Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the 'work shy' rhetoric is insulting?

132 replies

DeliaDerbyshiresSlippers · 11/03/2024 15:29

Who are all these great swathes of work shy people? The Express today, never grow tired of rehashing the same old pre-election trump card - convincing people that our most vulnerable are bleeding the country dry (shhh, don't mention the state pension).

Who even believes this stuff anymore? How did slashing benefits during austerity help anything, how did it fix the fucking country? It only created more decaying towns and a system that can no longer support those in need (kids mental health, dentistry).

Who is the demographic this illiterate garbage is aimed at? My guess is moneyed working class 'boot-strappers' (it's hardly a intellectual broadsheet).
I only know of two people who access the benefits system, both disabled and both actually work as much as they can.

Do people really think, considering the utter shit show we are in, that making poorer people even poorer is a good idea? Will it make some peevish armchair grump feel better about having to pay tax? And is this typical armchair grump completely unaware of tax avoidance? Or is that ok, because 'trickle down, blah blah, creating jobs, blah blah)?

The rhetoric itself is punitive and degrading. This idea that everyone in receipt of benefits (inc. in work benefits) is a shirking, scumbag. The language is reminiscent of how prisoners or deviants were discussed in medieval society.

I thought I was non partisan, or at best apolitical, the outlook for the poorest in the UK looks dismal no matter who is in power Sad

OP posts:
DeliaDerbyshiresSlippers · 11/03/2024 16:17

@Octavia64 multi generational poverty and unemployment is alive and well, particularly in the north west. I do not know the how the numbers pan out in total, across the UK though.
Most of what the press drags up is exaggerated and directly positioned to whip up anger and intolerance.

OP posts:
HelloMiss · 11/03/2024 16:17

You sound wound up op!

Lampslights · 11/03/2024 16:16

And here ends the party political broadcast.

DeliaDerbyshiresSlippers · 11/03/2024 16:14

It is the rhetoric that I find dehumanising.

I don't have much experience, no, but it still leaves me cold. I am aware that many generations of families that lost industry jobs in the 80's failed to adapt and move on, producing further generations who have only ever known life on benefits. This is a complex and terrible issue that no one ever seems to address - the media only focus on them as degenerates.

I know of immigrants from Europe who work hard from the ground up in the UK and build a good life. In comparison, we have entire areas of frequently semi-illiterate people who never recovered from the loss of industry jobs in the 80's (I used to work in local gov many moons ago).

Surely they had options to move to find new work back then, or at least since. How have they fallen off the ladder? Many of them are largely unemployable, if you discount manual (factory/warehouse type) labour.

I do believe making poorer people much poorer won't help this problem, may further compound it. The resulting crime and anti social issues connected to poverty impacts all those who live and work around it.
I don't know what the answer is, but the only dialogue whipped up by the rags is toxic and unhelpful.

OP posts:
Octavia64 · 11/03/2024 16:13

I remember when this was all whipped up last time.

Politicians talking about three generations of unemployed and then everyone went out looking for these people who had three generations of unemployment and no-one could find them.

www.jrf.org.uk/are-cultures-of-worklessness-passed-down-the-generations#:~:text=Key%20points-,The%20idea%20of%20'three%20generations%20of%20the%20same%20family%20who,to%20locate%20any%20such%20families.

Sparetoes · 11/03/2024 15:54

Undoubtedly some elements of press and politicians whip this up to be much more than it is, but you're just as bad if you want to deny it happens at all. You must move in very small or very privileged circles if you only know two people accessing benefits.

I work in education in East London and know of very many families where parents have never worked due to not speaking English, despite having been in UK for decades, for example. Yes, of course there are barriers, but there are also lots of opportunities to learn and take up other training, which of course many others in the community have done.

And don't knock the minimum wage jobs as a starting point either. With application, many of them bring good opportunites to progress.

DeliaDerbyshiresSlippers · 11/03/2024 15:43

I sometimes wonder if it is to make people feel better about working themselves to death. This idea that work shy people are having so much fun at our expense, watching TV's the size of a billboard and kicking little puppies.

Work can be shit, but it gives a certain freedom. People on benefits have so little choice. I would also like to know where all of these jobs are that aren't simply replacing fruit pickers and underpaid bar work. It's hardly like the UK is bursting with manufacturing jobs. The generationally unemployed probably don't even have a full set of GCSE's. With little support for adult training we are talking the worst possible jobs and pay.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread