Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the 'work shy' rhetoric is insulting?

132 replies

DeliaDerbyshiresSlippers · 11/03/2024 15:29

Who are all these great swathes of work shy people? The Express today, never grow tired of rehashing the same old pre-election trump card - convincing people that our most vulnerable are bleeding the country dry (shhh, don't mention the state pension).

Who even believes this stuff anymore? How did slashing benefits during austerity help anything, how did it fix the fucking country? It only created more decaying towns and a system that can no longer support those in need (kids mental health, dentistry).

Who is the demographic this illiterate garbage is aimed at? My guess is moneyed working class 'boot-strappers' (it's hardly a intellectual broadsheet).
I only know of two people who access the benefits system, both disabled and both actually work as much as they can.

Do people really think, considering the utter shit show we are in, that making poorer people even poorer is a good idea? Will it make some peevish armchair grump feel better about having to pay tax? And is this typical armchair grump completely unaware of tax avoidance? Or is that ok, because 'trickle down, blah blah, creating jobs, blah blah)?

The rhetoric itself is punitive and degrading. This idea that everyone in receipt of benefits (inc. in work benefits) is a shirking, scumbag. The language is reminiscent of how prisoners or deviants were discussed in medieval society.

I thought I was non partisan, or at best apolitical, the outlook for the poorest in the UK looks dismal no matter who is in power Sad

OP posts:
Pinkandspiky · 11/03/2024 21:04

Skittlebunny · 11/03/2024 19:11

We have been switched from tax credits to UC, because I am a full time carer for DS (asd, adhd, 12 and in special school) so I literally cannot work. I need the few hours he is at school to be able to get anything done- and occasionally to catch up on sleep.
I cannot believe how horrific changing has been- the whole system is set up to make you feel awful for being on benefits (even though I had to give up my career because I had no one else to look after him due to his extreme behaviours!) And, to top it off, they take my measly carers allowance away from what I would get from UC, because its another taxable benefit! It's... awful. And we can't be the only family being impacted like this. The system seems to be set up to make those claiming for legitimate reasons feel like criminals for daring to need support.
People need compassion and support these days, not blame and ghastly rhetoric!

It’s horrific isn’t it . CA shouldn’t be a taxable benefit. UC deducting it is like sending someone to a food bank then charging them on the way out 🤦‍♀️

Skittlebunny · 11/03/2024 19:11

We have been switched from tax credits to UC, because I am a full time carer for DS (asd, adhd, 12 and in special school) so I literally cannot work. I need the few hours he is at school to be able to get anything done- and occasionally to catch up on sleep.
I cannot believe how horrific changing has been- the whole system is set up to make you feel awful for being on benefits (even though I had to give up my career because I had no one else to look after him due to his extreme behaviours!) And, to top it off, they take my measly carers allowance away from what I would get from UC, because its another taxable benefit! It's... awful. And we can't be the only family being impacted like this. The system seems to be set up to make those claiming for legitimate reasons feel like criminals for daring to need support.
People need compassion and support these days, not blame and ghastly rhetoric!

Updownleftandright · 11/03/2024 19:07

Its just a load of guff. They are having fun being panto villians because this time next year they won't be in politics.

baileybrosbuildingandloan · 11/03/2024 18:54

There's been an update on the so called 'benefits street' of 10 years ago.
Most of the people in that street were working. They didn't show that as it didn't fit the rhetoric.

It's awful isn't it?

DeliaDerbyshiresSlippers · 11/03/2024 18:35

I can't imagine being so averse to paying tax that I could whistle whilst watching my country decay.

OP posts:
DeliaDerbyshiresSlippers · 11/03/2024 18:33

Perhaps instead of making the unemployed targets for derision, they could focus on making basic work pay, make working worthwhile (if you can't afford an eye test or a dentist, work is NOT paying), make it possible for young families to afford decent housing, ease the financial burden for students, enable women to work and study by providing childcare so they don't have to depend on men.
They could also reform the NHS, make it attractive to work in care or nursing, as it once was.
No, they will choose the cheapest, short term solutions that only ever benefit the already well off.

Since property acquisition (both for homes and investments) seems to over ride everything in UK society, it is no wonder we are worse off as a culture. Huge sums of money wrapped up in property does not find it's way back into communities. We could learn a good deal from neighbouring countries with regards to housing. It is a national obsession that eclipses everything else.

OP posts:
Jovacknockowitch · 11/03/2024 18:30

Who is the demographic this illiterate garbage is aimed at? My guess is moneyed working class 'boot-strappers' (it's hardly a intellectual broadsheet).
Sadly I think it's worse than that - the boot strappers can't be a large population.
It's a combination of -
People who have always been comfortable so have no experience of benefits etc
and
The worst sort of gradgrinds who think that children should still be sent up chimneys - these are the kind who pepper any radio phone-in telling you they had it even worse (and had to pay t'mill owner for permission to come to work) as if allowing yourself to be continually shat upon is some kind of virtue.

Angelsrose · 11/03/2024 18:26

I do think that the more pressing problem is the elite raiding the country's wealth. However there are sadly many British people who could work but do not. They seem to benefit the most from the current benefits system. The most vulnerable never seem to get what they're entitled to. Sadly because the Tories have taken so much / wasted taxpayer funds, soon the tax that workers' provide will not be enough to support the vulnerable or those who could work but don't.

Blackcats7 · 11/03/2024 18:24

@DeliaDerbyshiresSlippers yes, yes and yes.
Disabled/sick/ poor people are always the tories “whipping boys” and used to make a nasty section of society feel better about themselves because they can look down on someone.
Sadly the majority of the voting public are frequently easily manipulated.

DeliaDerbyshiresSlippers · 11/03/2024 18:19

Ponoka7 · 11/03/2024 17:11

Universal credit isn't fit for purpose. A barrier for teens and young adults goingvinto these jobs is the housing benefit rules. They become responsible for paying the rent on the parent/s house when the parent has a HB/UC top up.
Another issue is the length of shifts. There's been a few of my peer group 55+ who have taken the jobs. They could do a eight hour shift, but 10/12 is too much. There's lots of jobs in retail, they are for less than 20 hours, but full flexibility is wanted. As a si gke person, you can't live on that money, but don't qualify for top up benefits.

And it is very outdated.

They still presume that if a man and a woman share a house then they are sleeping together, therefore need less to live on.
If I were a renter on benefits and moved in with a male friend to save on utilities and rent, they would penalise us and our claims might be stopped.

Even if some people do abuse the system, it is dehumanising, not to mention sexist, anti-gay, and very limiting for most.
Thos who actually screw the system don't care. They do it anyway.

OP posts:
DeliaDerbyshiresSlippers · 11/03/2024 18:14

Obviously the vast majority of people on disability benefit are deserving of it and need it but believe me when i say there are LOADS of workshy lazy people abusing the system! I come from a council estate and people openly discuss how to play the system and also openly admit they don't want to work!

I know, but sadly these policies do promote hatred, the dialogue used by the press is basically demonising ALL claimants. The people who will be hurt most by this are the ill and disabled.

Getting some reticent people back in to work will not fix the country, but it seems like a jolly good scapegoat to paper over other cracks - stagnating wages and extortionate property prices for both owners and renters.

OP posts:
DeliaDerbyshiresSlippers · 11/03/2024 18:11

Harvestfestivalknickers · 11/03/2024 16:39

The UK does have an issue with productivity, we lag behind both the US and Germany so it's understandable that we need to get those that can work back into employment.
I do take issue with the OP saying there are people who are 'largely unemployable other than factory/warehouse work'. What is wrong with factory work and warehouse work ? We need a darn sight more factory workers and warehouse workers to make this country more competitive. We need people to make and move goods but no one values these trades.

Sorry, I meant that we have far less manufacturing than previously. So the work that people in (the now) depressed areas used to have. If the population has increased since the 80's, then we would expect more available jobs. Some towns (such as Bolton) have populations that have low aspirations and difficulty accessing stable jobs. There are many towns in the north where this has occurred, Blackpool for instance.

Factory work can be well paid, I appreciate that.

OP posts:
Gallowayan · 11/03/2024 17:14

Well said. Unfortunately there are a huge number of daily mail reading dick
heads who think exactly like this.

Ponoka7 · 11/03/2024 17:11

Harvestfestivalknickers · 11/03/2024 16:39

The UK does have an issue with productivity, we lag behind both the US and Germany so it's understandable that we need to get those that can work back into employment.
I do take issue with the OP saying there are people who are 'largely unemployable other than factory/warehouse work'. What is wrong with factory work and warehouse work ? We need a darn sight more factory workers and warehouse workers to make this country more competitive. We need people to make and move goods but no one values these trades.

Universal credit isn't fit for purpose. A barrier for teens and young adults goingvinto these jobs is the housing benefit rules. They become responsible for paying the rent on the parent/s house when the parent has a HB/UC top up.
Another issue is the length of shifts. There's been a few of my peer group 55+ who have taken the jobs. They could do a eight hour shift, but 10/12 is too much. There's lots of jobs in retail, they are for less than 20 hours, but full flexibility is wanted. As a si gke person, you can't live on that money, but don't qualify for top up benefits.

iamwhatiam23 · 11/03/2024 16:54

Obviously the vast majority of people on disability benefit are deserving of it and need it but believe me when i say there are LOADS of workshy lazy people abusing the system! I come from a council estate and people openly discuss how to play the system and also openly admit they don't want to work! Why would they when they can get the same in benefits that they would get in a minimum wage job working 40 hours a week? Those people who can't admit that there are PLENTY of people abusing the system are part of the problem as are the government who instead of forcing employers to pay decent wages go for the easy target of benefit claimants!

Willyoujustbequiet · 11/03/2024 16:50

Pinkandspiky · 11/03/2024 16:20

hard jobs such as childcare and elderly care should be paid well not the awful pay they are now for work which is physically and emotionally demanding and vital and valuable for society - I’ve known many carers get so burnt out (or injured due to the nature of the job sometimes ) that they then cannot work enough hours to get by due to the crap pay.

Also those on carers allowance - make it a non taxable benefit and raise it to actually reflect what these people are doing for society and the economy.

I couldn't agree more about carers.

They must literally save our society billions. Its an absolute scandal the benefit is so low and then to add insult to injury make it taxable.

Disgraceful.

Ponoka7 · 11/03/2024 16:43

HelloMiss · 11/03/2024 16:17

You sound wound up op!

We should all be wound up.

The government ate looking to cut £2bn from services this year and guess who'll get the blame? They are failing to tackle immigration, but guess who'll get the blame for needing them? They are looking to get new immigrants and possibly asylum seekers, with no checkable background to fill care jobs, but guess who'll get the blame when it goes to shit?

Harvestfestivalknickers · 11/03/2024 16:39

The UK does have an issue with productivity, we lag behind both the US and Germany so it's understandable that we need to get those that can work back into employment.
I do take issue with the OP saying there are people who are 'largely unemployable other than factory/warehouse work'. What is wrong with factory work and warehouse work ? We need a darn sight more factory workers and warehouse workers to make this country more competitive. We need people to make and move goods but no one values these trades.

DeliaDerbyshiresSlippers · 11/03/2024 16:38

No, he only received a knighthood for it or something Grin
A man who did well 'marrying up'.

I don't think it's just the right wing though, not now.

OP posts:
BobbyBiscuits · 11/03/2024 16:28

Yeah. The Express is not worthy of comparison to used bog roll.
As someone in receipt of pip and ESA, I tend to just ignore all the anti poverty/benefits stuff in the right wing press.
The fact is a small minority of people choose not to work. Is it because they have no education, no discipline, no direction? Is it to do with the fact they'd be worse off financially? Those alleged 'choices' are not really choices at all. Sadly some people are incapable of work, and not through disability or illness. There's way more unclaimed benefits than there are confirmed frauds.
I remember back in 2010 being repeatedly told by Ian Duncan Smith or some such cunt that all disabled people are liars and scroungers. That didn't work out so hot for him.

DeliaDerbyshiresSlippers · 11/03/2024 16:24

I'm not a fan of any political party, it all feels like the two sides of one coin to me.
But I am interested in why this topic comes up as part of political campaigns. Since it won't make a huge difference to the over all economy if a minority claim benefits, what is it being used for?
Are there people so angry about claimants that this is worthy of front page headlines?

OP posts:
Beezknees · 11/03/2024 16:24

Echobelly · 11/03/2024 16:20

All this stuff about vast numbers of people 'not wanting to work' is anecdotal nonsense. Yes, there may be a very small minority of people who don't work and I can only assume keep themselves afloat with petty crime or off-the-books cash-in-hand work, for whom benefits are just extra pockets money (because no one is living the life of riley, or even living really, on benefits) and those people will never be bothered by sanctions.

You see headlines about 'OMG, this many people were so LAZY they'd rather have their benefits cut than take a job when offered' - with no context. Maybe they couldn't get to that job; maybe they have caring responsibilites for someone that mean that job was impossible for them; maybe they have mental health issues or physical disabilities that (whatever the appalling work assessments say) mean they cannot possibly do that job; maybe the job doesn't cover the cost of their childcare and so on.

I do wish Labour would stop propping up this nonsense Tory narrative and say they will concentrate on being fair - not 'tough'. Personally I'd rather 'my tax' went on 10,000 'workshy layabouts' than one person starved to death because of their benefits being cut, which has happened https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/may/12/erroll-graham-missed-chances-man-who-starved-nottingham-report#:~:text=Welfare%20officials%20failed%20to%20properly,an%20official%20report%20has%20found. and more than once IIRC.

Spot on!

Echobelly · 11/03/2024 16:20

All this stuff about vast numbers of people 'not wanting to work' is anecdotal nonsense. Yes, there may be a very small minority of people who don't work and I can only assume keep themselves afloat with petty crime or off-the-books cash-in-hand work, for whom benefits are just extra pockets money (because no one is living the life of riley, or even living really, on benefits) and those people will never be bothered by sanctions.

You see headlines about 'OMG, this many people were so LAZY they'd rather have their benefits cut than take a job when offered' - with no context. Maybe they couldn't get to that job; maybe they have caring responsibilites for someone that mean that job was impossible for them; maybe they have mental health issues or physical disabilities that (whatever the appalling work assessments say) mean they cannot possibly do that job; maybe the job doesn't cover the cost of their childcare and so on.

I do wish Labour would stop propping up this nonsense Tory narrative and say they will concentrate on being fair - not 'tough'. Personally I'd rather 'my tax' went on 10,000 'workshy layabouts' than one person starved to death because of their benefits being cut, which has happened https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/may/12/erroll-graham-missed-chances-man-who-starved-nottingham-report#:~:text=Welfare%20officials%20failed%20to%20properly,an%20official%20report%20has%20found. and more than once IIRC.

DeliaDerbyshiresSlippers · 11/03/2024 16:20

HelloMiss · 11/03/2024 16:17

You sound wound up op!

Im having a discussion, why on earth should i be wound up? It is a fairly important topic. Add something of value to it, if you can master a paragraph!

OP posts:
Pinkandspiky · 11/03/2024 16:20

hard jobs such as childcare and elderly care should be paid well not the awful pay they are now for work which is physically and emotionally demanding and vital and valuable for society - I’ve known many carers get so burnt out (or injured due to the nature of the job sometimes ) that they then cannot work enough hours to get by due to the crap pay.

Also those on carers allowance - make it a non taxable benefit and raise it to actually reflect what these people are doing for society and the economy.