Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand the fuss about this photo?

194 replies

beeonmybonnett · 11/03/2024 13:39

Why is it all over the news about the Princess of Wales’ photograph being “manipulated “ (I assume that means it was photoshopped)

Am I missing something or have the media just lost the plot? It’s a photo? Who cares if she made some changes to it? I’m not sure how that makes our lives any different. Quite frankly, I find it absurd that this is even being given airtime when there’s much more important issues to be concerned about e.g. Gaza/Israel, Ukraine and cost of living!

OP posts:
Talkwhilstyouwalk · 11/03/2024 21:25

So what. I edit lots of my photos. Like anyone else she is totally entitled to do this.....people are reading into it way too much, surely they do this all the time?!

Wendysfriend · 11/03/2024 21:19

29andLost · 11/03/2024 21:14

There must be something seriously wrong with her if they can't publish a photo that isn't edited yet they let this one fly 😂

Oh god poor man he looks so frail. 😲

29andLost · 11/03/2024 21:14

There must be something seriously wrong with her if they can't publish a photo that isn't edited yet they let this one fly 😂

To not understand the fuss about this photo?
HaggisHhahaha · 11/03/2024 20:57

If your a mum doin a bit of light editing for FB-no one cares

if you are doing an official (their website) release portrait (it’s formal/static rather than an action shot) with multiple edits it seems dishonest and peculiar to heavily edit small features

when I first saw it I thought some thing was off but couldn’t figure it out

there is a a lot of blurred edges

colouringindoors · 11/03/2024 20:57

https://twitter.com/royal_suitor/status/1767248453602890217?t=EWgqwRfoZzajVg_FgWXuog&s=19

Because it's not a true, original photo. Given the huge amount of speculation about her wellbeing, it's bizarre to release a picture to the world's media (who given AI and digital manipulation, carefully scrutinise every photo), that is so obviously massively edited, to the degree that her head is very likely taken from her Vogue photo shoot. Stupid? Arrogant? Incompetent?

https://twitter.com/royal_suitor/status/1767248453602890217?s=19&t=EWgqwRfoZzajVg_FgWXuog

ForTonightGodisaDJ · 11/03/2024 20:55

PuttingDownRoots · 11/03/2024 17:14

FFS. If something was seriously wrong with Kate or she had passed away would her children be in school?
After the mistakes handling Diana's death and the then children William and Harry?

If Kate had passed away they couldn't keep it secret forever 😂also how would they explain the mothers day photo that came to be in the first place? Sorry I know you didn't say this but can't find the post you are referencing.

Terrribletwos · 11/03/2024 20:54

Deliadidit · 11/03/2024 14:13

*It is edited to the point that it looks like she has been superimposed on the photo. Ie she wasn’t originally in it.

This isn’t a filter or a tweak.*

Really? And what are you suggesting that this could mean? What am I missing?

I cannot get over this hysteria - this country has gone mad.

No its not!

minipie · 11/03/2024 20:52

Saschka · 11/03/2024 15:09

People have worked themselves up to believe Kate is seriously ill or dead. This photo was meant to prove she’s fine. Discovering it’s been edited, potentially to insert an old picture of her into a photo she wasn’t in originally, is obviously massive news. It has backfired ridiculously, to the point that it looks deliberate (what other bad news are they trying to deflect from).

I suspect she’s just ill and looks rough (she looked terrible in the car photo) and they edited together some old pictures to stop people harassing her. They would have been much better off saying nothing.

I think this is probably about right.

By now though, given all the speculation, the best thing IMO would be for her to appear in public properly, even if she does look rough.

OneMoreTime23 · 11/03/2024 20:52

FMLWTF · 11/03/2024 20:41

Can one of you photography experts explain what you mean by a fake photo? You keep saying it’s not just teeth whitening and hair smoothing. So what is it? What do you think is going on in the photo? Are you saying these four people didn’t pose like this, together? That they were added separately? Nobody is saying what they suspect. Just that something is up.

It looks like someone else was sat in the middle of the children and Kate’s head has been superimposed. Parts of her hair are blurred and around her hands. There’s a glitch in the pattern on the boy on the left of the picture’s shoulder. Charlotte is wearing one flat boot and one appears to have a heel. The cuff of her cardigan is misaligned with her arm.

ForTonightGodisaDJ · 11/03/2024 20:47

It is really ridiculous and quite shameful really.

shoppingshamed · 11/03/2024 20:45

TheChosenTwo · 11/03/2024 20:34

I saw the photo on the news this morning and literally couldn’t see where all this photoshopping had occurred 😂 either I’m visually challenged or people have too much time on their hands looking with magnifying glasses - there may also be a third option but I couldn’t see anything that looked weird about the photo!
There was talk about the little girls sleeve/cuff? Looked normal to me! And one of the boys had his fingers crossed - nothing especially unusual about that is there?

It's pretty obvious once pointed out that the hand/sleeve has been altered, have another look and I'm sure you'll see it

I'm not claiming to have noticed, I didn't look in any detail but once youve been told the eidts are obvioua

shoppingshamed · 11/03/2024 20:42

InBedBy10 · 11/03/2024 13:47

YANBU Every photo in the media and the large majority of photos on line are edited/photo-shopped in some way.

People are being hysterical about this. Some of the comments I've seen are ridiculous.... this is massive news.... this will expose the monarchy... this proves xyz... 🙄

People really need to get a grip.

Apparently not if we are to believe the news picture agencies.

How do you know that every photo is edited, are you in that line of work?

FMLWTF · 11/03/2024 20:41

Can one of you photography experts explain what you mean by a fake photo? You keep saying it’s not just teeth whitening and hair smoothing. So what is it? What do you think is going on in the photo? Are you saying these four people didn’t pose like this, together? That they were added separately? Nobody is saying what they suspect. Just that something is up.

TheChosenTwo · 11/03/2024 20:34

I saw the photo on the news this morning and literally couldn’t see where all this photoshopping had occurred 😂 either I’m visually challenged or people have too much time on their hands looking with magnifying glasses - there may also be a third option but I couldn’t see anything that looked weird about the photo!
There was talk about the little girls sleeve/cuff? Looked normal to me! And one of the boys had his fingers crossed - nothing especially unusual about that is there?

beeonmybonnett · 11/03/2024 20:27

I hear ya!

OP posts:
LakeTiticaca · 11/03/2024 19:07

It's ridiculous. People are acting as if she's killed someone's puppy, rather than published a photoshopped picture

Salacia · 11/03/2024 17:48

The news and photo agencies need to uphold their journalistic integrity (I’m not taking about the spin put on the stories/photos by the papers - how the mail reports something will be different to the BBC etc, but the actual original source provided by the agencies). If they accept images which have been shown to be heavily doctored/created artificially it undermines their reliability. If there was a mocked up photo of an atrocity that was passed off as real it has significant real world implications (a mock up of a soldier committing war crimes for example). If a fake photo of the royals doing something untoward was accepted by the agencies as legitimate they’d be the first to complain. If you can’t trust the agency or nobody is maintaining a journalistic standard then we may as well just go all in with fake news. The royal family are not above this.

It won’t be as minor as some photoshop tweaks (whiter teeth, smoothing away frizzy hair etc) - those are accepted from this sort of photo. Clearly the edits go above and beyond this though and the palace has refused to issue to undoctered image to help clear up the situation. To be ‘killed’ there has to be legitimate concerns that the photo (or elements of it) is fake.

It’s not a big deal for the reason people think it is (gossip/conspiracy theories about the royal family) but because it proves the royal family are happy to lie or manipulate images propaganda style and undermine the authenticity and journalistic integrity of the news agencies. There was no need for them to release any photo, certainly no need for them to try and pull the wool over the eyes of the press and public.

pootlin · 11/03/2024 17:32

beeonmybonnett · 11/03/2024 13:46

It’s a photo of a mum and her 3 kids - in this case I wouldn’t really say it’s a source of information

Because media agencies (Getty, AP, etc) can’t reject the image without an explanation, they have a reputation to protect.

It’s absolutely right that companies verify the integrity of photographs.

What you’re suggesting - that the agencies accept obviously doctored images because it’s ‘just a mum with her 3 kids’ - is absurd because it’s not just any mum and it reveals an ignorance of how the media works.

Theunamedcat · 11/03/2024 17:31

She was in the car earlier she is clearly alive stressed and under pressure but alive

Theunamedcat · 11/03/2024 17:30

If the news agencies were so concerned about phot9 shop why did they print the heavily edited pap shot of her in her car? The original one was grainy pixilated as hell suddenly this distorted and smooth photo is all over the place of course it looked nothing like her

clarepetal · 11/03/2024 17:27

InBedBy10 · 11/03/2024 13:47

YANBU Every photo in the media and the large majority of photos on line are edited/photo-shopped in some way.

People are being hysterical about this. Some of the comments I've seen are ridiculous.... this is massive news.... this will expose the monarchy... this proves xyz... 🙄

People really need to get a grip.

This.

RicePuddingWithCinnamon · 11/03/2024 17:27

A suspicious person might say that the fuss of the photo is to distract us from the COL crisis, babies being murdered in the war, the NHS dying etc

It’s me - I am the suspicious person.

Causewerethespecialtwo · 11/03/2024 17:24

The press are furious that the RF won’t give details on what surgery Kate has had and why. They are hounding them and will cause a fuss over lots of nothing, lots of negative press, scare tactics, stoke ridiculous conspiracy theories etc, until the palace back down and give them the sordid details they want. Awful bullying.

Changingplace · 11/03/2024 17:21

tittybumbum · 11/03/2024 16:40

It is NEWS AGENCIES who have pulled the picture. Not tabloid press.

Most news organisations follow their own strict guidelines on the use of manipulated photographs, only using them when accompanied by an explanation that the image has been changed from the original.

News agencies, such as AP, therefore make a commitment to their clients that their photos are accurate and not digitally manipulated.

AP's rules only allow "minor adjustments" in certain circumstances, including cropping and toning and colour adjustments, as well as the removal of dust on camera sensors. It says changes in density, contrast, colour and saturation levels "that substantially alter the original scene" are not acceptable.

The pictures have to be accurate otherwise imagery of war, political events and other important world events could be manipulated to change the narrative.

Of course this is just a family picture but it has to fit the guidelines. There are no exceptions otherwise the rules are pointless

Completely agree, it’s actually quite worrying that so many people have such little concept of how press guidelines operate in order to maintain a level of accuracy and trust outside of the tabloid world.

In this day and age when images and videos can so easily be altered it’s more important than ever that respected news sources maintain their standards.

PuttingDownRoots · 11/03/2024 17:14

FFS. If something was seriously wrong with Kate or she had passed away would her children be in school?
After the mistakes handling Diana's death and the then children William and Harry?

Swipe left for the next trending thread