forced her to play this silly game. If anything she’s setting a bad example for Charlotte. We all get sick, we all will get old. These are not unacceptable things.