Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the 'work shy' rhetoric is insulting?

132 replies

DeliaDerbyshiresSlippers · 11/03/2024 15:29

Who are all these great swathes of work shy people? The Express today, never grow tired of rehashing the same old pre-election trump card - convincing people that our most vulnerable are bleeding the country dry (shhh, don't mention the state pension).

Who even believes this stuff anymore? How did slashing benefits during austerity help anything, how did it fix the fucking country? It only created more decaying towns and a system that can no longer support those in need (kids mental health, dentistry).

Who is the demographic this illiterate garbage is aimed at? My guess is moneyed working class 'boot-strappers' (it's hardly a intellectual broadsheet).
I only know of two people who access the benefits system, both disabled and both actually work as much as they can.

Do people really think, considering the utter shit show we are in, that making poorer people even poorer is a good idea? Will it make some peevish armchair grump feel better about having to pay tax? And is this typical armchair grump completely unaware of tax avoidance? Or is that ok, because 'trickle down, blah blah, creating jobs, blah blah)?

The rhetoric itself is punitive and degrading. This idea that everyone in receipt of benefits (inc. in work benefits) is a shirking, scumbag. The language is reminiscent of how prisoners or deviants were discussed in medieval society.

I thought I was non partisan, or at best apolitical, the outlook for the poorest in the UK looks dismal no matter who is in power Sad

OP posts:
GoodnightAdeline · 14/03/2024 10:38

cordeliachaseatemyhandbag · 13/03/2024 08:35

There is nothing morally superior about employment over non employment.

We need to totally reject this orthodoxy.

What would be better for the country, everyone working or everyone not working?

OnlyTheBravest · 14/03/2024 10:19

@cordeliachaseatemyhandbag Can you give some examples? As I am not quite sure what you mean.

cordeliachaseatemyhandbag · 14/03/2024 10:16

@OnlyTheBravest @iamwhatiam23

You are conflating work with employment

Not everything that is good and worthwhile is able to be monetised.

TigerRag · 14/03/2024 07:08

LiquoriceAllsort2 · 14/03/2024 00:04

"despite signing at least one or two fit notes a day for patients as part of my job as a GP. If they tell me they are not fit for work due to bad back pain, depression, period issues, etc, I take them at their word"

People often say the DWP should accept a GP's letter for PIP and other benefits instead of the assessments, when they just take people at their word as quoted by the above GP

Mp GP knows far more about my disabilities. They can look at my notes and see what my consultants have said. My GP has never looked at my notes and asked what a diagnosis of mine is like the person who assessed me for pip. My GP has never seen a referral and questioned why I need it. I had my pip assessor question my disability. (I'd apparently grown out of something you can't physically grow out of)

DreamTheMoors · 14/03/2024 02:24

DeliaDerbyshiresSlippers · 11/03/2024 16:24

I'm not a fan of any political party, it all feels like the two sides of one coin to me.
But I am interested in why this topic comes up as part of political campaigns. Since it won't make a huge difference to the over all economy if a minority claim benefits, what is it being used for?
Are there people so angry about claimants that this is worthy of front page headlines?

Edited

You could actually be writing this about the USA.
Issues like this always come up in an election year and they’re always brought up by the conservative, or Republican Party.
What’s stupid, is the Trump maga people have now replaced the Republicans and 98% of the magas are not very bright - they believe everything Trump tells them.
Many magas are on some form of benefits and when Trump says he has plans to cut those benefits, they cheer him on, having no idea he means their benefits.
We’ve had a great recovery as a nation, thanks largely to smart moves by our current president and economic leaders. Still, there are doomsday folks like Trump and others in his party who will always go for the most vulnerable people first - and give all the advantages and tax breaks to the wealthiest people.
It’s who they are, whether it’s my country or your country or any other country. It’s a tale as old as time.
For us it’s (could be) Trump - for you, I guess it’s Sunak. I’ll never figure out how billionaires are supposed to relate to us regular people.

XenoBitch · 14/03/2024 01:48

LiquoriceAllsort2 · 14/03/2024 00:04

"despite signing at least one or two fit notes a day for patients as part of my job as a GP. If they tell me they are not fit for work due to bad back pain, depression, period issues, etc, I take them at their word"

People often say the DWP should accept a GP's letter for PIP and other benefits instead of the assessments, when they just take people at their word as quoted by the above GP

That doesn't happen. No one who who claims PIP has seen their GP and no one else. You will need a whole lot of evidence from consultants etc.
It is hard to get LCWRA on UC on GP evidence alone too.

No one sees their GP and gets told they can "ride the UC gravy train".

LiquoriceAllsort2 · 14/03/2024 00:04

"despite signing at least one or two fit notes a day for patients as part of my job as a GP. If they tell me they are not fit for work due to bad back pain, depression, period issues, etc, I take them at their word"

People often say the DWP should accept a GP's letter for PIP and other benefits instead of the assessments, when they just take people at their word as quoted by the above GP

Babyroobs · 13/03/2024 23:53

Firecarrier · 13/03/2024 23:50

I see your point, I have buckets of empathy for the myriad of reasons that people find themselves in difficult situations but it amuses me that the middle class types are often those who espouse the sympathetic narrative.

If you had grown up amongst and still know those who DO NOT WANT TO Work (yes - they exist) you would have a more balanced view.

Speaking as someone brought up in a very working class area, we all know of these types and it probably annoys us more because we know their game and see it up close.

If a man doesn't work he shouldn't eat.

Everyone can do something to contribute.

Agree with this. In my job I see whole families, parents and multiple grown up kids and no-one working. It's depressing. They just become unemployable really. There's always excuse after excuse.

Firecarrier · 13/03/2024 23:50

I see your point, I have buckets of empathy for the myriad of reasons that people find themselves in difficult situations but it amuses me that the middle class types are often those who espouse the sympathetic narrative.

If you had grown up amongst and still know those who DO NOT WANT TO Work (yes - they exist) you would have a more balanced view.

Speaking as someone brought up in a very working class area, we all know of these types and it probably annoys us more because we know their game and see it up close.

If a man doesn't work he shouldn't eat.

Everyone can do something to contribute.

Babyroobs · 13/03/2024 23:45

MohairTortoise · 11/03/2024 21:55

They deduct the amount you get for carers allowance from your UC? 😲
Isn't this replaced with carers element on UC?

Yes . I don't understand why people are up in arms about carers allowance being deducted. If it wasn't deducted they would be paying you twice and people get the carers element added. Uc is actually better in this respect because people who want to and can work and earn over the carers allowance earnings threshold can still receive carers element not matter how much they earn. This was never possible on the old tax credit system.

winterplumage · 13/03/2024 23:37

baileybrosbuildingandloan · 11/03/2024 18:54

There's been an update on the so called 'benefits street' of 10 years ago.
Most of the people in that street were working. They didn't show that as it didn't fit the rhetoric.

It's awful isn't it?

There were lots of protests outside the tv production offices at the time that was made. It was appalling misrepresentation and it contributed, no doubt, to the rise in violent attacks on disabled people at the time.

Babyroobs · 13/03/2024 23:37

Ponoka7 · 11/03/2024 17:11

Universal credit isn't fit for purpose. A barrier for teens and young adults goingvinto these jobs is the housing benefit rules. They become responsible for paying the rent on the parent/s house when the parent has a HB/UC top up.
Another issue is the length of shifts. There's been a few of my peer group 55+ who have taken the jobs. They could do a eight hour shift, but 10/12 is too much. There's lots of jobs in retail, they are for less than 20 hours, but full flexibility is wanted. As a si gke person, you can't live on that money, but don't qualify for top up benefits.

There is no non dependent deduction on parents UC rent element until a young person turns 21. That is actually an improvement on housing benefit where a young person is expected to start contributing at 18 ( assuming they are working).

winterplumage · 13/03/2024 23:33

THisbackwithavengeance · 13/03/2024 07:22

I know plenty of people who are workshy and either don't work and rely on benefits or work very minimal hours and rely on benefits. I also know people who claim to to be disabled to claim PIP and people who think that working is a mug's game and say so out loud.

So if I know people like that in my own little sphere then I'm sure that's multiplied around the UK.

But thankfully I know plenty of people who work hard and believe in contributing to the greater good of the 'system' and the economy. Which is good, otherwise we'd all be fucked.

Don't you need to believe it's a good "system" for it to be a good thing to work for it?

TheEverlovingFork · 13/03/2024 23:30

Ponoka7 · 11/03/2024 16:43

We should all be wound up.

The government ate looking to cut £2bn from services this year and guess who'll get the blame? They are failing to tackle immigration, but guess who'll get the blame for needing them? They are looking to get new immigrants and possibly asylum seekers, with no checkable background to fill care jobs, but guess who'll get the blame when it goes to shit?

Yup

2bn in services when you already can't get Gp appointment, an ambulance, a cancer diagnosis in time, or school meals or a freaking BUS out where I am as they trouser enormous private contract backhanders, but no, it's all the peasants' fault as the COL bites so hard your average person in full time work can't afford fucking Lurpak.

winterplumage · 13/03/2024 23:30

Sane people would be aiming towards building a society where everyone had to work less, so it's very odd, twisted and just nonsensical to place a disposition towards hard work on a pedestal.

Obviously it's a manipulative tactic to create division and part of the fallacy of capitalist opportunity and a legacy of the old protestant work ethic — all ways to keep the less well off in their place. Why anyone would fall for it in this day and age is beyond me.

HumanRightsAreHumanRights · 13/03/2024 23:23

OnlyTheBravest · 13/03/2024 11:28

@HumanRightsAreHumanRights They do what thousands of other people in the UK do who want to be their own boss and they identify their skills and talents and become self-employed.

It takes some serious hard work, years of sacrifice and money to start a successful small business.

People who don't want a job aren't likely to be the same group of people who just get on with it, do a shitty job they hate for years with a smile on their face while they get together the skills and finances to try and start their own business.

The benefits system nowadays is set up to make it almost impossible to start a small business while claiming benefits.

I've never met a lazy self employed business owner in my life, unless they are the pretend ones who have a super rich husband or parents to basically fund them playing CEO of their one man band even if they don't make a penny.

XenoBitch · 13/03/2024 21:08

OnlyTheBravest · 13/03/2024 11:28

@HumanRightsAreHumanRights They do what thousands of other people in the UK do who want to be their own boss and they identify their skills and talents and become self-employed.

The only talent or "skill" my workshy ex had, was smoking weed, playing XBox, and debating in the pub.
He has not worked for decades and is totally unemployable.

OnlyTheBravest · 13/03/2024 11:28

@HumanRightsAreHumanRights They do what thousands of other people in the UK do who want to be their own boss and they identify their skills and talents and become self-employed.

HumanRightsAreHumanRights · 13/03/2024 10:50

Who exactly is it that you think wants to employ those sort of people though?

I wouldn't take on someone who obviously doesn't want to do the job and is only there because they've been forced into it.

So, even if you make these people waste companies time applying for a job, who is actually interested or willing to employ them when they have better options?

I think some people are just not what you want in the working world.

I'm not talking about people with disabilities, ill health, or caring responsibilities that make their hours difficult; just the genuinely unwilling to work who I believe are a tiny fraction of the out of work population.

iamwhatiam23 · 13/03/2024 09:59

cordeliachaseatemyhandbag · 13/03/2024 08:35

There is nothing morally superior about employment over non employment.

We need to totally reject this orthodoxy.

Erm yes there is, especially when the unemployed are fraudulently claiming they cannot work and allowing all those that do work and pay tax to pay for their lifestyle!

OnlyTheBravest · 13/03/2024 09:58

cordeliachaseatemyhandbag · 13/03/2024 08:35

There is nothing morally superior about employment over non employment.

We need to totally reject this orthodoxy.

@cordeliachaseatemyhandbag If you are unable to work due to disability, retirement, caring responsibilities or self-funding.

However if you are able to work and choose not to but expect others to pay for your lifestyle choices then you can expect those working to feel morally superior to you and rightfully so because you are the definition of workshy. Disliking work and trying to avoid it when possible as defined by the Cambridge dictionary.

cordeliachaseatemyhandbag · 13/03/2024 08:35

There is nothing morally superior about employment over non employment.

We need to totally reject this orthodoxy.

SabbatWheel · 13/03/2024 07:26

Yep, I also used to live in an area where a small minority played the system very successfully while the rest of us got our arses out of bed every morning to go to work. Hey ho, while they are struggling on state pension and a bit of credit, I’ll have a decent works pension plus full state and be on more than I am currently working part time.

Thems the breaks.

THisbackwithavengeance · 13/03/2024 07:22

I know plenty of people who are workshy and either don't work and rely on benefits or work very minimal hours and rely on benefits. I also know people who claim to to be disabled to claim PIP and people who think that working is a mug's game and say so out loud.

So if I know people like that in my own little sphere then I'm sure that's multiplied around the UK.

But thankfully I know plenty of people who work hard and believe in contributing to the greater good of the 'system' and the economy. Which is good, otherwise we'd all be fucked.

RiderofRohan · 13/03/2024 01:15

DeliaDerbyshiresSlippers · 12/03/2024 22:58

Well, it sounds like you've just not come across the work shy.

it's the word, not the issue.
it smacks of tabloid obsessed small mindedness.
just call them 'problematic', 'unconventional', 'shitty'.

it sounds small minded. As if one receives all of one's education and cultural knowledge from Rupert fucking murdoch. A wee bit brexity. An inability to parse knee jerk headlines from nuanced reality.

We get it. Some people take the piss. But not all. Yet the hounds are happy to take the rest down too.

What word would you prefer?

Your working on weird class assumptions. The work-shy can very much be middle class. People can understand the term without being Brexiters.

As someone who never reads tabloids, didn't vote for Brexit and has never voted for Tory ( or any right wing party), I couldn't tell you what Murdoch is saying about the work-shy. Not a term I use in my every day life as I don't go around policing other people's work ethic, despite signing at least one or two fit notes a day for patients as part of my job as a GP. If they tell me they are not fit for work due to bad back pain, depression, period issues, etc, I take them at their word.

But when someone refers to the term, I understand that there are certain communities, such as the one I grew up in, who fit the description. This hardly means it applies to the majority of people who are out of work for legitimate reasons.

Swipe left for the next trending thread